Transcripts For SFGTV Public Utilities Commission 51016 20160514

Commissioner courtney commissioner caen Department Commissioner kwon and commissioner caen will be arriving shortly. Thank you the approval of the minutes im hoping commissioners had a chance to review the minutes is there a 340gs to adopt the minutes. So moved madam chair second. Public comment on the minutes hearing none, emphasize. Opposed . Minutes are approved next item is general Public Comment i have a card from mr. Da costa. So commissioners in general reading the record act and focusing on our hydro electricity we now have a serious issue with pg e theyre going to raise your rates as they deem necessary and we need to express upon them which weve not had at commissioners meetings that hetch hetchy power belongs to the public which this is the hoodwinks took over we dont have the pressure on, on pg e linked in the rincon hill act as we use our water to flush our toilettes having no sense at this late date in 2016 using gray water if not for the older and newer buildings we dont seem to mind b that he we have an infinite water to flush our toilets so im making a few comments i come from a time i will not be able to come from fremont once in three or four months because i need to pace myself on other important things i do our city is going through difficult times weve had 66yearold woman and 4 young men fascinating because of the what is happening in the city it is tied to housing and registration, huge rent increases and some people are just using pg e as a cash cow what they can squeeze from sfpuc and thats left to the general manager and im cool what him he can eight and left to the commissioners, i know most of you all some of i know two well and will do the right thing san franciscans are suffering and basically what is happening in the late 5 years 50 thousand families have left San Francisco those are the ones that contributed to our neighborhoods the commissioners, i want you to do the right thing there are many that come here the other one is the money you can give them the money but do the right thing for the community thank you very much. Thank you next Public Comment please. Yes. Please thank you. And if you wouldnt mind introducing yourselves thank you for having me. This is my wife osha im here renting e representing 5 members we moved to there to San Francisco and here to express our option felt sale of sf water 3 parcels of land that is adjacent to our houses and the sale of those properties will case us harm their described as underutilized those are adjacent to our houses and neighbors weve actually been preempted to use this since 1956 as you can see in the letter we have permission to use the land and maintained it as a garden every sense then weve received no notification from sf water those land are proposed for sale we praerd heard from an Real Estate Agent no idea that was going to happen, in fact, an hetch hetchy pipeline pipe under the land and development was not possible land is advertised for sale to developers and for sale signs r on the loaned that is causing us inconvenient people are knock on the doors we understand sf water is selling several prompts throughout the bay area and were we not here to contest that but we not to point out those property for sale are unique in rental neighborhoods we have permission to use those as on more than 60 years those properties have been allowed to be used by us so were simply here to make the commission aware of the fact the sale of the land a lot directly handler several hourltd in our area and that the sale of those lands is really something we wish we had been informed and here to ask we be allowed to work out a lease or permit rather than having this land is really as you can see from the photos it integrate with our houses and integrated with our yards the prospective of having it solid in our backyard was shocking and concerning to us at the inn our communication with our Real Estate Department we havent goggles a response were here to ask you to consider taking the houses off the market and account a lease or on the arrangement rather than sold to developers. Ill reiterate that again, we know that the aide is trying to sell underutilized properties from the photos those Improvements Properties those are from our yard and literally integrated you cant tell the difference between our property and the sf property the same for all 6 houses. To the best of your knowledge this is has been loudly for 6 months and copies of the permits as well. Thank you i know this is not on our agenda so we cannot decide or respond at this time but i believe well be addressing it in closed session. Medical marijuana this matter is not calendar for closed session im sorry it is in the agendized we cant theyre aware of your issue but cant decide it at the meeting. Im sorry. The commission has the discretion to follow up from the general manager but we cant talk about it at the meeting not agenda decided. We appreciate we left our Contact Information well appreciate any followup. Great. Thank you very much. Thank you. Additional Public Comment general Public Comment . Next speaker, please. Oh, yes. Quibble im with renaissance success thank you to the commission for creating a process for community to really get engaged with the southeast possible renovation or move into a different location i think that is very fair process which creates a situation for the community to really make a discussion on what they want to do i appreciate it we are part of that process and im happy to see this kind of outreach and process going on. Thank you, thank you any other general Public Comment at this time . Next item, please. Item 56 is communications. So you all have communications in our packets questions or comments from the commissioners. I have a comment under 5 c the pg e rate changes it operationally is true it will not have an impact on San Francisco. This year she is. Good afternoon, commissioners barbara hale assistant general manager this statement was in respected to our customer basis will have an impact on pg e customers and businesses in San Francisco. Why wouldnt have an impact on ours. Because we are not paying pg e retail rates wears paying for services from pg e. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Any Public Comment on communications . Hearing none next item, please. Item 6 is other Commission Business and commissioners . I have something id like to bring up and stop me if 24 has gun discussed i went there the minutes and couldnt find but an issue of openly up our water shed lands on the peninsula i wanted to know where we were on that in the past it is brought before the commission or to the best of my knowledge was never was i was wondering where were we are and if well done that and i do have issues on that. So what we can do come back with an update i know that we have been working with a lot of stakeholders to get input supervisors and so well come back and give you an update only who is going on. Okay. Thank you. Thank you other Commission Business comments on Commission Business north america. The Advisory Committee resolution. Good afternoon. Good afternoon commissioner vietor i have a couple of concerns issues in the past and some of the members have been concerned were not hearing back a response from casey or the commission i know you guys are busy but something we wanted to address we passed the resolution one around Public Access and the lake merced property area the other one about the bam balance that was one thought we didnt have members of the public coming to the meeting but quite a few of the members spoke been the balboa reservoirs and una happy about it arresting on fueling more Affordable Housing so we brought a resolution we thought would be mitigate in the 50 percent more Affordable Housing we we wanted to make sure this was something that could be agreed on by everything as you may know this is as ken tense issue the critics that is true u thought that was middle ground with that, i want to insure this issue is addressed i dont believe the commission has an advantage but this parcel of land is so unique because close to city college tweezer making sure that San Francisco is affordable city college educates so some low income people and elevates them out of poverty and work with the universities the other thing that part of my presentation is part of the citizens Advisory Committee were supposed to represent the citizens and voices there are people will give comments why the resolution matters and take up something simple in the reservoir soon. Most of the time with the balboa process. Theyre having their cac meetings i believe next week month supervisor yee will bring the housing and the one person was stlul against the 50 percent fueling i guess it is okay. And a lot of people the other 3 people were for is that caused a lot of fruition for the people with Public Comment and talking about their concerns about the reservoir so i believe is it do you know what date and the second monday in june. Theyll talk about the housing issue we want to bring this to you now you guys are a headsup on what is happening you read the resolution we think that is similar to other issues in the past weve talked about buildings housing for mr. Johnson people amarching we thought that one hundred and 50 percent the Mayors Office of office of Economic Workforce Development is asking for too close to marketrate so if we have Harvard Universitys and then one hundred 50 percent ami we have the Housing Stock into our Affordable Housing percentage. Maybe you know michael and others can add from the puc prospective were not you know our responsibility is not to determine how much Affordable Housing we have the land that people are purposing for the best use so and cant put restrictions on the land it is reels whoever is developing it the folks that. Agreed. So im saying i saw your resolution but correct me if i am wrong it is that we really cant weigh in on that in appetite were supposed to get the maximum for rate years so i think that is the challenge, however, you can focus on the folks that were responsible for building it so. Let me sorry can i ask a question on that. I mean at a certain pointed well need to declare surplus property; correct . In order to move forward and so is that there a way to craft the resolution were not mandating or directing some language that the city is facing an affordability crisis and our mandate to maximize the dollars in return we hope that Affordable Housing could be maximum missed on the properties. You, you should look at the city City Attorney for that advise in essence your you know lowering the value i mean, i think that is a great cause and i think that people have opinions on it but by doing that one could say youre lessing the value your constraining what will be built but ill defer to norway reign oar. The cac said youll take up a similar resolution we hope to come out of that and not telling this to be cut off so right. Michael deputy general manager the citys depth is 70 percent we accept this project working with the community right now at 33 percent. Can not us. Not us but the Mayors Office of housing and Community Development they need to bring on the developer that actually will come up with a hard number of developing the site and determining how much into the site were talking about percentages no land on the number of units the site will be configured a lot of variables and the general manager kelly said well trying to protect our Department Property in return when it comes back comes to you for a final declaration of surpassed youll have a passage package and the residual value of the land in conjunction with whatever the percentage happens on this site a longer discussion reels were going down by the next big step actually, if our presentation is bringing on someone that dozen the hard numbers thirty and 50 and 100 percent percent what guess that from the puc prospective. We appreciate the macys a maximize Affordable Housing and to agreement the 33 3ers will be floor and that kind of report. Within the legal bounds of wasnt we can do. Again, the public process is continuing the Advisory Committee or the balboa reservoir our own Advisory Committee has weighed in on it, it is excellent and all of that making it a Better Process and the lead is the Mayors Office of housing will be the Mayors Office of housing and Community Development were there to support it. Thank you thank you, again i want to reiterate it is one of our resolutions the last time we had that many people talking about this the cleanpowersf we know were there anticipate hopefully e hoping weve pushing in the right track. Commissioner courtney. Madam chair. Certain with wensdz leadership we the cac is a valuable resource for us and you want to encourage not only the engagement of the public in these kinds of Public Meetings by talk about the time and effort that adds value and it moves policy i would ask that of its okay with the chair we get some more formal instruction from council to the general manager point with our fiduciaries obligations the value id like this City Attorney to guide us so we have an opportunity to address all the issues you guys very carefully deliberately put forward without those as our policy objectives but make sure we graduate against and violations two harry lanes point this is ill ask the chair to consider that. Norway reign. Ill i belive to talk about the challenges with the board of supervisors and the mayor in issuing