radically transformed with the people in the room and the direction their bent is a complete shift that is due to the leadership you guys have shown us i want to say we support the legislation with the planning commission represents and the modifications add clarity to the ordinance and align it with the provision if the code and further consider the recommendations in supervisor farrell and supervisor sheehy letter from april 4th and hope that we can continue even beyond that into further efforts to make it an easier ordinance to use and encourage the homeowners to make those decisions on their own thank you very much. >> thank you. >> next speaker, please. >> afternoon supervisors thank you for the opportunity to speak and supervisor peskin for bringing forward this ordinance as well i'm excited to see this will bring our city into sync with the current facets ordinance that is coming in i want to voice the concerns of some of the folks mentioned that while this new ordinance brings us forward it didn't push us in the direction fully as it could to align people to use the space to provide for affordable housing on the market and particularly mentioned obviously freestanding adu's have in the been considered at all and those provide opportunity more affordable housing and i also want to second the comments or that we need an implementation document as quickly as possible that is a handbook no longer applicable and helpful for those going on to be the resources to find out what is possible in the city so that's all i have to say. you very much. >> thank you is there any additional public comment on item 3 seeing none, public comment is closed. >> supervisor tang. >> thank you. i had a clarifying question and it might be mindedly i had a question in response to the planning department for the rhd-1 and clarification about what it is that state law allows but i see on page 6 for example, so i guess exempt out rhd-1 if the criteria that you set up here i want clarification on that. >> the section that is in under page 6 that would put in the code when we're doing the citywide legislation and interesting basically excluding rhd-1 from the adu program that's why that was put in the code and the reason that the commission recommending to make it consistent because state law now applies single-family units in all district attorney's office should be consistent and no need for them to be singled out. >> right so i think i mean again timing that supervisor yee is here but in terms of how our local you know laws interact with state law will we run a risk because we didn't carve out rhd-1 i remember the conversation with the adu legislation but i think that sense the reason we're here because the state law i want to make sure that what we have here is okay. >> john gibner, deputy city attorney. the rhd-1 zoned areas will be subject to status our local program like everything else is all zoning district will be in compliance with state law will carved out but still subject to state law kwuz requests. >> okay. i guess how would radically be treated different than our program. >> so the department will need to interpret the state law in maybe create a temporary rhd-1 law basically to lay out the details of adu program and rhd-1 that's why the commission recommended to make it consistent so we'll not have to do that. >> right? so for example, are some of the things be different the approval process the timeline or i mean what are some of the key components differences we might see come up within the rhd-1 approval if adu versus the non- rhd-1. >> oh, i'll defer to the zoning administrator to interpret the state law basically i mean same effort that is gone through to put together this ordinance so we interpreted this and now have to do it for rhd-1. >> okay. i look forward to that conversation and supervisor yee hope you took note because i mean personally i feel that we should go with planning recommendation to make that consistent but defer to the district supervisor that made the request i'll look forward to following up once the zoning administrator has made that determination and okay supervisor peskin. >> i believe we've heard from the city attorney it is their position that does what needs to be done to comply with the state level with the single-family homes and appreciate colleagues our tying up this loss end and looking forward to work together to further strengthen our adu legislation from may 8th. >> and as a technical matter the clerk requests that i unduplicate the file we make aztec amendments to the amendments as and whole and 10 duplicate the file so in efforts to our great clerk i'd like to unduplicate the file and clothes ask we make the technical amendments that the john gibner, deputy city attorney. read into the record and then we'll duplicate it and send one forward with representations and continue the other to may 8th. >> okay. so just to be clear right now we'll make the meddles and . >> first of all, accept those amendments. >> without objection then madam clerk duplicate the file as amended and going to send the first version to san francisco board of supervisors and then motion take that without objection and the second item or i should say the duplicated if we accept that i described and continue it to the call of the chair. >> i've not read them but happy to do that to circulate them to the public and discuss them whenever you call it. >> a motion by commissioner tang and take that without objection okay. thank you very much madam clerk with that, will you call item 4. >> item no. 4 - planning code - off-street parking and loading requirements. >> clean and correct that that deals with the parking requirements. >> so thank you epic we have mta here, however, don't have the languages from the city attorney's office ready so colleagues to the next this is the regular meeting of the land use madam clerk next monday. >> the next meeting will be the 24. >> so colleagues open up for public comment but make sure we have the actual language before we discuss those issues hopefully it is technical in matters regardless but i think we should have it in front of the us to colleagues open up for public comment anyone wish to comment on item 4 on 4? >> come on board. >> tom, i can't be here on the 24 but want to thank the planning department staff and supervisor farrell for taking that on i mentioned we have the winchester planning code but going to clean up the code and that is the second phase of that effort right now if you look at the parking refreshed my recollection in the section that is unclear what the requirement for any given use that is described and referred to in other ways of describing uses or they were ambiguous those will clean up that we're glad the clean up and finding all the odds and ends up we that that is important project and completely unisex i didn't but makes life easier for the planning department to make life easier for the members of the public and the veterans and as we actually do go to make the subjective changes in the code with the adu ordinance having a lonely lion and organized code makes that easier your much less risk you're trying to do something substantive so we think this is an important project and commend. >> and hope you'll support it. >> thank you anyone from the public wish to comment item 4? >> we will continue. >> okay super quickly from spur we support in now and then substantive change and we'll echo the comments we would like to see the parking changes thanks. >> thank you anyone from the public wish to comment item 4 seeing none, public comment is closed. colleagues can i entertain to continue for one week. >> without objection madam clerk call item 57 item no. 5 - planning code - dwelling unit mix requirements. >> add an option for the dwelling unit mix for 50 percent of the bedrooms in more than one bedroom and making the appropriate understanding. >> it was sponsored by supervisor yee ultimatums but want to ask the madam clerk to be added as a co-sponsor thank you. >> thank you chair peskin and colleagues the legislation before you today has been you know words for over a year and as you may know i've been working with the planning department on identifying ways to make housing for family-friendly when we started working on the family-friendly housing policy that was published earlier this year we held a number of focus groups one of the urban forester meetings was with the market-rate developers to understand where the family-friendly units were not built in san francisco one the ingredient that supports this family-friendly 0 housing is the number of bedrooms and in the unit and obvious reasons they didn't feel a demand for three bedroom unit three bedroom units are expensive to build and the market didn't justify that cause and they even said that to me that they were told that the city didn't need those units one of the facility issues developers to my attention that the current mix in certain lands was also not conducive to building larger units with three bedrooms or more awhile credit was given for two bedroom units didn't apply to three bedrooms unit in the recent neighborhoods area there was two dwelling unit option one of them being that you will build 40 percent two bedrooms or thirty percent three bedrooms unit almost no projects opted out for the first option - i'm sorry almost all programs occupied leaving us with few three bedrooms built i worked on creating an option to allow for more flexibility to envelope vices the building of large unit by creating more of a mix of two bedroom and three bedrooms unit the origin legislation included an option that will have encouraged more multi units at least more than one bedroom and after the review we released that will currently for two bedroom unit but may want result in three bedrooms unit at all it will conflict with the goal therefore after discussions with at the planning commission i am presenting an amendment of the whole that rise the formula to require the minute number of three bedroom unit but lowers the requirement of multiple bedroom units for developers that will give the developers additional option this option will be that 35 percent of unit must have two bedrooms or three bedrooms with 10 percent of all unit being three bedroom unit i want to emphasize that 9 legislation will only be proposing an additional option for developers the existing options low remain in the eastern neighborhoods plan right here i'm enthusiastically that flexibility is key we have to have a serious conversation about what type of city we want to become already, we've got the sad distinction of the least you number of children in any major city the board has been clear this is not acceptable i recognize there are a lot of factors that play into the families decision to stay in the city affordability is at the top of that list, however, we also need to recognize the design and hosting play a role we are envisioning building a city with families with children of all ages a city where we can make housing for family-friendly by design bedrooms tdif our housing stock so that it will eventually be built more multiple bedroom units for families of all kinds i've encouraged by the positive discussions we're having at the board the planning commission and throughout the city how we can do more for families right now we have one single fix that will encourage for families sized units i want to thank the staff at the planning department, community members of the pentecostal boosters club and members of the developer community for - who have engaged throughout the process i also want to thank the housing action coalition