Live Breaking News & Updates on California Court Case|Page 6

Stay updated with breaking news from California court case. Get real-time updates on events, politics, business, and more. Visit us for reliable news and exclusive interviews.

Transcripts for CNN Smerconish 20240604 19:37:00

Sorts of contacts similar to what susan porter had engaged and that would be covered by the law. and um, i remember when i was working on this project, one of my colleagues said, are you really gonna make a constitutional case about hard, hard thing, and i understand that it s a little uh, maybe not what we think of when we think of protocol protests, but you know, it s so central and i think that the covid protests that you mentioned are a great example of how political expression takes all sorts of forms, and this is one that s very long standing. you might be surprised that some of these cases have been litigated in other parts of the country for years, and so i do think it is actually quite important, uh, for us to ensure that people can protest in the ways that they are supposed to be able to under the first amendment. you know that the majority opinion in this case, by the way, interesting that that 11 was obama appointed and the other was clinton appointed and they disagreed. yo ....

California Court Case , Susan Porter , First Amendment Expression , Protocol Protests , Majority Opinion , The Way ,

Transcripts for CNN Smerconish 20240604 19:32:30

Michael Smerconish tackles the American political and news stories of the week, offering only one kind of talking points: his own. ....

Supreme Court , Ariana Vogue , California Court Case , Car Horn ,

Transcripts for CNN Smerconish 20240604 19:27:00

They were telling lies. someday he or his supporters, maybe back in power. do you want to give them that ability to regulate the media in that way? i m gonna parrot churchill ins and say that the jury system is the worst possible means of resolving disputes. except for all the others. i rather like the idea that 12 people plus 12 alternates are right now being gathered in delaware they re going to represent. we hope all walks of life and we re going to let them sort it out quickly. you get the final word. i believe in the jury system, too, but i think it s important to remember that this case can easily become a surrogate for political viewpoints. the integrity of the election, all kinds of things that ultimately have very little to do with fox s actual malice. i suspect if this case goes against fox, we re definitely going to see an appeal and very possibly some reversals at the appellate process. well, thank you so much for your expertise. i appreciate ....

Jury System , Gonna Parrot Churchill , Plus 12 , California Court Case , Fox News ,

Transcripts for CNN Smerconish 20240604 19:33:00

Congressman darrell issa s in vista, california. it s about 40 miles north of san diego, and they went on for more than a year. the plaintiff in the case, susan porter, attended several of these protests and at one of them october 17 2017, several san diego county sheriff s deputies arrived and started putting parking tickets on cars . so she decides to move her car and as she drove past her fellow protesters, she honks the horn. in fact, she honks the horn 14 times. she was pulled over by a sheriff s deputy who wrote her a ticket for misuse of a vehicle horn. turns out that section 27001 of the state vehicular code states that the driver of a motor vehicle when reasonably necessary to ensure safe operation shall give audible warning with his horn and the horn shall not otherwise be used except as a theft alarm system. porter citation was dismissed ....

California Court Case , Susan Porter , San Diego , Min Vista , Darrell Issa , October 17 2017 , On The Road , Parking Tickets , San Diego County Sheriff , Sheriff S Deputy , Vehicle Horn , Horn 14 , Motor Vehicle , Theft Alarm System , Porter Citation ,

Transcripts for CNN Smerconish 20240604 19:24:00

The u. s supreme court, which is i is what i m afraid is going to happen, no matter who wins or who loses, and frankly, i would expect a split verdict on this case. the reason for this is we know that there are at least two supreme court justices that are eager to re examine new york times versus sullivan. i don t want to give them that opportunity. to me. this case speaks to the strength and wisdom of new york times versus sullivan. i know that that s probably a minority view among many who are in the political landscape. there s a very high bar here that needs to be met because dominion is a public plaintiffs, so it s not a negligent standard. it s actual malice. why wouldn t this perhaps be an affirmation of the wisdom of times versus sullivan? well i know a lot of people of media lawyers and others are saying this is the case that beats the actual malice standard. i m not entirely sure of that as a whole. i think that ....

California Court Case , Supreme Court , Split Verdict , U S Supreme Court , New York Times Versus Sullivan , Wouldn T , Media Lawyers ,