There was a Imarsana.com/news/moment-of-sIlence'>Moment Of SIlence at the Imarsana.com/news/unIted-natIons'>UnIted NatIons and If you want to carry on watchIng newsnIght, please turn over to bbc two, or watch on Iplayer. Next Its newsnIght. As Israel Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>Marks one year sInce the Imarsana.com/news/hamas-assault'>Hamas Assault on Its people, Its enemIes stIll want to destroy Israel, and Israel Is stIll tryIng to destroy Its enemIes. So how wIll these Imarsana.com/news/wars-end'>Wars End . Good evenIng, welcome to newsnIght. A year on from hamas� s kIllIng of 1,200 people In southern Israel and the capture of over 251 hostages, Israel fInds Itself fIghtIng wars on multIple fronts. Rockets have just been fIred towards tel avIv, whIch has been Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>MarkIng one year sInce the Imarsana.com/news/hamas-attack'>Hamas Attacks of Imarsana.com/news/october-7th'>October 7th. The bbc� s team took cover as Imarsana.com/news/Israels-defence'>Israels Defence systems swung Into actIon. Its belIeved thIs latest attack came from lebanon. MIllIons of people across central Israel would have rushed to shelters. TonIght, the IsraelIImarsana.com/news/defense-force'>Defense Force says Its fIghterjets launched mIssIles at hezbollah� s Imarsana.com/news/IntellIgence-headquarters'>IntellIgence Headquarters In beIrut. The day Itself has been Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>Marked by Imarsana.com/news/commemoratIon-ceremonIes'>CommemoratIon CeremonIes In Israel and across the world. Israel Is grIevIng, stIll, and prayIng for the return of the remaInIng 97 people stIll beIng held by hamas, desIgnated as a Imarsana.com/news/terrorIst-group'>TerrorIst Group by several governments IncludIng the uk. TonIght were goIng to reflect on some of the events of today and also ask how does Israel and Its allIes try and end these wars . Plus well hear from a palestInIan Imarsana.com/news/journalIst-and-mother'>JournalIst And Mother of two who weve spoken to on the programme before, forced from her home In gaza, where almost 42,000 people have been kIlled by Israels troops, accordIng to the hamas run Imarsana.com/news/health-mInIstry'>Health MInIstry. Here wIth us tonIght, Imarsana.com/news/sIr-Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>Mark-lyall'>SIr Mark Lyall grant, the Imarsana.com/news/uk-ambassador'>Uk Ambassador to the un from 2009 to 2015 and uks natIonal Imarsana.com/news/securIty-advIser'>SecurIty AdvIser 2015 to 2017. NomIImarsana.com/news/bar-yaacov'>Bar Yaacov from the Imarsana.com/news/foreIgn-affaIrs'>ForeIgn AffaIrs thInk Imarsana.com/news/tank-chatham-house'>Tank Chatham House and who works as a peace negotIator. Dr hassanjabareen, dIrector of adalah, a palestInIan human Imarsana.com/news/rIghts-organaIsatIon'>RIghts OrganaIsatIon In Israel. And dame louIse ellman, honorary presIdent of the jewIsh labour movement. Welcome to all of you, Imarsana.com/news/thank-you'>Thank You for beIng wIth us tonIght. FIrst, though, were goIng to speak to sharone lIfschItz. Her Imarsana.com/news/mother-and-father'>Mother And Father were taken hostage by hamas a year ago. Her mum was released on Imarsana.com/news/october-24th'>October 24th last year, her dad Is somewhere In gaza stIll. Thank you for talkIng to us agaIn, sharone. I wont ask you fIrst of all, how have you been Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>MarkIng today . I want to ask you. I have you been Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>MarkIng today . I want to ask you. Want to ask you. I flew In and arrIved thIs want to ask you. I flew In and arrIved thIs mornIng want to ask you. I flew In and arrIved thIs mornIng and want to ask you. I flew In andj arrIved thIs mornIng and then want to ask you. I flew In and arrIved thIs mornIng and then drove wIth a couple frIends Imarsana.com/news/up-north'>Up North to the commemoratIon of a Imarsana.com/news/daughter-and-mother'>Daughter And Mother of one of my best frIends who was murdered, the daughter was 13 and the mother, they were murdered In the grandmothers home, shot whIle they were embracIng. So we Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>Mark that and then I came back and pIcked up Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mum and we went to the servIce for the murdered 56 people from my communIty, we dId a small servIce, personal, IntImate servIce forthe servIce, personal, IntImate servIce for the kIbbutz and then I came back to Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mums. You for the kIbbutz and then I came back to Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mum for the kIbbutz and then I came back to Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mums to Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mums. You wIll know that tonIuht, to Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mums. You wIll know that tonIght. Mr to Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mums. You wIll know that tonIght, Imarsana.com/news/mr-netanyahu'>Mr Netanyahu to Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mums. You wIll know that tonIght, Imarsana.com/news/mr-netanyahu'>Mr Netanyahu has to Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mums. You wIll know that l tonIght, Imarsana.com/news/mr-netanyahu'>Mr Netanyahu has spoken to Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mums. You wIll know that tonIght, Imarsana.com/news/mr-netanyahu'>Mr Netanyahu has spoken of hIs determInatIon to brIng the remaInIng hostages home, IncludIng yourfather. I wonder remaInIng hostages home, IncludIng your father. I wonder If you thInk the wIdenIng of the conflIct wIll brIng your dad home any sooner. I certaInly do not. I thInk that If I was a hostage and I was sIttIng In a tunnel somewhere underneath Imarsana.com/news/khan-younIs'>Khan YounIs or gaza cIty, I would be petrIfIed of the prospect. My mum even was petrIfIed of soldIers comIng to try and rescue them. We know that quIte a few were murdered as a result of IsraelI army approachIng. Its only a deal that wIll brIng them back, that has not changed, but neIther has the deal come forward. And we are now facIng a year on, knowIng that the hostages are In dreadful condItIon. And feelIng a Imarsana.com/news/sense-of'>Sense Of despaIr and a Imarsana.com/news/sense-of'>Sense Of. FaIlure, Ifeela huge Imarsana.com/news/sense-of'>Sense Of. FaIlure, Ifeela huge Imarsana.com/news/sense-of'>Sense Of. FaIlure, Ifeela huge Imarsana.com/news/sense-of'>Sense Of faIlure. Sense of. FaIlure, I feel a huge Imarsana.com/news/sense-of'>Sense Of faIlure. Sense of. FaIlure, I feel a huge Imarsana.com/news/sense-of'>Sense Of faIlure. How much do you worry about Imarsana.com/news/sense-of'>Sense Of faIlure. How much do you worry about your Imarsana.com/news/sense-of'>Sense Of faIlure. How much do you worry about your father . Sense of faIlure. How much do you worry about your father . I Imarsana.com/news/sense-of'>Sense Of faIlure. How much do you worry about your father . I dont I worry about your father . I dont thInk ou worry about your father . I dont thInk you can worry about your father . I dont thInk you can worry worry about your father . I dont thInk you can worry any worry about your father . I dont thInk you can worry any more I worry about your father . I dont I thInk you can worry any more than worry about your father . I dont thInk you can worry any more than I worry could I absolutely worry for hIm, IfInd It hard to wIsh worry could I absolutely worry for hIm, I fInd It hard to wIsh for hIm, It has been a year and hIm, IfInd It hard to wIsh for hIm, It has been a year and I fInd hIm, IfInd It hard to wIsh for hIm, It has been a Imarsana.com/news/year-and-IfInd'>Year And IfInd It hard to not be able to console hIm. You know, I met today wIth many of the survIvors. We lost so many, so many of hIs frIends were murdered In the tunnels or were murdered on the 7th of october. Its very hard to tell them how we go on from here when they are In theIr Imarsana.com/news/70s-and-80s'>70s And 80s conduct there are the younger ones that I can see the future for but Its very exhaustIng for them. They have seen the ruInatIon of everythIng they worked for, both theIr communIty and the brIdges they have buIlt wIth the communItIes In gaza. � ,. ,. , gaza. And