European markets in the red take a look at the euros on. We have gains in paris and germany but the s p 100 is negative by 36. In asia overnight and make story as you can see fractional moves across the board. The worst performer is japan done what hopper said. In washington the House Holding the first impeachment inquiry hearing today as the white house goes on attack against congressman james comer after his committee released findings showing a delaware assistant District Attorney kept joe biden free from investigation from a larger probe. House Oversight Committee chairman james comer is here live in the 7 00 a. M. Hour with the shocking Text Messages between hunter biden and his uncle jim biden. More on why beijing sent 260,000 to joe bidens delaware home as he began his 2020 president ial campaign. 20 the conversation already long Strategic Wealth parker entrepreneur mark tapper, Washington ExaminerKaylee Mcghee white in Washington Examiner tn althou. Maria lets get into it seven candidates taking the stage for the second gop debate. Fox news correspondent bill melugin is on the ground at the Reagan Library in simi valley california. Good morning to you, quite a bit of bickering going on at the debate interrupting and seemed like several of the candidates had it out for Vivek Ramaswamy he was tingling with several of the candidates last night and some of them went after former President Trump that included forming a governor Chris Christie he broke his promises regarding the border policy. Listen. Donald trump failed on this as well he said he would build a wall across the whole border he built 52 miles of wall and said mexico would pay for, guess what mexico new he was only going to build 222 miles they mightve paid for the 52 miles. Another topic of conversation the United Auto Workers strike with President Biden joining the picket lines and candidates were asked to do they side with, the union or the Auto Companies per heres what Vivek Ramaswamy had to say. People are going to real hardship in this country. If i were giving advice to the workers i would say picket in front of the white house in washington, d. C. Thats where the protest needs to be. A big topic repeatedly brought up was china and the threat that china faces towards the United States as long as a National Security threat opposes to the United States the candidates were asked how they would handle it. Heres what nikki haley had to say about her former boss. This is where President Trump went wrong he focused on trade with china he do not focus on buying our farmland he did not focus on the fact that they were killing americans or the fact that they were stealing 6 600 billion in intellectual property. In all our Law Enforcement drones in america are chinese and we have all the surveillance. We need to focus on what keeps american safe. Back out here live after the debate was over, Florida Governor ron desantis sat down with sean hannity for an interview. During the interview he challenged former President Trump to a oneonone debate, the truck team responded on twitter is saying theyre not interested because theyre not thirsty or desperate for attention like ron desantis according to the trump team. Maria thank you very much. Bill melugin in california. Gop president ial candidate stepping up their attacks on former President Donald Trump last night as you heard slamming him for not showing up to another debate. Donald trump hides behind the walls of his golf clubs and want to appear to answer questions like all the rest of us appear are to answer. He put 7 trillion on the debt and he should be in this room to answer those questions. You are ducking these things and let me tell you whats good happen. If you keep doing that nobodys going to call you donald trump anymore theyre going to call you donald duck. He owes it to defend his record where the added 7. 8 trillion to the debt, that set the stage for the inflation that we have. President trump telling fox news digital and an exclusive news i thought it was much more important considering i have a 56point lead for me to be dealing with the uaw in fact the Biden Administration is going to destroy their jobs over the next two years by going all electric vehicles, lets talk about the debate and what we learn. I disagree with the characterization by desantis and Chris Christie that trump was missing in action. The fact is he was and he was just not campaigning for the primary he is campaigning for the general and given his massive lead i dont blame him for that. When you listen to some of the speech that trump gave to the uaw workers yesterday it was a moving and powerful dedication that he displayed to bluecollar workers who he won over in 2016 and he hopes to win over again. I think thats what was missing on the debate stage, yet several questions about the economy but no one gave an italic announcement about bidenomics in the way the economy is hurting and crushing bluecollar americans. Trump did that and for the uaw workers. We can debate about the merits of the strike it a little bit but he did give the denouncement and i think that is what was missing on the debate stage. Maria i think it was a missed opportunity. Biden economics as destroy peoples lives and hurt this economy. Heres President Trump with the uaw, watch. Join ultimate strike against the globalist cast