they knew they would get sued and they knew this would likely be halted at least temporarily but that s not the point. the point is to give boyden will make biden off oil and enemy to play politics with. sandra: a lot of the small businesses remain very challenging all of this as well. abiding by so many restrictions on top of that, and vaccine mandates. senator marshall, robert marshall is saying not only is the mandate a highly inappropriate invasion of personal decisions of residents but it threatens to worsen the current labor shortage. he says this directive will impact tens of millions of americans and he says that warrants a review. do you agree? no. and i m not related to him by the way, i was the marshall there. in 1905 and my home state of massachusetts the supreme court made clear and set a precedent for what the constitution allows the federal government to do or not to do. of the time it was smallpox and now it s covid. technically unless you are discriminating against
his workers. he says this, says he will not enforce any vaccine mandates for department employees, describes himself as the last line of defense from tyrannical government overreach. harry? forget about it. who should decide these things, shannon? look, people would say there is another scientific view, but that is what government does. they have had the authority to do it for 100 years. the riverside sheriff, you know, he needs to resign, and it won t last. only if there is a revisiting of the entire sort of health and safety rubric in this country starting with smallpox, something like this can apply. the governor and the government has power to do it, full stop. shannon: lawsuits and states all across the country so i have to think some of us bubbles up in some way to the court because everybody continues to cite back to this 1905 case that seems pretty definitive on that situation more than a century later, facing this very deadly pandemic, i think those justices
natural protections provided by such antibodies and claims they can do their jobs protecting themselves, fellow daily health screenings, wearing masks, and quarantine. john, we have seen some success on this front, they have had covid, natural immunity, reports it is superior to vaccines in a number of studies. is it going to be a legal argument? what the fact that you mentioned it is important because i think what will happen is the legal system will have to reconsider these very old cases, from 1905, which is still the last time the supreme court allowed the states to mandatory mandatorily vaccine everybody, not just employees, but everyone in a state. that was for smallpox, which was much more avirulent, watch more communicable than covid-19. you didn t have this kind of scientific evidence you re
measure in virtually every study on the subject better than immunity conferred by the vaccine doesn t make any sense. i argue it is a violation of our equal protection rights. shannon: your case is ongoing and harmeet dhillon you have several cases. while that conversation is continuing and we have no discussion from the biden administration about natural immunity, bone, there new mandates. here is what you had to say about that, let s get one thing out of the way, they are not unconstitutional in supreme court upheld the decision with smallpox vaccination in 1905 case and routinely require all school-age children to receive long list of vaccines. harmeet dhillon that case over and over but wyatt does it not be part of the conversation? i can spend an hour telling you why it does not apply to the situation but one simple fact that he gets wrong is it was a
actually disincentives for not being vaccinated, you are seeing the vaccination rates rise. when you look at between now and april, all of them requiring vaccinations support numbers have been raeen rising. and the employers and schools that want to do this, legally they are on solid ground. all the courts say it is perfectly legal for employers to mandate vaccines. we ve done it for other vaccines, we ve done it back to 1905 for smallpox. we know how do it. we ll see how it ends up in court. personal choice and public health, they should be more compatible. several school districts in florida have openly defied governor desantis ban on mask mandates. and in iowa, a federal judge is allowing schools to require masks after governor reynolds tried to ban school districts from trying to issue mandates. arkansas, oklahoma, tennessee already have their bans on mask mandates struck down and texas