Transcripts For CNNW CNN Newsroom With Carol Costello 20150806

Discovers. Discover discovered. Plus all of us running owe voters an explanation about who we are and what we plan to do if elected. And we thought it was a scary movie. Mistake down a man wielding an ax and a pellet gun at a nashville Movie Theater. Is it safe to see a movie . Lets talk live in the cnn newsroom. And good morning. Im carol costello. Thank you so much for joining me. The press secretary for malaysias transport minister telling cnn aircraft window parts, airplane seat cushions and Aluminum Materials have been found on reunion island in the west indian ocean. Its not clear if this is from that missing Malaysian Airlines flight 370. Reunion island was where part of an aircraft wing was found last week. Malaysia says its now conclusively confirmed that this wing part is a flaperon from a boeing 777. The french minister was more definitive though, saying more tests need to be done. A woman whose mother was on board the plane says she doesnt believe malaysias prime minister. I dont believe it. Im furious. And i think this announcement is very irresponsible. Lets talk about the breaking news this morning. Reporter im here about 120 miles away from reunion island where they discovered that flaperon. The reason were here is we got a chance to go up on a coast guard flight over the island to look for any signs of mh370. We got back just an hour ago. I tell you, being up in the air really sort of illustrated the challenges these searchers are facing. The water is expansive, the coastline is long. And this is a very tedious process. We were up there with a team of three. And they managed to spot what they said was a white object. One of the pilots just caught it in the corner of his eye. They turned the plane around toe try and find it again and it had disappeared. What they ended up doing was call into a dispatch on the island and they put out a boat to try and find it again. But by the time we landed still no signs of this debris. And it really illustrated just how challenging this search is. Thank you so much. Like i said at the top of the show though more debris was found on reunion island very near the island where Erin Mcloughlin is now. I want to talk about that debris for the moment. With me now cnn aviation analyst peter goals. Welcome, peter. Good morning, carol. Good morning. Are you surprised more debris was found . I am a little bit. But it has not been confirm that this debris is from flight 370. The malaysians are anxious to put a wrap on this portion of the identification. They moved quickly to identify the wing piece prior to anyone else was willing to do that. I think we ought to treat these latest discoveries with a little degree of skepticism. Lets see if theyre confirmed. Yeah. Because an airplanes windshield is a little more tricky to identify where that came from right . There should be serial numbers. But the issue is ive seen some distant video of the piece. It did not look right to me. But lets get it to the investigators, people who have the engineering drawings to compare the piece to. Lets be a little bit methodical about this. And then they said aluminum material was found and also seat cushions. Could seat cushions survive for that length of time in the ocean . Sure. A seat cushion could last over 500 days. And a seat cushion would be far easier to identify. You would know what kind of material if it had the exterior covering on it you could identify it through that. But again, i think this was a spokesperson for the minister of transportation who was not on reunion island. Theyre doing this through photographs at best. Id say we ought to take it slow down the train just a little bit. Will do. Thanks for your insight as always. I appreciate it. Onto politics tonight. 17 candidates descend on cleveland. Tonights objective is clear. Steel the spotlight from donald trump. But before that theres a socalled happy hour debate with the candidates who did not make the cut for prime time. And while the donald wont be anywhere near that stage, hes still rubbing some candidates the wrong way. In august of the year before the election its about name id its about celebrity. Its about having a talk show. Its about being related to president s. If lebron james were in this mix, hed be in the 7 00 debate and the governor of ohio would be with me. I dont know about that. Tonights showdown gives candidates a chance to test their positions on everything from domestic issues to the economy. Sarah murray is in cleveland. One burning question. We understand that this sound, a buzzer might be used to cut candidates off. Reporter theyre reporting that one of the things theyre considering to keep these candidates in line tonight is to use the buzzer the shot clock, to keep them on their time. Well have to see if that plays out. Campaigns are telling me theyre aware this is going to be a tricky format. You have 60 seconds to answer the