and spur for submitting letters of support i hope you will adopt that amendment as a whole and forward full board with the with a positive recommendation one other amendment i'd like to this committee to entertain which is to expand the dwelling units options to the zoning districts similar to eastern neighborhoods these will include all residential transit orbited residential and commercial and neighborhood commercial transit districts this was one of the recommendations from the city planners report city departments report to speak about our legislation and this possible amendment i'd like to bring up aaron starring from the planning department. >> mr. starr. >> good afternoon, supervisors aaron starr manager, legislative affairs, planning department. so the the item before you is adding an additional option for be reminded district to allow the vendors to have a mix of two and three units they heard it last year and recommended approve with modifications the commission property one provides the dwelling unit mix and nct 3 district supervisor yee mentions two to include a minute percentage for three bedrooms unit in the dwelling unit mix option and monitor the project that the two bedroom and include the data inventory in 2019 the department understand that supervisor yee amendments two and three but not recommendation one and thanks supervisor yee for adding those recommendations and hopes that further consideration will provide an option for other zoning district have the density control to make sure that outline at units are single bedroom a or san francisco and expanding that to all the controlled neighborhoods makes sense to us that concludes my remarks and available for questions. >> any questions for mr. starr. >> supervisor yee if you have noting no further comments i'll open up for public comment. >> thank you mr. starr for being here and also i can see that one of the public speakers coming up is actually for this where it oriented from thank you eric. >> mr. towel. >> thank you. i'm eric president and ceo of the corporation a multiple developer in san francisco having been doing housing development in san francisco for several years we know that how housing work in san francisco with a market driven force tempered by the policies and goals and we work together we try to find a balance to insure that investment continues to the city we can produce housing we temper the production by achieving the policy gospels we all support recycle trying, trying to keep as many families in san francisco as possible i as a family understand how difficult and work with supervisor yee's office to find a economically solution it that allows the developers to select an option right now the thirty percent three bedroom option is not clfthd everyone is left with 40 percent we solve so for the same outcome as the 40 percent two bedroom and dwelling unit mix with the two and threes we believe with outburst developer underwriting results this option is neutral two bedroom 40 percent a good option and hopefully, will result in some production in the districts thank you. >> hello corey smith on behalf of the housing coalition. also happy to stand here and support supervisor yee legislation so a number of times during the flexibility and obviously a huge proprietor in keeping people in san francisco and fully appreciate our efforts across the board with the legislation as well to looking forward to psa it forward today thank you. >> hi christie from spur and want to support the dwelling unit mix legislation and appreciating this is other option for developers it to follow that will allow within the existing policy for the new construction provides a mix of housing units and wanted to flag there could be conflicts coming up with the inclusionary legislation arrives both those proposals have different requirements you know different from what that is today and what that legislation proposes i hope that will get and appreciate schooez reaching out to us thank you. >> okay. >> next speaker. >> hello supervisors tony vice president and chair the development boosters association and thank you for having this hearing but ran over here to catch you in time how quickly you move we're in storage support and thank you supervisor yee we did a lot work on the measure we have a lot of experience negotiating with the developers in the neighborhood about trying to get more three bedrooms unit and we that this is an option legislation as written including the 35 percent, and 40 percent with three bedrooms it's e hits the sweet spot and we're able to get with the projects so we've managed to get to 42 percent 02 and three bedrooms but hardly any three bedrooms so a small production for this we're concerned so i'm in support and thank you for bringing this forward. >> thank you anyone from the public wish to comment on item seeing none, public comment is closed. supervisor yee. >> thank you i want to thank the public for coming out and especially eric powell when planted the seeds for this and if we could hold off a couple of seconds supervisor tang has a question for clarification? >> intern supervisor yee you can entertain us with singing. >> i could but i won't i safe that for my grandkids go ahead supervisor tang. >> we were trying to figure out on page 2 start on line 24 references the qualifications for ncd upper market and nct 3 district so no less than 40 percent of total number of dwelling units will have less than two bedrooms but this applies to the nct districts ct r and eastern neighborhoods we were trying to clarify with our city attorney's office there's or there's a repeat so two requirements so - >> clarification thank you. >> sewer john gibner, deputy city attorney. >> this is an issue with the existing law not the changes proposed in the ordinance mr. starr and i think that might mission street a reference to a mission rto but look account and rather than proposing an amendment today. >> we'll take note of that. >> so basically, i'm asking the committee to support would be this the amendment as a whole. >> which i'm happy to move. >> and to the additional amendments that is was passed out to you to include those other districts. >> i'm happy to move to the amendment of the whole. >> okay so we have one motion then to accept the motion as a whole and the additional amendment as a whole and then the forward to our john gibner, deputy city attorney. we can do this and send it out? >> i was discussing the rto issue the alleged amendment was - >> supervisor yee could you speak to the additional amendment. >> the additional amendment applies to the language that will clarify that those other districts will be approving to be added as using this option. >> okay. so the additional amendments to the substance of amendment that requires a continuance and another hearing in the city. >> as to the form based districts i'll move we continue this one week. >> okay. so we can we have a motion on the whole plus an additional amendment and part of that motion we'll continue for one week. >> one week. >> april 24th. >> okay motion by supervisor peskin and take without objection supervisor tang we're good okay so moved. >> madam clerk, is there any additional business to come before this body? >> there's no further business. >> thank you, everybody we're adjourned >> good morning, everyone and welcome to the san francisco board of supervisors meeting for tuesday, april 18, 2017, madam clerk madam clerk, please call the roll. >> thank you. >> commissioner london breed pr supervisor cohen supervisor farrell not present supervisor fewer supervisor kim supervisor peskin supervisor ronen supervisor safai supervisor sheehy supervisor tang supervisor yee supervisor farrell madam president all members are present. >> thank you, ladies and gentlemen, please join us for the pledge of allegiance. >> america and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> thank you madam clerk are there any communications. >> none to report madam president and colleagues any changes to the approval of the minutes for july 20, 2016. >> a motion to approve moved by supervisor cohen and seconded by supervisor yee approved an public comment. >> items 1 through 4 >> items 1 through 4 consent agenda all matters listed hereunder constitute a consent calendar, are considered to be routine by the board of supervisors and will be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the board. there will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of the board so requests, in which event the matter shall be removed from the consent agenda and considered as a separate item. >> from the consent agenda and considered as a separate item. >> roll call vote. >> commissioner london breed supervisor cohen supervisor farrell supervisor fewer supervisor kim supervisor peskin supervisor ronen supervisor safai supervisor sheehy supervisor tang supervisor yee there are 11 i's. >> those items are approved unanimously madam clerk items 5 and 6 together are two resolutions that approve two leases for items 5 lease with the american messaging, llc for a portion of roof and equipment and for item 6 the lease is with spok inc. with the equipment room for both lease at zuckerberg san francisco general hospital and trauma center 0 on potrero at a rent of 5 thousand dollars each will be waived while the equipment is provide for the city. >> colleagues, can we take that same house, same call? without objection the resolutions are adopted unanimously and item 7 please. a resolution to approve a lease between c and n, llc and the landlord as city tenants for equipment at the number one, bayview park road through march 31st 2017 with 3, 5 year options of 92 thousand. >> same house, same call? without objection the resolution is adopted unanimously >> next speaker, please. >> e next item, please. >> item 8 a resolution to approve a 25 year telecommunication ground lease after a radio telecommunication tower with the state of california department of general services and rec and park as left hand with the department of emergency management and the intentionally at the san bruno mountain state park of a rent of 44 thousand to fair enough a one and $75,000 payment to the state parks benefit funds. >> same house, same call? the resolution is adopted unanimously next item, please. >> item 9 to approve the rec and park department jd of a catastrophic failure and needed repairs to the estimated cost of more than 200 and 50 thousand >> same house, same call? the resolution is adapt unanimously. >> 10 for the appropriations limit of approximately $3.2 million for 2016/17. >> same house, same call? without objection the resolution is adopted unanimously item 11 to retroactively approve a $67 million grant agreement between the home bridge for the in-home care support and provider training and support program to the period to june 2019. >> supervisor peskin. >> thank you, madam president i would respectfully ask to request a one week continuance i have my staff has spoken to staff at the department of aging & adult services and concerns were raised by workers covered from the contract i want time to ask questions of staff and as far as this is a retroactive approval one week will not be a problem supervisor cowen's has made a motion to the meeting even if april 25th and seconded by supervisor kim colleagues without objection that will be continued to april 25th, 2017, item 12 to authors the sheriff's department for the agreement with leaders and to extend the term with no change in the agreement museum not to exceed $2 million and the approving the sheriff's department electronic monitoring program rules and