Half. Committee on the Judiciary Committee, United States house of representatives versus department of justice. U. S. Department of justice, mr. Letter counsel. Good morning your honor. May it please the court. This is a court denies the request for state and appeal for the opportunity to review the important questions of the day. The court denied that motion even though it is clear that once the grand jury secret issues are already close they cannot be undisclosed. The court denied that motion because effectively it was right on the merits. But as we explained that in her motion the District Court committed at least two serious errors of law in granting the request. Start with irreparable harm. It is the case that if we agreed with the District Court on the two prongs, the affable harm irreparable harm is not that important. I disagree. First, our contention in this case you thought we were would likely do this on the merits . What significance is it . I agree with you. In terms of t