Transcripts For CNNW State Of The Union 20110925

americans, 53%, feel president obama is greatly or moderately to blame for the economy. more people still blame former president george bush but president obama won't be running against george bush next year. with me, obama's 2008 presidential campaign advisor and now senior white house advisor. thank you, david, for joining us. before we get to the politics of it, which is fascinating to all of us, let's get to the president's jobs bill. wow would you be open to breaking up this bill for the parts that you know you could get agreement on? >> well, the president has been very clear as he's traveled across the country and in the speech to congress that he thinks this -- the american jobs act would have a profound impact on our economy right now. it would put a lot more people back to work, put more money in the pockets of workers, put construction workers, teachers, veterans back to work, help small businesses all across the country. this is what the economy needs right now. the question is, if you think the economy's doing okay, i guess you're not going to act. but if you think this economy is far too weak and needs a jump-start -- so we expect there will be an entire vote on the jobs act in september. these are things that generally would not be highly controversial. things that have brought bipartisan support in the past. >> you and the president both understand politics. there will be things in terms of paying for it that the republicans won't agree to. the republicans say we can agree to certain things, including infrastructure bank which is important for creating jobs. so push coming to shove, would you rather take parts of it, or do you have to have the whole of it? >> again, there's any number of hypotheticals in the coming months, but we're going to continue to demand this type of action that is going to have a profound impact on the economy right now aimed squarely at the middle class. so the question really for folks in congress is, do they want to go back at the end of the year and report back to their constituents that they didn't really do anything to help the economy, create jobs, help the middle class. we think at the end of the day there's going to be some action here. we think it needs to be the american jobs act is aimed squarely at providing the jump-start the economy right now but it is part after long-term economic strategy. get our fiscal house in order in the long term, continue to build new industries in high-tech manufacturing, investment in education, but the economy is far too weak right now. it needs a jump-start. that's what the american jobs act is intended to do. >> the president in his various appearances around the country pushing for the jobs act has been quoting mark zandi from moody's analytics about how many jobs this would create. mark certainly a guy that a lot of people quaut. i want to put up something for our audience that zandi said to the associated press on saturday. when he says he sticks by his numbers for 2012, but he said beginning in 2013, and certainly in 2014, the plan is a drag on the economy, because the stimulus starts fading away. so by 2015, the economy is in the same place as now, as if there was no jobs package. >> well, that statement points out how weak the economy is right now. and i think that if you don't act right now, the economy's going to be in a deeper hole. so we have to do some things right now to immediately jump-start the economy, but that will help lead to more consistent positive economic growth. investments in small business, investments in roads and bridges and ports, our schools. in many states teachers are being laid off. we don't have students learning. listen, they're competing against kids -- >> i guess his point is that they'll still be laid off when the stimulus money runs out. >> well listen. i think that we can act right now or we cannot act right now. if we act right now it is going to be part of strengthening this economy. this economy will eventually begin to fully recover and this is going to be an important part of it because obviously we had a couple of months early in the year where we had some very significant job growth. we're not producing enough jobs, we don't have enough growth. there's a lot of headwinds out there. we see what's happening in europe right now. another significant headwind on our economy. so we have to act right now, and do some things -- listen, mark zandi and others have looked at the american jobs act of the 2 million jobs -- >> has he signed on to what he thinks will happen in the out years? >> we think these things can have a profound impact not in the next year or year-and-a-half but provide foundation for longer term growth as we go through the decade. >> economists i talk to say there can't be any recovery until the housing industry recovers. do you all have anything else in the works, any kind of debt restructuring for homeowners under water or those about to lose their homes? is there something else you can do? >> the best thing we can do for the housing market is to have the economy recover. if you were able to drop the unemployment rate by a point -- >> you all say it will be around 9% this time next year. >> well, the fundamental recovery of the housing market is going to be twin to a recovery in the economy but there are some things we can and have done. we announced additional forbearance so people who have been unemployed have more time in terms of their home loans. the president announced in his jobs speech and plan two significant items. one a neighborhood stabilization fund to allow local communities to rehabilitate, tear down, turn into rental housing refinancing proposal that would allow millions of americans to save $2,000 a year. we'll explore additional ideas. we'll have to throw everything we can at this. >> there are other things you can do, such as? >> as i said, we announced those two in the jobs package. we think a refinancing proposal to give the average family $2,000 a year would be significant taking advantage of these historically low interest rates. we've obviously got in many urban areas in particular, you've got homes that are in need of repair, even demolition, turn them into rental. that would be an important thing to do. obviously we're going to look at every other idea out there. again, there's not going to be a silver bullet. it will take a lot of different things to make an impact. >> you heard that poll coming in to this interview that more and more people think the president is at least moderately to blame for the state of the economy. what then is your pitch in 2012? if it is going to be on the economy, you all know it's going to be slow through next year, have predicted it will be slow through next year, it seems as though you can't run on the economy. >> the american people understand it took us a long time to get to this point. it will take us a long time to get out. for the middle class this