regulations and approving evidence of financial responsibility. >> demonstrate by program administrator lc a for the consent agenda. >> same house, same call? without objection the resolution is adopted unanimously next item, please. >> item 13 for the construction administrator financial officer and contact for a proposed project to renovate county jail with the $6 million for county jail two and sharing the ownership of county jail number two. >> same house, same call? without objection the resolution is adopted unanimously next item, please. >> item 14 a resolution to retroactively authors the department of health to accept and expend in one $.3 million from the california public health for the hiv through 2017. >> same house, same call? without objection the resolution is adopted unanimously next item, please. >> item 15 a resolution to approve the issuance of revenue bond by the authority in agreeing aggregated principle amount not to exceed $045 million for outstanding debt obligations same house, same call? without objection the resolution is adopted unanimously next item, please. >> 16 a special on sale general theatre to the cutting ball theatre on 277 taylor street will serve the public convenience same house, same call? without objection the resolution is adopted unanimously next item, please. >> 17 to appoint members (calling names) terms ending 2018 to the market octavia citizens advisory committee program same house, same call? without objection the motion to approved a unanimously next item, please. >> 18 a motion to appoint supervisor safai for an indefinite term to the san francisco international airport round table colleague a motion to excuse supervisor safai seconded by supervisor kim without objection supervisor safai is excused madam clerk on the item madam clerk, please call the roll. >> 18 commissioner london breed supervisor cohen supervisor farrell supervisor fewer supervisor kim supervisor peskin supervisor cohen supervisor sheehy supervisor tang supervisor yee there are 10 i's. >> the motion is approved unanimously all right. madam clerk let's go to committee reports. >> item 26 was considered by the at a regular meeting of on april 13th item recommended to the board as a committee report the resolution to authors the rec and park department to apply for a grant in an amount of 200 and 45 thousand if the california department of forestry and green house gas emissions reduction to carry out a forest project commissioner london breed supervisor cohen supervisor farrell supervisor fewer supervisor kim supervisor peskin supervisor ronen supervisor safai supervisor sheehy supervisor tang supervisor yee there are 11 i's. >> the resolution is adopted unanimously item 27. >> was considered by the transportation to demand management committee on monday april 17th was amended with the same titles as a committee report and 27 to amend the green building code to establish the installation of electrical vehicle chargers infrastructure in new buildings or undergoing major alterations for the building owners and making the appropriate determinations and findings. >> same house, same call? oh, supervisor tang thank you quickly i want to thank everyone at the sf environment for working hard on this piece of legislation to get how city to be electrical vehicle ready colleagues, can we take that same house, same call? passed on the first reading madam clerk go to roll call. for introduction. >> madam president your first up today. >> submit. >> supervisor cohen thank you very much good afternoon, everyone thank you for joining us today, i'm introducing legislation that prohibits the sale of favored tobacco products and that includes the menthol cigarettes whether cigarette or smokeless or e product take into account excuse me - addressing products that are market that have added flavor to the tobacco component so tobacco loves to - manipulate and to take advantage of vulnerable populations nationwide they advertise ten times more in black neighborhoods the targeted marking things like gummy bears and candy products tearing down the lgbtq and the african-american community and the latino community and the asian pacific islanders community many of us have seen the commercial with children identifying tobacco products as candy and smelling good and everything from the label to the flavors that those companies have chosen for the products are all created and done with the intent of malice to miss guide our vulnerable members of the population and in the he said it is about primary care their lived here my whole life the tobacco pushes new would be smokers favored tobacco products and need new smokers they're killing people on an annual basis in the city and county of san francisco we spent $380 million annually addressing the healthcare costs for cigarettes smokers not an indictment but i'm here to talk about the legislation that will go restrict the sale of flavored tobacco products and regulating the sale is vital to insuring we give the next generation a fighting change to live a life people are disproportionately dying from diseases that are preventable focusing on favors to make sure that the eye popping tobacco illness and the outcome of disproportionate aggressive target marketing of those harmful produced to the vulnerable populations needs to end earlier this afternoon i am proud to stand with the mayor as well as supervisor safai and kicking off this legislation we were introducing it today, i think there is are a could have of co-sponsors i'm sorry, i don't have the list of supervisor farrell and commissioner london breed sponsored any others spornlz who supervisor tang is oh, supervisor sheehy is on board to supervisor kim, supervisor yee and supervisor peskin and supervisor ronen and supervisor fewer i'll be knocking on our door next that is important measure about life and death have an opportunity to real help safe lives that policy driven and driven by science and the no one more okay. now my other piece of legislation oh, this is very, very existing lamenting also groundbreaking i'm glad with a full audience san francisco as a city that values notification transparent and problem solving the board of supervisors is the public steward of those values and really passed with insuring that their consistent and the public process the public process that brings you here today in the chambers as how city and nation is unequal meaning a growing excuse me - a shrinking but going percentage of one percent and the rest are withering we need to take control of our destiny and continuing of the future opportunity before us our city treasurer our pension rent board and the board of supervisors has had to xhavnl evaluate one divestment we've heard from gun manufacturers we're heard from fossil fuel those calls need to be a thoughtful approach needs to be taken in understanding the divestment calls this is an attempt to safeguard our values to make sure our city continues security is not built on the backs of the vulnerable in the meanwhile you are financial system can't serve small businesses many people in the chamber may come from places not able to refinance their house mortgages has targeted the baby communities since 2008 and think how to approach those problems and support new industries like the cannabis that legalize last november i'm introducing to create a task force to create a muni bank in the hope that we'll find a systematic and thoughtful way of insuring that our city financial system provides the much needed sustainability and forward thinking policies we need as we venture into 0 the 21st century but the solving of the problem comprehensively without the piecemeal legislation your findings we as the members of the board are talking about or working with others shareholders so i hope that we will be able to have a comprehensive approach and while we're able to continue to build up the small business entrepreneur the inspiring homeowners and the hard working stolen is to sum up i'm requesting a request for a muni bank task force to come together and introducing legislation to prohibit the sale of favored tobacco the rest i submit. >> thank you supervisor cohen supervisor farrell thank you, madam clerk one resolution today following on supervisor cohen's comments we're a national leader we were the first city to fight for marriage quality and universal healthcare for city resident and the first for families leave for patterns we were the first employer in the country to offer the healthcare as part of care design and the internal revenue service or first to cover the gender reassignment for the transgenders those were recognized by paycheck to paycheck the way for the u.s. military to cover the sewers costs of gender this is prevalent a conflict between a assigned his or her or they identify and i can't imagine they experience significant depress and problems associated with that conflict the way they feel about their physical or assigned gender to complicate the matters further for the transgenders community the federal injunction suspected the affordable health care that had discrimination protects for transgender as a result of primary injunction some shows o choose to drop their coverage this is discriminates alive in 2017 with the trump and republicans currently call for the repeal and replacement of the affordable health care the future guarantee and protection for transgender coverage are in jeopardy this past thursday our health board i'm with the board of supervisors representative in response to the preliminary injunction approved the statement that they'll continue to fully recognition the medical treatment for genders as part of a scope of coverage to members the board with the professional association for the transgender on the necessity of treatment with the carriers and healthcare providers to eliminate transgender from their policy guidelines with supervisor sheehy i'm introducing to reaffirm the medically transgender phobia benefits 0 we are in solidarity with the transgender not only in san francisco but abroad the resolution with the department of health to continue over and over genders benefits for the affordable health care act is repealed and replaced we'll not let the transgender community be bullied by trump and the republican colleagues this will send a strong message that san francisco will stand up for and with our transgender community regardless of what happens in washington i know we'll not let trump and colleagues rollback the work we've achieved here in san francisco san francisco colleagues the rest i submit. >> supervisor fewer. >> yes. thank you very much today is theian the 1906 san francisco earthquake a disaster that claimed lives and demolished home i call for the reports of the emergency supply system to keep san francisco safe and prepared for when the next big one hits i sat on the in on the recent hearing that the puc emergency hearing and heard how now neighborhood eat the west side of san francisco will be protected in case of an earthquake and fire i understand that most of central san francisco is covered by the auxiliary a w sf a high pressure system with prior earthquakes but the west side and south side of san francisco are left vulnerable isn't case of a major disaster today supervisor peskin and i are calling for a report from the budget analyst to examine the alternative water system including a cost analysis of extending the a w sf to the west side of san francisco thank you the rest i submit. >> thank you supervisor fewer supervisor kim synonym submit. >> supervisor peskin submit superbowl thank you supervisor ronen. >> hi colleagues