ust to remInd our audIence gaza. And just to remInd our audIence, because gaza. And just to remInd our audIence, because you gaza. And just to remInd our audIence, because you told l gaza. And just to remInd our. AudIence, because you told us gaza. And just to remInd our audIence, because you told us about the volunteerIng work your Imarsana.com/news/mum-and-dad'>Mum And Dad dId when you were on the programme last year, your parents volunteered for a charIty that helped palestInIans get medIcal treatment outsIde the gaza strIp. And I wonder what hope there Is any contact lIke that, any cooperatIon lIke that at some poInt In the future. I lIke that at some poInt In the future. ,. , , future. I lIsten to Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mum, she ust, future. I lIsten to Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mum, she just. You future. I lIsten to Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mum, she just. You know. Future. I lIsten to Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mum, she just, you know, she future. I lIsten to Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mum, she just, you know, she came future. I lIsten to Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mum, she just, you know, she came back| future. I lIsten to Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mum, she| just, you know, she came back a future. I lIsten to Imarsana.com/news/my-mum'>My Mum, she just, you know, she came back a year ago 17 days and In her last IntervIew In IsraelI medIa she spoke very bravely and saId she absolutely belIeved that only dIplomatIc agreement between us and our Imarsana.com/news/neIghbours-cancer-core'>NeIghbours Cancer Core future for All Of Us. Can secure a future. She also saId that we have made peace wIth the germans after the second Imarsana.com/news/world-war'>World War and we have no choIce but to reach agreements. It Is a long road, we have seen Immense cruelty towards our people and I took It as a member of Imarsana.com/news/kIbbutz-nIr-oz'>KIbbutz NIr Oz, as a chIld of that kIbbutz. We have seen what happens when a total valtterI and regIme take over socIety and the level of Imarsana.com/news/cruelty-and-torture'>Cruelty And Torture that hamas and cIvIlIans showed the people of Imarsana.com/news/kIbbutz-nIr-oz'>KIbbutz NIr Oz were on that day, Its very hard to reconcIle It wIth wIsh for a good neIghbour a totalItarIan regIme. But both socIety have separate tremendously, you see the destroyed houses of the vIllages across, both our communItIes are destroyed and we need have prayed and true leaders that wIll lead us away from the Imarsana.com/news/path-of-destructIon'>Path Of DestructIon and towards a Imarsana.com/news/path-thatIs'>Path ThatIs of destructIon and towards a path that Is sustaInable for both natIons. There Is no alternatIve. Sharone, Imarsana.com/news/thank-you'>Thank You very much for talkIng to us thIs evenIng, we really apprecIate your tIme, Imarsana.com/news/thank-you'>Thank You. Sharone lIfschItz, whose father Is stIll beIng held In gaza. As I mentIoned a lIttle earlIer, almost 42,000 people have been kIlled by IsraleI troops In gaza and 96,000 have been wounded sInce Imarsana.com/news/october-7th'>October 7th, accordIng to the hamas run Imarsana.com/news/health-mInIstry'>Health MInIstry. The un says 70,000 Imarsana.com/news/homes-'>Homes have been destroyed. Lebanons Imarsana.com/news/health-mInIstry'>Health MInIstry say 2,000 people have been kIlled In lebanon. The government there say over Imarsana.com/news/a-mIllIon'>A MIllIon have been forced from theIr Imarsana.com/news/homes-'>Homes. 60,000 people have been forced from theIr Imarsana.com/news/homes-'>Homes In the north of Israel, accordIng to the IsraelI government. Today us presIdent Imarsana.com/news/joe-bIden'>Joe BIden says far too many cIvIlIans have suffered far too much sInce what he called the Imarsana.com/news/unspeakable-brutalIty'>Unspeakable BrutalIty of Imarsana.com/news/hamas-attack'>Hamas Attack. LouIse ellman, tell us what you are reflectIng on one year on. I louIse ellman, tell us what you are reflectIng on one year on. ReflectIng on one year on. I vIsIted wIth labour reflectIng on one year on. I vIsIted wIth Imarsana.com/news/labour-frIends'>Labour FrIends reflectIng on one year on. I vIsIted wIth Imarsana.com/news/labour-frIends'>Labour FrIends of reflectIng on one year on. I vIsIted wIth Imarsana.com/news/labour-frIends'>Labour FrIends of Israel reflectIng on one year on. I vIsIted | wIth Imarsana.com/news/labour-frIends'>Labour FrIends of Israel before the massacres took place and I vIsIted a peaceful place, where people lIvIng there were frIendly wIth the palestInIan neIghbours and sought peace. When I went there agaIn a few months later Injanuary, I saw a very dIfferent place, burned out buIldIngs, horrendous sItuatIons, photographs of young couples on the front door burned out houses where they had been burned alIve. A communIty destroyed. It was absolutely horrendous. And I thInk It Is very Important that pIece Is made but to do that, It requIres hamas to come to agreement wIth Israel, hamas to recognIse the state of Israel exIsts, and for Iran, whIch Is supportIng hamas and Indeed It has polemIcal In the north and the houthIIs In yemen, to be held back so that these places are not used as proxIes by Iran, who really has no Interest In the welfare of people In the regIon. Its a very broad pIcture and the answer of course Is eventually to have a Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State alongsIde Israel, but fIrst you have the hostages who have to be returned, the area has to be peaceful, gaza has to be run, by palestInIans but not the Imarsana.com/news/genocIdal-hamas'>GenocIdal Hamas so there are a lot of Issues to be addressed and Its very urgent that It happens. To be addressed and Its very urgent that It happens that It happens. NomIImarsana.com/news/bar-yaacov'>Bar Yaacov, how would that It happens. NomIImarsana.com/news/bar-yaacov'>Bar Yaacov, how would you that It happens. NomIImarsana.com/news/bar-yaacov'>Bar Yaacov, how would you say that It happens. NomIImarsana.com/news/bar-yaacov'>Bar Yaacov, how would you say Israel that It happens. NomIImarsana.com/news/bar-yaacov'>Bar Yaacov, how would you say Israel has that It happens. NomIImarsana.com/news/bar-yaacov'>Bar Yaacov, I how would you say Israel has changed sInce october seven . I how would you say Israel has changed sInce october seven . SInce october seven . I would say Israel Is In sInce october seven . I would say Israel Is In very sInce october seven . I would say Israel Is In very deep sInce october seven . I would say Israel Is In very deep trauma sInce october seven . I would say Israel Is In very deep trauma one | Israel Is In very deep trauma one Imarsana.com/news/year-Israel'>Year Israel Is In very deep trauma one year one. Israel Is In very deep trauma one year one. I Israel Is In very deep trauma one year one, I thInk the Imarsana.com/news/shock-and-horror'>Shock And Horror year one, I thInk the Imarsana.com/news/shock-and-horror'>Shock And Horror of year one, I thInk the Imarsana.com/news/shock-and-horror'>Shock And Horror of what happened stIll reverberates In socIety. Hamas Is stIll vowIng to try to elImInate the state. StIll vowIng to try to elImInate the state. As stIll vowIng to try to elImInate the state, as art hezbollah, and frankly. State, as art hezbollah, and frankly, as are Iran. We have just heard, frankly, as are Iran. We have just heard, Its frankly, as are Iran. We have just heard, Its not straIght forward. And I heard, Its not straIght forward. And I belIeve the only solutIon, lIke our and I belIeve the only solutIon, lIke our prevIous speakers lIke tImber lIke our prevIous speakers lIke tImber Is lIke our prevIous speakers lIke tImber Is to lIve Imarsana.com/news/sIde-by'>SIde By sIde In Imarsana.com/news/peace-tImber'>Peace TImber Is to lIve Imarsana.com/news/sIde-by'>SIde By sIde In peace but tImber Is to lIve Imarsana.com/news/sIde-by'>SIde By sIde In peace but a lot has to be worked out before peace but a lot has to be worked out before that peace but a lot has to be worked out before that. LIke Imarsana.com/news/sharone-lIfschIta'>Sharone LIfschIta before that. LIke sharone lIfschItz. RecognIsIng that Israel Is also lIfschItz. RecognIsIng that Israel Is also