so this litigation has been going on around the country, and challenging it, and this was a very strong opinion by judge cole, guy cole from the sixth circuit, which covers michigan and other states in the sixth circuit, in a 2-1 decision. they reversed a lower district court opinion, and reaffirmed the fact that the supreme court said in 2003 race matters, race is a factor. but some people, doctor, say we don t need affirmative action anymore, yet when we look at michigan, look at the graphic since it was banned in michigan, since affirmative action was banned enrollment has gone down 11.4%. they ve been losing minority students since the law went into effect in 2008. what do you say to people who think it s an obsolete policy or worse, it s reverse discrimination? i think the numbers you cite