questions, 30 second for a rebuttal. Thats a short amount of time even if youre not trying to navigate around donald trump, who is so unpredictable. What is donald trump going to do on that stage . When you talk to these other campaigns they are not interested in picking a fight with him. They realize he does hit back the hardest when he is attacked and they dont want to pick those fights. This is the biggest audience a lot of them have had throughout this president ial debate. So were going to be keeping an eye on all of that tonight as well as whether jeb bush can recover from his recent stumbles and have a breakout performance. How have they been preparing . John kasich lives here. It was a pretty easy commute for him. The rest of them are showing up in town. Some of them are hunkering down and doing debate prep today. Others are praising money. Others like donald trump flying in this afternoon and flying out the same night. As usual hes doing his own thing. Still to come in the newsroom, though the donald will be literally center stage at tonights debate a lot of eyes will be on jeb bush. Can he bounce back from recent gaffes . Well talk about that next. So youre a Small Business expert from at t . Yeah, give me a problem and ive got the solution. Well, we have 30 years of customer records. Our cloud can keep them safe and accessible anywhere. My drivers dont have time to fill out forms. Tablets. Keep it all digital. Were looking to double our deliveries. Our fleet apps will find the fastest route. Oh, and your boysenberry apple scones smell about done. Ahh, youre good. I like to bake. Add new Business Services with at t and get up to 500 in total savings. Every Auto Insurance policy has a number. But not every Insurance Company understands the life behind it. Those who have served our nation. Have earned the very best service in return. Usaa. We know what it means to serve. Get an Auto Insurance quote and see why 92 of our members plan to stay for life. I called for help as soon as i saw her. I found her wandering miles from home. When the phone rang at 5am i knew it was about mom. I see how hard its been on her at work and i want to help. For the 5 million americans living with alzheimers and millions more who feel its effects. Lets walk together to make an even bigger impact and end alzheimers for good. Find your walk near you at alz. Org walk. When broker chris hill stays at laquinta he fires up the free wifi with a network thats now up to 5 times faster than before so he can rapidly prepare his presentation. And when he perfects his pitch, do you know what chris can do . And that is my recommendation. Lets see if hes ready. He can swim with the sharks hes ready. La quinta inns suites take care of you, so you can take care of business. Book your next stay at lq. Com la quinta many wrinkle creams come with high hopes, but hope. Doesnt work on wrinkles. Neutrogena® rapid wrinkle repair has the fastest retinol formula. To work on fine lines and even deep wrinkles in just one week. Neutrogena®. Tonights big no huge debate will give candidates a chance to overcome Donald Trumps bombastic policy free style. And no one needs to do that more than jeb bush. Once a shoein, a gaffe prone bush is stumbling into this forum. Ive got a tshirt that says at the jeb swag store that says my dads the greatest man alive. If you dont like it ill take you outside. Knowing what you know now, would you have authorized the invasion . I would have. And so would Hillary Clinton. Knowing what we know now, what would you have done . I would not have engaged. I would not have gone into iraq. And while we know where bush and his rivals will be standing on stage tonight, we dont know what they will be asked. Twitter is stepping up with the hashtag, debate questions we want to hear. Colin asks quote, which of your relatives did worse as president . And one famous comedian is also taking a jab at the gop field. Kathy griffin asks how does it feel to officially be in Kathy Griffins act . Our next guest will be in the audience tonight. Welcome, paul. Good morning, carol. So has anyone offered to buy your ticket . The tickets are getting more and more popular. Ive had quite a few people asking yeah. No money offers though. So seriously jeb bush hes got a lot of ground to make up. He has to have a great performance, right . Hes got to start moving, you know in the right direction. And with the maximum of nine or ten minutes before they get the buzzer i think its going to be really hard for anyone to gain traction. None of us really know what to expect tonight. Thats what makes it so exciting. We are all in kind of uncharted territory. Weve never had a reality star rat at the center of a political debate before. Im trying to decide whether mr. Bush standing next to trump is a good thing for mr. Bush or a bad thing. Well the camera will be there a lot. You probably dont want to be at the wings of this debate since you will look like youre