Objective To assess the clinical and cost effectiveness of conservative management compared with laparoscopic cholecystectomy for the prevention of symptoms and complications in adults with uncomplicated symptomatic gallstone disease.

Design Parallel group, pragmatic randomised, superiority trial.

Setting 20 secondary care centres in the UK.

Participants 434 adults (>18 years) with uncomplicated symptomatic gallstone disease referred to secondary care, assessed for eligibility between August 2016 and November 2019, and randomly assigned (1:1) to receive conservative management or laparoscopic cholecystectomy.

Interventions Conservative management or surgical removal of the gallbladder.

Main outcome measures The primary patient outcome was quality of life, measured by area under the curve, over 18 months using the short form 36 (SF-36) bodily pain domain, with higher scores (range 0-100) indicating better quality of life. Other outcomes included costs to the NHS, quality adjusted life years (QALYs), and incremental cost effectiveness ratio.

Results Of 2667 patients assessed for eligibility, 434 were randomised: 217 to the conservative management group and 217 to the laparoscopic cholecystectomy group. By 18 months, 54 (25%) participants in the conservative management arm and 146 (67%) in the cholecystectomy arm had received surgery. The mean SF-36 norm based bodily pain score was 49.4 (standard deviation 11.7) in the conservative management arm and 50.4 (11.6) in the cholecystectomy arm. The SF-36 bodily pain area under the curve up to 18 months did not differ (mean difference 0.0, 95% confidence interval −1.7 to 1.7; P=1.00). Conservative management was less costly (mean difference −£1033, (−$1334; −€1205), 95% credible interval −£1413 to −£632) and QALYs did not differ (mean difference −0.019, 95% credible interval −0.06 to 0.02).

Conclusions In the short term (≤18 months), laparoscopic surgery is no more effective than conservative management for adults with uncomplicated symptomatic gallstone disease, and as such conservative management should be considered as an alternative to surgery. From an NHS perspective, conservative management may be cost effective for uncomplicated symptomatic gallstone disease. As costs, complications, and benefits will continue to be incurred in both groups beyond 18 months, future research should focus on longer term follow-up to establish effectiveness and lifetime cost effectiveness and to identify the cohort of patients who should be routinely offered surgery.

Trial registration ISRCTN registry [ISRCTN55215960][1].

The datasets generated during the study will be available upon reasonable request from the corresponding author.