traumatIsed and Its not only Is also traumatIsed and Its not only the Is also traumatIsed and Its not only the gazans and lebanese who have taken, you know, just been. I mean, have taken, you know, just been. I mean. The have taken, you know, just been. I mean, the sheer numbers speak for themselves. Im not comparIng the numbers themselves. Im not comparIng the numbers Im not comparIng the scope of the numbers Im not comparIng the scope of the trauma but I thInk there has to be of the trauma but I thInk there has to be a of the trauma but I thInk there has to be a recognItIon that there Is a trauma to be a recognItIon that there Is a trauma on to be a recognItIon that there Is a trauma on both sIdes and has been a Imarsana.com/news/blIndness-trauma'>BlIndness Trauma on both sIdes and has been a blIndness on trauma on both sIdes and has been a blIndness on both sIdes. NeIther sIde has blIndness on both sIdes. NeIther sIde has been wantIng to see Imarsana.com/news/the-other'>The Other, sIde has been wantIng to see Imarsana.com/news/the-other'>The Other, each sIde supportIng of Its own and other, each sIde supportIng of Its own and If other, each sIde supportIng of Its own and If you watch IsraelI televIsIon, for example, the one hand televIsIon, for example, the one hand and televIsIon, for example, the one Imarsana.com/news/hand-and-aljazeera'>Hand And Aljazeera on Imarsana.com/news/the-other'>The Other, you see Imarsana.com/news/hand-and-aljazeera'>Hand And Aljazeera on Imarsana.com/news/the-other'>The Other, you see two dIfferent narratIves takIng you see two dIfferent narratIves takIng place at the same tIme, neIther takIng place at the same tIme, neIther of takIng place at the same tIme, neIther of whIch refers to Imarsana.com/news/the-other'>The Other so I neIther of whIch refers to Imarsana.com/news/the-other'>The Other so I thInk neIther of whIch refers to Imarsana.com/news/the-other'>The Other so I thInk that Is a stage one but I agree so I thInk that Is a stage one but I agree that so I thInk that Is a stage one but I agree that the only way forward, there agree that the only way forward, there are agree that the only way forward, there are to make Imarsana.com/news/peace-plan'>Peace Plan Is on there are to make Imarsana.com/news/peace-plan'>Peace Plan Is on the table there are to make Imarsana.com/news/peace-plan'>Peace Plan Is on the table at there are to make Imarsana.com/news/peace-plan'>Peace Plan Is on the table at the moment, new and old Ideas, the table at the moment, new and old Ideas. One the table at the moment, new and old Ideas, one put forward the person who started the 2006 war, former IsraelI who started the 2006 war, former Imarsana.com/news/IsraelI-mInIster'>IsraelI MInIster had almost and former Imarsana.com/news/IsraelI-mInIster'>IsraelI MInIster had almost and former palestInIan foreIgn Imarsana.com/news/mInIster-nassar'>MInIster Nassar former palestInIan foreIgn Imarsana.com/news/mInIster-nassar'>MInIster Nassar kIdwell, who Is also yasser arafats nassar kIdwell, who Is also yasser Imarsana.com/news/arafats-nephew'>Arafats Nephew and both of them, serIous Imarsana.com/news/arafats-nephew'>Arafats Nephew and both of them, serIous experIence, not sprIng chIckens, serIous experIence, not sprIng chIckens, have both put forward a plan for chIckens, have both put forward a plan for peace. The plan Is there, the Imarsana.com/news/IsraelIs-plan'>IsraelIs Plan for peace. The plan Is there, the IsraelIs and palestInIans recognIsIng the mIstakes they have made recognIsIng the mIstakes they have made In recognIsIng the mIstakes they have made In the past, wIllIng or havIng put a made In the past, wIllIng or havIng put a plan made In the past, wIllIng or havIng put a plan forward, those applIances, one needs to have Imarsana.com/news/vIsIon-beyond'>VIsIon Beyond applIances, one needs to have Imarsana.com/news/vIsIon-beyond'>VIsIon Beyond the applIances, one needs to have Imarsana.com/news/vIsIon-beyond'>VIsIon Beyond the current government In Israel beyond the current government In Israel and beyond the current government In Israel and palestIne. Beyond the current government In Israeland palestIne. I dont beyond the current government In Israel and palestIne. I dont thInk much Israel and palestIne. I dont thInk much wIll Israel and palestIne. I dont thInk much wIll happen In terms of peace wIth the much wIll happen In terms of peace wIth the current IsraelI government. Who has wIth the current IsraelI government. Who has passed In the connectIcut that there who has passed In the connectIcut that there agaInst the Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State that there agaInst the Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State we that there agaInst the Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State. We need to plan for what comes state. We need to plan for what comes after In the connectIcut. But they cannot be peace untIl hamas recognIses that Israel has a rIght to stay as a jewIsh state. And the horrors of what happened now were launched a year ago when hamas launched a year ago when hamas launched Its genocIdal attack on IsraelI cIvIlIans, kIllIng, maImIng, rapIng, mutIlatIng, and huntIng down young people at a Imarsana.com/news/musIc-festIval'>MusIc FestIval before they murdered them and kIdnap them. The responsIbIlIty there Is hamass and I agree that peace Is to be made and Imarsana.com/news/It-takes-two'>It Takes Two partIes to fInd that and It has to be done but we must not forget how thIs was launched. ,. , � ~ we must not forget how thIs was l launched. The launched. No, I dont thInk. The horrors were launched. No, I dont thInk. The horrors were launched launched. No, I dont thInk. The horrors were launched by launched. No, I dont thInk. The horrors were launched by the horrors were launched by the Imarsana.com/news/terrorIst-organIsatIon'>TerrorIst OrganIsatIon. Let horrors were launched by the Imarsana.com/news/terrorIst-organIsatIon'>TerrorIst OrganIsatIon. Let me brIng In sIr mIke. TerrorIst organIsatIon. Let me brIng In sIr mIke, how Imarsana.com/news/terrorIst-organIsatIon'>TerrorIst OrganIsatIon. Let me brIng In sIr mIke, how do Imarsana.com/news/terrorIst-organIsatIon'>TerrorIst OrganIsatIon. Let me brIng In sIr mIke, how do you Imarsana.com/news/terrorIst-organIsatIon'>TerrorIst OrganIsatIon. Let me brIng In sIr mIke, how do you assess Imarsana.com/news/terrorIst-organIsatIon'>TerrorIst OrganIsatIon. Let me brIng In sIr mIke, how do you assess the | In sIr mIke, how do you assess the IsraelI response to october seven sIr Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>Mark. In IsraelI response to october seven sIr Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>Mark. ,. IsraelI response to october seven sIr Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>Mark. ,. , sIr Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>Mark. In the face of thIs horrIfIc and sIr Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>Mark. In the face of thIs horrIfIc and brutal sIr Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>Mark. In the face of thIs horrIfIc and brutal Imarsana.com/news/attack-I-sIr'>Attack I SIr Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>Mark. In the face of thIs horrIfIc and brutal attack by sIr Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>Mark. In the face of thIs horrIfIc and brutal attack by hamas It was horrIfIc and brutal attack by hamas It was InevItable horrIfIc and brutal attack by hamas It was InevItable Israel horrIfIc and brutal attack by hamas It was InevItable Israel would horrIfIc and brutal attack by hamas It was InevItable Israel would react| It was InevItable Israel would react very strongly It was InevItable Israel would react very strongly mIlItarIly It was InevItable Israel would react very strongly mIlItarIly agaInst very strongly mIlItarIly agaInst gaza very strongly mIlItarIly agaInst gaza I very strongly mIlItarIly agaInst Imarsana.com/news/gaza-IthInk'>Gaza IthInk very strongly mIlItarIly agaInst gaza. I thInk what very strongly mIlItarIly agaInst gaza. I thInk what was very strongly mIlItarIly agaInst gaza. I thInk what was less. Gaza. I thInk what was less predIctable gaza. I thInk what was less predIctable was gaza. I thInk what was less predIctable was the gaza. I thInk what was less predIctable was the prIme I gaza. I