Thank you mr. Chief justice and may i please the court. The basic prescription on automated calls to cell phones in the years that followed dave field the constitutionality in the content of natural restriction on the use of calling technologies consumers found particularly intrusive and annoying. Congress enacted the exception in 2015 did not introduce any constitutional infirmity into the statutory scheme that exception is limited to the category of calls that intrude less severely on Consumer Privacy than does the typical automated call into the countervailing interest in protecting. Theres been a good deal of back and forth about whether respondents challenge the exception or the general automated call restriction and in circumstances because therere isnt a right or wrong way. There is simply here we think both challenges could have been both but would fail. Id like to focus first on the challenge the respondent is asserting that is a challenge to the automated restriction into the
The boards social policy one meeting in which not a successful vote of the board to engage and special meeting in february which she was he present and in fact seconded the motion and voted in favor of the motion. Okay. Thank you i have in my votes different from that but. I think on the main point the intent is that ive actually made extra efforts to attend and be involved in that its an area that was per mixing i went with another person the kennedy are big advocates we were other n out in boston with the pension fund i was telling supervisor avalos it was disstressing to people hadnt step forwarded in the pension like new york and areas like that and gone to level two or three so i feel we need to find out why thats the case but i would vac advocate that i think its a good idea and again, you dont move forward rationally you need to have beneficial results you can take little steps and move forward and we couldnt be at the for front of that. Im hearing from staff you were not presen
Get to fuels would skyrocket or have great volatility in the market were seeing across the globe in o peck to the producers in the United States theres conflict moving on to when the prices change weve seen the prices of oil has gone down between 50 from 100 and seeing the market look you know a investments go down because of the vital in the market as 3rek9d it something we expect to continue for years to come forever moving forward so it didnt make Financial Sense that we pool you know our public dollars out of you know those industries that are looking at having very fluctuating types of returns so that to me was an important reason why looking forward were seeing take effect into the financial market. You and i talked about this as jeremy grant says those are depleting resources it is costing us more and more money its okay. When did areas are new and but as time goes on we wont have those resources in the future so i think that spending more time with him hes one of the best inves
Prices of oil has gone down between 50 from 100 and seeing the market look you know a investments go down because of the vital in the market as 3rek9d it something we expect to continue for years to come forever moving forward so it didnt make Financial Sense that we pool you know our public dollars out of you know those industries that are looking at having very fluctuating types of returns so that to me was an looking forward were seeing take effect into the financial market. You and i talked about this as jeremy grant says those are depleting resources it is costing us more and more money its okay. When did areas are new and but as time goes on we wont have those resources in the future so i think that spending more time with him hes one of the best investors and understanding how to do that we can take a leadership really in that id like to spend more time when i went with commissioner bridges out the Kennedy Compound for the conference they had 60 representatives from around the c
The market look you know a investments go down because of the vital in the market as 3rek9d it something we expect to continue for years to come forever moving forward so it didnt make Financial Sense that we pool you know our public dollars out of you know those industries that are looking at having very fluctuating types of returns so that to me was an important reason why looking forward were seeing take effect into the financial market. You and i talked about this as jeremy grant says those are depleting resources it is costing us more and more money its okay. When did areas are new and but as time goes on we wont have those resources in the future so i think that spending more time with him hes one of the best investors and understanding how to do that we can take a leadership really in that id like to spend more time when i went with commissioner bridges out the Kennedy Compound for the conference they had 60 representatives from around the country they said this is distressing p