just wasn't about what happened in 2008 in the great recession. for a long time they've been seeing their wages stagnate, they are falling farther and farther behind. that's the central mission for our country and for president obama. >> couple quick questions as we close this out. does the president expect to make any major changes in the white house staff or in his cabinet between now and the election? any of that in the works? >> i think the president is very competent in his team, in the direction we've laid out here. we've laid out for the american people a clear plan for immediate action on the economy through the american jobs act. an approach to our long-term fiscal future that we think is smart and balanced. so no, i think he's got a good plan. he's got a good team to execute that. >> so no major changes in either staff or cabinet that you can say particularly on the economic part of the -- >> i don't expect that, no. >> let me ask you about pakistan. we had admiral mullen, chairman of the joint chiefs out there saying, look, pakistan supported the haqqani network attack on the u.s. embassy. you now have the pakistanis firing back saying u.s. policy is confused and in disarray. what is the state of u.s.-pakistan relationships right now? >> we've made it clear and admiral mullen and secretary clinton talked to their counterparts in pakistan as recently as this week, that obviously with the haqqani network there are safe havens there that are being abided and they're links. >> so this seems a little ratcheted up. >> well, the message has been clear. obviously the haqqani network provides great danger to the people of the pakistan, to the people of the united states, to other countries, and those links and those safe havens, we are continuing to insist that the pakistani government make clear and take action to make sure that these safe havens and these links are eliminated because it is providing clearly the situation where they are free to operate in a way that's quite dangerous. >> again that's kind of been so for some time now. this is now saying pakistan -- the intelligence arm of the pakistani government supported an attack on the u.s. embassy. can you let that stand? >> well, listen. we obviously continue to engage in a great deal of cooperation with pakistan. 20 of the top 30 al qaeda leaders have been eliminated, including obviously osama bin laden. so we've made great progress. but obviously we're going to continue to intensify and make the case that any arm of the pakistani government that's provided aid, comfort, providing safe haven for the haqqani network, we can't abide that. >> or else? >> well, we're going to continue to make the case in every way possible -- as i mentioned secretary clinton, admiral mullen met with our pakistani counterparts as recently as this week. we have to continue to make progress on this. >> haven't you been making the case for some time? >> well, we have been making the case for some time. >> does there have to be an "or else"? in aid we give them billions. >> we have. and obviously there's been some i think mention that some aid could be in jeopardy here but i think we're going to continue -- we have to work closely with them obviously in terms of the fight against al qaeda in that region. but at the end of the day, we have to continue to make the point, yes. >> just to pinpoint this. you would think about cutting back aid? >> well, again -- >> you agree to that? >> again, those discussions are happening between our foreign policy and national security teams. obviously we need to continue to have as much cooperation as we can but we cannot abide the situation where the haqqani network is being provided safe havens. any links there need to be decoupled and that's going to be a very important aim for us in the coming period of time. >> david plouffe, senior advisor at the white house, thanks for joining us. >> thanks, candy. when we come back, round three of a looming government shutdown with senators mark warner and lamar alexander. meineke's personal pricing on brakes. i tell you what i can spend. i do my best to make it work. i'm back on the road safely. and i saved you money on brakes. that's personal pricing. joining me to talk about the latest budget showdown in congress, from nashville, republican senator lamar alexander from tennessee and here with me, senator mark warner from virginia. gentlemen, thank you both. we are now in the midst of a discussion about a third government shutdown in a year. let me start with you, senator warner, and ask you if you think there is a point where this is embarrassing? >> yes, it is. >> are we there? >> can we once again inflict on the country and the american people the spectacle of a near government shutdown. i sure as heck hope not. if we're going to have the discussion right now, it is about how we pay for emergency assistance, fema. the senate passed with the support of republicans fema legislation that would point -- >> the emergency management agency which helps people after hurricane irene, anything -- >> disasters. we've seen now come out of the house driven by a small group within the house of the tea party crowd that says hold on here, the deal we cut at the end of july that said we're not going to try to do another fight at least through the balance of this year about the budget numbers, that deal is no longer being put in place and there is this effort that's my way or the highway again. the senate is saying -- we're going to be back in on monday -- why should we in effect rebuild schools in iraq on the credit card. but expect rebuilding schools in joplin, missouri, at this moment in time have to be paid for in a way that's never been in any of the previous disasters assistance we've put out before. i think we need to find a resolution of this. the choices pay for it now or never pay for it. i think there are alternatives. let's do rolling ten-year average for relief. in the end of the day the most important thing is we should not give in to an 11th hour shutdown potential on friday. >> senator alexander, let me ask you if you buy into senator warner's premise that tea party folks are basically at fault but that the tea party backed folks in the house, are the ones behind this stalemate that is now threatening yet another government shutdown. do you agree with that? >> no, i don't. i'll give the senate democratic leader most of the credit. he manufactured a crisis all week about disaster when there's no crisis. everybody knows we're going to pay for every single penny of disaster aid that the president declares. and that the fema certifies. and the house sent over a bill that does that, and the senate should have approved it. what it did was take $1.5 billion of unobligated funds and say instead of adding to the debt we're not going to add to the debt when we do this. now what we should have been doing this past week is all we could do to create an environment so the work that senator warner, senator