thInk what was less predIctable was the prIme Imarsana.com/news/mInIster-netanyahu'>MInIster Netanyahu predIctable was the prIme Imarsana.com/news/mInIster-netanyahu'>MInIster Netanyahu would predIctable was the prIme Imarsana.com/news/mInIster-netanyahu'>MInIster Netanyahu would establIsh predIctable was the prIme Imarsana.com/news/mInIsterj-netanyahu'>MInIsterj Netanyahu would establIsh mIlItary Imarsana.com/news/oals-netanyahu'>Oals Netanyahu would establIsh Imarsana.com/news/mIlItary-goals'>MIlItary Goals rIght netanyahu would establIsh Imarsana.com/news/mIlItary-goals'>MIlItary Goals rIght at netanyahu would establIsh Imarsana.com/news/mIlItary-goals'>MIlItary Goals rIght at the netanyahu would establIsh Imarsana.com/news/mIlItary-goals'>MIlItary Goals rIght at the Imarsana.com/news/start-netanyahu'>Start Netanyahu would establIsh Imarsana.com/news/mIlItary-goals'>MIlItary Goals rIght at the start whIch goals rIght at the start whIch he has not goals rIght at the start whIch he has not been goals rIght at the start whIch he has not been able goals rIght at the start whIch he has not been able to goals rIght at the start whIch he has not been able to achIeve I goals rIght at the start whIch he I has not been able to achIeve after 12 months has not been able to achIeve after 12 months and has not been able to achIeve after 12 months and some has not been able to achIeve after 12 months and some of has not been able to achIeve after 12 months and some of whIch has not been able to achIeve afterl 12 months and some of whIch were unachIevable 12 months and some of whIch were unachIevable and 12 months and some of whIch were unachIevable and are 12 months and some of whIch were unachIevable and are unachIevablej unachIevable and are unachIevable wIthout unachIevable and are unachIevable wIthout allowIng unachIevable and are unachIevable wIthout allowIng a unachIevable and are unachIevable wIthout allowIng a polItIcal unachIevable and are unachIevable wIthout allowIng a polItIcal horIzon for the wIthout allowIng a polItIcal horIzon for the palestInIan wIthout allowIng a polItIcal horIzon for the palestInIan people. WIthout allowIng a polItIcal horIzon for the palestInIan people. So wIthout allowIng a polItIcal horIzon for the palestInIan people. So I for the palestInIan people. Sol thInk for the palestInIan people. Sol thInk we for the palestInIan people. Sol thInk we now for the palestInIan people. Sol thInk we now have for the palestInIan people. Sol thInk we now have a for the palestInIan people. Sol thInk we now have a wIdenIng I for the palestInIan people. So I thInk we now have a Imarsana.com/news/wIdenIng-crIsIs'>WIdenIng CrIsIs In the thInk we now have a Imarsana.com/news/wIdenIng-crIsIs'>WIdenIng CrIsIs In the regIon thInk we now have a Imarsana.com/news/wIdenIng-crIsIs'>WIdenIng CrIsIs In the regIon wIth thInk we now have a Imarsana.com/news/wIdenIng-crIsIs'>WIdenIng CrIsIs| In the regIon wIth hezbollah comIng In the regIon wIth hezbollah comIng In and In the regIon wIth hezbollah comIng In and Israel, predIctably, In and Israel, predIctably, Imarsana.com/news/retalIatIng-In'>RetalIatIng In and Israel, predIctably, retalIatIng very In and Israel, predIctably, retalIatIng very strongly. In and Israel, predIctably, retalIatIng very strongly agaInst them retalIatIng very strongly agaInst them and retalIatIng very strongly agaInst them. And these retalIatIng very strongly agaInst them. And these Imarsana.com/news/exchanges-retalIatIng'>Exchanges RetalIatIng very strongly agaInstl them. And these exchanges wIth retalIatIng very strongly agaInst them. And these exchanges wIth Iran, them. And these exchanges wIth Iran, the houthI them. And these exchanges wIth Iran, the houthIIs them. And these exchanges wIth Iran, the houthIIs In them. And these exchanges wIth Iran, the houthIIs In the them. And these exchanges wIth Iran, the houthIIs In the south. Them. And these exchanges wIth Iran, the houthIIs In the south. DespIte the houthIIs In the south. DespIte the houthIIs In the south. DespIte the fact the houthIIs In the south. DespIte the fact that the houthIIs In the south. DespIte the fact that Is the houthIIs In the south. DespIte the fact that Is relatIvely the houthIIs In the south. DespIte the fact that Is relatIvely huge the fact that Is relatIvely huge amount the fact that Is relatIvely huge Imarsana.com/news/amount-mIlItary'>Amount MIlItary the fact that Is relatIvely huge Imarsana.com/news/amount-mIlItary'>Amount MIlItary success the fact that Is relatIvely huge l Imarsana.com/news/amount-mIlItary'>Amount MIlItary success agaInst the fact that Is relatIvely huge Imarsana.com/news/amount-mIlItary'>Amount MIlItary success agaInst Its tradItIonal Imarsana.com/news/amount-mIlItary'>Amount MIlItary success agaInst Its tradItIonal enemIes, Imarsana.com/news/amount-mIlItary'>Amount MIlItary success agaInst Its tradItIonal enemIes, It Imarsana.com/news/amount-mIlItary'>Amount MIlItary success agaInst Its tradItIonal enemIes, It Is Imarsana.com/news/amount-mIlItary'>Amount MIlItary success agaInst Its tradItIonal enemIes, It Is not tradItIonal enemIes, It Is not makIng tradItIonal enemIes, It Is not makIng Israel tradItIonal enemIes, It Is not makIng Israel more tradItIonal enemIes, It Is not makIng Israel more secure. I tradItIonal enemIes, It Is not. MakIng Israel more secure. And tradItIonal enemIes, It Is not makIng Israel more secure. And It wIll not makIng Israel more secure. And It wIll not make makIng Israel more secure. And It wIll not make Israel makIng Israel more secure. And It wIll not make Israel more makIng Israel more secure. And It wIll not make Israel more secure. WIll not make Israel more secure untIl wIll not make Israel more secure untIl there wIll not make Israel more secure untIl there Is wIll not make Israel more secure untIl there Is a wIll not make Israel more secure untIl there Is a sustaInable wIll not make Israel more secure I untIl there Is a sustaInable process of negotIatIons untIl there Is a sustaInable process of negotIatIons whIch untIl there Is a sustaInable process of negotIatIons whIch leads untIl there Is a sustaInable process of negotIatIons whIch leads to untIl there Is a sustaInable process of negotIatIons whIch leads to at I of negotIatIons whIch leads to at least of negotIatIons whIch leads to at least gIves of negotIatIons whIch leads to at least gIves a of negotIatIons whIch leads to at least gIves a polItIcal of negotIatIons whIch leads to at least gIves a polItIcal horIzon of negotIatIons whIch leads to at least gIves a polItIcal horIzon for the palestInIans. Least gIves a polItIcal horIzon for the palestInIans. So least gIves a polItIcal horIzon for the palestInIans. So I least gIves a polItIcal horIzon for the palestInIans. So I worrIed I least gIves a polItIcal horIzon for. The palestInIans. So I worrIed thIs conflIct the palestInIans. So I worrIed thIs conflIct Is the palestInIans. So I worrIed thIs conflIct Isjust the palestInIans. So I worrIed thIs conflIct Is just establIshIng the palestInIans. So I worrIed thIs conflIct Is just establIshIng a conflIct Is just establIshIng a Imarsana.com/news/cycle-conflIct'>Cycle ConflIct Is just establIshIng a cycle of conflIct Is just establIshIng a cycle of Imarsana.com/news/vIolence-conflIct'>VIolence ConflIct Is just establIshIng a cycle of vIolence that conflIct Is just establIshIng a cycle of vIolence that wIll. ConflIct Is just establIshIng a cycle of vIolence that wIll goj conflIct Is just establIshIng a Imarsana.com/news/I-cycle'>I Cycle of vIolence that wIll go on IndefInItely. Cycle of vIolence that wIll go on IndefInItely, even cycle of vIolence that wIll go on IndefInItely, even If cycle of vIolence that wIll go on IndefInItely, even If there cycle of vIolence that wIll go on IndefInItely, even If there Is cycle of vIolence that wIll go on IndefInItely, even If there Is a l IndefInItely, even If there Is a shortterm IndefInItely, even If there Is a short Imarsana.com/news/term-truce'>Term Truce IndefInItely, even If there Is a short Imarsana.com/news/term-truce'>Term Truce whIch IndefInItely, even If there Is a short Imarsana.com/news/term-truce'>Term Truce whIch may IIndefInItely, even If there Is a I short Imarsana.com/news/term-truce'>Term Truce whIch may well happen, short Imarsana.com/news/term-truce'>Term Truce whIch may well happen, It short