things going entirely or forever. judge jeanine: jack, look, i watched homeland and 4. at the end of the day, you have another government who is saying we have a guy in the united states who might be a terrorist. we need your hope. you go in and what does he say i m not a terrorist and then you call it a day. in. i don t take issue with terry. i have a lot of respect for terry. when you get a lead from a foreign government like this and let s say it was the russians and they tell you that this guy has not only coming into the country but may be joining underground groups you own this case. it is not the russians that own the case. we own the case. this guy is in our country. gentlemen thyes, the guidelineu to do certain amount of, the fbi acknowledged that they scrubbed his background. looked at internet traffic and the phone records. probably did the financial workup. at the end of the day you and i sitting across from the table.
unconstitutional and i don t believe we he have a true basis to do this. i say interrogate the heck out of this guy i disagree. as long as it takes but let s have a trial. jay is absolutely, correct. he can be he designated an enemy combatant and get as much entell against as we can from him. it is up to the president. the president is not going to do it. let s deal with the cards we have. that doesn t mean he should don t it. he should do it. judge jeanine: based upon the way the u.s. attorney has spoken we are going in under the public safety exception and charge him and once they charge him and the federal defender is jumping up and down trying to get permission to represent him it is clear that both are going to happen. we need to say to the world that our criminal justice system will take you down if you take americans down. i m proud of our system. he did take americans down and we don t know he if they are going to take him down. we have to get the intelligen
him. you are allowing the taliban and al-qaeda and the people that hate you and me and what we stand for and the people that we love in this country, there has to be and i think and i respect you and i love what you say all the time. there has to be some respect for the constitution and i know you fight every day for the constitution. peter judge jeanine: the issue is that the federal court convictions are many in the years since 9/11 and in the military tribunal very few and they have been subject to a lot of reversals. so michael is sullivan let me go to you. which way do we go. in do we want to be assured of a conviction that is longstanding or is it better to send a message and keep this guy under questioning for the next three and a half years like jose padilla? it doesn t have to be one versus the other. i would suggest that essentially you exhaust his enemy combatant status to get
points to a fundamental problem with thinking about mir randiesing. do we want a prosecution or an investigation to determine how deep the terrorist links might be and whether there were additional plans for terror activity. an awful load of weapons that the two possessed. the situation with the travel to russia. all miranda means and judge you know this, if there is a statement given by the defendant before he is mirandaizeed it may not be admissible. an evidencery point. affirmative defense to the admissibility of a piece of evidence. they already made statements to the person they carjacked saying they did this. i m not really wore relationshipped about prosecution here. this is a perfect example of when serious consideration should be he given to enemy combatant status and needs to be looked at seriously. judge jeanine: the obama administration has indicated they are going through the public safety exception but you all indications are that they want to prosecute this guy in
shut them dune. i talked to the ceo and he said we are not taking any chances at all. most companies said forget it everybody stay home. the lost money and needless to say we understand how you important the emotional and human toll is, that super cedes everything. it will take awhile to know the real cost of this. geraldo: in the double digit billions? where are do you figure? could very well be a billion plus. i would give it that at the moment because you also have major league sports that had to postpone two games. last night you had the red sox shotting down and saying no game. shut down fenway park because they hadn t caught the guy yet. you cannot take that chance. if you look at the gate receipts for rest so red sox ga sing isle home game $2.2 million in lost tickets. the fact is last night all of the bars and surrounding restaurants got hammered. the bruins game versus the pittsburgh penguins.