chambliss and others have done to reduce the debt by $4 trillion succeeds. that would have been a good use of the week instead of this chest-pounding and game-playing that's been going on. >> we kind of are where we are. and monday, as far as we understand it there will be a key test vote in the senate which is not -- the senate version at this point being we will accept the spending levels in the house bill for federal emergency management agency and other things, but we will not do the offsets or the pay-for-it parts of the house bill. it looks like that's not going to happen. it looks like that cloture vote, it is a test vote, will fail. what then, senator alexander? >> well, that's up to senator reid, senator mcconnell and others but let's be clear about this. we spent all week talking about this with senator reid saying we had to have $7 billion. when nobody certified that much damage, then on friday the republicans said, okay, let's vote today. let's not wait over the weekend so puts it off until monday. i don't like this business of sitting around blaming each other over such small potatoes. what we really ought to be doing is spending time to see if we can get $4 trillion in debt reduction. senator warner, chambliss and others have rounded up 37 senators equally divided by party who agree we should do that. we'd like our super committee to succeed. if we could do that, we could begin to get the economy in better shape and gain some confidence in the country. >> senator warner, back to the sort of larger question rather than the inner workings of this bill. and that is secretary geithner actually put it this week, he talked about how our global trading partners think that the u.s. political system looks manifestly broken. is there something that you could -- i mean you hear this. senator alexander saying we're talking about the wrong thing, this was a manufactured political debate, regardless of whether you agree with anybody, you think it was a manufactured political debate, too, only you blame different people. so why shouldn't we look at this and go, this should be the year of the anti-incumbent, just vote for any name you don't know. >> i agree with senator alexander that we need to get back to the single biggest thing we could do to restore confidence, both internationally and domestically, and that is to put in place a long-term, $4 trillion debt reduction plan. i think that would give confidence back to consumers to start spending, businesses who are -- actually large businesses who are sitting on a couple trillion dollars of cash on their balance sheets. i think that would be very, very positive. senator alexander's been very supportive of this effort. we've got an equal number of democrats, republicans trying to do this. but i would say, i mean, one point about who to blame or not to blame on this current, hopefully non-shutdown, is that there is a group -- and i do believe it is mostly centered in the house in terms of some of these tea party republicans -- who say on every issue, we're going to make this a make-or-break. we saw it on the faa when they shut down the federal aviation administration. we're seeing it now on this debate about fema. we should be able to have a legitimate debate about emergency aid. why link that into a government shutdown or not? so my hope is that cooler heads will prevail on this short-term so-called continuing resolution budget extension. but i do agree with senator alexander, we've got to get back to the bigger issue which is how do we send confidence back to the american public and to the markets. the only way we're going to get that done is if we actually, democrats and republicans, start being americans before they put on their partisan hats. >> it's sort of what we've been talking about for a long time now. it never quite seems to happen. let me move you to the so-called super committee which is looking to find -- has to find $1.2 trillion to $1.5 trillion in savings that everyone can agree on by the end of the year. this seems to me to be a very tall order and it also seems to me that we are seeing more and more stories now about how this is not going to happen. can you all afford to not come up with some agreement? because then, as you know, supposedly automatically budgets will be cut -- >> here's the circumstance. every economist that i've heard of has said that if we don't get $4 trillion in debt reduction over the next ten years, then we're not going to put our economy and get ourselves the debt-to-gdp ratio on a sustainable path. the challenge the super committee's got is we've cut about $1 trillion. even if they do $1.5 trillion more, that's really not going to be enough. so we've got to go ahead and say to them, go ahead and take on tax reform and generate some additional revenues, take on entitlement reform and make sure programs like medicare and social security are going to be there for the next 75 years. and what our group is trying to say, democrats, republicans alike, business leaders, if you will do that, we've got your back. if you will go big, we will stand there and be supportive. because this is a once in a long time opportunity, because whatever they come up with will get a straight up or down vote. that doesn't often happen. we can actually then cut out the rhetoric and see where you stand on this issue. >> senator alexander, i'll give you the last word on this. i know you hope that the super committee can go big or can at least go to what it's supposed to be doing. but i want you to tell me what you honestly think will be the work product of the super committee. >> well, i'm not sure exact -- i'm not sure the details but i'm hopeful. i'm optimistic. the budget agreement that we agreed on in august is better than people think. it took 40% of the budget, the discretionary part, everything from national defense to national parks, and it's got it going up over the next ten years at about the rate of inflation. 