not really a part of it. Youve got ten people. Youre not going to get a lot of closeups there. Being next to him, yeah good the camera is on you. But also likely to be overshadowed. Do you think trump will go on the attack . Do you think hell actually talk about policy. We know he hasnt prepared only because he says he hasnt prepared. Maybe he did. I dont know. I wonder whether donald trump knows what hes going to do tonight. He seems to like to wing it. He did do a somewhat substantive interview with bloomberg. Hes a businessman, so you could see some substance there. Hes going to feel it out. If hes attacked expect him to attack back rather viciously. You know perhaps we havent talked about it much but ted cruz is a great debater, right . In college he was masterful at that. He might be an interesting presence at that. Youve got a few people up on stage who are fairly talented and experienced debaters. This isnt your standard debate format. Theyve probably never been in a debate with ten other candidates. Its not as much a debate as a sound bite war. Youre going to get 60 second to Say Something. And we all know what you say during the debate isnt as important as whats reported that you said at the debate the next day. Youre going to be trying to get that sound bite for the next nights coverage. And make it perfect. Because if you Say Something wrong or its a gaffe, that too is going to be played over and over again. Well check back with you. Thank you so much. Checking some other top stories. A manhunt underway in louisiana after a shreveport officer was shot and killed. The officer was responding to a call about a prowler when he was shot six times. A helicopter is now assisting in the search. Bounty hunters botch their search when they show up at the wrong house. Guess whose house it was . It belonged to the chief of police in phoenix. 11 people with two different bond Recovery Companies ran to his front door demanding he come out. Some of them were armed. The bondsmen were looking for a drug say did not match the chief of polices description at all. So far one of the bondsmen has been arrested. In japan tens of thousands gathering at hiroshima peace park. Later today u. S. Ambassador Caroline Kennedy will attend a Memorial Ceremony with the japanese prime minister. In nashville a man attacks moviegoers with an ax and pepper spray, next. You are so out of here ahh. The complete balanced nutrition of great tasting ensure. With nine grams of protein. And 26 vitamins and minerals. Ensure. Take life in. Woman this is not exactly what i expected. Man definitely more murdery than the reviews said. Captain obvious this is a creepy room. Man oh hey, captain obvious. Captain obvious you should have used hotels. Com. Their genuine guest reviews are written by guests who have genuinely stayed there. Instead of people who lie on the internet. Son look, a finger. Captain thats unsettling. Man you think . Captain all the time. Except when i sleep. Which i would not do here. Hotels. Com would have mentioned the finger. My name is chris hughes and i am a certified arborist for pg e. I oversee the patrolling of trees near power lines and roots near pipes and underground infrastructure. At pg e wherever we work we work hard to protect the environment. Getting the job done safely so we can keep the lights on for everybody. Because i live here i have a deeper connection to the community. And i want to see the Community Grow and thrive. Every year we work with cities and schools to plant trees in our communities. The environment is there for my kids and future generations. Together, were building a better california. Female announcer youre on the right track to save big during sleep trains triple choice sale. For a limited time you can choose up to 48 months interestfree financing on a huge selection of tempurpedic models. Or choose to save hundreds on Simmons Beautyrest mattress sets. You can even choose 300 in free gifts with sleep trains most popular Stearns Foster mattresses. The triple choice sale ends soon at sleep train. Sleep train your ticket to a better nights sleep we turn now to that terrifying attack inside a nashville area Movie Theater as a man carrying a real gun snapped. Listen to the 911 call. I was in the Movie Theater like literally a minute or two ago and this shady looking guy stood up with like two bags and he walked toward the back of the theater and he pulled out like a hatchet and started attacking this family. Then he pulled out a gun and we all ran out of the theater. That attacker Vincente Montano was shot by police his mother confirming his long history of mental illness. Police say he pointed this at him and pulled the trigger. It looks real. Its actually a pellet gun. Nick valencia is in nashville this morning. Reporter this is the second Movie Theater shooting in the United States in two weeks, a fact that is not lost on people here in nashville. Its really unnerved and unsettled this