Imarsana.com/news/term-truce'>Term Truce whIch may well happen. It wIll short Imarsana.com/news/term-truce'>Term Truce whIch may well happen, Imarsana.com/news/It-wIlljust'>It WIlljust short Imarsana.com/news/term-truce'>Term Truce whIch may well happen, Imarsana.com/news/It-wIlljust'>It WIlljust happen short Imarsana.com/news/term-truce'>Term Truce whIch may well happen, Imarsana.com/news/It-wIlljust'>It WIlljust happen agaInj happen, Imarsana.com/news/It-wIlljust'>It WIlljust happen agaIn wIth the happen, Imarsana.com/news/It-wIlljust'>It WIlljust happen agaIn wIth the next happen, Imarsana.com/news/It-wIlljust'>It WIlljust happen agaIn wIth the next generatIon. Happen, Imarsana.com/news/It-wIlljust'>It WIlljust happen agaIn wIth the next generatIon. [5 happen, Imarsana.com/news/It-wIlljust'>It WIlljust happen agaIn wIth the next generatIon. WIth the next generatIon. Is that how you see wIth the next generatIon. Is that how you see It. WIth the next generatIon. Is that how you see It, that wIth the next generatIon. Is that how you see It, that there wIth the next generatIon. Is that how you see It, that there Is wIth the next generatIon. Is that how you see It, that there Is a l how you see It, that there Is a cycle of vIolence that wIll contInue . That already we are there. No one, of course. Already we are there. No one, of course, predIcts what wIll happen, although course, predIcts what wIll happen, although many analysts say and IncludIng although many analysts say and IncludIng the IsraelI left, that thIs longest occupatIon sInce the second Imarsana.com/news/world-war'>World War wIll brIng catastrophe for both sIdes, and thIs Is what happened. For the IsraelIs, they perceIve It as they have never had experIence sInce the holocaust as thIs had experIence sInce the holocaust as thIs experIence. For the palestInIans, they have never had experIence palestInIans, they have never had experIence lIke that, even the nakba. ExperIence lIke that, even the nakba, the Imarsana.com/news/kata-sthree'>Kata Sthree of the palestInIans, that compared to what happened palestInIans, that compared to what happened In 1948, cannot compare to the genocIde they are facIng In gaza the genocIde they are facIng In gaza. ,. The genocIde they are facIng In gaza. ,. , gaza. That Is what Is your assessment gaza. That Is what Is your assessment that gaza. That Is what Is your assessment that Is gaza. That Is what Is your assessment that Is goIng | gaza. That Is what Is your Imarsana.com/news/I-assessment'>I Assessment that Is goIng on, genocIde, as a human rIghts lawyerof course. Israel rejects the accusatIon. You have 10 of the populatIon of Imarsana.com/news/gaza-who'>Gaza Who you have 10 of the populatIon of Imarsana.com/news/gaza-who'>Gaza Who were kIlled or Injured or dIsappeared. Take uk. Uk, Imarsana.com/news/70-mIllIon'>70 MIllIon dIsappeared. Take uk. Uk, Imarsana.com/news/70-mIllIon'>70 MIllIon. ImagIne Imarsana.com/news/7-mIllIon'>7 MIllIon were kIlled. MIllIon. ImagIne Imarsana.com/news/7-mIllIon'>7 MIllIon were kIlled, Injured or dIsappeared. BesIde kIlled, Injured or dIsappeared. BesIde that, 70 of any buIldIng, any street besIde that, 70 of any buIldIng, any street on the earth was destroyed. ImagIne 70 of thIs country destroyed. ImagIne 70 of thIs country were destroyed. Can we see that thIs country were destroyed. Can we see that thIs Is country were destroyed. Can we see that thIs Is not Imarsana.com/news/genocIde-mIcro'>GenocIde MIcro can we that thIs Is not Imarsana.com/news/genocIde-mIcro'>GenocIde MIcro can we say that thIs Is not Imarsana.com/news/genocIde-mIcro'>GenocIde MIcro can we say that thIs Is not genocIde . So what amazed me on Imarsana.com/news/october-genocIde'>October GenocIde . So what amazed me on Imarsana.com/news/october-the-7th'>October The 7th or the war of october. October the 7th or the war of october, the response of the InternatIonal communIty. We thought that after InternatIonal communIty. We thought that after the holocaust, the never agaIn that after the holocaust, the never agaIn was that after the holocaust, the never agaIn was serIous never agaIn. But here we agaIn was serIous never agaIn. But here we see agaIn was serIous never agaIn. But here we see for the fIrst tIme In the hIstory, televIsed genocIde lIve. The hIstory, televIsed genocIde lIve. And the hIstory, televIsed genocIde lIve, and we see people are kIlled daIly lIve, and we see people are kIlled daIly. Today they are kIlled. It Is Israel defendIng daIly. Today they are kIlled. It Is Israel defendIng Itself. Today Israel defendIng Itself. Today they Israel defendIng Itself. Today they are Israel defendIng Itself. Today they are kIlled, IIsrael defendIng Itself. Today they are kIlled, tens and thousands, they are kIlled, and we dont thousands, they are kIlled, and we dont see thousands, they are kIlled, and we dont see them never agaIn In the world dont see them never agaIn In the world that dont see them never agaIn In the world that you have serIous response for that for that. However. We wIll for that. However. We wIll come back to you. I have to apprecIate the response of the youth I have to apprecIate the response of the youth In I have to apprecIate the response of the youth In the world, the unIversItIes, In the campuses. They are dIfferent than the state. They are dIfferent than the state. They are not are dIfferent than the state. They are not acceptIng genocIde. They are not acceptIng that theIr money goIng to our not acceptIng that theIr money goIng to our genocIde. Let to our genocIde. Let me brIng In louIse ellman, IfI let me brIng In louIse ellman, If I may. What Is happenIng Is horrendous, and many what Is happenIng Is horrendous, and many cIvIlIans what Is happenIng Is horrendous, and many cIvIlIans are what Is happenIng Is horrendous, and many cIvIlIans are dyIng, what Is happenIng Is horrendous, and many cIvIlIans are dyIng, but what Is happenIng Is horrendous, and many cIvIlIans are dyIng, but thIs many cIvIlIans are dyIng, but thIs Is not many cIvIlIans are dyIng, but thIs Is not genocIde. Many cIvIlIans are dyIng, but thIs Is not genocIde. It many cIvIlIans are dyIng, but thIs Is not genocIde. It Is many cIvIlIans are dyIng, but thIs Is not genocIde. It Is Israel Is not genocIde. It Is Israel defendIng Is not genocIde. It Is Israel defendIng Itself. Is not genocIde. It Is Israel defendIng Itself. It Is not genocIde. It Is Israel defendIng Itself. It Is Is not genocIde. It Is Israel| defendIng Itself. It Is Israel defendIng defendIng Itself. It Is Israel defendIng Itself defendIng Itself. It Is Israel defendIng Itself after defendIng Itself. It Is Israel defendIng Itself after a defendIng Itself. It Is Israel. DefendIng Itself after a horrIfIc attack defendIng Itself after a horrIfIc attack on defendIng Itself after a horrIfIc attack on Its defendIng Itself after a horrIfIc attack on Its cItIzens defendIng Itself after a horrIfIc attack on Its cItIzens In defendIng Itself after a horrIfIc attack on Its cItIzens In theIr I defendIng Itself after a horrIfIc Imarsana.com/news/I-attack'>I Attack on Its cItIzens In theIr own Imarsana.com/news/homes-'>Homes. Attack on Its cItIzens In theIr own Imarsana.com/news/homes-'>Homes. And attack on Its cItIzens In theIr own Imarsana.com/news/homes-'>Homes. And young attack on Its cItIzens In theIr own Imarsana.com/news/homes-'>Homes, and young people attack on Its cItIzens In theIr own Imarsana.com/news/homes-'>Homes, and young people at attack on Its cItIzens In theIr own Imarsana.com/news/homes-'>Homes, and young people at a Imarsana.com/news/I-attack'>I Attack on Its cItIzens In theIr own Imarsana.com/news/homes-'>Homes, and young people at a Imarsana.com/news/musIc-festIval'>MusIc FestIval. Homes, and young people at a Imarsana.com/news/musIc-festIval'>MusIc FestIval. And Imarsana.com/news/homes-'>Homes, and young people at a Imarsana.com/news/musIc-festIval'>MusIc FestIval, and after Imarsana.com/news/homes-'>Homes, and young people at a Imarsana.com/news/musIc-festIval'>MusIc FestIval, and after that Imarsana.com/news/homes-'>Homes, and young people at a Imarsana.com/news/musIc-festIval'>MusIc FestIval, and after that horrendous I festIval, and after that horrendous attack festIval, and after that horrendous attack from festIval, and after that horrendous attack from terrorIst festIval, and after that horrendous attack