55% that's mandatory spending is going up at three times the rate of inflation. i hope that the super committee works on that part of the budget and i'm willing to define success in terms of what happens not just in the next ten years but the ten years and the ten years after that. because as mark said, we're looking at 75 years of solvency for medicare, social security and these programs. we've been making real progress in that area, i think that would be success as well. >> senators, thank you both so much. up next, another republican presidential debate that left more questions than answers. [ hayden ] what if there was a makeup that didn't just hide your breakouts... but actually made them go away. neutrogena skin clearing makeup has our proven blemish fighting formula so it clears your breakouts. now that's beautiful. neutrogena®. toi switched to a complete0, multivitamin with more. now that's beautiful. only one a day women's 50+ advantage has ginkgo for memory and concentration, plus support for bone and breast health. a great addition to my routine. [ female announcer ] one a day women's. oh, we call it the bundler. let's say you need home and auto insurance. you give us your information once, online... [ whirring and beeping ] [ ding! ] and we give you a discount on both. great! did i mention no hands in the bundler? bundling and saving made easy. now, that's progressive. call or click today. six republican presidential debates so far and a lot to ponder. rick perry's less than smooth performances. >> as a matter of fact, between books, your hard copy book, you said it was exactly what the american people needed to have that romney care given to them as you had in massachusetts. >> and michele bachmann's suggestion that the president is so weak, republicans can choose a conservative candidate instead of a moderate one deemed more electable. >> every four years conservatives are told that we have to settle. and it's anybody but obama. that's what we're hearing this year. i don't think that's true. we need to choose a candidate who represents conservatives and constitutional conservative positions. >> whether governor perry's texas decision to give college tuition assistance to the children of illegal aliens will cost him part of his conservative fan base. >> if you say that we should not educate children who have come into our state for no other reason than they've been brought there by no fault of their own, i don't think you have a heart. >> and has the rest of the republican field become just background noise? next up, a man who thought about but ultimately backed away from his own presidential bid, indiana governor mitch daniels.h m the pollen that made me sneeze. but with 24-hour zyrtec®, i get prescription strength relief from my worst allergy symptoms. so lily and i are back on the road again. with zyrtec®, i can love the air®. she won't eat eggs without hot sauce. she has kind of funny looking toes. she's always touching my hair. and she does this dancing finger thing. [ male announcer ] with advanced technology from ge, now doctors can diagnose diseases like breast cancer on a cellular level. so that women, like kristy's mom, can get personalized treatment that's as unique as she is. [ kristy ] she's definitely not like other moms. yeah, my mom is pretty weird. ♪ uh yeah, it's a chevy volt. so you're just here rubbing our nose in the fact that you don't have to buy gas? just plug in and go? that make you feel better? well i still pay about $1.50 a day in electricity... on average. you know he's just here to use the bathroom. customers only. no gas, no bathroom. ok, i'll buy gas. [ father ] whoa, what are you doing? thought these were electric? that didn't just hide your breakouts... but actually made them go away. neutrogena skin clearing makeup has our proven blemish fighting formula so it clears your breakouts. now that's beautiful. neutrogena®. [♪...] >> male announcer: now, for a limited time, your companion flies free, plus save up to 65%. call 1-800-sandals. conditions apply. joining me here in washington, republican indiana governor mitch daniels whose new book is called "keeping the republic, saving america by trusting americans." governor, thank you for being with us today. appreciate it. i want to start off talking a little bit about the republican field which you chose not to join, and ask you to size it up for me. you're watching from afar as most americans are watching right now. they're not as intensely involved as, say, reporters -- >> maybe further than some of them, yeah. >> who do you think is standing out at this point in the republican field? >> i don't have anything original to say. i think the two governors, romney and perry, seem to be getting the most attention. and for the moment at least, seem to be the dominant personalities in the race. >> i wanted to play you something that mike huckabee said about governor perry's performance in this past debate. >> i think rick perry is not prepared for the pressure of the presidential stage yet. rick perry's got a struggle ahead of him. >> now you add to this that the "weekly standard," a conservative publication, called it almost disqualifying, speaking of perry's performance in the debates. he seems to be fading partially because running for governor is not the same as running on the national scene. do you envision a republican party that at this point would pick rick perry? >> yeah, maybe. i think it's way too early to know or to issue -- pronounce last rights over one performance. there are so many of these -- too many maybe. so he hasn't been in it that long. i understand what governor huckabee was saying, but i'd cut him a little slack, give him a little time. >> one of the things that you have said over time is that you've been a little disappointed of the things the republican field has chosen to take up. the things that they're saying. what in particular do you think they're not talking about? >> i don't think they're yet talking about the things that the two senators just spoke to. the things that have a lot of zeros attached to them. the ones that are threatening to kill not just an economy but the entire idea of america, the idea of upward mobility from the bottom and tomorrow's better than today. and so i'm hoping that things will evolve. i tell you what brothers me a little bit, candy, the president is clearly in very desperate political shape. seems more clear every day. i worry a little bit, ironically, that the republican field or our nominee might look at that and say, i'll just play it safe. i'll get elected as the default option. he made it worse, i'm not him, vote for me. and that will be, i think, a huge missed opportunity, because there's a clock ticking. this is not a philosophical argument i make in this book or anywhere else, it is arithmetic. very encouraging here, by the way, to hear senator warner speak to it as clearly as he did. wish he were president. and so -- >> there's a little bipartisanship there. >> it's going to take that. the brits have a great saying -- now that the money has run out we shall have to begin to think. i just hope that even though the chances of electoral success next year look pretty good to me and better all the time, next year i think should be seized as an opportunity to talk with all our fellow americans about this common problem. it threatens us all, left to right, r & d. i hope our party -- i mean, this president's not going to do it, so it has to be our nominee. >> in fact you said in your book, that u.s. debt is more likely to sink democracy or personal freedom than in previous times when the soviet nuclear threat was seen as the big danger to democracy. just explain that in terms of what happens if we have a debt? because there is this feeling that, well, debt doesn't actually matter that much, there doesn't seem to be that kind of urgency -- there's politics to it, that's where the politics are right now, but is it where the urgency is? >> well, it needs to be. because