Isnt The Main Argument News Today : Breaking News, Live Updates & Top Stories | Vimarsana

Stay updated with breaking news from Isnt the main argument. Get real-time updates on events, politics, business, and more. Visit us for reliable news and exclusive interviews.

Top News In Isnt The Main Argument Today - Breaking & Trending Today

Detailed text transcripts for TV channel - MSNBC - 20120326:19:23:00

This plan so they re trying to find a way out of it. that s the argument here. the opponents. they re arguing in the 90s. it is interesting, this sort of, what mitt romney has been caught up in, of course. because he is now opposing nationally. but this is, in regard to this whole tax versus penalty fee question. this is one that i don t think the court wants to put off a decision on this. because the more it goes into effect, the more precedent is set. it become more disruptive to the court than if they were to decide against it. for many reasons, they want to settle this whole matter. i want to get your opinion before we go. this issue of recusal. ....

Isnt The Main Argument , Supreme Court One Way , Mitt Romney , Penalty Fee Question ,

Detailed text transcripts for TV channel - MSNBC - 20120326:19:06:00

Product. they re not separable. and the solicitor general was trying to separate them. tomorrow he wants to argue they re two different thing to preserve the tax argument and the mandate argument under the tax laws. you and i did an interview during the midst of your lawsuit when you first filed it. you said you would not have filed the lawsuit had the government argued that it was a tax. that you would have said no, no, if they had passed it as a tax that you did not believe you had any standing to challenge. so you may not like the legislation but that is a political argument. that there is not legal standing. correct. and that question has been litigated. the social security case, it was mentioned in court today. and frankly took a little bit of a beating from all sides today. settled that question. if they had done this as a tax, meaning, you re going to pay. you and i are going to pay x dollars a year and we ll take that money into the federal government and pay for health ....

Tax Argument , Solicitor General , Mandate Argument , Tax Laws , Isnt The Main Argument , Social Security Case , Health Care ,

Detailed text transcripts for TV channel - MSNBC - 20120326:19:22:00

Argument. that ultimately they re saying you can choose to look at it as a tax but it isn t the main argument. that s right. this is all about the power of congress. to pass the law. and as ken cuccinelli that, they can t make you buy insurance. the obama administration s main argument is that there is commerce in insurance so congress can pass this law. it doesn t have anything to do with tax. the government would be okay losing this argument. today they get out of today s argument, they get a ruling that the lawsuit can go forward. we ll get an answer. tomorrow they hope to get out of that argument a ruling. between the states. it is interesting that this is happening this week. this whole issue of mandate. you can t help but look at this and say, republicans don t like ....

Isnt The Main Argument , President Obama , It Doesn T , Ken Cuccinelli , Republicans Don T ,

Detailed text transcripts for TV channel - MSNBC - 20120326:19:21:00

Device. that was justices briier and ginsberg. two people you would assume would be favorable to the president s cause here on this. if they re not buying the tax argument, what does that tell you? sure. let s set the table a little bit. there is a statute called the anti-injunction act. it says you can t sue ahead of time over taxes. what they were saying was something favorable to the government. this is not a tax so you can bring the suit now and we can decide the case now. but there is another side of the coin for the government. that is tomorrow, when it is the main event, defending the individual mandate. the government has two arguments. one is that this was passed under congress s commerce power. that s the main argument. then their back-up argument is that, by winning today, that this isn t a tax so the lawsuit can go forward and get an answer about the constitutionality of the statute. they are losing a little of the argument tomorrow. not the main argument. you ve call ....

President Obama , Tax Argument , Precedent Setting Case , Lt Sue , Anti Injunction Act , Commerce Power , Back Up Argument , Isnt The Main Argument , Isn Ta Tax ,

Detailed text transcripts for TV channel - MSNBC - 20120326:19:08:00

But for them to uphold the mandate, they have to take the outer reach of the commerce clause and move it way, way out from where it stands. how is it moving that much farther out? look, i didn t go to law school. but reading the case that everybody brings up. it is among the reasons why the government believes they re going to win this argument. that they will convince possibly kennedy, roberts and maybe even scalia, all three of them on this. how did that not stretch the outer limits? it did. you ve picked the farthest limit right now of the commerce clause. you picked the right case. in that case, farmer philburn was doing something. he chose voluntarily to go do something. plant wheat, use it, feed it to his hogs and so forth and sell those. here the person being compelled by the health insurance is literally doing nothing. they re doing nothing. their choice is to sit still and do nothing. but the argument is they are ....

Supreme Court One Way , Commerce Power , I Didnt Go To Law School , Isnt The Main Argument , Precedent Setting Case , Justice Roberts , Farmer Philburn , Farthest Limit , Do Something , The Outer Limits , Health Insurance , Plant Wheat ,