by casting your vote by a gentleman known as donald j trump. Trump is gambling but he needs those voters in michigan because he won michigan by a thinner margin the biden dated 2020. It was a thin margin anyone so sure of the union vote. The pushback against trump with the uaw voters is very thin and they were very scared to come to a guy with a 56point lead. A fight for second place which is very disappointing for somebody like desantis who needs to make this a two man race. Thats why dana perinos question at the end was so crucial. What is your pathway to defeating trump, right now he is your guy the pushback couldve been not only bidenomics a 17 increase in overall prices since he took office but the Auto Industry with new cars 21 more expensive, car parts 22 more expensive, used cars 27 more expensive in the auto workers want a 46 wage increase to work at 32 hour work week. And you could realistically criticize that for the same we should be criticizing joe biden for becoming the first president to ever stand with union like this and the taxpayers have bailed them out. There was no substantive critique of trump so he was the winner last night. I think Chris Christie couldnt wait to come up with this oneliner. He mustve practiced that one. Maria trump made it important point in front of the uaw. The entire biden agenda is about Climate Change and about electric vehicles. That is putting you out of a job. Electric vehicles require 30 less labor. I assume thats why they want to get paid for a full work week only working four days a week that has to be playing into that a little bit. I was impressed the candidates all obeyed the rules for the first 30 seconds and then they were done then it went off the rails. There were minimal attacks on biden, there were attacks on trumps and there was a lot of fighting amongst the candidates. Go after biden he is the one that you have to be. Somebody attacks on donald trump and no, how bad biden policy. They completely missed the ball. Try to attack trump on abortion. I get here in the granular fight of the Prolife Movement trumps comments have been offensive but is aiming for general and he saw what happened during the midterms you cannot attack them from the right on abortion on the general election. Maria gradepoint allaround, lets take a short break we have nancy mace coming up next. Stay with us, dont miss Texas Governor greg abbott coming up in the program. Providing for your family is a top priority. But what happens when you need Affordable Health care . Christian Health Care Ministries could save you up to 40 today. As a member, you can choose your provider without network restrictions. Sign up at your convenience with our anytime enrollment. Join a Christian Community that supports each others medical expenses, offering peace of mind as you prioritize whats most important. Enroll now at your chm dot org this isnt just freight. These arent just shipments. Theyre promises. Promises of all shapes and sizes. Each, with a time and a place theyve been promised to be. A promise is everything to old dominion, because it means everything to you. Welcome to ameriprise. Im sam morrison. My brother max recommended you. So my best friend sophie says youve been a huge help. At ameriprise financial, more than 9 out of 10 of our clients are likely to recommend us. Our neighbors, the garcias, love working with you. Because the advice we give is personalized, hey, john reese, jr. Hows your father doing . To help reach your goals with confidence. My sister has told me so much about you. Thats why its more than advice worth listening to. Its advice worth talking about. Ameriprise financial. Were traveling all across america talking to people about their hearts. Ooh, take this exit. Hows the heart . I feel like its good. You feel like its good . How do you know when its time to check in on your heart . How do you know . Let me show you something. It looks like a credit card, but it is the kardiamobile card. That is a medicalgrade ekg. Want to see how it works . Yeah. Put both thumbs on there. That is your heart coming from the kardiamobile card. Wow with kardiamobile card you can take a medicalgrade ekg in just 30 seconds from anywhere. Kardiamobile card is proven to detect atrial fibrillation, one of the leading causes of stroke. And its the only personal ekg thats fdacleared to detect normal heart rhythm, bradycardia and tachycardia. How much do you think that costs . Probably 500. 99 oh, really . You could carry that in your wallet of course you can carry it your wallet, right . Yes, yes. Get kardiamobile card for just 79 this world heart day. Dont wait. This offer wont last. Get yours today at kardia. Com or amazon. Maria welcome back the houses first impeachment inquiry is today at 830 eastern. For witnesses, forensic accountant bruce tversky, assistant Jonathan Turley at unc capitol hill Michael Gerber hurt, and also the democrats witness, obtaining testimony who is expected to say this while shell companys can be used for legitimate Business Activities more often Shell Companies are associated with tax invasion, Money Laundering, hiding of assets and other illicit practices, jointly South Carolina congresswoman nancy mace of the house Oversight Committee. Its good to see you thank you for being here. Good morning. Thank you for having me. Tell me about