today, i'm introducing a resolution call on the city to support the community 0 lead action on mayday in san francisco and thank you every single for covering this resolution this resolution is about reinforcing our cities values and doesn't to the support all workers including the independence their invaluable lash makes san francisco the incredible place with the hour we're taking a solidarity with the tens of thousands of workers in san francisco who lives are tabloid by the trump modification this is meaningful we've come together with a day without immigrants and recognizing rectifying recognizes our movements are stronger in the face of federal that's as a city continue to stand point against trump policies for his bigoted travel bans against muslims and moving forward to expand the wall between mexico and the united states thank you. the political correct of ton to one a drafting this and mobile to be where little cable cars climb halfway to the stars this today, i know that local 87 and fernandez from the mission have been hard working to have this historic day is recognizes the importance of may day and the challenging political times but also encourages city departments to participate in may day action at this time i want to thank and recognition every single one of my colleagues on this board that have committed to taking part in may day and a shout out to supervisor fewer and supervisor kim who along with me will be closing our offices on may day in support of immigrants and the working community the rest i submit. >> thank you, supervisor ronen. >> supervisor safai thank you, colleagues you might have read in the news that one of our new or only service companies chariot in a major labor dispute for all my brothers and sisters in labor they've been organizing anti union campaigns we find out yesterday they've hired mendelsohn the attorney they're the most anti labor attorneys in the bay area and for those of you who don't know that understand neutrality 93 or 94 of the brothers and sisters from those drivers had submitted cards for election and now chariot is diego's to change and move the ball so today bans previous work with sfmta back in 2015 in terms of submitting labor harmony in the shuttle operators we're essentially asking for the same today where multiple multiple drivers as a result that have labor harmony and negotiations with the commuter services over 8 hundred drivers from loop and compass we drive have all negotiated with organized labor to have full representation of those drivers and that's a positive outcome so we've asked in our resolution today, if the mta should finalize a permit for a chariot operators include the labor harmony in the provision and explore every way to encourage them to immediately cease their anti union tactics the rest i submit. >> thank you supervisor sheehy supervisor safai submit. >> thank you, supervisor supervisor tang thank you, colleagues today, i'm introducing a resolution to declare april as national donate life month in san francisco curbing one 19 thousand people in the natural transplant waiting list and 6 hundred and 65 actually live in san francisco and there are actually disproportionate number of people waiting for a transplant whether you compare in the city 44 percent of people waiting for a life-saving a transport are asian, 19 hispanic and 19 caucasian and another 10 minutes someone is added to the waiting list 22 people die everyday in united states waiting for a transplant a huge need of people list themselves as donors only a few allow for tissue donations the reason i'm introducing this to provide awareness and education amongst the residents here about organ donations but because you know this issue hits home as some of you may know colleagues my legislative aide ashley her husband charley he actually is waiting for a life-saving kidney transport right now he suffers in a condition of kidney disease and kinds of the grow on his kidneys that cause failure at a little of 34 only four percent of kidney function and performs diagnoses two hours or more per week the average time people wait is 5 to 10 years but charlie as only been on the list for two years and hearing about charlie undergoing a kidney diagnoses at a young age i can imagine what that is like especially having a young daughter at home personally i saw my grandmother go through kidney diagnoses. >> charging lists father passed away at 44 years and his brother always several years ago so when living donors is important they can not only save lives like charging i didn't but for other to receive a donor so with this i'm trying to spread the awareness and try to help charlie find a building donor to get back to his family and begin his career in the fall as a public school teacher that is a personal decision for everyone but maybe surprised to learn that people can live what one kidney and if you're interested in donating to charging yes. you can feel out a www.donor.org and contact our office to find out more information i'm existed on friday i'll be joining for network the mayor's office, c ph the unidentified pool district i know supervisor sheehy is having a birthday but the city is expanding educate people about a donations and join this proper information at the wellness center you can designate yourself as a donor thank you for listening to this 0 effort we have and hopefully, you'll help us find charging i didn't. >> living donor the rest i submit. >> supervisor yee. >> thank you, madam clerk colleagues today, i'm requesting a hearing on the safety and testing of the san francisco public works ground water supply that blends hetch hetchy with ground water this district one 2, 4, 8 and 11 are some of the first district that will get the majority of this bloentd water i want to change supervisor sheehy and supervisor safai and supervisor farrell for covering this hearing currently san francisco see water supply is mostly water from the hetch hetchy reservoir and 15 supplied by other reservoirs, however, due to the risk of drought or natural disaster the puc created a plan that would de, if any, the source of water from a more local source the san francisco public works spent a decade testing the use of ground water in the city's water supply and decided that when benevolent there will be - be able to provide customers with high quality drinking water that meets the qualities standards set by california state water resources control board drinking of drinking water and i mean division of drinking water and the u.s. protective agency the water will mix water from the west side ground water basin and will think distributed across san francisco the new blend i'm sorry the new blend will not include more than 50 percent of ground water awhile san francisco public works staff assured the customers there will not be a notable taste community members across the city have raised concerns some have asked if the 91 trait levels will rise to the health risk due to the presence in the wells as part of project and others are concerned about the taste and odor as noticed in december last year when the self-public works changed the hunters point water in other reservoirs i want to protect the puc san francisco public works and another opportunity to address the public and hopefully resolve the outlying questions since the proposal was made another item i want to introduce is a resolution and this will be an imperative item i'll talk about right now a few weeks he closed the march 23 board meeting in memory of the great chinese-american giant and san franciscan phillip choi today, i want to introduce a commentary resolution declaring april 23, 2017, and phil p choi day in honor of celebration of any life this coming sunday that will be held on treasure island i'm proud to introduce this simple resolution no honor of this great legacy and his family from the request of the phil's colleagues at san francisco state and the friends of the chinese-american community to honor in honor of the celebration of his life today marks the one hundred 11 of the 1906 san francisco earthquake in san francisco and phillip choi was one the 3 individuals to whom the rove was dedicated the other two were gladys and mr. starring he he was a proirlg chinese-american and proirlg of chinese-american history architect, professor, thorough, activist devoted family man and researched and promoted much of what we know about the many significant contributions chinese-americans made towards the development of our country i community roll in americans history phil passed away at the age of '90 diagnosed with cancer this year like me grew up in san francisco chinatown and attended city college and grateful for having known him personally he listed in the arm air corp. and trained mississippi he missed the rash injustice towards blacks his advocacy on behalf of of the civil rights is timely given the recent anti immigrant policies of the current modification and this year is also the one and 35 anniversary of the bar of chinese people from mating to the us after world war ii graduated if uc berkley as an architect i want to honor his contributions to the chinese-american community phil choi was tireless this writing and chinese-american history and accomplishments together with him and mark he helped to teacher the first course in chinese-american history in the country at san francisco state in 1969 this course substantially became the model of course programs throughout the country's growing up a time against asian phillip was not one to be easily intimidate as a trained architect working in a firm discriminated because of this is a rays and told not ever getting a job he ran a business until 2000 when he was invited to the 1965 transcontinental through a was no mention of the pivotal role of the chinese played in the western half the central pacific which included the difficult era phil was outraged by the chinatown contributions to the railroad and didn't take f this injustice lying counsel gave an interview to the chronicle that made the front page news. >> gardened wide attention simply phillip is inreplaceable in the chinese-american community and he played a major roll in preserving the immigration center and in addition designed the chinese museum in orville i encourage you all to visit in the middle of california he was the president of the chinese historical society in 1965 and ongoing writing boxes and creating documents, movies and so forth and i am personally grateful for phillips work that taught me so much about my heritage and he will be socializing misses by the chinese-american community and survived by his children and 6 grandchildren and he was known for his sharp witness and great love for life learning and his family i encourage those of you to attend his celebration of life in memoriam serve and at the international infection at the one p.m. and want to thank supervisor kim, supervisor peskin and commissioner fewer and others for covering this resolution the rest i submit. >> thank you supervisor yee madam president that concludes the introduction of new business it is the for the. >> xhomsdz this is from supervisor commissioner fewer. >> thank you very much president colleagues this week i'm dllthd to be you honoring a valuable institution the branch library created it in 1932 it is the 17 branch to say established in the san francisco public library system and was created after voters approved a charter amendment to raise tax for construction and what a wonderful investment that has been amongst early supporter 85 years with the neighborhood balboa park merchant association over the past 85 years there