it is a mathematical fact that we are headed for debt levels we cannot sustain. in simple terms -- >> what would that mean practically speaking? >> in practical terms, it would mean mortgage payments, just the interest payments we are making as a federal government, not to mention states or even private citizens, is consuming so much money, there's not enough left to hire anybody. it is consuming so much money on the public side that public education will be devastated. and it means -- >> so higher interest rates for -- on everything, and less money to spend on things -- >> too much money going to the mortgage and not enough to pay the rest of the necessities of life. it's very clear, and again, it's not ideological in any way, it's very clear that nations that go past a certain point of debt do not recover. the heart of my concern has to do with the promise of america and we're starting to see that fraying around the edges. without an america in which people really believe, even though things are tough today, things will be better, my kids will live better, without a stable hopeful middle class, we'll lose something even more precious than material well-being. we'll lose the self-governance that we've brought to the world. >> the underlying premise of your book, "keeping the republic, saving america by trusting americans," is that americans will step up to the plate if you just tell them the truth, if you lay it out for them. who's not telling the american public the truth and what is the truth, as you see it, that we can handle? >> well, the truth is that we just talked about the first -- again, arithmetic fact. it's not a matter of opinion, it's math. secondly, that we cannot possibly continue on with the safety net programs we have in exactly the current forms. >> social security, medicare, medicaid. >> that's right. we can say to today's seniors and those entering in the next few years, don't worry about a thing, nothing changes for you, you are good to go, a deal is a deal. now, please, join with us, and let's create new programs starting in the future that mean that the young people who are paying for your retirement have some protection, too. and those programs will have to look different. they'll have to stop sending checks to the wealthiest citizens, for instance. but you know, this is what mark warner was talking about, and senator alexander, and the sooner people from both sides concentrate on that problem, and then all of the rest of the grossly excessive federal government spending that we're doing, the sooner we can get on the way to an economic recovery. >> indiana governor mitch daniels, thank you for joining us. the book is "keeping the republic." i appreciate you stopping by. after the break, governor perry takes a distant second to herman cain in the florida straw poll. is perry's front-runner status in jeopardy? we're going to ask our panel. [ male announcer ] this is the network. a network of possibilities. excuse me? my grandfather was born in this village. [ cellphone translating ] [ male announcer ] in here, everyone speaks the same language. ♪ in here, forklifts drive themselves. ♪ look at the map. okay. [ male announcer ] in here, friends leave you messages written in the air. that's it right there. [ male announcer ] it's the at&t network. and what's possible in here is almost impossible to say. today i own 165 wendy's restaurants. and i get my financing from ge capital. but i also get stuff that goes way beyond banking. we not only lend people money, we help them save it. [ junior ] ge engineers found ways to cut my energy use. [ cheryl ] more efficient lighting helps junior stay open later... [ junior ] and serve more customers. so you're not just getting financial capital... [ cheryl ] you're also getting human capital. not just money. knowledge. [ junior ] ge capital. they're not just bankers... we're builders. [ junior ] ...and they've helped build my business. ♪ hush, little baby ♪ don't you cry ♪ soon the sun ♪ is going to shine ♪ [ male announcer ] toyota presents the prius family. ♪ walk if i want, talk if i want ♪ [ male announcer ] there's the original one... the bigger one... the smaller one... and the one that plugs in. they're all a little different, just like us. joining me now, susan page, washington bureau chief for "usa today," and michael crowley, deputy washington bureau chief for "time" magazine who we forgive for mispronouncing his name correctly. let me start with the florida straw poll results in which we saw herman cain take 37.1% of the folks voting down there, florida activists, followed by rick perry and mitt romney virtually tied, down to santorum, then ron paul. so this was characterized as a big surprise that herman cain was everybody's second choice and became everyone's first choice after the debate. you buy that? >> you know, i was down there, i talked to a lot of delegates yesterday coming in and, yes, a lot of delegates said i wanted to vote for rick perry but i was just concerned about his debate performance but even more that than that, about his stance on immigration. then he didn't show up with the speeches to the convention yesterday afternoon. herman cain was there, gave a real stem-winder of a speech. i think that just tipped people -- people were not quite ready to endorse rick perry. and her man cain gave them a place to be. >> because we're getting a lot of talk now that perry's fading and part of it is his -- we should just explain that his immigration stance being that he gives in-state tuition aid to the children of illegal aliens and this makes him -- this is not a popular position inside the -- certainly not a conservative position inside the republican party. do you think he is fading a la michele bachmann in that it is hard to see a path for her toward the nomination? or is this a temporary thing? >> well, i don't know if it is temporary. i would be very surprised if he disappeared the way bachmann has. it's been incredible the way she essentially vanished, in large part due to perry. but i think he has much more credibility as president. i think his electability case is much stronger. obviously he's run the largest or one of the largest states in the country for a decade. he has much more establishment support. but he's clearly failed to close the deal early on and i think you do still see there's this energy on the right of the republican party, this kind of desire for visceral satisfaction that you got first from donald trump, then from michele bachmann, and now maybe herman cain is having his moment. i think perry's profile has enough gaps in it on the right that that's still going to be sloshing around for a while. he's got to find a way to lock those people down if he wants to put romney away. >> we also had another straw poll from michigan this morning and i think it was 50% -- more than 50% here. 50.9%. the mackinaw straw poll, rick perry 16.8%. mitt romney runs away with it now. he's basically the hometown boy in michigan. his father was governor there and this is activist republicans, romney's a very familiar name. is there anything we should read into any of these straw polls? >> you don't want to overinterpret straw polls. 