talking to the jury about that? i don t know a single thing about that. i know y all represented that to the court and i don t have any reason to doubt it. that s consistent with the data that the fbi did, the on star data? the on star i think the on star data and the telemetry data are different. you don t think they re consistent with one another? is that what you re telling the jury? i m not telling the jury anything about that. i think they re telling i think the on star data tells one gives you one set of information and the telemetry data gives you another set of information. you don t think they re consistent? i mean, you talked about it to this jury. i think we re struggling on what s a fairly simple point,
or for instance, if this was a civil trial and we found that on star data during the third or fourth week of trial, you wouldn t be able to use it because you re past deadlines. in a criminal case you are able to use it. you would agree that none of that was the fault of anyone on this side of the table, that gm initially responded they had nothing and then responded all of a sudden they did? i don t have an opinion. it s not anything i m intending to convey. you talked to the jury a lot of about that, but you know nothing about that particular part? you talked to the jury a lot about the gm data, but you re telling me you re unaware that gm responded to the request and said they didn t have that, but during the course of the trial said we found something and that s the reason it arrived late? you re saying you don t know anything about that after
investigating the facts of the case, yes. all right. you were involved in gathering less say telemetry data from automobiles, correct? telemetry data like you presented in this courtroom this week? yeah. you never did that? i ve never had a case specifically where the type data that ya ll have presented in this case that i ve used. i ve had data from automobiles. i ve had on star data, data from the black box. telemetry data? i don t believe i ve had one of those. but on star and black box data, correct? moore so the black box event reporter. mean times in a wreck, the event reporter will tell you things leading up to the wreck. sure. i ve been in numerous cases where those were involved. and you ve had cases where cell phone evidence was relevant
correct? the ups case i handled? yes. yes, sir. as part of that, developing those types of cases, you were involved in investigating the facts of the case, correct? yes. all right. you were involved in gathering data from automobiles, correct? data like you presented in this courtroom this week? yeah. you never did that? i never had a case specifically where the type data that y all presented in this case that i ve used. i ve had data from automobiles. from their computers? on star data, data from a black box, but on star and black box? more so the black box event
0 was doing it and i had that document prepared, handwritten in the neatest handwriting that i could make because a secretary other than mine, a paralegal other than mine was going to be the person who was going to put those that financial information into the final document. and that s the document that mark ball talked about that he found on my desk whenever it was that he found it. so that is what was going to be, if necessary, what was going to be used thursday. the jury has heard about testimony of you stealing client funds. did you do that? i did. did you steal or divert that fee away from the law firm? i did. how did you get in such a financial predicament that led you to steal money that wasn t yours? you know, i m not quite sure how i let myself get where i got. it came from i battled that addiction for so many years. i was spending so much money on pills. i got in a spot i couldn t what type of addiction are you referring to? my addiction is to opiate pain