the entitlements for development you will have a role not just in making the determination as to who the property is surplus to the needs of other utilities but in entering into angle inclusive invocation with the developer that will be selected bans proposals that is being developed there the builders Advisory Committee and in the rfp those perimeters about what a Successful Development could look like will be presented to the Development Community and the people will expedite with each other to meet the overarching aide goals for development and i know that is important to keep in mind with respect to Affordable Housing some of the Financial Support for that out of the land values and come from other Funding Sources i know that the Mayors Office of Economic Workforce Development is looking at these those other city financing tools and applying tax increment financing from the increased tax generating if the in any development to underwrite avenue, i do think that the there is a very robust public process and discussion and it is maybe premature for the commission to weigh in on what youre ultimately going to do because your vote will come after the rfp is out there and after the process is selected of proposed developers and then a Long Development process and Environmental Review so, anyway this will be the beginning ill be happy to provide you with confident legal advice what the perimeters are. Yeah. If you could please do that i think that will be that would be helpful and sooner or later i understand your actual opportunity to weigh in is doored and a lot of process and public process to get up to speed about our opportunities and limitations that would be helpful. Thank you, madam chair with respect to the two pieces that can you see me concern actually 3 the obligations we have the difference between 33 and 50 and im not inclined to sign off on that one hundred 50 percent ami we like that piece now were getting way out of our legacy at the same time what i hope weight get if council a draft that resolution that shows you us where the land mine exists; right . We want to encourage the continued engagement that is, i think a priority for all of us i want to see that piece included in our confidential advise related the drafting into the problem areas that way we still have that product. Uhhuh. Right and just to be clear it is important to not make for if this probation officer body that will be a Decision Making body on the project to not a look at by decisions before you have the benefit of the environmental analysis in the planning and zoning from the entities that have those charged responsibility. Thank you commissioner moran. You a maid 2 sounds like it was what with Public Utilities commission but if were part during the land splaus surplus a large role outside of ceqa kind of role we should have the opportunity to instruct the negotiationers if thats a part of is that kind of discussion if it is simply a two roles as far as declaring surplus with the environmental documents. We hope that will serve with the discussion and i know we have contentious issues no one is happy and not part of legislation because the Legal Affairs we are happy so meet in the middle were doing is a go job. Thank you commissioner caen. I want to interject it is premature i think that we should think about the fact this is out of our realm were not developers and i think we should carefully as we go forward think about the role that we should be playing in this is a thought and ill talk about the other discussion. Any other commissioner questions or comments any Public Comment on this item . Beth would you like to come up. How are you today . Good afternoon, commissioners im legislative aide to is supervisor avalos i know that our office and the commissioner appreciate the work and partners with the clean power so from the supervisor the balboa reservoirs at 17 that is acres bus plus or minus the largest land available to the city and for the new neighborhoods that serve the people of San Francisco that could a respond to our housing crisis the balboa revision in district 7 a citywide projection in size and uniqueness our office deeply appreciate the hard work of the imp Advisory Committee under wendys leadership and it is difficult to have the discussions about the balboa reservoirs resolution as part of the project should maximize the income for the lower residents we support the minimum of 50 percent Affordable Housing on that site the supervisor avalos urges the puc to support this resolution of having 50 to 100 percent Affordable Housing on the reservoirs as the puc work to advise in the San Francisco reservoirs the supervisor urges the puc for the transfer the reservoir in a way to support of the maximizing of Affordable Housing thank you. Thank you other Public Comment . Hello good afternoon, commissioners my name is charley a district 11 resident a ratepayer and people to demand the economic and development respect were a partner to the puc with the Community Development to the park id like to speak in support of puc resolution regarding the reservoir that is not only a puc asset but. Citywide resource i urge you to Pay Attention steward is it to make sure it meets the current and future rate payers those are the same rate payers in the midst of an unpreened housing crisis with a vast and increasing san franciscans from sfreel protecting and moderate and middleincome unfortunately puc is absent from the public dialogue regarding the future of the reservoir and a lot of mistrust by the Mayors Office of Economic Workforce Development oewd is pushing for a majority of luxury austin on this site and honestly the public process that has lasted over a year and a half weve seen after numerous testimony by Community Members over the last year and a half the housing perimeters have not changed one 3wi9 since a year nature ago we dont have much feedback theyve made clear to prioritize the prop k housing goals that passed overwhelmingly and the land that passed in november as the city we need to make Affordable Housing a take up proprietor and doing everything we can to support this we want to thank the cac for the leadership for the vote of the resolution and district 7 and district 11 will representatives the two areas that most immediately impacted by the balboa reservoirs so i urge you to take action to adopt the resolution of the cac again, because the public process unfortunately has not been that 0 moving in a way dialoguing the Community Impact and this says that 15 percent is affordable our goal to really see the maximum number of Affordable Housing and production machine that site we would like to see 100 percent as a public resource that matches the incomes from low to moderate income san franciscans the cac laid the ground work and want to make sure the public lands will achieve the Public Benefit thank you. Can i ask you a question about the tools your tracking you know wendy maybe but staff i know there is Affordable Housing bond measures and all kinds of impact fees and conversation an opportunity from our prospective to increase the affordability numbers. One of the additional measures that was passed the prop a Affordable Housing bond an unpreened bopped of 10 million i believe in Affordable Housing that speaks to the support from the Mayors Office to move forward Affordable Housing needs but weve also learned in the Mayors Office of housing that the majority of the funds are earmarks for projects underway now not in development 5 or 10 years down the road at the same time the projects are moving forward abused the political realm have been in place to move forward oewd didnt want an department in the project thats why theyre looking to maximize the marketrate this is in contradiction to the goal the city set to increase Affordable Housing production to the scale of the need of the housing crisis. Thank you for coming out really appreciate your thoughts on that. Additional any Public Comment on this item . Good morning ive been living in the city every time i go to the meetings you know they tell me the same thing about you know Getting Better you know, association to get a housing my kids been 5 years and the list were 8 and one house we got only one toilet and some is have to sleep in the front room and some certain places it is very hard i wish you would understand what were going through any family is going through i pay taxes i come for everything and im still every time i go to the meetings you know theyll say thag going to give us us something ive talked with the supervisors and no response my kids like i said theyve been on the list and not called i wish you would understand what were going through thank you. Thank you. Next comment please. Good afternoon. My name is a jessie fernandos with the people organizing with the environmental rights ive been working with the organization for just 3 months now and been imposed to the process of the balboa reservoir this is an inu unprecedented opportunity to provide Affordable Housing for a site that should be utilized for Public Benefit that means addressing the needs of people that are impacted by the housing crisis with the affordability and met frankly over and surpassed the requirements for marketrate pr the public process is the balboa reservoirs has been stymied by o s weve been despite Ongoing Community input and advises the perimeter have not changed at all going on for several months now and ive get little faith in the process Going Forward and as the opportunity closed the impacts rfp language i want to highlight documents i have to share that are coming from the council of Community Housing organizations that provide an independent analysis outlining how feasible to produce one hundred affordability at the site and another range of configurations for affordability this is founded and completely logical those are they represent 24 Nonprofit Developers and housing advocates and this is been met by just being pushed aside and i have those documents for you here id like to urge the commissioners to adopt the resolution pass by the puc, cac and highlight that theyve really been representative of the kind of engagement and dialogue it is necessary not been represented at the bayshore cac and thank you for your time. Thank you, very much. Next comment good afternoon. Im kevin were a 41yearold organizations in San Francisco working with children their patents and families around issues that impact their lives im here to ask to you port the Advisory Committee resolution regarding the balboa reservoirs were in a housing crisis and families cant afford to live in San Francisco im asking you to be leaders and stand up for the families on the edge of being pushed out im sure there is reflection of the best interests of the city and free market a lot of people can profit off of the development if not more Affordable Housing leads to a lot of community being pushed out and africanamericans are punched out for quite a while loose students that graduate from high school dont center the opportunity to stay in the courses but loophole be heroic and doing everything we can to promote the Affordable Housing for people in the sfgovtv. Org San Francisco that are on the verge of being displaced. Im getting uncomfortable at the risk of upsetting some people im going to remind folks that the obligations that we have up here to the rate payers we have the obligations we got into i feel this is more of a conversation that is supposed to take place in chambers across the way as it relates to the affordable crisis i dont want to get into my numbers and set aside so in light of that fact i know there is Public Comment we urge it but the tone went off of our mission and i think that was appropriate for me to say that so this is we do a lot of Community Work im just going to risk it and say i dont know this is the right forum i still think were heroic laughter and i think we stated well doing everything we can but i hope you guys understand why. Maybe what we can do is to understand and maybe ask the office of Economic Workforce Development to come and give us an update what have the are the conditions you have an idea and maybe 19 a chance to ask questions i think it ties to the value of property you know for example can you Affordable Housing than you have to get the land for free we need to know if that is what narrowing asking us so maybe it is good to have that conversation early and see what their plans are. That would be great. Then people can comment. If we could agendize this and have an understanding the perimeters legally and financially and hear from the Mayors Office on the timeline and the sequence of the events and how and where to weigh in that would be helpful. Im very motivated in terms of excusing of adopting the resolution everyone has been working hard at it at this time we do need to do our Due Diligence and have the expertise to make sure were not finding ours into something that binds our obligation to you wendy and our team and the folks around that issue that had is to be made clear at least from where im sitting im getting nervous about the dialogue. Thank you other Public Comments on this item. Hearing none, next item, please. Item 8 is report of general manager. So good afternoon my first item is actually exciting topic we have herb that has worked us with 3 seven years calling it a day. clapping. so in 5 years ill be there joining you laughter . So you know actually herb worked in the Treatment Plant and operations he served the city 3 seven years Outstanding