He is very explicit about this. He says what is not now decided is whether these provisions could be upheld under the congress clause. That is not decided as well. What is clear is that bradleys favorite of the law comment reaches less far juridical he\\\ly that has been imagined. Bradley is preserving it in the context where republican administrations are making headway and are using the Voting Rights theory that he has already provided. This context, we are using 15th amendment exemption and federal elections law i am keeping this concept available. He is the one who first made available in 1874, and it was the klan lawyers who attacked his theory in 1876. This is his first chance since then to rearticulate it. It is vital to see newspapers sevis see this. Newspaper coverage sees this concept. I have given you an excerpt the tribune the black citizen enjoys everywhere the same clinical and civil rights they are calling the vote a civil right. The same political and civil rights under