the inquiry hearing this morning and what you are expecting to hear and what youre expecting to solicit from the witnesses. The witnesses are experts in investigation of the law and able to lay out how unusual the biden Family Activity behavior was all around joe biden in the Mainstream Media they dont want to tie any evidence to joe biden were going to do that today in the ways and means had an investigation and that information came out yesterday that the investigators at d. O. J. Tried to remove any mention of joe biden and documents and you will see all that starting today. Lets talk about the evidence in the house ways and means releasing 700 pages of irs whistle evidence. The department of justice delayed charging hunter biden ahead of the midterm elections. This is incredible to me, tell us more about that republicans producing an email showing the d. O. J. Ordered investigators to remove any reference of joe biden to political figure in the search warrant related to the edges registration act probe also flagging this text message, jim biden said to hunter biden back in december of 2018 in which he discusses working with joe biden in the past saying we as usual justine several months of his help for this to work. How do you read these things . This ties directly to joe biden. Some of the text and emails that jim biden referenced joe biden as brother and all capital letters indicating that is who joe biden was in the joe bidens name was trump he wouldve been thrown in jail for the illegal activity that we are going to show today we are going to show investigators stonewalled the investigation they stonewalled search warrants months before the election which it was picking up steam in joe bidens name was removed from any documentation that couldve ever been in the search warrant. You learned that the fbi tipped off the secret service, i am going today to showed joe bidens connection to a Chinese Company called cefc that they denied the connection and payment but by the way biden was paid in back pay as soon as joe biden left the vice presidency for work that they did during the vice presidency. Hunter bidens words that he was the key to the only asset that the family ever had are good to come back and haunt him. Maria and graduate brought up csc, is about the company that we got the emails of 10 held by age for the bigeye it was cefc that they were doing a deal with and emails as they were organizing the ownership there, the email says 10 held by age for the bigeye with regard to cefc. What can you tell us about that. They did a deal was cefc during joe bidens vice presidency. They just did not want to get paid for during his presidency. Everything was on the up and up why would you hide this payment or behavior. Why would you hide joe bidens involvement or meeting with cefc about the deal and thats what they tried to do sweep it under the rug and hide it from the American People and we are going to show the evidence today. Maria what about 260,000 that was sent to hunter biden from joe bidens home in delaware. There is an article i was reading that said at that time hunter was living in california. Why was a check sent to joe bidens home. It is very strange indeed. Again another example of direct evidence what the American People should also be asking were taxes paid on it, highly doubtful, was Money Laundering involved, didnt check to watch another member of the biden family after that wire came through its all very strange behavior, none of it happens without the number one asset, joe biden being aware and being involved in the shady schemes going on. Maria let me switch gears and ask about the budget battle you are underway with the House SpeakerKevin Mccarthy said he will not bring the continuing resolution up for vote whos to say there will be a Government Shutdown if biden stays on the sidelines and does nothing about the border. The gop candidates discuss the spending battle during the debate, lets take a listen. People in washington are shutting down the American Dream with their reckless behavior, where is joe biden he is completely missing in action from leadership. Congress only delivered a budget on time four times in 40 years. If they dont keep the government open they should not get paid. 90 of the resources that we sent to ukraine is guaranteed alone. Are you expecting the government to shut down . Thats a 33 trilliondollar question anybodys guess what happens over the next 24 48 hours but we should not be blaming one side or the other on this thing this is republicans and democrats alike, 33 trillion in debt and counting. The last time a historical reference that we balance the budget, in fact we had a democrat president and a republican controlled house. I know we had the power and ability to do it but the will does not exist. Its going to be a problem every hardworking american has to balance a checkbook every single week but congress does not have a free faucet of free money that they keep spending into oblivion every single year end something has to give. Maria are you working on a continuing resolution that you dont have the votes for or are you looking to get votes for the individual spending bills, where are you for appropriation bills this week right . Yes amendments to single subject appropriation bills, there are four that will get a vote on the floor of the