Service and began his criteria in engineer as the department of Public Works Bureau of Water Pollution and control that became puc wastewater in 1996 i remember that very well so hes done extensive work in the maintenance and collection and consistently provided Excellent Customer Service and spent a lot of time mentoring a lot of folks in the agency and he has been an outstanding person and known you for a very long time well miss you at the puc you want to come up and say a few few words. Thank you and its been great ive been enjoying any retirement but ive been in bayview 3 off the of 4 days in the late 80s working with the planets so i want to remind people some people are out there and some people need to take our place im not leaving the Community Behind you work in berkley and it in bayview and will, working the permit chunk of time since ive retired in the last two weeks is there im not going to be a stranger thank you all and great not to be at will work at 6 00 a. M. clapping. before you go my great pleasure to present you with a certificate of honor in thanks for 3 seven years of axiliary work to promote environmental steward that benefits the San Francisco public works in the city and county of San Francisco thank you so much. clapping. thank you. clapping. item . Thank you. Next speaker, please. So the next update would be the contract update steve richie. Excuse me steve richie for water ill provide a drought update a summary and a couple of slides focusing on yesterday first on the storage level in the reservoirs theyre looking good not as high as we like but better than the last three or four years good shape were covering this weve been moving the water around and in good shape the precipitation is an uptick were continuing to get precipitation and definitely above 100 percent so good year in terms of perspiration and show pack we have there at the end were not as medium levels were well above the last foe years and in terms of our water available to the city in filling up the reservoirs we call the roll are at w68dz and 20 levels well anticipate be below the roirsz by 100 percent plus and totally that is an improvement over the last few years on the demand front we continue to be bow last years demand fluctuated with the weather it goes up and cooler months it drops down and the citywide demand is below any other demand weve been again going a great job of conservation now the interesting thing yesterdays the governor issued a executive order for the transitioned to permanent long term improvements by doing certain things the message is transitioning to permanent 4r0er7b89 improvements the governor is making clear the things that have outdoor to develop a more permanent atmosphere about the certain things we putdown into place and the other tile talk about latent finger print and the commercialism regulations taking into account the allegations and continuing the same conservation was not the budget finance best thing but sending them through january of 2017 that last part the governor made it clear hell not say were out of the drought this year might have been in some places but cant say were out of the drought he made it clear next week weigh look at that and the permanent pharynx for the 20 percent reduction by 2020 did message the existing legislation by plan for more conservation in the future and making the monthly reporting requirement for all departments a permanent activity what our usage and amount of conservation and the fofrtsd weve been monthly for the last two years but now a permanent fix terry it is your and. Number of those are mundane things but not calling them emergencies if you wash your car have a shut oval that should be a permanent thing and soda permanent prohibition the things that is pushing the envelope and direct actions the water shortage for the consistency plan that will be a big deal for people throughout the state the water storage is continued and it was put into effect didnt do the job and the public water should be requirements for those a lot of discussion between now and january of next year of what changes if any will be required for the shortage continuance and lastly updating the agricultural the soft requirement in the 2009 legislation the governor wants more requirements put into that no more teeth both that. Than the potential action on the modest actions on may 18th to extend the regulations to live 2017 and to provide for selfreliability and specifics that we should, using 3 additional years of drought if 2013 to 2015 and to the extension of 2020 were doing that analysis well be in good shape one of the things well convey to the state in comments that might be on indicator that is not how we plan for the future by more robust activities from the results should we run short of water in the 3 years that will be a commercialism into focus to zero water as or if you have another water to survive the next two years for a water manager thats not good enough well be having to do better than that well provide comments by the end of the friday and looking at the state board a week from wednesday ill be happy to answer any questions you may have. About where we at. So the week if wednesday is when theyll consider permanent. Extending the drought regulations. Saw in this article it talked about the interests of govern and making the cuts permanent so those are the water waste requirement and yeah. And the notion we should have a permanent framework for the 20 percent by 2020 a in a week theyll be voting no the prohibition is not going to happen right away but the Water Resources will be put together by january of 2020 for the next 6 months well be working with that. Yeah. So as i understand it each Water District will decide what the allocations should be. Yeah. Accepting it provides if you demonstrate to have enough water thats one of the good things you, you need to present that in a clear transparent way and make it available for people to side thats a good things but if you certificate certify if you have enough water whats our recommendation and we dont know the analysis well have the answer first but the answer will show we have enough water ill suggest at this point any recommendation is probably right now we should at least call for the continued 10 percent volunteer reduction system wide because we still have not fullness next year could be dry and assume next year well enter into not a good year and come back probably on may 24th or the first part of june for a recommendation. Sounds like youve that put this page in here san franciscans the folks have begun a tremendous job of conserving water people think in the long terms. Thank you. Great. The great thing is that weve been asking people to conserve last year and theyre cutting more than they did last year this year. Yeah. If they only would use as much as at the did last year that would be better laughter . Just one a couple of comments one id like to echo the comments of the commissioner weve done a fine job of conserving and our inthoerl consumers have done as well a reflection on the system and the other comment for a budget siementsz this year and part of the lesson range the water use continues to be low so to some degree we are already going down the path of long term reductions in water use. Yeah. Great, thank you. Next speaker, please. Clean power; right . Public comment. Public comment on the drought . All right. Next item, please. Is an update on cleanpowersf barbara hale. Thank you general manager barbara hale general manager for power i have two one quick item and one a little bit longer an update on the program and then innovative jason fried, executive officer inform lafco to brief you on the study he prepares in the packet by way of update your last reporter on the last Commission Meeting our cleanpowersf program is now serving consumers some the first time i get to say that yeah clapping. as of may 1st enforced customers we are cit over to cleanpowersf with in their meter read date our opt out is loans one percent we still are very seeing low opts out and issuing the two additionally statutory notifications to customers they may opt out of june we are getting to the point by the next meeting or the next meeting after that over one percent but way below the 20 weve projected we finally lists some additional power transactions this past week so resource accuracy are required and additional kilowatt hours were purposing the adequacy products from hetch hetchy and purchasing the energy if hetch hetchy so the hetch hetchy transaction is doing business as ourselves and Hunters Point is the seller and the total payments from cleanpowersf to hetch hetchy power is one hundred and 73 or 74,000 not the dollars that make it worthy mentioning process were moving to experiencing our ability to take advantage of the extra power that hetch hetchy has for the services to cleanpowersf were foreperson our standard paradises for sales to third partys hetch hetchy power is treating cleanpowersf as a third party were going though the practices and following the incur management policy we have turning to sign up activities for the august 1st deadline three hundred and four folks that preimplored theyve either prerolled by working with us to sign them up or going to cleanpowersf. Org this includes the bumper in signs ups over even though earth day we were participating in a lot of the festivals and events 52 hundred plus are supergreen so more than 2 3rds of the folks that prereportedly with that, im going to turn it over to to jason is. Is there a plan for a supergreen push. Were going to do more of a supergreen push and part pdf the kind of festival streets activities that happen route at this time of year in spring and summer and participate in the events and ill be happy to our Communications Director charles come in and report on the future activities. Maybe real target and the plans with the biggest festivals to get as many people also possible i dont know. Maybe keep in mind the next phase is 20 kilowatts of power we cant go beyond that and anticipate a certain number of supergreen and so thats why strategies was not just to go citywide and you know we asked do supervisors to have People Volunteer yre out commemorate will be low as we enforcement in certain areas well do outreach and focus attention thats where the people have the ability to sign up you know so anyway maybe we should come back and talk about but we are planning to have an event for all of the folks who really move to make this happen so were discussing what that looks like and the key part of this whole thing. Thank you. With that, ill ask jason fried, executive officer from lafco. Thank you very much jason fried, executive officer for lafco and congratulations for serving the consumers i like to get to say that. And thank you to you jason a long congratulations to you. Thank you very much so where the report came into from the initial thinking lafco did the report the program talked about you can there are over 9 thousand jobs created and been a lot of questions by some people will the questions where are the jobs and where are the jobs at we dont see 9 thousand jobs you promised keep in mind were talking about 20 or thirty years not a day one type of production we did working closely with our staff came up with the concept of what cleanpowersf moving forward as far as the job projection that report came out of that report we looked at what do the other cacs do this was launched and technically got done before the launch of cleanpowersf what did the 3 other cac programs look like on day one and moving forward with job creation i broke down one the main part we looked at the construction of new up renewals and theres a second layer it is relevant in San Francisco which was the creation of Actual Program and the those places youre creating brand new departments 0 we created for jobs then created in San Francisco because we have the sfpuc in place and theres a different some kind of style of job creation that happens with us and theyre creating brand new agencies and departments to do that on the job creation what you saw the first cac they launched their project program there was not new construction they remember the first cac and issue to work through and doing what they needed to do in order to have that and after that 2, 3, 42012 they created a few jobs you saw in 2012 the expansion of their program they were talking about 10 megawatts and the next day less and phase one bigger the first two phases for our program so they started off and once they expand they brought in the jobs and working on a thousand jobs a year bigger cleanpowersf but smaller than cleanpowersf will be in the long run so you can soma they laundry and didnt create jobs from new constructions they relied on the cleanpowersf nord to get their program and once again easier to get the customers and build the rating and horizontal after the first floor r first year they got the construction for the new facility online that is physically online to remember what those programs the long timeframe it can take multi years to get online and file number serve the public to soma is in the process of creating that process online and doing after that as they moved into year 2 brought on large projects unfortunately soma contract go didnt allow us to dots analyze so we cant into the weeds so we were not able to look at the individual projects in soma as marin and done those jobs to make that public in the project and the third launch was lancaster they have one project