from Imarsana.com/news/terrorIst-organIsatIon'>TerrorIst OrganIsatIon. Attack from Imarsana.com/news/terrorIst-organIsatIon'>TerrorIst OrganIsatIon Imarsana.com/news/hamas-attack'>Hamas Attack from Imarsana.com/news/terrorIst-organIsatIon'>TerrorIst OrganIsatIon hamas stated attack from Imarsana.com/news/terrorIst-organIsatIon'>TerrorIst OrganIsatIon hamas stated through attack from Imarsana.com/news/terrorIst-organIsatIon'>TerrorIst OrganIsatIon hamas stated through Its attack from Imarsana.com/news/terrorIst-organIsatIon'>TerrorIst OrganIsatIon hamas stated through Its Imarsana.com/news/leaderl-attack'>Leaderl Attack from Imarsana.com/news/terrorIst-organIsatIon'>TerrorIst OrganIsatIon hamas stated through Its leader that they would hamas stated through Its leader that they would do hamas stated through Its leader that they would do thIs hamas stated through Its leader that they would do thIs agaIn hamas stated through Its leader that they would do thIs agaIn and hamas stated through Its leader that they would do thIs agaIn and agaIn I they would do thIs agaIn and agaIn and agaIn they would do thIs agaIn and agaIn and agaIn untIl they would do thIs agaIn and agaIn and agaIn untIl Israel they would do thIs agaIn and agaIn and agaIn untIl Israel no they would do thIs agaIn and agaIn and agaIn untIl Israel no longer and agaIn untIl Israel no longer exIsts and agaIn untIl Israel no longer exIsts Its and agaIn untIl Israel no longer exIsts. Its also and agaIn untIl Israel no longer exIsts. Its also the and agaIn untIl Israel no longer exIsts. Its also the case and agaIn untIl Israel no longer exIsts. Its also the case that I exIsts. Its also the case that hamas uses exIsts. Its also the case that hamas uses Its exIsts. Its also the case that hamas uses Its cItIzens exIsts. Its also the case that hamas uses Its cItIzens as I exIsts. Its also the case that hamas uses Its cItIzens as human shIelds. Hamas uses Its cItIzens as human shIelds. So hamas uses Its cItIzens as human shIelds, so InevItably, hamas uses Its cItIzens as human shIelds, so InevItably, many shIelds, so InevItably, many cIvIlIans shIelds, so InevItably, many cIvIlIans are shIelds, so InevItably, many cIvIlIans are beIng shIelds, so InevItably, many cIvIlIans are beIng kIlled,. ShIelds, so InevItably, manyl cIvIlIans are beIng kIlled, and shIelds, so InevItably, many cIvIlIans are beIng kIlled, and that Is deeply cIvIlIans are beIng kIlled, and that Is deeply dIstressIng, cIvIlIans are beIng kIlled, and that Is deeply dIstressIng, and cIvIlIans are beIng kIlled, and that Is deeply dIstressIng, and as cIvIlIans are beIng kIlled, and that Is deeply dIstressIng, and as soon as the Is deeply dIstressIng, and as soon as the fIghtIng Is deeply dIstressIng, and as soon as the fIghtIng ends Is deeply dIstressIng, and as soon as the fIghtIng ends wIth Is deeply dIstressIng, and as soon as the fIghtIng ends wIth a as the fIghtIng ends wIth a ceasefIre as the fIghtIng ends wIth a Imarsana.com/news/ceasefIre-agreement'>CeasefIre Agreement as the fIghtIng ends wIth a Imarsana.com/news/ceasefIre-agreement'>CeasefIre Agreement and I as the fIghtIng ends wIth a IImarsana.com/news/ceasefIre-agreement'>CeasefIre Agreement and the as the fIghtIng ends wIth a Imarsana.com/news/ceasefIre-agreement'>CeasefIre Agreement and the return of the Imarsana.com/news/ceasefIre-agreement'>CeasefIre Agreement and the return of the hostages. CeasefIre agreement and the return of the hostages, the Imarsana.com/news/ceasefIre-agreement'>CeasefIre Agreement and the return of the hostages, the better. CeasefIre agreement and the return of the hostages, the better. But. CeasefIre agreement and the return of the hostages, the better. But It. Of the hostages, the better. But It Is not of the hostages, the better. But It Is not the of the hostages, the better. But It Is not the holocaust of the hostages, the better. But It Is not the holocaust that of the hostages, the better. But It Is not the holocaust that you of the hostages, the better. But It Is not the holocaust that you are IIs not the holocaust that you are ImplyIng Is not the holocaust that you are ImplyIng IIs not the holocaust that you are ImplyIng Imarsana.com/news/IobIect-'>IobIect Is not the holocaust that you are ImplyIng. I object to Is not the holocaust that you are ImplyIng. I object to that Is not the holocaust that you are ImplyIng. I object to that very IImplyIng. I object to that very strongly. ImplyIng. I object to that very strongly. Andm ImplyIng. I object to that very strongly, and. ImplyIng. I object to that very strongly, and. ImplyIng. I object to that Imarsana.com/news/very-stronal'>Very Stronal , and. ,. , strongly, and. You can obect, but the world sees, strongly, and. You can object, but the world sees, InternatIonal the world sees, Imarsana.com/news/InternatIonal-human-rIghts'>InternatIonal Human RIghts the world sees, Imarsana.com/news/InternatIonal-human-rIghts'>InternatIonal Human RIghts organIsatIons, around the world. RIghts organIsatIons, around the world, they see It dIfferent than you world, they see It dIfferent than you the world, they see It dIfferent than you. The world sees a dIfferent value you. The world sees a dIfferent value the you. The world sees a dIfferent value. The campuses of unIversItIes, they see value. The campuses of unIversItIes, they see a value. The campuses of unIversItIes, they see a dIfferent venue, and I may add. They see a dIfferent venue, and I may add, thIs Is not the fIrst war between may add, thIs Is not the fIrst war between Israel and hamas, It Is a seven between Israel and hamas, It Is a seven. Between Israel and hamas, It Is a seven. , ,. , seven. Let me pause, because I want to brIne In seven. Let me pause, because I want to brIng In sIr seven. Let me pause, because I want to brIng In sIr Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>Mark. To brIng In sIr Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>Mark. You have to be lIke. Thank you have to be lIke. Thank you, doctor. | you have to be lIke. Thank you, doctor. You have to be lIke. Thank ou, doctor. , � ~ Imarsana.com/news/thank-you'>Thank You, doctor. I dont thInk we need to argue Imarsana.com/news/thank-you'>Thank You, doctor. I dont thInk we need to argue about Imarsana.com/news/thank-you'>Thank You, doctor. I dont thInk we need to argue about whether Imarsana.com/news/thank-you'>Thank You, doctor. I dont thInk we need to argue about whether It Imarsana.com/news/thank-you'>Thank You, doctor. I dont thInk we need to argue about whether It Is Imarsana.com/news/l-need'>L Need to argue about whether It Is genocIde. Percent of populatIon to be deleted, and you percent of populatIon to be deleted, and you accept that easIly . We have to study and you accept that easIly . We have to study the lessons of the second world to study the lessons of the second Imarsana.com/news/world-war'>World War. What are the lessons, If not to Imarsana.com/news/world-war'>World War. What are the lessons, If not to be~~ not to be. I not to be. I strongly object. LadIes I strongly object. LadIes and I strongly object. LadIes and gentlemen, you I strongly object. LadIes and gentlemen, you Imarsana.com/news/cant-speak'>Cant Speak over each other, because Imarsana.com/news/no-one'>No One can hear you If you do. Bear wIth me wIth me. I wIth me. | I strongly wIth me. I strongly object to wIth me. I strongly object to the statements you are I strongly object to the statements you are makIng. I strongly object to the statements you are makIng. Is I strongly object to the statements you are makIng, Is the I strongly object to the statements you are makIng, Is the horrendous| you are makIng, Is the horrendous sItuatIon~~ sItuatIon. I sItuatIon. | I agree wIth sItuatIon. I agree wIth you sItuatIon. I agree wIth you about. Two I agree wIth you about. Two states, Israel and palestIne, that Is two states, Israel and palestIne, that Is the two states, Israel and palestIne, that Is the way forward. That Is the way forward. You that Is the way forward. You know that Is the way forward. You know the that Is the way forward. | you know the dIfference that Is the way forward. You know the dIfference between that Is the way forward. You know the dIfference between Imarsana.com/news/me-and-you'>Me And You . You know the dIfference between Imarsana.com/news/me-and-you'>Me And You . I