have been many improvements on the opening day in 1932 the branch had 8 thousand plus today over one and 90 thousand items in circulation at that branch and one thousand visitors this last year the library there are went a roopgs in not and 2011 it it became the second san francisco branch library for certification and thanks to organ the branch changed the charm and historic character with feelings and original built book shelves and tables and chairs they serve an important role for lifelong learning education and programs that range from reading if young children and taken care of languages and a community hub the labor has posted story times with 5 thousand attendees 52 class invites from c-3 reaching students and preschool reaching 3 willed and 72 preschoolers and adults program for many attendees congratulation for the amazing 85 years keep up the good work and look forward to our upcoming 90 celebration i want to recognize our wonderful and hard working larger than megan branch manager and terry carlson the northwest manager division. >> (clapping.) >> hello. thank you supervisor fewer and members of the board for this recognize and the budget committee stowe of this award chief suhr has basically said a lot of what i was about to stay it is truly a branch library for the residents of san francisco as she mentioned a special task was tasked through the city charter amendment and 50 thousand later when the branch opened in 1932, 11 thousand books were in circulation today 85 yors later the branch has 48 totality a genius amount of toilets for the russian and chinese community we serve the residents west of 33 after the branch follows the mission statement of the san francisco public library to serve owl residents and visitors throughout the entire world we basically follow the libraries mission statement that is summed up in 3 world all is welcome we have story times and ti which he lessons and hosted programs in the past that include the citizenship classes and hands on programs including weaving, cooking, cheese making and a petting zoo exhibit for the young children and parents on may 13th the san francisco public library will lead the summer reading program we hope you have time to go to the local library to participate and doesn't closing thank you to chief suhr for her recognition of the branch library and the next time you're in the outer richmond check us out on 37th avenue within geary thank you very much . >> (clapping.) >> thank you supervisor fewer and congratulations and thank you for your services. >> with that, madam clerk please read public comment. >> at this time, members of the public may address the commission items thirty to 32 public comment will not be allowed advise sfgovtv, and take it down when you are finished. >> first speaker please. i'm here to request that the rfp for the formerly what is it - the man, i got a senior moment here oh, the addition now called the addition once called the - that rfp be put off for a month and not be voted on, on april 22nd because community has met with some of the investors and i tried to reach one of the investors this morning september e-mails and seems like that person doesn't exist or they have not gotten back to me so we can't afford for anything to go wrong with this this time the building has been closed for a long time in the community and the community has been really take advantage of and so i'm asking the supervisors if you would not accept the april 22nd date and prolong it until i know the bidders because we don't know we meet with people and can't get back in touch with them i'm hoping that happens forgive me for forgetting. >> thank you and hold on a second mr. yip? general public comment if you're here for the special order 3:00 p.m. this is judge general public comment mr. yip. >> good afternoon andrew yip civilization works on the unintended for maximum mission for the people for the democracy for the people social on the unitem no. 17 - 2016-005702cua, 524a clement street,conditional use authorization. >> for the people true principle works on the universe for the people political leaders must struggle for the amounting of the people the destiny of a career through political leaders must deliver policy legislation with the visual of good peace the social and economic issue is the downfall of human hearts political leaders must apply the holy reduce that is the process to ones good nature pure and kind and from an ideal state everyone of the people have self-control for the country by virtue and everyone of the people would practice virtue in taking on the pathway to promote love and kindness in the future with the intellectual in politically the universal laws of principle of humanity and william and destiny the true - thank you. >> thank you. >> next speaker, please. >> good job board of supervisors my name is joseph bryan the vice president of ton to one san francisco relocate here with our director of the regional david and also our streevenl coordinator peter i want to say thank you to the board of supervisors so many supportable resolutions introduced today, we're here to seek in regards to the resolution to support the may day action we feel is that the mayday action is part of a birth resistance we're asking for the support for in terms of resolution but in terms of spirit i think one of the things we certainly realized is that like with mayday needs to be more political education in may day is lights proffered as immigrants national in a national day but also derived ♪ country's was the establishment of part of establishment for the 8 hour workday under the new modification i'm sure he wanted to take that away >> thank you to everybody for their support. >> thank you for you comments. >> i'm david the director for 10 to one and in support of sxheflgz resolution on may day i think that resolution will go a long way to join the actions they'll not be retaliated by the city and county of san francisco we hope to see you in overseeing marches on may day. >> thank you for your comments. >> next speaker, please. >> good afternoon, supervisors peter strategic coordinator for ton to one and thank you to supervisor ronen and give you a little bit of background the majority of world holds celebrates labor day on may 1st to commemorate the hay market massacre a bomb was thrown by an unidentified individual the police charged 8 of the speakers with conspire and hanged four of them the rest of the world celebrates this in honor the united states we don't celebrate that ourselves in 1921 named this the american day in 1949 loyalty day and 1958 law day this is how scared our government is of the working class and 2006 it was the day without protesting. >> notice o now we have an modification that is opposed to workers and immigrants san francisco want to be seen as the beacon against the trump administration it is imperative this this body supports this resolution and this city condominiums to supporting the workers that take that day off to engagement if in the action thank you for your comments next item, please. >> good afternoon. i'm michael bear a resident of district 3 and last year, i was asking for a resolution to against the prosecution of gay member i'm here to support condemning the lgbtq in the chechen republic isn't that true san francisco has historically been a light house for people coming all around the world to speak and fits within the political action and ask you to support this resolution thank you. >> thank you. next speaker, please. >> >> i'm mark a member of the local 87 the executive board members and here to speak in support of may day resolution i think that is really important for everybody in the city to see the supervisors out with us i'd like to ask you all you guys to support the resolution and thank you. >> thank you >> next speaker, please. >> good afternoon, everybody buenos dias i'm the president of the suv local 87 and secretary treasurer the labor council we took a moment if the contract negotiations to make sure that we ask every one of our board of sups to my own on the resolution by sxhefl that is a critical time in history the first mayday march increase in new modification this commitment that every one of board members has done san francisco is a beacon but we want is to make sure that the resolution has the full support of every single one of our board members and that we are also you to instantly stand with us and march with us on my day. >> (speaking spanish.) >> mayday is not solely for immigrants it is about working families and in san francisco the brothers and sisters stand behind me the carpenters can you stand every single one of the single carpenter in you're a working if you have a hard hat stand i believe that w two the working families we're fighting for labor day and mayday wire struggling to provide i'm asking you to sign on to the resolution. >> thank you for your comments. >> (clapping.) >> i'm bill the chair the labor studies at the city college of san francisco also a member of 2121 and the lash history is important to note that mayday is too hot to handle the tradition in united states it is history denying labor day in september and may day come out of structural for the 8 hours day people have to work up to 14 hours a day and chicago was an immigrant city people fought for the 8 hour day but people have to work two or three jobs to work and make ends meet i'm here to thank my supervisor supervisor ronen and those who are in support of may and urging full support from the city government you know that city college was almost taken down we were able to save the college we educate the immigrants workers as to their voting rights and english and job skills and this was in defense of working people with the immigrants in particular so i ask you, please give our full support in this and join us in marching on may day thank you. >> thank you for your comments. >> next speaker, please. >> i'm automobile and representing city college in support of may day resolution i believe 0 as long as we allow this prosecution of immigrants all workers are disadvantaged and i'm unwillingly to be party to that and hope the board votes according thank you, thank you for you comments. >> next speaker, please. >> hi my name is monique here as a private citizen in district 5 and thank you all, all members of the board of the board of supervisors for supporting in may 1st resolution i've not been to the board of supervisors this is my first time speaking but i am torn and heart broken by the people just couldn't sit back in the haight and be silent so thank you all for that and especially thank you to say supervisor jane kim and supervisfor closing our officer. >> thank you supervisor fewer is a flower. >> sorry. >> next speaker, please. >> my name is raphael i'm a seiu 1021 school district department and in here to hope every board members supports may first and one the organizes of may 1st, the action taken a day without an immigrant more than a day without an immigrant everybody's rights brown and black or gay or lesbian this is all our fights trump is coming down on everybody we see that everywhere whether the working-class people or our communities we need action we need the president to hear our voices we need to be a big event in san francisco hopefully it is one of the biggest events inform where the people are standing up and taking a stance guns the racism and the bigotry that donald trump is showing our country we can't stand for this is a community multiple times are uniting we the board of supervisors to take a stance this is a sanctuary city utilizes prove that by signing the resolution