house. It is tough to say what kind of cr is going to come to fruition by the end of the week. Maria good to see you thank you nancy mace. Well be right back. Explore endless design possibilities. To find your personal style. Endless hardie® siding colors. Textures and styles. Its possible. With james hardie™. Is it possible to fall in love with your home. Before you even step inside . Discover the Magnolia Home james hardie collection. Available now in siding colors, styles and textures. Curated by joanna gaines. The power goes out and we still have wifi to do our homework. And thats a good thing . Great in my book who are you . No power . No problem. Introducing stormready wifi. Now you can stay reliably connected through Power Outages with unlimited cellular data and up to 4 hours of battery backup to keep you online. Only from xfinity. Home of the xfinity 10g network. Maria welcome back but take a look at futures, the nasdaq is down 20, s p up by a point. We want to take a look at the price of oil spiking prices, the price of crude oil at 93. 21 a barrel that is down after the price hit the highest in 13 months yesterday. A tight supply concern, joy to me Lpl FinancialTechnical Strategist adam turnquist, thank you for being here your reaction to oil and its relation to the Inflation Numbers that were get to be watching and the next couple weeks. Certainly not what the fed wants to see with crude oil breaking out weve seen clear resistance at 83 now are getting into 93 plus a barrel scene resistance, were talking triple digit oil going back and retested the 22000 highs 125 130 camp as you mentioned its all about supply you have opec plus cutting the production into december, russia also reducing their exports and david of the u. S. The stockpile drawdown hitting yeartodate lows its a supply driven market receive a little bit more demand with china importing near record levels back in august certainly improving backdrop for now the path of least resistance means higher. We dont have a lot of wiggle room of the United States joe biden sold off sold off so much oil for Citizen Administration to have to fill it up at 90 plus dollar a barrel. Its undermining any effort to take down inflation. We have more economic data, the final read of secondquarter gdp out this morning at 8 30 a. M. Eastern are you expected this economy to slow down estimate calls for a growth of 2. 1 for the Second Quarter that will be the final read. Its hard to bet against this resilience with the u. S. Economy right now that is something that the fed talked about at the fomc meeting at the betterthanexpected Economic Situation in the u. S. That is starting to lift longer duration treasury yields working against the market i think for the gdp report not any surprises and tomorrow will get the pce data and thatll be the big one for the Economic Calendar in the oil market right now weighing in on the inflation outlook. Maria the oil spike is undermining the efforts to take that inflation you mentioned august pce report out tomorrow Morning Academy start expecting prices to be up to tens of a present month over month and up yearoveryear. As we look at more inflation data which is elevated. We see the fed in the future market pushing back the expected first cut to the back half of next year but there is openness to one more rate hike we see in the fed board split on another rate hike coming in through this year were getting bad news on cpi and pce what should we look at the pce data tomorrow to expected sooner than later rate hike getting another won this year what should we look at if theres a spread that continues to grow. Will look at the super core inflation so Core Services x housing thats when the fed has talked about to see if that continues to come down in the overall trend in inflation we had the fed talk about six months of improving inflation backdrop with pce so we will see if we get a lowerthanexpected. Tomorrow i think that would be welcomed by the market were oversold going into this event tomorrow so well see if we get any type of downside and inflation that would be a catalyst for relief rally on the oversold levels. Maria the other issue, were watching Interest Rates and you have a spike in the tenure in the twoyear that is undermining daily ability for people to get back into the housing market, pay their bills and take down their debt because rates are at the highest level of ten or 15 year. The highest level in ten or 15 years and jamie dimon says theres a possibility that they go to 7 and were at 5. 5 right now another six hikes the market is only pricing to your point half an additional hike right now which probably is not going to cut it if you look forward to december, last december oil average wti average 70 a barrel right now is 9315 more, 19 more, all of the sudden oil becomes additive to cti. Maria ten years up about three basis point right now. Thank you, sir. Adam turnquist joining is your morning mover pelaton gaining after a five year deal with lululemon the Digital Fitness provider providing all access, classes for members beginning november 1, lululemon will also make a cobranded clothing sold by pelaton online and retail stores. The stock this morning up 14 on peloton it is still down 5. 