600 or 700 people in michigan voting in that, 400 or 500 in florida. the races continue to be unsettled. i think what we've learned this weekend is that there's going to be an extended fight between mitt romney and rick perry. they both have some strength. they both have a considerable amount of money, we think, the ability to raise money. and neither of them have closed the deal. that's what i take away from this weekend. >> mitt romney has been an incredibly lucky candidate. when he was coasting along as the front-runner, in the spring and summer the other candidates didn't want to engage too much with one another. they were introducing themselves. tim pawlenty famously shied away from an attack in the debate, a key reason he got out of the race. then when we got to the fall and it was time, now, everybody gang up on the front-runner. it wasn't romney anymore. it was rick perry. now herman cain steals the straw poll in florida. romney was not a force in the straul poll. we're not talking about that. then they go right to michigan, romney's home turf. one break after another. i think sooner or later we'll start a conversation about all these flip-flops. i think perry's going to look forward to that. and the pack is going to turn on romney as they have on perry. i think that's a little early to say perry's done and romney's got it. >> i saw a poll recently that said that about half of republicans said that they really want a conservative candidate, that that was their first choice over someone electable. i find that so hard to believe. when you look at the polling, certainly romney stands out as more electable, not that much more electable, but more electable than governor perry. what's going to win out in the end? >> well, i think you often see early on a desire for ideological credentials. i think back to the 2004 presidential campaign when howard dean was galloping away, democrats were so frustrated with president bush, but they were saying give him hell, somebody who tells it like it is, is going to be fearless, is really going to change things. finally they said john kerry, we don't love him but he might be the guy who could actually get the white house back. if i have to bet, i'd say that's the dynamic that will play out this time. but with 24-hour zyrtec®, i get prescription strength relief from my worst allergy symptoms. so lily and i are back on the road again. with zyrtec®, i can love the air®. that is better than today. since 1894, ameriprise financial has been working hard for their clients' futures. never taking a bailout. helping generations achieve dreams. buy homes. put their kids through college. retire how they want to. ameriprise. the strength of america's largest financial planning company. the heart of 10,000 advisors working with you, one-to-one. together, for your future. ♪ today i own 165 wendy's restaurants. and i get my financing from ge capital. but i also get stuff that goes way beyond banking. we not only lend people money, we help them save it. [ junior ] ge engineers found ways to cut my energy use. [ cheryl ] more efficient lighting helps junior stay open later... [ junior ] and serve more customers. so you're not just getting financial capital... [ cheryl ] you're also getting human capital. not just money. knowledge. [ junior ] ge capital. they're not just bankers... we're builders. [ junior ] ...and they've helped build my business. mathis team of guinea pigs to ty boanso to save some y, d inea pig: row...row. they genatectry, wch le me rf t. guinea pig: row...row.took one, 8 months to get the guin: ..row.ow...row. they genatectry, wch le me rf t. lile cbby one to yell row! guineaig: ro's kof strange. guinig: row...row. such a simple word... row. anncr: t an easierayof strange. save. get online. go to geico.com. get a quote. e u 15% or more on car insurance. helps defends against occasional justconstipation, diarrhea,alth probiotic cap a day gas and bloating. with three strains of good bacteria to help balance your colon. you had me at "probiotic." [ female announcer ] phillips' colon health. we are back with "usa today" susan page and "time" mag seeb's michael crowley. i was fascinated by your poll this week in "usa today," which showed now a majority of the americans do moderately or a lot blame president obama for the state of the economy. this to me was a pivotal moment, and a bad one for him. >> there's a point where a president owns an economy, even if he inherited a bad of indepy he bears some responsibility for economic woes. blame for president bush going down and i think at some point before the 2012 election those lines will intersect. and it will be obama's economy for good or ill. >> the white house issing looing at this, yes, we get it, we understand it. the fact of the matter is, that when people get a gander at rick perry or mitt romney, they will come back to the president. do you -- i mean it may be their only defense at this point, but do you buy that? >> i think it's their only hope, when unemployment is in this condition, when the public is no longer even assigning primary blame to the past administration, i think republicans have done a very effective job in suggesting for instance a stimulus program which i think there's a lot of evidence softened the blow of this terrible recession. republicans have done a great job suggesting it exacerbated the problem, obama's policies are making things worse as opposed to not sufficiently improving them. you have so little to run on in that area you have to do contrasts, you have to say do you want to go back to the policies of the past? these guys are out of the mainstream, there will probably be some character based attacks so i think we're in for a pretty meggive campaign as a result. >> what we're seeing of course that independents are just leaving him in droves, i think 52% of independents voted for him, his popularity, his approval rating is about 35%. i want to talk about a different part he cannot win without, that's his base. this was the president last night at a congressional black caucus dinner. >> i don't have time to feel sorry for myself. i don't have time to complain. i'm going to press on. i expect all of you to march with me and press on. take off your bedroom slippers. put on your marching shoes. shake it off. stop complaining. stop grumbling, stop crying. we are going to press on. we've got work to do. >> this is to his base, and we have seen a big drop in african-american support for the president, but realistically speaking, it is very hard for me to believe that the people that he complained are grumbling, complaining, crying are going to pick up election morning 2012 and go vote for the republican candidate. >> i think one of barack obama's great political strengths is