you know the dIfference between Imarsana.com/news/me-and-you'>Me And You . I accept the tragedy. That and you . I accept the tragedy. That It and you . I accept the tragedy. That It Is and you . I accept the tragedy. That It Is a and you . I accept the tragedy. That It Is a tragIc thIng that happened to the IsraelIs, and my students. Happened to the IsraelIs, and my students, some of theIr famIlIes, jewIsh students, some of theIr famIlIes, jewIsh students were vIctIms, and I sympathIse and I feel what they feel~ feel. 0k. Feel. Ok. I wIll IeeI. Ok. I wIll now brIng In sIr Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>Mark. Doctor hassan. ForgIve me. We dont have experIence sInce the holocaust we dont have experIence sInce the holocaust that people, 10 of people were kIlled wIthIn less than a year. We dont were kIlled wIthIn less than a year. We dont have thIs experIence. ArguIng we dont have thIs experIence. ArguIng about whether It Is genocIde or not Is really slIghtly besIde the poInt. I mean, a lot of human sufferIng Is happenIng, obvIously. The dIffIculty I have wIth the mIlItary response from Israel Is, It Is makIng Its enemIes pay a prIce, as netanyahu saId agaIn yesterday. That Is the language of retalIatIon, rather than deterrence, and I dont see all the sufferIng that Israel Is now ImposIng on Its enemIes Is makIng Israel any safer than It was. ThIs Is the problem. Its not actually a successful strategy. Its actually a successful strategy. Its a tactIcal approach by Israel whIch has been very successful mIlItarIly, partIcularly In the last few weeks agaInst hezbollah, but Is not achIevIng any strategIc aIm of makIng Israel safer. That Is the problem wIth where Israel Is goIng at the moment. We are goIng to come back to thIs, I promIse, Injust a we are goIng to come back to thIs, I promIse, Injusta moment. In gaza, Israel saId Its aIms were to destroy hamas and rescue Its hostages. It has massIvely degraded Imarsana.com/news/hamass-mIlItary'>Hamass MIlItary and governIng capabIlItIes, but at the cost of huge cIvIlIan casualtIes, and as we know, there are 97 hostages stIll beIng held captIve. Israel Isnt allowIng InternatIonal journalIsts from medIa organIsatIons, IncludIng the bbc, Independent access to gaza. Weve been speakIng to a palestInIan Imarsana.com/news/freelance-journalIst'>Freelance JournalIst and mum of two, ghada al oudah, who Is shelterIng In the Imarsana.com/news/deIr-al-balah-refugee-camp'>DeIr Al Balah Refugee Camp In the centre of the gaza strIp. Shes lost several members of her famIly. Ghada al oudah. A year on from Imarsana.com/news/october-7th'>October 7th, Israel has degraded hamas In Imarsana.com/news/gaza-and-hezbollah'>Gaza And Hezbollah In lebanon and there Is an attack on Iran to come, we are told. Does Israel have any Idea how Its goIng to end these wars . NomI, what do you thInk . Im not sure the IsraelI nomI, what do you thInk . Im not sure the IsraelI government nomI, what do you thInk . Im not sure the IsraelI government has I nomI, what do you thInk . Im not l sure the IsraelI government has any plan to sure the IsraelI government has any plan to end sure the IsraelI government has any plan to end these wars, but I thInk the people plan to end these wars, but I thInk the people who are In the. LIke the people who are In the. LIke sharone lIfshItz, lIke Hassan Jabareen lIke sharone lIfshItz, lIke Hassan Jabareen, lIke All Of Us on thIs panel jabareen, lIke All Of Us on thIs panel would lIke to see the war and, you have panel would lIke to see the war and, you have a panel would lIke to see the war and, you have a fantastIc plan by hIs roval you have a fantastIc plan by hIs royal hIghness the kIng of Imarsana.com/news/saudI-arabIa'>SaudI ArabIa royal hIghness the kIng of Imarsana.com/news/saudI-arabIa'>SaudI ArabIa and hIsjordanIan arabIa and hIs jordanIan counterpart. ArabIa and hIsjordanIan counterpart. 57 IslamIc and arab states counterpart. 57 IslamIc and arab states have put forward a plan offerIng states have put forward a plan offerIng Imarsana.com/news/normalIsatIon-and-securIty'>NormalIsatIon And SecurIty guarantees for Israel If Israel were to allow guarantees for Israel If Israel were to allow the palestInIans to realIse theIr rIght to allow the palestInIans to realIse theIr rIght to Imarsana.com/news/self-determInatIon'>Self DetermInatIon and establIshed an Independent sovereIgn and contIguous state alongsIde Israel, so the plan Is there. AlongsIde Israel, so the plan Is there. And alongsIde Israel, so the plan Is there, and the questIon Is, who Is goIng there, and the questIon Is, who Is goIng to there, and the questIon Is, who Is goIng to make sure that It Is Implemented . RIght. Can It happen under Imarsana.com/news/benjamIn-netanyahu'>BenjamIn Netanyahu . Neta nyahu . I netanyahu . I dont thInk so. If you thInk of the last 100 years, the closest we have come to some settlement of the Israel palestIne Issue was the oslo agreements. The two people who opposed the oslo agreements were Imarsana.com/news/hamas-sIde'>Hamas SIde and netanyahu on Imarsana.com/news/the-other'>The Other sIde, who was leader of the opposItIon. He has been very consIstent In hIs approach of opposIng any prospect of a Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State, but I dont thInk Israel wIll ever be fully secure wIthout an agreement, at least a polItIcal horIzon, for a Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State, so that Is probably goIng to need a change of government In Israel to brIng that about. How do these Imarsana.com/news/wars-end'>Wars End, do you thInk . I agree wIth what was saId here, and I agree wIth what was saId here, and IthInk I agree wIth what was saId here, and I thInk that I agree wIth what was saId here, and I thInk that thIs war Is dIfferent as a I thInk that thIs war Is dIfferent as a polItIcal moment, as a crItIcal moment as a polItIcal moment, as a crItIcal moment than In 1948 and 1967, In that there moment than In 1948 and 1967, In that there Is no vIctorIous sIde In thIs war. That there Is no vIctorIous sIde In thIs war, and there Is no defeated sIde thIs war, and there Is no defeated sIde both thIs war, and there Is no defeated sIde. Both destroy each other, and because sIde. Both destroy each other, and because both rely on that they can destroy because both rely on that they can destroy each other, I thInk that thIs war destroy each other, I thInk that thIs war must raIse a questIon of how to thIs war must raIse a questIon of how to lIve thIs war must raIse a questIon of how to lIve together, not how to kIll each how to lIve together, not how to kIll each other. And thIs mIlItarIstIc approach Is not the answer~ mIlItarIstIc approach Is not the answer. The IsraelI government stIll belIeves. Answer. The IsraelI government stIll belIeves, notjust netanyahu, before that, except the rubbIng government, all of those that, except the rubbIng government, all of those governments belIeve the mIlItarIstIc all of those governments belIeve the mIlItarIstIc approach Is the answer. The mIlItarIstIc approach Is the answer. The rabIn mIlItarIstIc approach Is the answer. The rabIn government. ThIs wIll show the rabIn government. ThIs wIll show that the rabIn government. ThIs wIll show that the mIlItarIstIc approach Is not show that the mIlItarIstIc approach Is not the show that the mIlItarIstIc approach Is not the answer for reachIng a solutIon Is not the answer for reachIng a solutIon, and It seems that wIthout an agreed solutIon, and It seems that wIthout an agreed solutIon by the partIes, It wont an agreed solutIon by the partIes, It wont reach a peace. Do It wont reach a peace. Do you It wont reach a peace. Do you agree wIth that, louIse . We need a ceasefIre now that Includes we need a ceasefIre now that Includes the we need a ceasefIre now that Includes the release we need a ceasefIre now that Includes the release of we need a ceasefIre now that Includes the release of the IIncludes the release of the hostages Includes the release of the hostages. That Includes the release of the hostages. That Is Includes the release of the hostages. That Is urgent. I Includes the release of the I hostages. That Is urgent. And Includes the release of the hostages. That Is urgent. And then a pathway hostages. That Is urgent. And then a pathway to hostages. That Is urgent. And then a pathway to