and walk the streets and march thank you, thank you for your time. >> thank you for your comments >> next speaker, please. >> my name is ace washington first of all, apologize to the city specifically to supervisor cohen for my out busts last week and thank you for supervisor kim to chill me out i'm here i sweet and look like a ravaged person with sweat my name is ace and i'm on the case. >> thank you to my supervisor had a wonderful meeting in the west side so that's out of the way my apologizes accepted and tell you what i'm here for mayday i'm here for immigrants but here about out migration and talking about and will to the day recognized was as are in a state of energy mayday mayday what the hell is happening in the city by the bay i want to talk to trump we talk to tweet tweet tow truck on fillmore street street to talk about what we lost i'm an advocate please forgive me, i'm a troubled man like marvin gay stay in our line i'm lawsuit for the black folks i keep on saying 3 generations i have a moral obligation you instant stop me the man upstairs can i am looking at for the black necessarily gross i'm not a rate of interest i'm a realistic we're in the state of emergency and if the city didn't admit to it i'm on my way to washington, d.c. i'm on my way but stop until sacramento and talk to the governor newsom's what is happening to the city by the bay area my name is ace and i'm on the case. forgive me supervisor cohen. >> good afternoon. i'm halley and work for downtown streets for homeless individuals in the area i brought something to pass out if this is okay the clerk will be there in a moment to pick up. >> i'm here to advocate for a smooth new neighborhoods we're the team in bright yellow shirts on the civic center thank you those folks including the person behind me are unhouse individuals we're there everyday to beautiful that and pickup several needles and the folks behind me are using their time to contribute to the community but their working on further goals for housing and employment like calculated and the impact i passed out right now we're active in civic center and union plaza and in may opening up a tenderloin team and looking for other areas something we found specifically in san francisco hoe who wants to go to the mission and any other neighborhood they want to clean up the neighborhoods best we can open up positions for the neighbors had already live and stay there thank you for your comments >> next speaker, please. >> local i'm george i work for d s t it's been a good experience for me helped me reestablish mitchel as being my work ethic and helped me try to regain a status in life to where i have housing and a full-time job opportunities and its been a good thing to beautiful the civic center area union square and other areas so we feel good about that and hopefully, we're a positive force for the city and whoever is involved in our existence in our future thank you very much. >> thank you for your comments. >> next speaker, please. >> my name is otto and support mayday in its fullest meaning if you look at the image here who know that he was a chemist i hope that some of the people practicing the religion if we continue to take as important a focus on the things he i am not i don't believe in kick california comes around but jose recognizes a problem with superficial like alternating traffic parents is not remotely enough how hard to get electrical vehicles we are scraping the surface an approach to global climatic change will not displace people long term residents not at that particular time what in their immigration status thank you for your comments. >> next speaker, please. >> tom gilberty president trump as allowed the managers of 40 is k they reduce the amount of returns for people but a payoff a kickback last week, i mentioned we have a chief of justice it decided that corporate orders superseded a trucker leaving his rig and saving his life the corporations rule and you as a that he on a capitalist ideal lit 49 years old and last week he mentioned gavin newsom tried to establish a court procedure keeping that open to over roll the it to one vote to negative at 8 washington because it restricts the financial growth of the real estate industry i presume he's what we call a social corporate democrat and now i kind of want to read from an article from the chronicle september i sat in a restaurant one of the developers walked in late to one meeting i saw him disappear into the back i ask do waiter yeah, he said the mayor is there i had a slow finish to the meal and watched as every major builder left the restaurant from what i hear the basement was the cool $1.2 million or the mayor that was written by willie brown, jr. do we have reforms from those people. >> madam president seeing no other members of the public public comment is closed. madam clerk go to the special order 3:00 p.m. >> items 19 through 22 is the special order continued if march 27 in the determination of exemption from the environmental review under the california environmental quality act orientated as a exemption and approved by the planning commission on september 22, 2016, for the proposed project locked other 277 taylor street to allow the occasion of 3 two-story houses and construction of a 40 foot toddler residential building and item 20 to affirm the planning department proposed to exempt this project from future environmental review in the community plan exemption and item 2 is reverses that determination and item 22 the motion to direct the findings. >> okay before i review the details of that hearing want to acknowledge supervisor ronen. >> thank you commissioner borden. >> colleagues a month ago you allowed me to continue this item for a month so i can common with parties to see if they could have a meeting of mind which would allow the wall of this appeal and want to assure you, we have been working hard over the past month assess development groups and calle quarto have come together and working hard and really been trying to hear one another and make agreements that can get us to an agreement on this project we are close to an agreement but there are a few details that need to be accounted so i'll ask you for the last time to indepartment of technology me to the may 9th meeting and 4 o'clock i'll appreciate that time and if we would make use of it to reach on agreement on that project. >> thank you commissioner melgar has made a motion to continue this appeal to the meeting of may that 9 at 4 o'clock p.m. and seconded by supervisor peskin i will now open up for public comment specifically to talk about the turns any members of the public that would like to make comments about the continuance ever this appeal please come forward. >> my name is owning martinez representing well, a member the san francisco latino historical society not representing them i support the continuance but to give you a little bit of background on this whole situation back in the early 2000 in the eastern neighborhoods plan was started the planning department didn't think they had to do the historic surveys and took a couple of years after a lot of public pressure and pressure from the board of supervisors that they finally did the survey and the eir for the eastern neighborhoods acknowledges that the resources survey with lagging behind seriously behind and when the mission - the survey for the mission was completed and present to the public it was discovered a serious omissions in the latino history was not covered after 1848 we're in the process of doing a historic statement technically the work shouldn't have happened without the work being done now the plan should include the historic cultural heritage and the support for the sustainability of resources including the cultural resources so never the ground work for the latino historic resources in an ideal world that would have been put off until after december when we had the statement available but for now i support the continuance thank you. >> thank you. next speaker. >> noipdz a ann good afternoon, supervisors i one of the researchers and also with the latino historical society the reason we started it because we were left out of this our history was left out of historic resources report and one the finding to date the mission district was the center the china movement that recognizes internationally and our political latino political and social justice movement as well as the latino labor movement for those of you who don't know is it hadn't been the effort of social central caucus of labor two 61 and others latinos would in not to have a political voice in the city and a building they taught language to their workers so 0 without the union force we wouldn't have had a political voice and would have never had the city hall the l.b. s where the dignitaries in mexico and movie stars fernandez and all of those historical moments caesar chavez who was involved a lot of for those of you who don't know the union agreement was signed off on at the goorm center when we started out had an office of the item on 16th street a lot of the stuff has not been documented i support the stuns we spent 66 years in trying to get a voice we need the voice ben martini basically stated you have to hear us you need to hear us you need to hear our voice we support the continuance but hopefully, the context statement will be implemented. >> can i remind the members of the public that is specifically about the continuance so if we can focus our comments on the continuance that will be appreciated next speaker. >> good afternoon. supervisors corey smith on behalf of the housing coalition. hopefully in a another of touch couple of weeks this is a ceqa issue rather than other difficult challenges i hope that two weeks we're not taking another day to plug that out that's the plug thank you. >> thank you. >> next speaker, please. >> good evening board of supervisors i'm carla san francisco resident and a labor journey man laborer and in support of this project going forward because this is the helping me to raise my family in san francisco and pay for their education forward in their lives. >> thank you very much. >> next speaker, please. >> good afternoon. my name is latisha perps san francisco resident i live in fulsome street between 14 and 15 i'm a laborer union for 12 years and work with fisher and i'm here in support it is good for me and my family. >> thank you very much. >> next speaker, please. >> hello supervisors i'm a san francisco resident i work for fisher and i'm here to support this project and against the appeal. >> sir it is this is particularly about the continuance so if you could stick to whether or not you support the continuance. >> i support the project. >> thank you for your time. >> next speaker, please. >> good afternoon. members i'm alex with carpenters local 22 we're here in support of continuance we understand the project sponsors and the appellants reached a tentative agreement to continue this year for a couple of weeks to the continuance you know one of the things i've been doing a research analyzed i've been outstanding why housing prices with the way they are and a good touchstone is the research for the state of california the supportive of housing committee one of the things that showed is that meetings over and over and over and over again have some of the most significant costs or significant impacts to the project costs so let's look at where we are this is our 5 continuance we support that but step back and ask yourself whether this has nothing to do with with the ceqa issues and ask ourselves if 0 anyone there are our need to house people that are living