come online and still in the construction phase and serving consumers with knock it out of the park and two key things about lancaster it is in one of the best spots in the entire country with the solar and especially compared to the bay area they dont have clouds coming over their city it is a great day and great place for solar give us a benefit where you have projects that elm on price in the bay area if you put that exact one in lancaster it to be more Cost Effective theyre not in pg e service theyre in Southern California he had son and a lower pga so they have a couple of things working to their advantage and the other cacs in marin and soma have as well it shows that jobs can be created theyre not there on day one of the program but can be created once the program is date we have the program rolling and still in the launch face marin and soma the other two wait until they were after they were down done with the launch and after the first phase thats when they had discussions about the new construction looks like pea how to get runld on line and current Available Energy to get launched exactly what our stiff is relying on the current what is available and then i know in discusses theyll look at though to pass the phase one of launch with the job creations and how to bring jobs online and the next part so weve looked at what the others ones did and what can we do in San Francisco it becomes an important discussions for the purposes of how do we get to that 9 thousand plus jobs in the internet sport we pulled out with our staffs help pulled out good information out of the system we know that depending on the model we have more information than reported so do more fine tuning and in the long run by 2030 a scenario we are creating over 9 thousand jobs cumulative but getting past this youve heard me talk about we need to launch and get everything in place this is the key thing the projects we have i used in december of 2015 the Business Plan in december as the model for what this Program Looks Like that has an 15 opt out if we do better than that if we are less than a percentage has we go into the future phases you might have to rise those numbers and could go up in the left turn in the short term lets get basis phase one and move towards bringing an individual programs the other key piece the staff is working on i going want to bug them but what is the Energy Efficiency this is some of the early jobs should be coming 40 from people will tell you tell you to reduce and get to the minimum and that is when you need to bill for and part of staff is putting together those programs and needs it takes time so that metering went before you and hopefully in the next couple of months getting a feed and Takeover Program those programs are audio up and online theyll generate people building new projects we are doing better than pg e offers and thats the benefit to the program so the initial phase if you look at the costs and benefits youre looking at three hundred jobs out the phase one that our own staff did that analysis as part of Business Plan i look at it the internet study and couldnt find anything wrong seemed a good proposal that is good Accurate Information what phase one will look like so jobs will be created in phase one not thousands of jobs but we werent anticipating a thousand jobs thats a 20year plan as we get to that well do that and the late thing ill say there are going to be choices of how we move forward and i think that as we the key to let phase one move forward ill say for the most important job is there are staff positions that are going though the department of Human Resources that is a slow process added times we do the best we can to free those up in my opinion if those ten nature fulltime positions the staff will by looking at theyre the most critical to producing the long term jobs theyll create the programs that are put in place that gets us to real jobs so get the city to shake the tree and get the positions hired those are the individual ones two of them are filled and others still empty and needs to be filled get the last two positions in place and resolve to give us what were looking at for for job creations ill be happy to answer any questions you may have. Expedite those positions id like to talk about the offer of overall circle i know about the pend tsunami that is coming so second i think you brought up yesterday for the clean power power sign up jason brought up the neighborhoods San Francisco residents and have a sign up table so jason and i will be signing people up. Absolutely i didnt go to our website there are not ones coming up in the future i dont know what the next dates are coming up. We will. Well talk after the meeting. Commissioner courtney im sorry. Of the 9 thousand and of the three hundred how many do you figure to say public versus private sector positions. Thats will partly dont think on who is constricting the jobs the sfpuc land therefore be ill assume youll go through our process some of them are very well maybe on private lands that has not being figured where the individual sites will be the staff is putting that together heres how much money we anticipate being spent and the actual site tooivenlg i dont know it depends on when the sites occur whether their public or private jobs until we get the specific sites i cannot give you that. Can i add i think either way if we are taking the responsibility are we in some publicprivate agreement that had been can contractor that is doing it we hire the contract as part of deal so i am not well have staff to deal and install so at least thats not my understanding so i think those jobs will be private. So thank you harlan. So the public to private and the construction and the Service Pieces of that 9 thousand three hundred how many do you figure are construction versus service. Yeah. In the report itself and i can give me a second a chart that talks about how those number are brought up let me one second to find it go to page 11 what you have is the new solar capacity once again really comes to where you develop tour solar the same question we get to most of them will be in construction and actually, i apologize as im looking this we didnt include oh, no theyve thats a 13r5i9 item not the o and m between construction if you look at there are charts how you come up with those numbers most of numbers on the Construction Side with a very small number on the o m, m this i can get that chart after this meeting is offer. Thats good thank you jason thank you very much. Other questions thank you very much any Public Comment on the clean power report. Good afternoon mr. Brooks. Good work commissioners now that i made it through the building under security im eric brooks sf green party our city sf clean energy advocates. And california for incur choice i want to say that once again thanks for sfpuc and lafco staff for getting us to the launch i think that is time for advocates to start again pushing and raising concerns about the this will take 20 years to get a comprehensive local build out should shows it can be done in 10 years the previous studies by the power shows the same thing 10 in house jobs 2, 3, 410 years and proposed it in a short period of time we need two things one that we need to not have the customer inclusion the automatic enrollment in pieces over a 5 year period were seeing that the business customers were rolled in first if youve run a business you know that is savior stuff business customers are convert where they stay in what program the fact their opt out rate we have to go for lunch to invite in hundreds of thousands of customers within the next two years and get the funding available to build out in 5 and 10 years what the 50 percent of local knock it out of the park weve been pushing for and the other thing we need the local installation plants were still hearing from staff that one projection at a time if you all will go and look at the internet for the sidney renewal incur plan thats what it is called youll see the city of australia has a Installation Program for the city that is absolutely amazing and we now need to do that for San Francisco we pushed for a plan for a allocating and net got the nexus study but i have to commissioner courtney pushed longer than the advocates did i have to thank commissioner courtney for being really strong on this issue of wait a minute whats up with the jobs piece and commissioner courtney wed like rely on you if we make the 10 thousand jobs in 10 years happen well need you to push hard for that and cindy like plan and gets get this sucker off the launch pad please step up. Commissioner has been involved and id like her to be involved. Ill support that as well and i do hope and i think this was mentioned theyll appoint 6 months from now or some point to review you know the speed of the Program Understanding that is more successful to date than anticipated a lower opt out rate we set the targeted on megawatt numbers does that need to be revived and shift the program for acceleration in a Sustainable Way we have hiring questions and outstanding questions. Each year we can definitely come back and kind of update where we are and how fast we can roll out keep in mind the finances we cant go out there and Start Building or get customers that have the revenue of the bank to actually do that to secure a line of credit we have eric who has she saided us through this we try to cleanpowersf we want to make sure were successful i hear you want to move fast but fast cautiously. Thank you conditioner. And the other thing id like an update at some point is you know where we are in the tie of go solar with the rollout we talked about the concepts of coming up for a provision of the standard go for a contract when available with tcca customers. Well given that a lot of thought and barbara when can we come back and talk about the stuff weve been talking about. Probably in early june we have some stakeholder meetings we still want to have we have one but we want more before we bring the recommendations to you and the commission. Great okay. Thank you. Other comments on cleanpowersf . Next speaker, please. General manager. So the next item is an update on the outreach and engagement for the about which facility and Green House Gas. Renee. Good afternoon, commissioners if i could have the slide please. Good afternoon my name is renee owe manage the Strategic Initiative im happy to be here to revitalize the southeast facility and the purpose of the presentation on the speed of progress and the facility and the timeline for when well come back for recommendations my presentation today is covering highlights of the historical background owe the vision that created the facilities weve cover the efforts to revitalization the green house and spent a lot of time ill wrap up with the proenld timeline and if you have any questions, ill be happy to answer them on the process the Southeast Community of ground level Green House Gas to address did southeast Treatment Plant it was to provide educational and Job Opportunities for the residents in the bayview and to serve a thriving Community Members to assess the programming the Green House Gas many communities leaders were involved in determining what the appropriate mitigation including dr. Espanola jacksons who we all honored her life and dedication this year i want to take a second. Talk about the visionary leaders that set the tone for the mitigation without their vision and work and commitment to the Community Activism noun of us would be talking about how to invest in the future so youll eights can benefit from their with work the Southeast Commission was created in 1987 a key participate and i want to recognize executive director and commissioner chair which i know thank you for being here and all the Community Partners two years ago a debate and thorough legal history for both facilities was provided to the commission weve taken the time to put this on our website if youre interested in the members of the public or others want to go through that go to sf water. Org and before the confusion ill talk about the more recently efforts of Green House Gas and turn to the research and outreach starting with the Southeast Community facility in 2011, we were hearing concerns about the lack of utilization and in response to the feedback we started the Community Process to see what needed improvement in notifying one hundred stockholders participated the building was underutilized and lacked a vibrancy and had egress with Security Issues and we heard about the lack of appropriate parking the candle stick point lack of appeal and the usability of the space more questionable in response to the feedback in 2011 our agency made a decision to renovate the building in phase two a smaller renovations and the next renovation of the entire building by 2014 we completed phase one ramgsdz and beautified it and adam more spaces we learned that many significant champs to the building couldnt be addressed though the challenges and that that leaks and because of updated design the egress and ingress was a challenge as we started the phase two in late 2014 the significant investment the challenges of the building couldnt be addressed around this time harlan kelly and others turned off a brand new boys and girls down the block touring the Brand New Community center we saw the potential for building a new center with more than design and the allocate technology thinking the community deserves the eliminator involvement for the mitigation in early 2015 we explored the poebltd