30 a share, coming up fireworks in simi valley as seven gop candidates go headtohead on a whole host of issues mark penn is here to break it down and give his assessments. Stay with us. I got into debt in college and, no matter how much i paid, it followed me everywhere. So i consolidated it into a lowrate personal loan from sofi. Get a personal loan with low fixed rates. Borrow up to 100k. And no fees required. Sofi. Get your money right. That first time you take a step back. I made that. With your very own online store. I sold that. And you can manage it all in one place. I built this. And it was easy, with a partner that puts you first. Godaddy. Maria welcome back chinese hackers getting into the state Department Emails in a breach. Cheryl casone with all the details. Chinese hackers at breach microsoft internal systems earlier this year stole tens of thousands of emails from the state department relation from the Senate Staffer said 60000 emails were stolen from ten state department accounts, the information coming from a briefing from state Department Officials the cyber attack also breached 25 organizations including the u. S. Commerce department, beijing and denies these charges. The manhunt for the man suspected of killing 26yearold tech ceo may be over, there is printed report this morning that he was captured late last night this is the suspect 32yearold jason aldean billingsley he is considered armed and extremely dangerous there are new reports that he is better rested she was found dead monday, she was featured in the forbes 30 under 30 list there was a 6000 reward for information leading to an arrest, critics say the whole story is another example of failed progressive policies in the criminal Justice System in the d cursor ration movement in general that pushes basically to let prisoners go free he was sentenced to 30 years in prison only spent seven years behind bars he is also suspected another brutal attack and rape last week. Finally the delta ceo after fierce criticism of the companys overhaul of the Skymiles Loyalty Program he announces the changes went too far, speaking of the rotary club of atlanta it will be announced in the next few weeks more changes, the first changes for the medallion status drastically increases by the requirements there were new limits to sky clubs for the amex card holders, they added delta received a lot of feedback. That is an understatement there is a stock fractionally lower do not mess with people status, they went too far. You shouldve seen the social media post about the whole thing. A lot of feedback. Maria people rely on it and they want to make sure their statuses were they thought it was. Lets hold the fort, dont go too far especially with the club access everybody. Postcode bid the clubs are packed because they change the qualification and the postcode bid and now all the clubs are so packed. Are probably going to be packed again. Thank you so much candidates taking the stage at the second gop president ial debate, take a watch. We need a leader who contacted people make them understand if you are prolife you have to be prolifer the entire life. The former president is missing in action he has a lot to say and he should explain his comments militarize the southern border stop funding sanctuary cities and in foreign aid to mexico and central america. Last debate he said we were bought and paid for and i thought about that for a little while. I cannot imagine how you could say that knowing that you were just in business with the Chinese Communist party. You hung them on your curtains. They were there before i showed up at the residence. You are scrapping. We meant to the president situation. My wife isnt a member of the Teachers Union but i gotta admit ive been sleeping with the teacher for 38 years. Mark penn righted an oped joe biden democrats have every reason to be jubilant after the second Republican Debate the man himself stock while chairman and the chairman of the harris poll, mark penn is also a Senior Advisor to the clintons. Great to see you. We gotta get back to the, of mike pence sleeping with the teacher for 38 years im not sure why he decided to go that way. First lets talk about your thoughts and your oped. I think as long as a Republican Opposition is fragmented trump is winning biden is winning and he goes to sleep knowing there is no clear opponent who could really beat him in the general election. Last night everyone did too w well, desantis was president ial scott was emotional and nikki haley was issue oriented. I think the field has to narrow. You say nobody can be biden butts take a look at the polls this week trump is beating biden by ten points now are looking at the Washington Post abc poll that says trump is at 52 biden is at 42 and hes beating him right now we also have a poll with nikki haley beating biden by 60 points. Our own poll shows about fourpoint trumps direction. Its true trump has surged theres a long way to go the biden camp of the democrats believe that they can beat trump. If you look at it nikki haley is probably the most electable because she takes the suburbs and a lot of doubtful republican women. Maria she had her arms around the issues the most she was very specific and she has experience. She drew blood the first person for a direct attack at desantis focusing on his proposal to ban fracking and 40 which he did have on his Campaign Website in 2018 he did want to ban fracking because