his african-american base. they're going to be with him. i think his bigger problem are other parts of the coalition he put together, young people, hispanics, people who are not reliable voters. he got them to turn out last time. if they're not really enthused, will they turn out to vote? probably not. that's what history tells us. >> and that is going to be where their turnout effort is focused, which is the base which is where everybody focuses because those are the folks you know are going to vote for you and are deciding as they walk into the booth. the question is whether some of this base is going to be depressed and just staying home. >> you're not going to see a lot of african-americans defecting to the other party. the students, the young people, the new voters who came in the system last time in particular that's a big worry area for them, and you can imagine not to get too hypothetical but a scenario rick perry is the nominee, his record on immigration from the perspective of hispanic voters is not that bad and marco rube yo on the ticket, you can scramble that part of the equation. obama at his best, the fire people don't see, he looks joking, applause is rising as he's hitting his notes. that appealed to people in the last campaign if he can get himself away from the white house podium where he looks dry and professorial, it might work for him. >> fill in the blank, in order for president obama to win re-election he has to -- >> show some economic results. if they see unemployment and worried about the future for their kids, that is a hard environment for an incumbent to get reelected. >> and the strange way to think about it, angela merkel is with europe, and if europe and obama can't get this out, it would be hard to recover from another stepback in the global economy. >> thank you guys. >> thank you. up next the stop stories and fareed zakaria on "gps" talks to members of the united nations general assembly. there when you need them. helping millions of americans over the centuries. the strength of a global financial leader. the heart of a one-to-one relationship. together for your future. ♪ time for a check of today's top stories. two american hikers released from an iranian prison last week are back in the u.s. josh fattal and shane bauer landed at jfk airport last hour after being freed wednesday. they were held for more than two years in iran on spy charges. the men are scheduled to appear at a news conference in new york later this afternoon and cnn will have live coverage of the event. a mass grave believed to hold more than 1,200 victims from a 1996 massacre has been found in libya. the grave was discovered by libyan opposition fighters last month in tripoli. a member of libya's transitional government says it could take years to identify the victims. 19 people were killed today including two americans when a small plane crashed in nepal. it was returning from a sight-seeing tour when they hit a mountain and broke into pieces about seven miles from the airport. women in saudi arabia will be allowed to vote and run for office in future municipal elections. king abdullah made the announcement today on saudi state tv. although saudi arabia is holding elections thursday the change for women won't take effect until the next set of elections which haven't been scheduled. those are today's top stories. thank you for watching "state of the union." i'm candy crowley in washington. stay tuned for next week, dick cheney, joined by his daughter, liz cheney, coauthor of his book, next sunday, 9:00 a.m. and noon eastern. up next for our viewers here in the united states,ed frommed from fa red zakaria gps.

Related Keywords

Politics , Michael Crowley , State Of The Union , Magazine , Candy Crowley , Usa Today S , Susan Page , 2012 , Economy , Barack Obama , Ownership , Time , Majority , People , President , Running , Won T , George Bush , Saving America By Trusting Americans , 53 , 2008 , It , Advisor , David Plouffe , White House , U S , Campaign , All Of Us , Jobs Bill , Let , Country , Bill , Parts , Speech , Agreement , American Jobs Act , Congress , Wow , Money , Construction Workers , Work , Impact , Businesses , Workers , Pockets , Things , Question , Vote , Jobs Act In September , Republican , Terms , Support , Jobs , Infrastructure Bank , Number , Shove , Hypotheticals , Whole , Folks , Action , Class , Type , The End , Part , Anything , Constituents , House , Order , Term , Education , Industries , Strategy , Investment , Manufacturing , Lot , Something , Mark Zandi , Guy , Associated Press , Appearances , Audience , Moody S Analytics , People Quaut , Plan , Numbers , Drag , 2014 , 2013 , Place , Jobs Package , Statement Points , Stimulus , You Don T Act , 2015 , Growth , Schools , Small Business , Lead , Investments , Sports , Bridges , Investments In Roads , Point , States , Kids , Stimulus Money , Students Learning , Listen , Job Growth , Headwinds , Couple , Others , Headwind , Europe , Recovery , Economists , Foundation , 2 Million , Thing , Homes , Works , Kind , Homeowners , Debt Restructuring , Housing Industry , Water , Housing Market , Unemployment Rate , This Time Next Year , Twin , 9 , Forbearance , Jobs Speech , Home Loans , Items , Two , Everything , Proposal , Rental Housing , Communities , Millions , Ideas , Neighborhood Stabilization Fund , Tear Down , One , 2000 , 000 , Interest Rates , Particular , Areas , Refinancing Proposal , Advantage , Family , Idea , Demolition , Need , Rental , Repair , Estate , Interview , Pitch , Silver Bullet , Questions , Recession , Wasn , Wages Stagnate , Mission , Election , Team , Staff , Many , Changes , Cabinet , Direction , Approach , Admiral Mullen , Pakistan , Chiefs , Attack , Counterparts , Embassy , Policy , Pakistanis , Disarray , Secretary , Haqqani Network , Relationships , Safe Havens , Links , Little , Message , Government , Countries , Danger , Way , Situation , Arm , Stand , Deal , Progress , Cooperation , Leaders , Pakistan 20 , Al Qaeda , Osama Bin Laden , 30 , 20 , Aid , Case , Comfort , Safe Haven , Clinton , Else , Haven T You , Fight , Yes , Jeopardy , Region , Discussions , Foreign Policy , Security , Teams , Aim , Lamar Alexander , Government Shutdown , Mark Warner , Back , Brakes , Pricing , Thanks , Candy , Ground , Meineke , Three , Back On The Road , Discussion , Budget Showdown , Midst , Gentlemen , Virginia , Tennessee , Nashville , Republicans Fema , Emergency Assistance , Spectacle , Heck Hope , Senate , Emergency Management Agency , Disasters , Legislation , Hurricane Irene , Group , Tea Party , Crowd , Being , Budget Numbers , Balance , Least , July , Effort , Saying , Rebuilding Schools , My Way Or The Highway , Credit Card , Iraq , Resolution , Assistance , Choices , Missouri , Joplin , Relief , In The End , Average , 11th Hour Shutdown , Alternatives , 11 , Ten , Fault , Premise , Stalemate , Ones , Disaster , Crisis , Credit , Don T , Democratic Leader , Everybody , Penny , Debt , Environment , Unobligated Funds , 1 5 Billion , 3 5 Billion , Chambliss , Chest Pounding , Use , Game Playing , 4 Trillion , Trillion , Test Vote , Levels , Version , Cloture Vote , Offsets , Reid , Let S Vote Today , Damage , Nobody , Senator Mcconnell , 6 Billion , 7 Billion , Weekend , Business , Debt Reduction , Doing , Mother , Potatoes , Senators , Super Committee , Party , 37 , Confidence , Shape , Partners , Workings , Sort , Trading , Political System , Debate , Anybody , Name , Anti Incumbent , Shouldn T , Spending , Long Term , Consumers , Domestically , Democrat , Balance Sheets , Cash , Issue , Some , Current , Faa , Link , Emergency Aid , Public , Hope , Markets , Cooler Heads , Continuing Resolution Budget Extension , Done , Hats , Everyone , Savings , 2 Trillion , 1 2 Trillion , 1 5 Trillion , 5 Trillion , Stories , Budgets , Circumstance , Economist , Has , Path , More , Challenge , Tax Reform , Debt To Gdp Ratio , 1 Trillion , Programs , Social Security , Business Leaders , Medicare , Entitlement Reform , Revenues , 75 , Doesn T , Opportunity , Once , Rhetoric , Up Or Down Vote , Word , Work Product , Budget , Budget Agreement , Details , 40 , Times , Rate , Defense , Parks , 55 , Success , Inflation , Solvency , Area , Up Next , Makeup , Hayden , Breakouts , Skin Clearing Makeup , Blemish Fighting Formula , Neutrogena , Complete0 , Toi , Multivitamin , Women , Announcer , Bundler , Women S , Concentration , Breast Health , Memory , Ginkgo , Bone , Addition , Routine , 50 , Ding , Both , Auto Insurance , Discount , Information , Beeping , Whirring , Progressive , Bundling , Hands , Rick Perry , Debates , Performances , Six , Fact , Mitt Romney , Michele Bachmann , Matter , Hard Copy Book , Books , Suggestion , Care , Massachusetts , Candidate , Electable , Conservatives , Four , Children , Aliens , Fan Base , Positions , College Tuition Assistance , Texas , Reason , Field , Cain , Mitch Daniels , Indiana , Heart , Rest , Pollen , Background Noise , Bid , 24 , Road , Allergy Symptoms , Hair , Zyrtec , Hot Sauce , Toes , Eat Eggs , Mom , Dancing Finger Thing , Doctors , Level , Technology , Breast Cancer , Diseases , Age , Kristy , Gas , Treatment , Uh Yeah , Moms , Nose , Chevy Volt , Bathroom , Electricity , Customers , On Average , 1 50 , 50 , Father , Didn T , Thought , Save , Companion , Conditions , Sandals , 1 800 Sandals , 1 , 800 , 65 , Book , Governor , Republic , Bit , Deputy Washington , Reporters , Say , Governors , Attention , Race , Mike Huckabee , Performance , Personalities , Pressure , Stage , Weekly Standard , Struggle , Publication , Scene , Rights , He Hasn T , Slack , Disappointed , Zeros , Bottom , Mobility , Nominee , Me A Little Bit , It Safe , Clock Ticking , Option , Default , Argument , Arithmetic , Anywhere , Chances , Bipartisanship , Brits , Problem , Americans , Left To Right , Dr , Democracy , Threat , Freedom , D , Soviet , Debt Doesn T , Urgency , Feeling , Debt Levels , Citizens , Interest Payments , Mortgage Payments , Side , Mortgage , Life , Necessities , Nations , Concern , Fraying , Edges , Promise , Middle Class , Self Governance , Well Being , World , Truth , Plate , First , Eforms , Math , Opinion , Safety Net , Medicaid , Nothing Changes , Little Baby Don T , Seniors , Checks , Instance , Protection , Retirement , Sides , Straw Poll , Break , Florida , Herman Cain , Network , Front Runner Status , Is Perry , Second , Panel , Keeping The Republic , Possibilities , Grandfather , Village , Cellphone Translating , Messages , Language , Forklifts , Map , Friends , Stuff , Financing , Restaurants , Banking , Ge Capital , Wendy S , At T , 165 , Engineers , Lighting , Energy Use , Capital , Junior Stay , Ways , Knowledge , Human Capital , Junior , Bankers , Builders , Hush , The Sun , Original , Prius Family , Toyota , Bureau Chief , Straw Poll Results , Activists , Down To Santorum , Ron Paul , 37 1 , Choice , Delegates , Surprise , Immigration , Stance , Speeches , Convention , Stem Winder , Talk , Position , Immigration Stance , Tuition Aid , Nomination , Way Bachmann , La , Largest , Electability Case , Credibility , Desire , Energy , Establishment Support , Satisfaction , Donald Trump , Michigan , Profile , Gaps , Sloshing , Romney Away , Mackinaw , Hometown Boy , 50 9 , 16 8 , Straw Polls , Strength , Races , Voting , 400 , 500 , 600 , 700 , Front Runner , Candidates , Spring , Coasting , Summer , Ability , Amount , Another , Tim Pawlenty , Everybody Gang , It Wasn T Romney Anymore , Conversation , Force , Romney S Home Turf , Flip Flops , Pack , Half , Polling , Someone , Howard Dean , Credentials , 2004 , John Kerry , Somebody , Dynamic , Bet , Futures , Buy Homes , Bailout , Generations , College , Clients , Dreams , Ameriprise Financial , 1894 , Planning , Company , Advisors , 10000 , Future , Row , They Genatectry , Row , Mathis , Inea Pig , Wch Le Me Rf T Guinea Pig , Guinea Pigs , Ty Boanso , 8 , Quote , Car Insurance , Ro S Kof Strange , Guin , Row Ow , Guineaig , Guinig , Wch Le Me Rf T Lile , Anncr T An Easierayof Strange , Geico Com , Eu , 15 , Strains , Probiotic , Day Gas , Colon , Colon Health , Bloating , Diarrhea , Justconstipation , Bacteria , Alth Probiotic Cap , Phillips , Mag Seeb , Poll , Blame , Bad , Indepy , Responsibility , Woes , Lines , Hill , Issing Looing , Gander , Unemployment , Job , Stimulus Program , Administration , Condition , Evidence , Blow , Policies , Contrasts , Independents , Guys , Attacks , Result , Character , Mainstream , Droves , Course , Pretty Meggive , 52 , Base , Approval Rating , Popularity , Last Night , Congressional Black Caucus , 35 , Going To Press On , Me And Press On , Bedroom Slippers , Dinner , Marching Shoes , Shake It Off , Stop Complaining , Stop Grumbling , African American , Complaining , Drop , Grumbling , Voters , Strengths , Coalition , Hispanics , Turnout , History , Home , Booth , Students , Worry Area , System , African Americans Defecting , Rube Yo , Record , Scenario , Perspective , Ticket , Equation , Best , Podium , Joking , Applause , Notes , Fire People Don T See , Re Election , Professorial , Blank , Fill , Results , Incumbent , Angela Merkel , Stop Stories , Gps , Talks , Stepback , Fareed Zakaria , Members , Relationship , Global Financial Leader , United Nations General Assembly , Hikers , Check , Prison , Jfk Airport , Josh Fattal , Shane Bauer , Iranian , Men , News Conference , Massacre , Spy Charges , Event , Victims , Coverage , New York , Cnn , Mass Grave , 1200 , 1996 , Fighters , Grave , Member , Libyan Opposition , Libya , Tripoli , 19 , Plane , Airport , Women In Saudi Arabia , Sight Seeing Tour , Pieces , Mountain , Office , Nepal , Seven , Elections , Haven T , Announcement , Change , Effect , Set , King Abdullah , Saudi State Tv , Saudi Arabia , Dick Cheney , Coauthor , Liz Cheney , Next Sunday , 00 , Shutdown , Agenda , Campaign Mode , Stairdown , Batchmann Tumbles , Warrior , Presidential Field , Viewers , Zakaria Gps , Noon Eastern , Fa Red , Ed Frommed , 408 ,