other than the street or more specifically whether or not it in any way advances or reduces the pushing of people out of our community right now lastly i want to ask you to ask yourselves what did it do to the people these people took time out of their day and now will support a project to be able to and be able to provide the livelihoods of their family yet we keep on going around in circles that doesn't have relevant we need to make that project happen and get on with building housing for people i will remind members of the public that this is to specifically state about whether or not you support or you don't support the continuance please keep our comments in around the continuance thank you very much. >> next speaker >> i'm tim senior organizes for carpenters local 22 i'm here tonight to represent the members standing apprehend me we hope to have a chance to speak about the appeal we understand we want this project to go through we hoped you'll have a had an to tell those workers they got their books and believe in their livelihood and need this job we hope that you'll have the chance to tell them you support the career pathways for motorist and women and say yes to our homegrown developers that don't have deep pockets that believe in what we do and last night this developer met with the members and add to their demands still they addressing agreed to the appeal the folks nationwide are fighting for the livelihood we fight against right to work legislation we fight for tax on prevailing wage and n rb it is stacked and fighting our own instrument for the livelihood supervisor peskin ounce told they so goes in san francisco so goes in california and nationwide i believe in these comments we hope that ceqa process dealing projects that need to go forward is not the new normal but we can support the housing and development support our communities thank you. >> thank you. >> next speaker, please. >> good afternoon, supervisors i'm eric and we're in support 37 continuance we want to make sure that all our local laborers here in san francisco go jobs in san francisco and our youth in the area we're in favor of this continuance and work on those issues. >> thank you very much. >> next speaker, please. >> my name is lauren gary's i'm with the latino historical and cultural society you all received our letter all the points still hold i supports the continuance and hoping that is you move forward with the continuance that you will take note of detailed we laid in p there not only includes the workers but includes people that make us up the complex culture complexity of the mission calle quarto so i hope out not lose sight of that that is all i have to say and please review that letter thank you. >> thank you very much. >> next speaker, please. >> good afternoon my name is john i'm in support of the continuance i want to read one short paragraph this is a strong carpenters town they were established after the borders were changed the city and county of san francisco needs to decide if they want to be a union town or whether or not they want a blue color workforce. >> thank you. >> next speaker, please. >> good afternoon. my name is laura i'm here to support the continuance i think we'll get a better project my husband is a retired carpenters local 22 and i totally support the trades and i think that holding this off for a couple of more weeks will mean that all trade workers will have a better deal on the project thank you any member of the public that would like to comment? to the continuance of this project please come forward seeing none, public comment is closed. this item has been moved to continue for may 9, 2017 at 4:00 p.m. and seconded madam clerk madam clerk, please call the roll. >> commissioner london breed supervisor cohen supervisor farrell supervisor fewer supervisor kim supervisor peskin supervisor ronen supervisor safai ? not present supervisor safai absent supervisor sheehy supervisor tang supervisor yee there are 10 i's that will be continued to the meeting of may 9, 2017 at the 4:00 p.m. madam clerk call the special order 3:00 p.m. >> items 23 through 25 are the special order this hearing has been scheduled pursuant to a motion approved in 2016 for a hearing of persons interested in the determination of exemption from the environmental review under the california environmental quality act issued as a - by the planning department on july 2016 and approved by the planning commission on august 11th. >> providing an additional information and analysis regarding a location of 1515 south van ness avenue will result in the greater soviet in the eastern neighborhoods rezoning districts and ifrpt and item 24 to have the departments determinations this project is further exempt from environmental review under the community plan exemption and item 24 to reverse that determination. >> thank you before we precede i want to ask the members of the jury if you can exit the chamber quiet we have business to attend to and thank you very much for being here today supervisor ronen. >> yes. colleagues i'm extremely glad to say that the parties involved lennar i see calle quarto have reached a settlement and the process that withdrawn i feel that the outcome was incredibly positive for the community again, thank you loren our calle quarto doing the hard work to get there and with that i'd like to move to table. >> supervisor ronen made a motion to table item - sorry. >> can i read that. >> thank you. >> make a motion to file items 23, and 25 and i'm sorry 23 and 25 - and to approve item 24. >> okay. so supervisor ronen has made a motion to approve item 24 and table item 25. >> yeah. >> yes and it is seconded by supervisor peskin supervisor peskin i saw your hand like up for 3 minutes. >> you have said what the maker of the motion meant to say that is table 25. >> okay. and before i open up for public comment commenting you had comments. >> yes. i wanted to thank and acknowledge supervisor ronen office and previously supervisor campos for the work on this and want to recognize and acknowledge lennar for being the first to commit to 24 percent affordable housing and come mr. pickering with prop c even you've started your fire without up zoning that is a great commitment to the neighborhood and really demonstrating we can get working-class in the housing so thank you very much for doing that and thank you for your office and the community work in making sure we have a great project that all of us support. >> you're here. >> thank you any members of the public that want to provide public comment on this hearing related to this particular project mr. campbell. >> thank you board supervisor president london breed and members of the board good afternoon danny the representative for local one 04 and thank the folks with lennar working with the community and reaching out early to the san francisco building and construction trades council all the affiliates of the council that project is demonstrates with affordable housing meeting the requirements that supervisor kim just said the voters adapted along with the pdr says that the other community benefits that it's going to be be build 100 percent union meaning that all the youth men and women and the mists will have career pathways regardless of which craft they choose whether or not sheet metal workers or carpentry whatever will be afforded that opportunity thanks to lennar so we look forward to approving the item 24 that supervisor ronen suggested thank you. >> thank you. >> next speaker, please. >> iris a nurse 40 years to the mission senior and getting older everyday at those hearings on in front of 15, 2016 at the last board of supervisors hearing on 1515 south van ness avenue you voted for a third eir on the gentrification and on the mission and throughout the city some supervisors spoke about needing a sea change that will be 100 percent real affordable housing at the site creating a community of families for example, the families that were victims of fire an missions and 29 street a community of maturity aid with the senior on shot well instead of the urgently needed sea change question get the sea items 30 through 32. will continue with displacement and out regionally unaffordable housing i do appreciate the efforts of the supervisors to hammer out a compromise for more affordable housing units and relieved that people that are homeless will have an navigation center but on temporarily but can't accept the agreement in light of the despite need you see everyday on the streets of mission in addition lennar has a history ever hiring contractor that produce radioactive soil samples and violating and department of water & power people if la and vallejo and treasure island, bayview hunters point and the mission those actions should be reasons to reject lennar's proposal not to come up with a compromise i feel will contributed to the destruction of our neighborhoods thank you thank you >> next speaker, please. >> good afternoon, supervisors my name is eddie live on folsom street at the corner of 21st and folsom i live between the lennar and access project lived in district since 1992 and folsom for 12 years before i was evicted and ellis acted and been there 12 years opposed to the lennar project and opposed to this deal as iris mentioned the effects of this live project will be raise property values in the neighborhood that is an incentive for property owners to sell they're building where people live under 6 units these attendant will be evicted that may not happen immediately but bargain a shock to the city it happened to me twice and my neighbor across the street and a building one the last year ellis acted are a crisis in the city and this body is virtually done nothing to stop it so i'm opposed to this deal a maintained into a fund will not bow one building in the mission and in the meantime 6, wanted building will be flipped you're not southern california the 0 project by making a deal not see the million dollars and rather see the people on this board stand point and vote yes or no on the project that's what i rather see we see who your you're with the renters want the property values to stay or go down or stay with the property owners that profit off the loss of affordable housing i'm opposed to the project when it comes up in three weeks i'll be opposed to whatever that won those projects hurtsz the neighborhood i find it ironic in a day you supported the march with a day without immigrants you've lied to a neighborhood without - >> in such again tom gilberty i'm thinking of a need of the community basically maybe that's what the people of san francisco want is to help the needs and what we're seeing on the streets of the homeless seniors being sent away families sent away none in the local environmentalist being able to for the record a newly built home no great movement from a long time rental to a new places they can for the record and help the oldest landlord and the new landlord to spread the wealthy around the community keep the gentrification down and also help that community stay a community i was in this chamber when a few years ago when representatives of japantown came and said thank you for this little piece of legislation so we can hold on the remedy amenity of japantown we have chinatown, we have the mission and great cultural centers and the people that live there that made this to we need to be able to move people into the new housing from the locals zip codes and the community and the status of the city of san francisco i think we can do this if we just open up to thirty percent open market and especially, if it is thirty percent open market in this rental