peace hostages. That Is urgent. And then a Pathway To Peace Based hostages. That Is urgent. And then a Pathway To Peace Based on hostages. That Is urgent. And then a Pathway To Peace Based on a hostages. That Is urgent. And then a Pathway To Peace Based on a Imarsana.com/news/securel-pathway'>Securel Pathway to peace based on a secure Imarsana.com/news/Israel-pathway'>Israel Pathway to peace based on a secure Imarsana.com/news/Israel-and-pathway'>Israel And Pathway to peace based on a secure Israel and an Pathway To Peace Based on a secure Israel and an Independent Israel and an Independent palestInIan Israel and an Independent Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State, but Israel and an Independent. PalestInIan state, but there Israel and an Independent Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State, but there Is a long Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State, but there Is a long way Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State, but there Is a long way to Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State, but there Is a long way to go Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State, but there Is a long way to go to Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State, but there Is a long way to go to achIeve Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State, but there Is a long way to go to achIeve that, l Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State, but there Is a long way to go to achIeve that, and when long way to go to achIeve that, and when the long way to go to achIeve that, and when the prevIous long way to go to achIeve that, and when the prevIous dIscussIons long way to go to achIeve that, and when the prevIous dIscussIons andI when the prevIous dIscussIons and negotIatIons when the prevIous dIscussIons and negotIatIons were when the prevIous dIscussIons and negotIatIons were held when the prevIous dIscussIons and negotIatIons were held In when the prevIous dIscussIons and negotIatIons were held In the when the prevIous dIscussIons and| negotIatIons were held In the past, It was negotIatIons were held In the past, It was the negotIatIons were held In the past, It was the palestInIans negotIatIons were held In the past, It was the palestInIans who negotIatIons were held In the past, It was the palestInIans who walked | It was the palestInIans who walked away from It was the palestInIans who walked away from agreements It was the palestInIans who walked away from agreements that It was the palestInIans who walked away from agreements that Israel| It was the palestInIans who walked I away from agreements that Israel had made away from agreements that Israel had made for away from agreements that Israel had made for there away from agreements that Israel had made for there to away from agreements that Israel had made for there to be away from agreements that Israel had made for there to be a away from agreements that Israel had made for there to be a palestInIan made for there to be a Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State. Made for there to be a Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State. So made for there to be a Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State. So lets made for there to be a Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State, so lets hope made for there to be a Imarsana.com/news/palestInIan-state'>PalestInIan State, so lets hope that state, so lets hope that doesnt happen state, so lets hope that doesnt happen agaIn state, so lets hope that doesnt happenagaIn I state, so lets hope that doesnt happen agaIn. I thInk state, so lets hope that doesnt happen agaIn. I thInk It state, so lets hope that doesnt happen agaIn. I thInk It Is state, so lets hope that doesnt| happen agaIn. I thInk It Is urgent that progress happen agaIn. I thInk It Is urgent that progress Is happen agaIn. I thInk It Is urgent that progress Is made happen agaIn. I thInk It Is urgent. That progress Is made so, ceasefIre fIrst, that progress Is made so, ceasefIre fIrst. The that progress Is made so, ceasefIre fIrst, the release that progress Is made so, ceasefIre fIrst, the release of that progress Is made so, ceasefIre fIrst, the release of all that progress Is made so, ceasefIre fIrst, the release of all hostages. FIrst, the release of all hostages and a fIrst, the release of all hostages and a pathway fIrst, the release of all hostages and a pathway to fIrst, the release of all hostages and a pathway to peace fIrst, the release of all hostages and a Pathway To Peace BasedI fIrst, the release of all hostagesI and a Pathway To Peace Based on fIrst, the release of all hostages. And a Pathway To Peace Based on a secure and a Pathway To Peace Based on a secure Israel and a Pathway To Peace Based on a secure Israel and and a Pathway To Peace Based on a secure Israel and palestIne. Secure Israel and palestIne. How secure Israel and palestIne. How much secure Israel and palestIne. How much are secure Israel and palestIne. How much are we secure Israel and palestIne. How much are we waItIng I secure Israel and palestIne. | how much are we waItIng for secure Israel and palestIne. How much are we waItIng for the us electIon In November The 5th . Is that relevant to thIs now . ItrefoIl that relevant to thIs now . Well It Is very relevant that relevant to thIs now . Well It Is very relevant In that relevant to thIs now . Well It Is very relevant In terms that relevant to thIs now . Well It Is very relevant In terms of that relevant to thIs now . Well It Is very relevant In terms of the l Is very relevant In terms of the western response. It Is clear Israel Is goIng to respond mIlItarIly agaInst Iran before Imarsana.com/news/the-end'>The End of thIs month, In the next days and weeks. The amerIcans clearly want to effect cannot heavIly they respond and whether they hIt chemIcal sItes, nuclear sItes, etc, and of course, Imarsana.com/news/joe-bIden'>Joe BIden Is boxed In by the amerIcan electIons. It Is constraInIng hIs abIlIty to put pressure on Imarsana.com/news/benjamIn-netanyahu'>BenjamIn Netanyahu to have a ceasefIre, because every mInute that thIs war goes on, It probably helps Donald TrumpIs constraIned by the comIng electIons, undoubtedly, In terms of amerIcan polIcy. Very brIefly. About a your report, when there would about a your report, when there would how about a your report, when there would how Israel does not allow foreIgn would how Israel does not allow foreIgnjournalIsts Into would how Israel does not allow foreIgn journalIsts Into gaza. Would how Israel does not allow foreIgnjournalIsts Into gaza. There wIll be foreIgnjournalIsts Into gaza. There wIll be a foreIgnjournalIsts Into gaza. There wIll be a moment when journalIsts wIll be a moment when journalIsts wIll be wIll be a moment when journalIsts wIll be allowed Into gaza, and that wIll be allowed Into gaza, and that wIll expose the scene. It wIll be sImIlar. WIll expose the scene. It wIll be sImIlar, and sorry for comparIson, but the sImIlar, and sorry for comparIson, but the sItuatIon Is sImIlar, well people but the sItuatIon Is sImIlar, well people dIscovered what happened In the second Imarsana.com/news/world-war'>World War, and people were shot the second Imarsana.com/news/world-war'>World War, and people were shot from that, then the world there were shot from that, then the world there were were shot from that, then the world there were polItIcs Im Imarsana.com/news/caItrIona-perry'>CaItrIona Perry In washIngton. ThIs Is bbc world news amerIca. Israel Imarsana.com/news/mark-'>Marks the annIversary of the Imarsana.com/news/october-7th'>October 7th Imarsana.com/news/hamas-attack'>Hamas Attacks that kIlled more than 1,200 people. IsraelIImarsana.com/news/prIme-mInIster'>PrIme MInIster Imarsana.com/news/benjamIn-netanyahu'>BenjamIn Netanyahu vows to contInue fIghtIng even as regIonal tensIons flare, wIth Israel comIng under rocket fIre. In gaza, nearly 42,000 people have been kIlled sInce Israel began Its operatIon. Welcome to world news amerIca. Im caItr ona perry. IsraelIs have spent Imarsana.com/news/october-7th'>October 7th rememberIng the 1,200 who were kIlled one year ago to the day, as well as the many others who were abducted and later dIed In captIvIty. It was 6. 30am on Imarsana.com/news/october-7th'>October 7th, when fIghters from hamas and other