of. Brand new Center General manager kelly considered our site as an ideal location this site is directly on the third street corridor and 5 acres twice the angel of the current building we have been planning on comploeld the wastewater staff but the leading community will be a better programming site and general manager kelly halted any developments to explore this we have nifshl conversations with city college and others with the possibly of joining the Academic Building that severs as a pipeline for part of Community Center for Educational Opportunities awhile internally were excited about the opportunity to build new we so you get the communications and met with over 2 had had Community Members to hear their thoughts and heard a lot of excitement but we heard that Community Members said more robust discussion to renovate or the option to rebuild before getting behind any plans hearing the feedback weve developed this 2016 Community Engagement process walk us through today before i turn to that ill provide contacts about the background. Similar to the outreach for the focus on improving the Green House Gas was the longer leases expired and when all tenants were notified there was a competitive process aligned with the mitigations to determine the future leases in 2013 we are worked collaboratively with the tenant to begin to track the performance and impact in the community that year we called for process letters to gather phone Call Information about polk future programming at the Green House Gas to cover a wide range and received 9 letters the proposal was exciting and included agricultural and other programming all of those letters mentioned intensive focus on local job and Educational Opportunities we realized at this time to activate those like b will have to be upgraded we leefrpd healthy issues the Green House Gas were beyond repair or build new and understanding the deteriorating conditions it is made a decision to vacate weve been working with each tenant group on the relocations so insure minimal impact were partnering with the organisms to conduct an on one job replacement for any impact of an employee that could be impacted by the end of this year and going over the next 6 months were developing an internal plan to make sure the this intern plan will be held with the green house plan with the community through our Engagement Process the community is getting an opportunity to have a medicaid waiver vision some of the ideas a Grant Programs for the cbos for urban agriculture and Public Opinions housing or a new builds on the sfpuc land site this is up to where we are today our agency is committed to honoring the mitigation and seeing how we can build for the future for the future generation a crossroad in the efforts and asking Community Input on two important questions first should we renovate the center are build a Brand New Center second what interim plan for green house gs to date weve heard that the oak daily skepticism from the promises of the past and heard about the folks in did facility and stronger educational processes and meeting the people at street fairs in their homes, at communities events those are the four major Outreach Strategies weve been conducting in january that goes through july of this year there the outreach weve reached 25 house households for the opportunity and invite people to participate to date knocked on seven hundred doors well provide information on the future at 10 Community Events and have 22 presentations we know that to reach a Difference Community audience we have to partner with the organizations in the community weve Strong Community pinching and working with over 16 organizations including the ymca and the Community Youth center and others to develop 12 focus groups cover seniors and youth and other organizations well be partnering with youth oefshgsz throughout the learning grant to hem the summit to get the youth activated around the probably of the future the memoranda communications well engage audience through the social and Community Letters and studio productions and lastly conveying a group of Community Leaders from the tenants from the Community Center and the Commission Members the Southeast Working Group and other interested stakeholders to help to shape the process and learn more delays on the process and in all the engagement collecting the qualitatively and quantitatively data the survey examines the transit accessibility and location and other options also for a process of renovating or rebuilding New Buildings it asks for a prefer of Green House Gas this will be crucial in the Community Discussions by the end of jill collecting several skies through community pitchers and important to note . The phase one of what a many year of Community Engagement right now looking at the location of the center and the Green House Gas in 2017 we can partner with the Southeast Commission to look at programming future programming and the Community Center and the longterm plan what the green house this is a at some point we have attended 4 Large Community on the mardi gras and other celebration one of the things in the initial outreach people want to us activate oakdale weve hosted oakdale and other communities to share and participate in the vision so far weve reached three hundred plus surveys this friday well hopeful other third street and next community to oakdale i invite you to join and on the 24 well present a young radio effort and events on the website sf. Org back slash looking at the time ahead well wrap up by july and in august combine the report vomiting documenting and report bay back to the sealing and report for the Advisory Committee and then back to you all with our recommendations moving forward the hope in january 2017 we can start the design for renovated southeast at oakdale a brand new one and launch or launch the green house were asking everybody to join the conversation were created a facebook site and trying to drive traffic on twitter with the handtohand and trying to activate the community with dialogue so thank you, ann deceased for leading the engagement and again the Southeast Community and commission that is walking in full partnering and, of course, all the Community Members that participated and leading this discussion ill be happy to answer any questions you may have. Commissioner courtney. Thank you commissioner vietor that was extremely valuable over the course of the past 5 years weve heard a lot of promises that were made and lack of quality visually i personally have been listening youre looking for that engagement at the risk of kind of jumping in with two feet a couple of conversations i personally really, really like the idea of a new facility the reason i like the idea of a new facility you get to talk about a new vision and beginning a new relationship, a new trust the difference between government now and 35 or 40 years ago there was no question what was said the records are there the meetings are taped nothing has to come up with a piece of paper and saying those are the promises youre breaking im really excited about the potential to do that right hero right now moving forward with the next 35 years somebody has any question about the things were talking about a community that is underserved and under represented we have a to double down. Thank you, commissioner. I have a question i did not see the prongz maybe youll tease that out but financial to where the community sits own this the survey the data to political potentially you know what the real issues is it seems like the sooner we surface those the more we can weigh in well be able to weigh in and guide and advise the process. With the outreach process well go into the details the partnerships around each omission and the Community Concerns about each option as were hearing that we can start to feed that information and share all the information we have and also i mean, we love to come back or have a workshop with you if you want to see the detail. Yes. At the appropriate time that that would be helpful a big decision and commissioner courtney decision the community deserves an active participation and even to the question of what is gained and lost; right . That is fundamentally something we need to look at. Commissioners anything else on this Public Comment . I have a few cards here. La tries alexander. Good afternoon you just wanted to say way appreciate big deal a part of this process from the start to the finish we collected over seven hundred surveys which it wasnt easy because you know the city also have surveys going on in the communities we want what is best for our community we are excited about the probability of a new Community Building with our neighborhood we just want everything to keep the heritage of our parents and grandparents had for us thats pretty much thank you. Thank you for your words and being here today dr. Church well. Gamechanger good afternoon, commissioners im dr. Caesar for the africanamerican chamber of commerce representing over three hundred Small Businesses and former commissioner south i want to brought to your attention the members that are directed direct benefit of the contract opportunity created by this program while we are investigating infrastructure and buildings in the southeast we are also above all investigating in investigating in our people as former Southeast Commissioner who works diligently with the community and development a plan for the green house this project grant us the opportunity to insure actual employment and training in our art custodials that is whether your new commissioners we work diligently in the years before to get this facility built and the purpose was the education teach them how to from a seed to the product to the benefit like so therefore create jobs and also businesses so i encourage the puc to continue to investigate in the Treatment Plant and develop responsible programming for the green house in which creates Economic Development that can benefit the broadly communities now this program was a facility a teaching facility and it was put together to teach horticulture from the seed to the product in that interim the beneficial the plants and animals so this program we are asking you to consider and the development and so we can continue this Educational Program to present Small Businesses and jobs thank you. Thank you very much next item, please. I understand that you may be retiring at some point. We dont like to hear. But i dont know if now is the appropriate time to recognize our service but im hoping that will be a further time and pubically acknowledge it before you speak so thank you for your years of service. Thank you very, very much before i speak i want to yield to michael the chair with our permission. laughter . I just want to at a thank you, dr. Moss us ill be very brief i want to say as a little girl i grew up in the ear at 116 point rose the st. Francis this is now malcolm x the marshall with in junior high and from there to San Francisco State University im honored to see the process and have concerns as a senior from a little girl recognizing that there were so many opportunities and sometimes whether we have children we have to give them medicine they might not like it but take it and have feel better, more Smiling Faces dear puc commissioners thank you for hearing the adjustments ones the existing opportunities to Work Together to insure the Southeast Community and green house are assets for generations to come as part of the Southeast Community Facility Commission im fully in support of outreach process and building our commission in partnership with the sfpuc what assure the vision certificate mitigation in the field and expand upon i look forward to continuing the Community Dialogue around the future of the center and green houses and look forward to coming back to you all in the fall with the recommendation thats been guided and shaped by this revolting Community Outreach process happening this year this is from vice chair steve good and all the commissioners working together were attending a lot of the meetings and andrea is having meetings and mixers but good dialogue throughout our community and a new type of Energy People are excited some people seem anger because the fear of the unknown were there to continue to work that are our general manager and persons thank you very much. Dr. Moss us thank you, thank you congratulations on our appointment and thank you for your leadership we look forward to working closely together to work on new vision. Thank you very much. Dr. Good afternoon, commissioners im that executive director of the society enrichment outgoing on behalf of if you i want to thank you for your support most importantly im here today to thank the sfpuc staff or others general manager harlan kelly and also shes wonderful, wonderful staff juliette and others for their outreach and Community Center and the green house i have attended many of the support groups and which is feedback from the residents and everything from that part of town the promise of very, very positive and really am encouraging so today, im just here to thank you, again. And were looking forward to work closely with you im retiring im still a resident the southeast and be to all your meeting thank you for everything youve done for us thank you. Thank you and im so glad because youre retiring didnt mean youll go away youll participate in the conversation we value our opinions to thank you. Additional Public Comment . Good afternoon. Im david im with the community Bayview