[1]: /external-ref?link_type=ISRCTN&access_num=ISRCTN55215960

Related Keywords

Italy , Netherlands , Norway , Glasgow , Glasgow City , United Kingdom , Newport , United States , London , City Of , Bristol , America , Norwegian , British , Italian , Andrew Robertson , Karim Sillah , Milind Rao , Anissa Benchiheub , Rebecca Bruce , Maria Laye , Tracy Scott , Rhian Warman , Geert Koffeman , Momin Malik , Kathryn Webb Warwick , Charmaine Shovelton , Sandra Mann , Carina Galpin , Deena Harji , Jolene Witherspoon , Oneil Welch , Veronica Campbell , Libby Graham , Safia Begum , Keith Boath , Mazuin Abutalib , Angela Doyle , Alison Avenell , Siddek Isreb , Bridget Campbell , Sam Dutta , Joanna Allison , Yvonne Gleeson , Claire Price , Muwaffaq Telfah , Matthew Mason , Viktoria Cripps , Julie Haydock , Jess Perry Yeovil , Cleo Brown , Graeme Maclennan , Nathan Curtis , Louise Duncan , Ewen Griffiths , Murugappan Shanmugam , Mel Penacerrada , Debra Campion , Raj Nijjar , Andrew Mcdarby , Sarah Brown , Abigail Patrick , Alison Moss , Heeam Nassa , Miriam Brazzelli , Rezwana Chowdhury , Rajendirin Ashwin , Laura Smith , David Chadwick , Godwin Dennison , Tabinda Kharodia , Sophie Mason , Jane Blazeby , Evelyn Baker , Liz Baker , Aya Musbahi , Judith Rozentals , Faye Moore , Linda Howard , Peter Mekhail , Lorna Fleming , Kanapathi Rajaratnam , Karlygash Ausel , Olga Tucker Birmingham , Frances Walsh , Sarah Clark , Jody Carvell , Peter Murchie , Laura Jones , Yogesh Kumar , Kate Beesley , Richard Welbourn , Martin Grigg , Simon Parsons , Natalie Kenny , Laura Beveridge , Antonio Foliaki , Lucy Knibbs , Paul Glen , Rodolfo Hern , Rajnish Mankotia , Bernard Croal , Irfan Ahmed , Amy Nicol , Sandapa Punchihewa , Susan Dale , Karen Spicer , Alison Lewis , Dave Gribble , Andrea Kay , Karen Innes , Nancy Hawkings , Retno Walandari Bedford , Christine Eastgate , John Saunders , Rebecca Goodchild , Alexandra Smith , Frances Venn , Keith Roberts , Diana Nayman , Samantha Wileman , Jemma Hudson , Tanvir Hossain , Gail Williams , Carol Dalton , Mark Forrest , Lorna Van Lierop Aberdeen , Ravi Marudanayagam , Manijeh Ghods , Nilanjana Tewari , Fady Yanni Nottingham , Mokhtar Eltair , Lindianne Aitken , Craig Ramsay , James Catton , Shirley Pyke , Sally Abbott , Arlo Whitehouse Birmingham , Samia Hussain , Sonia Puig Compano , Esther Zebracki Musgrove , Katie Gillies , Julie Markley , Maryam Hussain , Maria Oleary , Samantha Stafford , Julie Colley , Vasileios Charalampakis , Bussa Gopinath , Claire Mcneill , Edward Lopez , Jemma Tuffney , Jenny Porter , Corinne Pawley , Stef Hobson , Steven Henderson , Suvi Virupaksha , Helder Filipe , Francesca Westwell Royal Liverpool University Hospital , Debbie Wilson North Tees University Hospital , Royal College Of Pathologists , Caroline Young University Hospital Of Wales , Care Research , Elizabeth Williams Sandwell Medical Research Unit , Ami Wilkinson University Hospital North Durham , Gillian Rice Queen Elizabeth University Hospital , National Institute For Health , Bristol Biomedical Research Centre , Centre For Healthcare Randomised Trials , Department Of Health , Study Group , Health Technology Assessment , Gabriele Marangoni Coventry University Hospital , Association Of Clinical Biochemistry , Clinical Trials Unit Standing Advisory Committee , Italian Group For The Epidemiology , North America , Italian Group , Healthcare Randomised , Asian British , James Milburn , Lorna Van Lierop , Aberdeen Royal Infirmary , Dipankar Chattopadhyay , Beena David , Retno Walandari , Bedford Hospital , Robert Sutcliffe , Elizabeth Cornes , Sharon Garner , Arlo Whitehouse , Birmingham Heartlands Hospital , Jamie Young , Joy Dawson , Laura Stephen , Borders General Hospital , Davido Reilly , Caroline Young , University Hospital , Jawad Ahmad , Gabriele Marangoni , Coventry University Hospital , Zaher Toumi , Ami Laidlaw , Tami Wilkinson , University Hospital North Durham , Peter Driscoll , Sue Pick , Victoria Hospital , Simon Gibson , Gillian Rice , Queen Elizabeth University Hospital , Markos Daskalakis , Rishi Singhal , Paul Super , Olga Tucker , Christopher Halloran , Lorna Fleming Bird , Francesca Westwell , Royal Liverpool University Hospital , Andrew Beamish , Michael Nutt , Ashraf Rasheed , Georgia Mallison , Grace Okoro , Elaine Wall , Cerian Williams , Royal Gwent Hospital , Talvinder Gill , Ish Ahmed , Kyaw Toe , Debbie Wilson , North Tees University Hospital , Ravinder Vohra , Tracy Brear , Kate Marks , Fady Yanni , Nottingham City Hospital , David Stell , Aleasha Udal , Natasha Wilmshurst , Plymouth Hospitals , Brian Davidson , Kurinchi Gurusamy , Royal Free Hospital , Andrew Torrance , Liam Preece , Elizabeth Williams , Sandwell Medical Research Unit , Marianne Hollyman , Katrina Butcher , Ami Mackay , Hamish Noble , Mariao Leary , Esther Zebracki , Musgrove Park Hospital , Paul Marriott , Indy Atwal , Angela Day , Penny Parsons , Kathryn Webb , Warwick Hospital , John Spearman , Jess Perry , Yeovil District Hospital , National Institute , Health Services Research Unit , Biomedical Research Centre , Trials Unit Standing Advisory Committee , Mechanism Evaluation , Clinical Biochemistry , Royal College , Open Access , Creative Commons Attribution ,