of the states natural resources. She kind of seemed like the only one who was gunning to fight trump there was a kumbaya element to the firing squad where Vivek Ramaswamy were everyone bought and paid for and sit everyone on the stage is a good person. Desantis did not want to get down to fights with people easy add homonyms with trump but it did not seemed like anyone was fighting for trumps spot was there any sense it was a dominant, did haley come off as too shrill or did everyone else, were they to sing when and their fight . I was surprised nobody had a real substitute for bidenomics. They dont show economic expertise when the economy is the number one issue. I thought they did not attack trump and did not attack biden in any real substantive way they said trump you are not here youre missing in action that is not a real attack on trump. You said South Carolina senator tim scott and north dakota governor doug burgum is a loser. I thought doug burgum make great points. I dont know what will happen in the future, obviously he doesnt have the support the others did but why did you think he was a loser. Is get a dropout he has no chance or constituency. Chris christie, mike pence, burgum have to drop out. The last question if no one drops out who do you think you should vote off the island. Maybe its the other way around if you want republicans to win whos going to drop out to consolidate against trump. I hate to be a broken record, there is no consolidation, trump winds that is the math. I think it was clear in the debate between nikki haley and tim scott that they do recognize that people are going to have to start dropping out there is a very clear competition to see who is going to be the representative for South Carolina and whos good with the state in the primary, it was interesting to see the fight between the two. I think nikki haley was disappointing to me. I think she was a little bit shrill, the comment to Vivek Ramaswamy that every time he talks she feels dumber and it was a low blow and came across as immature which was a departure from the first debate when she did seem very serious, she seemed issues oriented and she had a few good replies here and there but people want to know that you are serious we dont want the ad hominem attacks. She did come across the serious. Is that a bad thing in this electorate when trump made his candidacy by fighting does he want somebody willing to fight or the statesman above it all that desantis tried to do with that resignation with voters. When candidates try to out trump donald trump it does not go well. Thatll happen to run desantis initially. They need to be their own unique person, we can have mudslinging in debate but stopped trying to out trump donald trump is not going to happen. I thought tim scott got me when he talked about american overcoming slavery and is believed to the country. Nikki haley was a most assuring shed the best plan on education by far. Im used to president clinton who had a fourpoint plan on everything, most of the candidates most of the time im getting close the border im going to solve crime they were not realistic about what a president can do and how they were going to do it. Maria how incredible they were not more prepared on bidenomics. Look at the price of oil and everything in terms of inflation. Youre on fox business. I did not hear about the Vivek RamaswamySemi Conductor thats one of the key tenets of his economic plan is for us to be some i do independent. As it relates to nikki haley i want to touch on that really quick nobody has done more homework or debate on their opponents the nikki haley she did very well but on the other hand no one has done any debate prep on nikki haley they failed to challenge her on her fiscal policy, she claims that she is running on fiscal discipline but not a single governor on the stage grew the size of the government more than nikki haley and for her attacks against Vivek Ramaswamy against Business Operations in china she was on the board of boeing. Im pretty sure they operate in china. Nobody came back in on that, it is surprising that she seemed to be the leader going into this debate and nobody had any ammo on her. I think she comes out and scared, ron desantis also had to get a little gas in his car in his campaign the question did he really do that coming out of this debate i think he looked were president ial and had better answers in the past. One theory hes going to come in second in iowa and rolled into New Hampshire and it will become him against trump that is his best theory. If he doesnt come in second someone else does the knees going to be in real trouble and that will upset the whole race. Great to get your insights, thank you so much, later in the show i want to get all of your take on who won the debate. Quick break lots of talking to lots of attacks, Vivek Ramaswamy over tiktok makes a buzz. Youre watching mornings with maria live on fox business. Stay with us. Let newage products transform your garage into an area of your home you can be proud of. Modular steel cabinets let you pick and choose the Storage Solutions to keep your garage organized, with overhead racks and shelving, slat wall, workstations and flooring that let you create a showroom garage to call your own. Designed for diy installation. All you need is one weekend to take your garage