we want that rent-controlled we want those people to be part of community and have a chance instead of their rent increases or the common things that people can't afford that will in the city. >> thank >> next speaker, please. >> good afternoon corey smith on behalf of the housing coalition. thrilled to be supporting the highest privately financed affordable housing project in the history of san francisco this will help people coupled with neighborhood preference legislation low income and the tenant in the neighborhood that will get to live here the safety and that's really, really cool in my opinion i also want to point out that last year san francisco is the highest number of total highest marketing and generally building this has helped to lead to prices are down citywide and putting additional housing on the market helps to prevent displacement we're very, very supportive. >> thank you. >> any other members of the public would like to speak on this item seeing none, public comment is closed. and we'll be filed and on the item madam clerk to approve 24 and not approve or table item 25 please call the roll. >> supervisor president breed. >> supervisor cohen supervisor farrell supervisor fewer supervisor kim supervisor peskin supervisor ronen supervisor safai supervisor sheehy supervisor tang supervisor yee there are 11 i's. >> the motion to approve item 24 and table item 25 is approved unanimously madam clerk let's go to the items for adoptions without reference to committee. >> items 0 thirty through 32 are considered a single vote have an item severed colleagues those items sheriff mirkarimi without objection approved unanimously supervisor safai yes can we make a motion to rescind that supervisor safai has asked for a rescinding and colleagues without objection the vote has been rescinded to continue the folsom hearing to the meeting of may 9 at 4:00 p.m. and on the item colleagues, same house, same call? without objection the folsom street will be continued to the meeting of may 92017 at 4:00 p.m. madam clerk the in memoriams for for the imperative agenda. >> forget about that offered by supervisor yee a resolution declaring april to be phil choi day in the city and county of san francisco. >> supervisor yee would you like to make the motion for this particular imperative item. >> sure i'd like to make a motion to move this item. >> that it is purely commentary and the need for action has taken care of after the agenda was made public. >> that is because of the (laughter) you got you supervisor yee ceasing a second seconded by supervisor farrell without objection those finding with approved unanimously and on the specific item are there any public comment on this item? to provide public comment on the combefrts item and public comment is closed. same house, same call? without objection that item is approved unanimously madam clerk please read the memoriams will be adjourned in memory on behalf of supervisor peskin for the late ms. joan. >> all right. colleagues to the end of business today madam clerk, is there any additional business to come before this body? >> that concludes our business for today folks we're adjourned have a wonderful >> what if you could make a memorial that is more about information and you are never fixed and it can go wherever it wants to go? everyone who has donated to it could use it, host it, share it. >> for quite a great deal of team she was hired in 2005, she struggled with finding the correct and appropriate visual expression. >> it was a bench at one point. it was a darkened room at another point. but the theme always was a theme of how do we call people's attention to the issue of speci species extinction. >> many exhibits do make long detailed explanations about species decline and biology of birds and that is very useful for lots of purposes. but i think it is also important to try to pull at the strings inside people. >> missing is not just about specific extinct or endangered species. it is about absence and a more fundamental level of not knowing what we are losing and we need to link species loss to habitat loss and really focuses much on the habitat. >> of course the overall mission of the academy has to do with two really fundamental and important questions. one of which is the nature of life. how did we get here? the second is the challenge of sustainability. if we are here how are we going to find a way to stay? these questions resonated very strongly with maya. >> on average a species disappears every 20 minutes. this is the only media work that i have done. i might never do another one because i'm not a media artist per se but i have used the medium because it seemed to be the one that could allow me to convey the sounds and images here. memorials to me are different from artworks. they are artistic, but memorials have a function. >> it is a beautiful scupltural objective made with bronze and lined with red wood from water tanks in clear lake. that is the scupltural form that gives expression to maya's project. if you think about a cone or a bull horn, they are used to get the attention of the crowd, often to communicate an important message. this project has a very important message and it is about our earth and what we are losing and what we are missing and what we don't even know is gone. >> so, what is missing is starting with an idea of loss, but in a funny way the shape of this cone is, whether you want to call it like the r.c.a. victor dog, it is listen to the earth and what if we could create a portal that could look at the past, the present and the future? >> you can change what is then missing by changing the software, by changing what is projected and missing. so, missing isn't a static installation. it is an installation that is going to grow and change over time. and she has worked to bring all of this information together from laboratory after laboratory including, fortunately, our great fwroup of researche e-- g researchers at the california academy. >> this couldn't have been more site specific to this place and we think just visually in terms of its scupltural form it really holds its own against the architectural largest and grandeur of the building. it is an unusual compelling object. we think it will draw people out on the terrace, they will see the big cone and say what is that. then as they approach the cone tell hear these very unusual sounds that were obtained from the cornell orinthology lab. >> we have the largest recording of birds, mammals, frogs and insects and a huge library of videos. so this is an absolutely perfect opportunity for us to team up with a world renown, very creative inspirational artist and put the sounds and sights of the animals that we study into a brand-new context, a context that really allows people to appreciate an esthetic way of the idea that we might live in the world without these sounds or sites. >> in the scientific realm it is shifting baselines. we get used to less and less, diminished expectations of what it was. >> when i came along lobsters six feet long and oysters 12 inches within they days all the oyster beds in new york, manhattan, the harbor would clean the water. so, just getting people to wake up to what was just literally there 200 years ago, 150 years ago. you see the object and say what is that. you come out and hear these intriguing sounds, sounds like i have never heard in my life. and then you step closer and you almost have a very intimate experience. >> we could link to different institutions around the globe, maybe one per continent, maybe two or three in this country, then once they are all networked, they begin to communicate with one another and share information. in 2010 the website will launch, but it will be what you would call an informational website and then we are going to try to, by 2011, invite people to add a memory. so in a funny way the member rely grows and there is something organic about how this memorial begins to have legs so to speak. so we don't know quite where it will go but i promise to keep on it 10 years. my goal is to raise awareness and then either protect forests from being cut down or reforest in ways that promote biodiversity. >> biodiverse city often argued to be important for the world's human populations because all of the medicinal plants and uses that we can put to it and fiber that it gives us and food that it gives us. while these are vital and important and worth literally hundreds of billions of dollars, the part that we also have to be able to communicate is the more spiritual sense of how important it is that we get to live side by side with all of these forms that have three billion years of history behind them and how tragic it would be not commercially and not in a utilitarian way but an emotio l emotional, psychological, spiritual way if we watch them one by one disappear. >> this is sort of a merger between art and science and advocacy in a funny way getting people to wake unand realize what is going on -- wake up and realize what is going on. so it is a memborial trying to get us to interpret history and look to the past. they have always been about lacking at the past so we proceed forward and maybe don't commit the same mistakes. >> the office of controllers whistle blower program is how city employees and recipient sound the alarm an fraud address wait in city government charitable complaints results in investigation that improves the efficiency of city government that. >> you can below the what if anything, by assess though the club program website arrest call 4147 or 311 and stating you wishing to file and complaint point controller's office the charitable program also accepts complaints by e-mail or 0 folk you can file a complaint or provide contact information seen by whistle blower investigates some examples of issues to be recorded to the whistle blower program face of misuse of city government money equipment supplies or materials exposure activities by city clez deficiencies the quality and delivery of city government services waste and inefficient government practices when you submit a complaint to the charitable online complaint form you'll receive a unique tracking number that inturgz to detector or determine in investigators need additional information by law the city employee that provide information to the whistle blower program are protected and an employer may not retaliate against an employee that is a whistle blower any employee that retaliates against another that employee is subjected up to including submittal employees that retaliate will personal be liable please visit the sf ethics.org and information on reporting retaliation that when fraud is loudly to continue it jeopardizes the level of service that city government can provide in you hear or see any dishelicopter behavior boy an employee please report it to say whistle blower program more information and the whistle blower protections please seek www. >> welcome to the regular scheduled san francisco ethics commission. i will call the roll call. chiu here, renne here,

Related Keywords

New York , United States , Mission District , California , City College , Washington , Hetch Hetchy Reservoir , China , Bayview , Russia , Mississippi , London , City Of , United Kingdom , San Francisco , Mexico , Sacramento , Balboa Park , San Bruno Mountain State Park , Spain , Chicago , Illinois , Americans , America , Spanish , Chinese , Soviet , Russian , American , Hetch Hetchy , Willie Brown Jr , Francisco Latino , Caesar Chavez , Phil Choi , Eric Powell , Corey Smith , Jane Kim , Aaron Starr , Terry Carlson , Gavin Newsom , Phillip Choi , Andrew Yip , Joseph Bryan ,