Branch officer in over 50 plus years housing to the development for stronger api were increasing and expanding in the behaving for the past 5 years and keep that in mind with it in comping o coming communities and the Africanamerican Community were trying to foster racial harm in any and were asking and what working to create be a taken into consideration what the Community Want in the development of the Southeast Community and work hard and continue to work hard to make sure the Community Voices is heard especially the existing Africanamerican Community and the Latino Community we thank you for your efforts and hope the community is take into consideration when this city is making thank you. I have a card for patton. Good afternoon good afternoon. Commissioners, i thank you thank you for your time 2, 3, 4 listening to us this evening im more appreciate the update in the sfpuc if beer continent in our education no way this is it is a success we need to hear from all the tint beneficiaries so many times the with only that recent the loudest are the ones that get heard this allows to us dig in deep the intended fiduciary that smell with the viral issues that are going on now we would like to recommend the outreach be increased around the options and become a new vision for this green house we have a huge opportunity to get it right the first time we did not put compliance requirements with the people had to go to training was a compliant requirement how many people goat employed willynilly does have numbers an opportunity we have the opportunity to reserve the right to make sure our communities benefits and to make sure there is compliance to make sure that the for profit have substantial mitigation that does not deter to the community and as we move forward the thing we need to understand this is not political status quo this needs to be a real intentional effort absolutely books the community and in a substantive way that was meant to do not done needs to be an exception thank you to the commission and the Community Members and very, very interested and very enthusiastic about this process moving forward with a new vision and a new energy thank you. Thank you. Next comment please. Hello my name is a resident in the hptd Hunters Point and i said to say i appreciate you guys fwifg us the opportunity to speak and letting us when a know what is going on most of the time in the community that i live in we are not updated on what is going on i want to speak for my community and say thank you all. I want to say your tang United States for letting you speak you but thank you for you speaking up on behalf of our community clapping. mr. Good afternoon, commissioners eric brooks sf green party our city sf clean energy advocates. Been involved many over a decade now helping fight some bad impacts not just for the wastewater Treatment Plant but Real Estate Development and hypes and the bayview Hunters Point and just wanted to talk about how it is great were talking about well should we had a new facility are renovate the old ones i want to make sure we talk about what is happening inside the facility something for several months some of your staff has taken part if in that we wanted that to, more robust and hopefully to get a gm to bring back reports a new process in the bayview Hunters Point and it is on third wednesday 2 00 p. M. To 4 00 p. M. In the oakdale campus in the alice pinch room and new task force it is deal with waste and hazard and others issues not bloifrptd were expanding to talk about Treasure Island the idea point task force 19 to use a model that is that organizations like green action and others and mine are joining in to get a process going where the bayview Hunters Point Community Members show up in the room and talk about problems that are actively occurring and also all the state federal and local agencies including our own that has impacts that impacts the problems weigh getting them to show up every month the point of the task force is the Community Driven the community is it in the drivers seat getting all the agencies in one room together to talk about problems that are happening so that agencies cant point im not suing you guys but hoof agencies point fingers at each other this is getting them in the room they cant do that the problems get solved like that our staff has taken part in the process and the other thing we want that more robust and like to see maybe once every couple of months juliette bring a report about the task force a quick report so youre aware of what is going on and aware of sfpucs roll in solving wastewater sewage Treatment Plant and other problems that are happening open Treasure Island so that your involved in that intern process of the commission thanks. Thank you. Good afternoon hi i think i spoke on the wrong title i apologize were one of the outreach partners with the project and actually dreamforce was someone that was admired she interested me to the Environmental Justice things that are take place in the bayview Hunters Point i want to say this says that a underutilized and like to see every effort to make sure it is utilized to the moomentd capacity but i want to say im existed about working on this project i seen objective be all of that with a healthy skepticism but attending the workshops for all organizations and looking at the material im happy to see that the effort is truly to try to find out what the Community Worksheet with the spaces and if not necessarily involved whats the cost of this and that is about what the Community Want interest how do you feel about it renovate or about the location to the tune i think that people are afraid of which was but people feel theyre in control of the change they can let the fears go and think about what is the best space so i just to encourage everything to do what theyre doing the process i feel like the Community Feels their asked a question about where they want it to happen and this process to know when theyre decision is and whatever the decision 3 community occupies with i want to say im excited and encourage you all to get up e keep open doing exactly what youre doing and the best decision will be made. Thank you. Any other Public Comment. Comment. I want to thank the gentleman it spoke and the process of vetting the neighborhood not just the currently groups but also age i think about the Public School High School Kids the exams are happening now that space if they can utilize and learn more so often what the adults learn in to is from our children and consider their choices i appreciate your comments. Can i add for me this is a really important project you mean 9 program were doing it to fix the infrastructure and taken advantage to update our Treatment Plant through the plant and so you know it is not just you know renewing the admission fact of the matter tfa naefblth we wanted to take it beyond that when you look at the mitigation i think a lot of folks issue is they look at the old building and thats what they fought for they fought for that by having the Treatment Plant in the community i think as a fondness so we talk about a new vision but still need to recognize the old facility and i think most of the people are concerned once the new vision consults theyll tear down the old and the planned to tear down the old and to recognize that was the old mitigation and if we move to the next one well go into the story this our new and this is the old thats the way to get there sanctions were doing more than the green houses or the Community Center we are the footprint to maintain were creating open space and the other thing were doing is looking at waisz ways we have Environmental Justice if there is land we need more space and happens to be a recycling place well eye that that helps the inspirational justice were using the policy you put if place to as a utility purpose to help us laid out with the space is it says the project make sense so i wanted to thank the gentleman for his leadership next month well throw a party im sure you have a Party Everyday next month and introduce dj who is the new person in his place. clapping. is training right now so we brought him on early i think you start in a couple of weeks; right . So hope so so a slow process as someone said earlier but make sure that he was time to work with toy yeah, so the transition can be earlier so wanted to add that well, thank you and if no further comments on this item we want to commend thank all the Community Members for coming out, i want to encourage you to stay in the process please stay active and share our voice and encourage the communities to engage in the process as well next item, please. Next item, please. We want the state legislation update opens the cal screen. Great jutting yet general manager for the cal i want to thank toy yeah too thank you toy yeah, and coming back next month with at resolution foyer to recognize the hard work hes been doing so commissioner vietor you asked you us to come back with an additional update ill be brief as background a total design to identify communities that are disproportionality by pollution stat fires developed at methodology that identifies the community for Department Opportunities and specifically tied to the cap trade dollars generate at the state level an agency under the Cal Development the green to meet this requirement in 2013 that was most recently updated in 2014 as heard from folks that came to the Commission Members of the committee will be concerns that the puc with regards to the application of the tool abused it does exclude in some murnts like bayview Hunters Point because it didnt account for cost of cost of living 4d we know is relative higher in San Francisco based on those types of indicators in San Francisco Community Like bayview Hunters Point are rising to the surface with regards to the screen since we last updated the commission only march 18 Assembly Members amended the senate bill to require an update for the tool to get our higher poverty and high cost of living this will help addresses side concerns from folks if come to the Commission Meetings and the concerns that the puc has also had because it addresses bayview Hunters Point as part of the screen it is a step in the right direction we in addition to the Side Department want environment have been working with the citys state legislation body and it is on tomorrow at the monthly meeting to take up this meeting and work with the Mayors Office and others organizations working on this effort to push the 2292 to the finish line those the processes progresses the issues have expense a concern with the spearheaded and championed by the assembly map. In the spirit of having heard under members of the public and issues on the bayview neighborhood great predicament to lend our support every at the commission or the staff to encourage you know the issues that were fashioned as a community. Definitely. Commissioner courtney. In the Data Collection with the comments weve heard last meeting. Exactly so theyve been tracking this in conversation with bright line around those issues it is come up for the past several years we worked with the Mayors Office to identify the cap trade dollars generated and spent and allocated but communities like bayview Hunters Point and as configured doesnt expedite as other places because San Francisco is a wealthy Overall Community and not looking at apples to appless. It operationally is the homeowners piece. It is the im not looking at particular neighborhoods particularly within a ami zip codes. A portion of cap trade legislation sp 435 it is directing a portion the explores to dollars to the protecting community but the bayview Hunters Point and other protecting communities are not on the cal screen the tool being used it is not you know we have not be able to take advantage the dollars and direct them to community most in need an important issue to continue to track especially, as we look at our investment in the bayview Hunters Point community and potentially got from the state to add that po 3 with the communities. As far as, how we applied the screening weve looked at the cal model and augmented it as we looked at the viral justice analysis and adam other indicators with ethnicity and looking at things like holders that receive food stamps received the income tax credits, etc. To try to make that a better, more accurate picture. And the useful tools maybe needs a refresher. Ill keep you abreast through the written correspondence. Thank you very much Public Comment calaveres. Next speaker, please. An update on the Water Enterprise Capital Improvement Program kathy. Good afternoon so im here to report on times water capital so in terms of what is either late or over budget we dont have anything over budget but have two background cheese cakes that are running late and two local projects for the regional projects san antonio and which is wait an Electrical Equipment purposes that is coming but were still waiting openings on the mortuary control equipment and southern skyline rich trail extension and been a delay were trying to cooperate to get a state grant for that project and on the local side we have candle Fire Suppression again waiting on equipment or actually a second water storage tank and finally fground water working with rec and park to make sure their irrigation system can take our recycled water ill be happy to answer any questions you may have. Commissioners. Report. Thank you commissioners. All right. Next item is the quarterly budget states report. Eric. General manager and cfo we have a brief presentation can i have the slides please. So the theme is the same thing that we have been hearing for the past 9 months water and wastewater continue to experience reduced revenues as a result of reduces water sales has to a wrolg trend in q one fortunately, the action weve taken to reduce the expenditures partially have the revenue reductions on the water enterprise we see the reduction in sales as you can see 41. 