from unusable to unbelievable. Visit us at newageproducts. Com. About a cashew farmer from mozambique named carlos. Carlos lifted himself out of poverty with the help of techoserve. Go to technoserve. Org and see how you can support struggling farmers like carlos. Its a different way to make a difference. Every day, businesses everywhere are asking is it possible . With comcast business. It is. Is it possible to help keep our Online Platform safe from cyberthreats . Absolutely. Can we provide health care virtually anywhere . We can help with that. Is it possible to use predictive monitoring to address operations issues . We can help with that, too. With the advanced connectivity and intelligence of global secure networking from comcast business. Its not just possible. Its happening. Goli, taste your goals. I have a radical idea for the Republican Party we need to win elections and part of how we win is reaching the next generation of Young Americans where they are. When i get into office ive been very clear kids under the age of 16 should not be using addictive social media. This is inferior rating tiktok is one of the most dangerous social media assets that we can have and what youve got i feel a little bit dumber for what do you say. That is the boarding buzz gop president ial candidate nikki haley slamming president ial candidate Vivek Ramaswamy on the stage last night on his stance on tiktok at the second gop debate. Obviously she wanted to keep coming back to china and tiktok, what are your thoughts on Vivek Ramaswamy on china, does he have the issue. On the substance haley is correct the vic has made a complete decoupling of the chinese economy as centerpiece of the economic agenda and then he flipflopped on the crucial issue of tiktok after one meeting with logan paul that is not a great look and especially when we consider the biggest risk to tiktok is not the fact that young people use it and is making our young people dumber which chinas algorithm and we know what that is for the u. S. Is intentional but more the data aggregation and ip theft and more domestic surveillance of americans. Nikki haley is right on the substance. I think she was wrong on the style and otherwise she had a strong debate and i think she is betting that Vivek Ramaswamys negatives are high enough in her attacking him will get more support from the moderate flank of the party that is really her breadandbutter thats her only path to a 3 11th place in South Carolina victory. They want this group to get smaller, she wants to consolidate she wants to be there and shes trying to knock out Vivek Ramaswamy and Chris Christie and burgum. Its now or never if she does not make it now the worst thing that happened shes kicked off the stage and inevitably if donald trump is the nominee you go to him, no one else on the stage is going to make if they dont start drawing blood. When it comes to nikki haley this is to debates in a row where nobody has come after her. Kudos to her she dodged the bullet in some way. Her one comment every time i hear you i feel a little bit dumber to Vivek Ramaswamy, no one on the stage believes and what theyre saying more than Vivek Ramaswamy, nobody speaks with as much confidence about what theyre saying as Vivek Ramaswamy so to call him dumb i think she completely missed. Were all dumber for having to listen to the constant interruptions and overrating that took place last night. The constant oneliners that they all got prepared to throw at us. America is smarter than that and felt like the contestants were fighting the moderators almost more than they were fighting each other into the question the question was great and we want to hear the response and i think the cop out at the end refusing to respond to danas crucial question about who would you vote off the stage that was really disappointing for everyone i kind of respect Chris Christie for having an answer to that. It was an easy answer and delay up the everyone set them up for because donald trump was not on the stage it is true he did answer the question. I agree i felt at one point the candidates were talking to each other rather than talking to the public and we said were watching from Home Millions of us are watching to try to understand who you all are, dont talk to each other talk to us. What are the great things that Kellyanne Conway said last night stop searching for moments and click bait videos its a long race a longhaul in the oneliners are so frustrating americans dont care about that we want substance hidden agenda in actual policy, no one on that stage had that to offer last night. The one moment when Vivek Ramaswamy said bought and paid for he probably regret that because they went after him so hard for the oneliner. He kept trying to say everyone on the stage is a good person. He did. When we come back the United Auto Workers strike still going on no end in sight, day 14 as more strikes are promised for tomorrow Edward Lawrence is live in michigan with the latest there. Smart guys are still talking in negotiating to try to end the strike the union is still on strike day 14 all of the leading candidates talked about and youll hear about that next. upbeat music woah. Constant Contact delivers the Marketing Tools your Small Business needs to keep up, excel, and grow. Constant contact. Helping the small stand tall. Maria