negative examples that would result from this type of thing. jonathan that s like saying your motto needs to be fish baby fish, when we ve whale oil being used to power electricity. we ve got to advance somewhere. i agree with the carbon tax. you think carbon okay carbon isn t poison. i didn t say it was. this is the washington mentality. let s see what we can get in under the gun. christian, five seconds. yeah. i think we all agree that the timing is wrong, but jonathan, you are absolutely dead wrong, especially your being a market guy. you should recognize that the price of car done does not reflect its cost and the carbon tax is designed tho do that. but we shouldn t look at it as a big revenue raiser. we should look at it as a way to normalize the market and make it equitable. i want to stay on this environmental story because coming up, lights are still out