Doctrine or keep it. Chief Justice Roberts we hear argument first this morning ase 221219, relentless versus the department of commerce. Mr. Martinez. Oral argument of roman marti on behalf of the petitioners martinez mr. Chief e, and may it please the court for too long, chevron has distorted the judicial process and undermined statutory interpretation it should be overruled for three ass. First, chevron violates the constitution article iii empowers judges to what the law is. It requires them to interpret federal ates using their best and independent judgment. Chevron undermines that duty. It reallocates interpretive auory from courts to to adopt inferior agencycourts constructions that are issued fotical or policy reasons. In doing so, chevron blocks judges from serving as faithful agents of cong it mandates judicial bias and encourages agency overreach. And by removing key checks on executive power, it threatens individual liberty. Chevron allates the apa. The most straightforward
This is about two hours. The court squarely held us much just a few years following adoption of the amendment. The the president makes easy work of the case. It is undisputed the petitioners realize nothing from their stock investment. They were taxed not because they had income but because in 2017 they happened to own shares in a corporation. This is a tax on the ownership of property. Dispensing with the need for realization, the framers regarded this as the essential check on the power of congress to tax property. The government cannot identify a single thing congress could not tax its income under its position realization is unnecessary. Without realization there is no limiting principle. Accepting the government position on income would make a cap hash of the current law. Gateway definition of gross income asserts congresses taxing power under the 16th amendment through reaching all income from whatever source derived. If the government possession position in this case is right th
A Public Service along with these other television providers. Giving you a front row seat to democracy. The suprem court heard oral argunt on whether the consumer fincial Protection Bureaus ndg structure is unconstitutional. The case stems from thegencys payday lending role, the sixth rcuit court of appeals previously ruled against it prompting the federal government to appeal e decision to the supreme cot. The justices have through june 2024 to issue a ruling. We will hear argument this morning in case 22 448, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau versus the Community Financial services association. Mr. Cef justice and may it please the courtthe Circuit Decision in this case is the firs tim any court in our nations historyas held that congress vioted the appropriations clause by enacting a statute providing funding. Roviding funding. This court shouldphold the cfpbs funding statute because it is firmly gunded in constitutional text andn historical practice datin back to the founding. T
Leader for on aftermath Justice Scalias death. Again republican senator from maine. Heres what she said among other things. I thought it was a shame instead of honor his life and legacy and extend our condolences already where in a political fight. New Jersey Governor Chris Christie went a step further urging the committee to hold hearings. Governor christie said i believe absolute right thing to do is to have hearings. People cant vote up or down they choose the hearings should be held. There is no reason for them to not take on this nomination. Governor christie this right. Theres no reason for the Supreme Court nomination not to have a full hearing and a vote. Theres a resource or republicans not to give a nominee to the Supreme Court and the income hearing and a vote. All were saying is do your job. One Republican Congress and republican i repeat published an editorial in one of the largest newspapers in the entire state urging Republican Leaders to give president obamas nominee al
Privy Council hypocrisy - Trinidad and Tobago Newsday newsday.co.tt - get the latest breaking news, showbiz & celebrity photos, sport news & rumours, viral videos and top stories from newsday.co.tt Daily Mail and Mail on Sunday newspapers.