not exist in 1905. looking at it with that kind of ancient crack lens will not give a clear picture of what people s rights are today. so i applaud the lawsuit but my friend from law school todd wiki with a similar lawsuit in george mason. and the school back down and allowed him to teach without restrictions so i hope we see more challenges. shannon: doctor, quickly i want to get a comment from a story earlier which is the fact nurses are resigning in mass and other professionals also will so come i will not stand or a vaccine mandate and the staff is available for the surgeon in that area. quick comment on that? you don t persuade people or regain trust in the institution and public health by trying to force people s hands and very well educated, very experienced frontline health care workers like doctors and nurses, many reached out to me in recent weeks and received a flood of
was polio. nobody made up fake stories about how you shouldn t get your polio vaccine. in fact i think when i was in kindergarten or first grade we had to get a shot. we all go downstairs in roosevelt grade school in jane, wisconsin, to get a shot. you imagine the euphoria when you found out you could take a little sugar water with it and you didn t have to get a shot anymore. nobody said this was something the government couldn t do. it is simply made up. all the way back to 1905 in jackson versus massachusetts, the supreme court of this country has upheld the ability of government to protect the people through mandatory vaccinations if in fact that s what this was, and that isn t even what this is. right. because it was such a clear exchange here and, you know, we go where the evidence is, i would say credit to chris wallace for asking the factual question and putting this into the public record, people can
clearly the administration has had more trouble than they expected in convincing the vaccine reluctant to go ahead and get a shot, so i think what they decided to do is what david axle rod said is getting caught trying, that you re better off trying to do something sweeping to get this pandemic under control, even at the risk of court challenges from all these republican governors. chris: chuck, as our supreme court watcher, how strong do you think the president s case is that through osha, which says that it can establish emergency rules to make a safe work of place, that they have workplace, that they have the authority to do this? i have to say in the last week, i ve been reading up on the 1905 case of jacobson v massachusetts where came fringe, mass threw chew massachusetts was able to order an individual to get a vaccination for small pox. does the federal government and joe biden, do they have the authority to do this? well, that president is very
school. it can get our families back together again. it can get us traveling again. the motion that somehow the republican party has decided to demagogue this is truly extraordinary because they claim it s all about freedom. the reality is that freedom is always been balanced with responsibility. the united states supreme court back in 1905 balanced out what was the meaning of liberty. personal liberty didn t mean anything if we did it to destroy the community. yeah. i mean there go to is to try to
clearly the administration has had more trouble than they expected in convincing the vaccine reluctant to go ahead and get a shot, so i think what they decided to do is what david axle rod said is getting caught trying, that you re better off trying to do something sweeping to get this pandemic under control, even at the risk of court challenges from all these republican governors. chris: chuck, as our supreme court watcher, how strong do you think the president s case is that through osha, which says that it can establish emergency rules to make a safe work of place, that they have workplace, that they have the authority to do this? i have to say in the last week, i ve been reading up on the 1905 case of jacobson v massachusetts where came fringe, mass threw chew massachusetts was able to order an individual to get a vaccination for small pox. does the federal government and joe biden, do they have the authority to do this? well, that president is very