Watch live coverage of house rules tuesday at 11 00 a. M. Eastern on cspan3. Watch online at cspan. Org impeachment, or listen live with the cspan radio at. The fourth circle Circuit Court of appeals listened to arguments, which bars president s from receiving gifts from foreign governments while in office. The president illegally profited from dignitaries staying at the trump hotel. A threejudge Panel Previously found the district in maryland did not have standing to bring these lawsuits. The courts decision will determine whether the lawsuit can move forward. Oh yay, oh yay. The court is now sitting. God save the note states in the United States in this Honorable Court. The District Court committed multiple errors in refusing to dismiss this suit and plaintiffs can i ask you to speak up just a little bit . Bring the microphone a little closer if you can. And the plaintiffs are fundamentally mistaken in asserting that this court is powerless to correct any of those errors at this time
All of the judges below concluded that plaintiff s core mory is by eight ball and they had the merger theer of liability, promising liability on the alleged decision of attorney general ashcroft to merge the new york list of detainees which had not been fully vetted by the ins list and continue to hold until cleared policy for detainees on both lists. The liability does not attach here for at least three reasons. First, the bivins remedy should not be extended to National Security and immigration policy decisions by senior officials in the wake of the september 11th attacks. In the damage remedy is to be impose side for not congress to do so. The list merger theory suffers from the same pleading deficiencies that the court identified in it ball itself. Among other thing, there is an alternative and a list merger decision. Given the uncertainty about the status of detainees on the new york list, the list merger was undertaken to avoid the inadvertent or premature release of a dangerous