1 million of the 57 million revenue decreases associated with is what i live revenues and steve presented our water sales are down driven by the revenues on the plus side we saw some one time savings as a result of debt funds that offset much of that as well as others salesforce the general manager talked about earlier this year. The wastewater enterprise seeing the reduction of 13 plus Million Dollars offset entirely on the budget and then the power enterprise we have reduced sources in terms of sales to the w s p p marketrate for powsdpo low and on the power enterprise we continue to meet all the fund balance and the coverage metrics and conditions one item id like to update that provides you a more thorough information at the next Commission Meeting today, we sold 308 million in wairmentd enterprise Revenue Bonds and over the next strooerld successful Interest Rate for including all costs for the year debt and many bids extremely competitive bids very happy with the pricing and as well two weeks ago we had the watermelon was part of progress a rating from the stated and poorest and moodys a credit upgrade and it is rated x x and very good press as a result of this a significant portion that of green bonds as i mentioned and were the first agency to issue the green bonds according to the certification of the climate bonds so were very excited about the sale and with the funding for the ssip and the r r work ill have a more complete report at the next Commission Meeting ill be happy to answer any questions you may have. Does do those bonds need to be targeted i dont know if so this the right word. Allocated for the ssip. Actually we remember able to certificate a Third Party Agency we were able to certify the investments the r r not green. Because of the resiliency or other language. Uhhuh. How much is the total. 308 million. 308 million. Generates in pare the 30 million in precedes from construction bonds were sold at a premium. Great congratulations. Yeah. A great job. Thank you. Other questions. Thank you. Public comment on the financials. All right. The last item is the audit and performance nancy. Good afternoon. President and commissioners jansz nancy with the internal controls as presented the report is an equal summary the puc before you this presentation will highlight the core parted with a year to date of all projects and highlights the levels of the organizations south provides for frequent updates for planning and transparency and the timeliness to address did audit plan and may i have the slide please. As highlighted in the executive director summary with the Third Quarter of 54 projects in stages of progress to be routine by the planning commission, and may be acted upon by a single roll call vote increase of 7 from prior quarter that must be or number will increase and it operationally is inclusive of any surprise audits from outside agencies 18 in process and 16 to begin in the upcoming months the following 3 audits were completed in quarter 3 listed by the ordinances date businesses have successfully completed the requirement in the balances in 20142015 this was presented no internal controls with the the report on the soma valley the cf a provided 7 recommends to improve the timely Records Management and accurate change orders costs and the proper treatment and management concurs with the majority of the recommendations and lastly the Controllers Office completed their o and b88 through the federal grants there were no recommendations for the puc as well and that was in regards to the federal program were precipitating in for renewal empower research and development and the acts recommended to the rim fire the following im sorry 9 next 6 months the Department Anticipates 16 audits not all not able ones are financial for the tax related to the 2016 for sale of taxed for out of state transactions the beginning of this month for the fiscal years 20152016 for all statement for all 3 enterprises and the vicinity counts, we will begin with C Organization a and under performance well have citywide Fleet Management audit and also participating in the expansion the Community Evaluation framework and the performance audit of okay at the last presentation of the support in january 26th a resolution of prior opened audits and recommendations in q3 management made efforts to close those and ill be happy to i didnt want the significant process has been made with a note closure of 72 percent of recommendation and 33 outstanding audits 100 percent plus out of the 3 audits those highlights are inclusive through march 31st and anticipate process this is inclusive the remaining inventory if prior years so the process had not been accomplished through internal follows up that management has taken on these items and well continue to keep you upgraded this concludes any update. Good work questions or comments on the audit. Thanks again that concludes any short report. Well take a 5 minute break and be back by 4 oclock. Well call items together so well tell you which ones wellgood. Okay welcome back donna will read our content items. Actually were on item 9. The wart quarterly update and report. Hello. Good afternoon, commissioners dan wade couldnt be here ill try to be brief in the interest of time were covering the Quarterly Report if january 1st to the ends end of march we have the region local at 99. 8 basically, he wanted to point out that you will notice a site that was less than loose quarter the percentage is 2k5i9d and calculated based on the new march 2016 revised with the baseline and recent accomplishments that are also in the report but what i wanted to get to the two remaining preconstruction alameda and Alameda Creek fish facilities we making 95 percent for the Alameda County creek recapture and the first administrative draft eir under review so maybe a quick question but what fish species are impacted with the white hooker and the trout. Im not that much a fish person so steve would know that. That was regarding this Alameda Creek facilities yes. Well, there are primary trout hopefully in the longterm two steel heads but variations the residential trout pass the dam. Thank you. And then here is the calaveres replacement and construction is more than 75 Percent Complete on the dam serving as the dam directing user during construction so the dam can be constructed down stream and more than 7 million yards of soil we looked to milestones first that was constructed and april 1st shut down the outlet pipeline to finish the valley to prepare the foundation for the new dam by early fall we expect to begin construction as a new earth and rock filed dam and have an outlet tunnel to be in service so far the winter season this is a recent photo that shows the no incompleted show way 40 feet tall and over 15 hundred feet high with hundreds of yards eve concrete discharge in the probable flood and approximately 3 times the capacity of other 80 away 2, 3, 42006 during the scale model constructed and tested in the ohio drastic looks about so our project engineer and staff was present when the testing was conducted for various swell conditions and designs for the based on the model. And in this april 2016 point out we celebrated and standing in inside the bridge and commissioner moran and other members of the project team for those of you it will give you a better sense the banner was hanging off the bridge 10 feet tall by 50 feet wide phase one construction contract for regional ground water is 50 Percent Complete and on at t all 50 we will sites 2gs the drilling at one of the sites it as factory testing and will think delivered and installed it will start in summer of 2016 and extends to early 2017. The valuation of the potential sites for phase two well sites continue and were currently performing environmental a 30 prospective sites this is one of the well stations under construction at the well facility this next one is the one of the sites from bio regional habitat and Alameda Creek shed and in son all this photo is one of the sites gold fishpond located south of calaveres. Were in bio regional habitat. I want to ask some order. Okay. So one is in construction and going to break ground in 2017 thats right. 13 well sites currently under construction and two we have to negotiate the exact location out of the 13 those are all currently under construction and and scheduled to come openly starting in 2017. Yes. Actually in early 2017 start up and testing for the summer of 2016 but stepped through 2017. And remind me when those are. In the peninsula and are in san brunts. When is that coming online im not but were running late. 2017. Off the top of my head what i read what about 6 months. Great, thank you. And to see the photo of other site that is plowed the long term plant establishment period at sheep creek and so a lot of the sites have struggled to object this Mountain Valley pipeline 0 due to the plant issues and navigated the san antonio longterm was extended by one year because the drought and final completion in may of 2017. And then the peninsula two waterings will be completed this spring with that, im concluding the quarterly update ill be happy to answer any questions you may have. Commissioners. Thank you, very much. And now well move on to oh, Public Comment in these. Consent items. Item 10 at this time, members of the public may address the commission on items of interest to the public that are within the subject matter jurisdiction routine commission. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of the commission, the public, or staff so requests accept contract number by 200 plus consequent days and a board contract in the amount of 6 million plus to the lowest quality responsive bidder throughout the construction and c approve the spivengsz in and award the contract in the nouchl of 5 million plus to the lowest quality responsibly and responsive bidder provision engineering. Any a votes on the calendar. Public comment on the consent calendar. All in favor, say i. I. Opposed . Were to read without objection items 11, 12 and 13 and vote on that palace but call them together weve heard about the rates in the presentation at our last meeting and perhaps tloos not any additional comments or questions but mr. Sandler is here in the event there is. Thank you donna. Discussion and possible action to adopt a charge for hetch hetchy empower and electrical lights for certain municipal customers over and over other governmental agencies for the after july 31st, 2016, and the druksz to adopt a proposed new retail electrical fees and charges for residential and convert eat remain with the hetch hetchy debris enterprising for retail consumers not residential or after item 13 paeshgz discussion and possible action to adopt a selfgeneration for the net meeting with the empower schedule. Ethic cfo barbara hale and i presented at the last Commission Meeting i just to want point out are item leveling was modified audits ill be happy to answer any questions you may have. Commissioners a motion to approve item number 11. Second. A comment i appreciate the additional language put in there it is basically asking staff and our various continent sisters how fast we can bring the cost of Service Rates up i want to reiterate that was presented as a contest between sufficiency and affordability i know this is a short time truth and a long term falsehood if you get our power rates up it is also be volleyball by any reasonable standard and has a represent for the department and implementation issue involved not an affordability so thank you for including included. Thank you for getting that on the Public Record any Public Comment on item 11. Mr. Brooks. Good afternoon eric brooks sf green party our city sf clean energy advocates. So just real quickly want to reiterate the support for continuing to as commissioner moran said to get the rates up and once again currently the Enterprise Staff to come up with expensive programs to work on youll see city of dptd and hospitals to help them demand response as they cost is up to what it ought to be were saving them on the builds i dont know how expensively it is being done to help to mitigate the increase but good to see the rates will continue to go up i know none the departments are enjoying me aig that but make sure we are helping them to do efficiency and demand responses and storage will be Cost Effective pretty soon to make sure the hit is less and good to hear from colorado enterprise at some point the department of the environment is helping to do outreach on that thats correct. If not further all in favor, say i. I. Opposed . Unanimously goes forward next item, please. Number 12 is there a motion to pass that item . Ill make a motion. Second. Public comment on item number 12. Good afternoon eric brooks sf green party our city sf clean energy advocates. Just want to reiterate something i said last meeting he talked with staff and sounds like it is possible with Net Metering Program we need to as soon as possible to get a chart to show potential customers what pg e pays for electrical compared to what we pay a little thing on the website