Commerce Clause Power News Today : Breaking News, Live Updates & Top Stories | Vimarsana

Stay updated with breaking news from Commerce clause power. Get real-time updates on events, politics, business, and more. Visit us for reliable news and exclusive interviews.

Top News In Commerce Clause Power Today - Breaking & Trending Today

Detailed text transcripts for TV channel - MSNBC - 20120630:17:38:00

Of a one off on this particular case. joshua, building on what margot said there, chief justice roberts, will we see a change perhaps in the way that he votes going forward, or is this just a one-off if you will? i don t think this case augers one way or another. i think we just can t tell. but i do think, as to the point as to whether or not that commerce clause holding, which is at the very givening of chief justice roberts opinion, whether or not that will be good law going forward, whether the court has announced some new hard limits on the commerce clause, i think that is more likely. i read that part of the decision to be necessary to chief justice roberts judgment. he s got fourç additional vote for that. and i think in the future we re going to see that part of the decision get applied. margot, talk to that, if you could. when we think about conserve of tiff constitutionalists, what does this mean to them in the commerce clause? this is something that they might celeb ....

One Way Or Another , Very Givening Of Chief Justice Roberts , Joshua Holly , Commerce Clause Holding , Commerce Clause Power , Tiff Constitutionalists ,

Detailed text transcripts for TV channel - MSNBC - 20120630:17:39:00

Celebrating week. randy barnett, a law professor and who has been very deeply involved in this case, was quoted in the washington post this week saying, we won in every way except in the outcome. he hnl hoad been hoping for the to be overturned but he was pleased with two ways the court went, one they believed his argument on the commerce clause which was highly criticized and also that the court did strike down part of the medicaid expansion that was part of the law. that s a really new area of law that may turn out to be more consequential because the court said there are limits on congress ability to influence state behavior by spending money. there s a point at which that becomes coercive. the court had gestured in that direction before but never of actually laid out a limit. good commentary there. josh, when we look at chief justice roberts, something we were talking about earlier this morning, fe wif he was an assoc justice, would he have made a different call on that? i t ....

One Way Or Another , The Washington Post , He Hnl Hoad , Law Professor , Randy Barnett , Commerce Clause Power , Tipping Point , State Behavior , Very Givening Of Chief Justice Roberts , Associate Justice , Fe Wif ,

Detailed text transcripts for TV channel - MSNBC - 20120630:17:37:00

Had not seemed much interest in that rationale at oral argument. so the means toreç tor the gros for his decision were a surprise. the voting coalition was a surprise. but i think, upon closer examination of his opinion and given his concern about the institutional reputation and standing of the court, i think the opinion is not quite so surprising as it first seems. let s bring in our other guest. we have margo singer-cass, the health care correspondent for the national journal. margo, you know, is the health care case so unique in this situation, when you look at it, highly political as well, that we can t infer too much meaning at the moment from chief justice roberts decision? yeah. there seems to be some debate among legal xscholars about whether the ruling will have a broad impact upon first of all whether the chief justice will continue to side with the liberals on these high-profile cases but also whether the rule on the commerce clause can be applied to other cases and ....

Oral Argument , Voting Coalition , Tore à Tor The Gros , Margo Singer Cass , Health Care Case , Repla It , Very Givening Of Chief Justice Roberts , Justice Roberts , Commerce Clause Power ,

Detailed text transcripts for TV channel - MSNBC - 20120630:16:33:00

There are personal stories as to why patient protections that are in this bill make a difference in the lives of those families. msnbc host melissa harris-perry joins us right now. melissa, thanks for staying with us. of course. 6-3, did she expect roberts to go the way she did? i think she would have expected roberts to go there with kennedy so that i mean, i think the sense was that roberts wants to preserve the sense that this court is not a partisan court, that this court is actually making decisions based on the law, based on what has already stood. as she said in her interview with me, they thought about a supreme court challenge before they actually drafted this. they understood there was a taxing power and maybe even a commerce clause power. i don t think she expected him to be a 5-4 decision maker. when we look at the conversation that you had with her, was there a sense of vindication? ....

Melissa Harris Perry , Patient Protections , One Way Or Another , Supreme Court , High Court , Commerce Clause Power , Decision Maker ,