and be handouts look youll get a better tale from us than the pg e so we can marketed public power and green cleanpowersf more easily to folks every time i talk to anyone about is cleanpowersf for example, at the they have solar panels they say how much you know be able to show them an easy box that shows them did cost differential it is attractive to an power customer or a cleanpowersf customer. You know id like that idea as this conversation we can talk about you know what that looked like from a cost differential and what you get if you get into the program as well and mc that more trophy any other any Public Comment on item 12 all in favor, say i. Opposed . That motion carries. Final item number 13. Is there a motion . So moved. Second. Public comment . All in favor, say i. I. Opposed . That motion carries. Thank you rates have passed. Thank you. Next speaker, please. If you wouldnt mind reading item 14. Consider count wholesale requirement for the fiscal year ending 2017 on Net Metering Program around july 16th. A motion to adopt the rate schedule and move it. Im second. Public comment welcome. Thank you good afternoon nicole ceo for bosca im here in support of the item but to express my appreciation this an been hard to deal with the water i pushed this hard to get the numbers early this year so our agencies can prepare were here today a good result i wanted to express that thank you. Thank you always noise to her an appreciative word any other Public Comment. All in favor, say i. I. Opposed . That motion carries next item, please. And item 15 public hearings the draft 2015 urban water Draft Program a. No action june 14th will come back to the mission for approval. Steve richie general manager for water a ones every 5 year effort we need to go through to demonstrate weve look forward the demand and a couple of things that are not here weve changed our method of modeling the land use to the metric model this is the differences and also new assumptions built in i had a few slides im to get to the one slide with the note if i could have the slides please this shows the data about the water system and two things the red line is the rescues and under planned bay area as you can see the fine print in 2035 San Francisco about break the one million population that is different than before this is a significant increase in population to dense if i around the transportation human beings despite the decrease demand over time it is a low level it increase in demand to make your total water demand going up it steadily goes down but if those projects are try that is a major difference were seeing increases 90 in population out to the thirty 25 and 2040 timeline and pick up in other 5 years if you havent noticed it picking you up because the building that is goepg this is a public hearings to make sure were on the record it is open and bring this in june for adoption. Ill be happy to answer any questions you may have. Thats it thats it great thats short and sweet thank you very much next item, please. Public comment. Good afternoon again commissioners im sorry you have to hear from me so many times a lot of important items on your agenda the loose slide was important i work on various organizations on water issues weve seen over the past several delineations the population of california go way up and the water use maintain itself on a level Straight Line so we realized your staff wants to be conservative of the future projects we see this in many communities in california we are assuming a demand well likely not have if we aggressively introduce Water Conservation 0 lets keep in mind that even though staff is showing those projections their job to be conservative about the fire chief of future that is not likely the situation weigh see leveled use or gunmen decline in use it is instead of increasing i want to make sure that level is on the table from the advocates out in the water communities thanks. Thank you i have a speaker card from kenneth gibson. Good afternoon. Good afternoon, commissioners im kent ethic with the sierra club San Francisco Bay Committee willow presenting an urban Water Management plan is a state mandated exercise it is the type of planning by sfpuc those major urban Northern California agencies should think about beyond the box and lead the rest of the state in addressing what is a growing water problem the 2010 plan population growth for the Retail Service at least from puc growing two or three percent more or less the 2014 is population over 5 percent every 5 years. Now nobody in the room has any idea what is more likely reilly governed we know in the next 4 years will grow faster in 2010 so we need to have enough flexibility to accommodate faster or slow growth with the technology in place to make the best use of water possibly recognizing at times demand is far blow capacity and we still have to pay for the capacity 2015 plan wisely considered the prospective that drought any occur in the next 25 years it looks at the only the 3 year drought scenario which is what the state requires that is problematical beyond that particularly for the wholesale in the plan take the whole brunt of any cutbacks necessary almost the whole brunt of the cutbacks the 2015 plan includes cycled water by 2040 for the water progressing promotions it shows in increase in the water supply after 2030 this it seems to me short site the recycling should be where we get the water not imaging there is more rain in the future. And the plans do not address Water Pricing i know when our trying to balance supply a limited supply against the growing demand pricing is one of the techniques with the most impact and from the pricing structure is made progressive will not harm the economically disadvantaged overseeing living in small spades without lots of grace around them their rates should think lower than they are today while the yours that are just extravagant or waste shall pay through the pricing in advance for their keys. Thank you. Im sorry. I thought that was my voice cracking. Thank you laughter thank you very much appreciate our comments other Public Comments on the urban Water Management plan. Hearing none, next item, please. Item 16 approve the amendment for the c s with the expectation of one year and 11 months. Is there a motion to approve the expectation. So moved. Ill second. Any Public Comments or questions. All in favor, say i. I. Opposed . That motion carries thank you. Our next item. Item 17 authorize the memorandum of understanding with the United States department of the interior National Parks yosemite not to exceed 12 million and the consideration of two years. Is there a motion to approve. Ill move it. Did we have this in place before. Excuse me did we have this type of thing negative impact place before. Yes. We had a 86 mou we looked at seven years but limited to two years because of the budget challenges on the federal side wanted to option for things different with a 2 year extension. Is the cost of it comparable. Yes. It is. So theres a monoxide i did not hear a second. Public comment. Good afternoon again commissioners this is the last time i promise eric brooks sf green party our city sf clean energy advocates. So want to call your attention to manage as a 12ik i didnt problem for the staff but crucial the very first thing i worked on in doing in the 90s was helping to when i was with the purges and segue to get the new law passed in the 90s that greatly eliminated the use of herbicide a and pesticides should recall over in the 6 we got that passed and the National Programs come up and exemptions were unbeknownst id gone to another department we have chemicals pesticides for the purpose of goat quote restoring natural habitat and bringing back the b. C. And various advocates have been battling out at the indictment and the commission of the environment with rec and park to get especially those 20 tier one Hazardous Materials like round up out of the process well not use this heavy toxic chemicals not acceptable for people and children and pets to be exposed o to those chemicals there are other ways and cost for money to do rotation restoration those federal programs on federal land and they are also using those hazardous chemicals to do restoration promotions first of all, were saying well not win that battle on the city level want the sfpuc to get on board were not icing these heavily toxic schemz there are federal regulation about the federal properties that insist on using the chemicals i want to flag it to figure a way inform push back on the federal government and get alternative transportation so in the restorations were not using chemicals that are like that we need to get away from that that is bad to use those chemicals so thanks for whatever you can do to pursue and push back against the feds and get those chemicals out out of our restoration. Is there any additional Public Comment . That motion carries. Item 18 an agreement with the water term with the sewer system projects and the auxiliary pumping stations for contract over may 10th , 2016. Im here to present the resolution to authorize the general manager to execute the extension for the water Improvement Program into the water system and the auxiliary pumping station and oneonone want to highlight a couple of key terms well be update the first term updates arbitrator for the translators and authorize the process to the p l a and mature agreement of the ash translator and some of the work covered by the innovate agreement the thirsted major update exempts micro lbe set aside and contractor award until lobe contractor have been a award 5 million and the final major modifications will be around updating our construction trucking this is in the p l a those are the Major Updates and to take one quick second he get to be up here but been a work with a ton of people he wanted to acknowledge our trade partners that worked with us on this mike and bob and oscar and larry have been really good partners and your joint administrative members from the consultant around the project agreement and been through many meetings pat and from city build and organisms and quibble to the City Attorneys office and our partners eric and julia our own norway reign have been wonderful with with a lot of pressures to turn those documents around and i said to thank martin and my staff for working on this i get to come up here but want to acknowledge the work and with with that, we submit the resolution to please approve. It is that exist i know it is a heavy lift and a lot of work i want to appreciate all the work so thank you very much. And with that, ill take a motion. Ill make the motion with a comment. Okay great work. And martin and the whole team but to illustrate how really difficult complicated delicate i had an opportunity to meet with john dourth for lunch the head the Nutrition Community please do our best to reach out and issues i promised him, i will mention that pubically but im still moving and confident you will under the leadership usual this through and persuade proud to make that motion. Other comments on this all in favor, say i. I. Opposed . That motion carries unanimously we will now be moving into closed session and commissioner secretary will read the items 27 through 3 tip of the iceberg anticipation litigation and litigation for et al. Versus the city of San Francisco court of appeals 6 appellant district and 33 the Real Property for Real Properties rowlings road San Francisco and persons negotiating residential and for the college code, llc terms of payment and price and item 24 unmitigated claims, llc versus of cc finger f and the tasmanian house versus the city and county of San Francisco and item 26 utilization restore hetch hetchy versus the city and county of San Francisco and again, items 27 through 3 that will not be heard thank you another motion to assert Attorney Client privilege. Motion to assert the privilege. All in favor, say i. I. Opposed . Great Attorney Client privilege is asserted well goitems. Id like to announce if p weve settled on items 24 and 25 and no action an ax to disclose. Move not to disclose. All in favor, say i. I. Under the influence any other new business. Sorry if i may i just learned that the city of phoenix is just about to send a delegation to San Francisco i mend to the general manager earlier today it is in relationship to a lot of did preheinecke for those of you who dont know arizona not a Stronger Union town laughter by the way, i think that is pretty exciting im hoping he with the commissioner ze we will have conversations about the great work youve done with the training and the continued outreach in the community 12 courses and a lot of the stuff that tommy has done with the engineers it is basically the exact at the same time developing the Career Pathway to make sure that people have an opportunity 47 percent of our staff a getting ready to retire weve mentioned that they understand we understand im looking forward to engage this body and those conversations and theyre kind of start to be planned but towards the end of june ill asking you to mark your calendar you if you guys participated and any other Commission Business there is none meeting is adjourned all right. Good afternoon, everyone id like to call this meeting to order the regulars meeting of the Land Use Committee my name is supervisor cowen the chair of the committee to any right is supervisor wiener the vice chair of the committee and supervisor peskin will be joining us and sitting on the left clerk victor young thank you, mark and