community. People we have spoken to say theyre proud of their Police Department and how quickly they responded, certainly preventing something that could have been much worse. This shady looking guy stood up with like two bags and he walked toward the back of the theater. Reporter a frantic 911 call released this morning, revealing the chilling moments inside the nashville theater. He pulled out a hatchet and started attacking this family. Then he pulled out a gun and we all ran out of the theater. Reporter Vincente Montano armed with an air soft gun, a hatchet and cans of pepper spray. We heard screams coming from another theater. We thought it was a scary movie. Reporter attacking this father slicing his shoulder with an ax and causing minor injury. His wife and child doused with pepper spray. Im grateful to the nashville Police Department for their Fast Response and the fact that no one else got injured. Reporter two officers working a car crash right in front of the theater. The officers stopped what they were doing and ran to the theater. Our response was probably 60 to 90 seconds. Reporter motano raised his gun. Minutes later the swat team converged into the theater donning gas masks when the suspect tried to escape. A firefighter fight ensued. The gunman tried to go out through a rear door. There were other officers waiting. [ gunfire ] reporter montano was believed to have been homeless. His mother filed a missing persons report with the texas rangers, saying her son was a diagnosed paranoid schizophrenic and had a hard time taking care of himself. Carol . Checking some other top stories for you at 26 minutes past a michigan judge says he wants more time to consider whether or not to go easy on a teenage sex offender. He admits to having sex with a 14 girl who lied about her age on a dating act. Michigan law allows discretion in sentencing teens convicted of sex offenses. Human rights group are sounding the alarm over video that purports to showing mo mar inging gaddafis son being tortured in prison. Hes being held in pretrial detention along with other officials of the gaddafi regime. Army helicopters crashed in the Southern Province along the pakistani border. Donald trump has been touting his great business tactics every chance he gets. But will being a great businessman make him a great president . Well talk about that next. Fifty ok . All right. The big debate set to get underway in just a matter of hours. The arena in cleveland could be a make or break moment for anyone in a crowded republican field. Donald trump says he plans to be himself. And by that he means a mega rich ultra successful businessman who is able to force countries like mexico to build a great big wall because he says so. Its simple. Theyre taking in billions and billions of dollars. Im going to say, mexico guess what this is not going to continue. Youre going to pay for the wall. And ive said they are going to pay for the wall and they will pay for the wall. They will pay for that wall. We expect trump to play up his businessman credentials big tonight. Here to talk about that cnn president ial historian douglas brink brinkley. Youre the big business guy. You listen to donald trump. He says i can force mexico to do that because im tough and theyll do it because i say so. First of all, theres Business People and then theres donald trump. Lumping them back together this is a problem that Business People have when they go into politics. They always say theyre going to bring rational Business Practices to politics. But its not that easy. They want to bring accountability and transparency. Thats fine. Were all for that. But its more complicated. Outcomes take a lot longer. Sometimes its a bad mix. Sometimes it can be a bad mix because you do sort of have to be a politician right . You cant just go tell a lawuw lawmaker you do it because i say so. And the lawmaker says no im going to make it as hard as only for you because youve just done that. Ceos like to bark orders and have things move. Doesnt work that way in washington. It isnt a good idea for a president to be deeply unable to handle the kind of tick tokck more likely than not, you will find candidates most famously franklin roosevelt, warring against factors of great wealth. Theres a populace message from the left theres a lot more middle class americans than there are rich people. Billionaires seem to live in their own fantasy bubble. Is that true andy . Fantasy bubble maybe is a little strong. But i dont disagree. If you think about it just to echo what douglas was saying ceos are used to a command and control system. Everyone reports up to them. In washington as president you also have to deal with the Judicial Branch and congress. If youre not used to being clab ra ra collaborative, youre not going to succeed. I think about Mike Bloomberg in new york city was very good at transformation transformational government. Otherwise the record is sort of mixed. Warn harding was a newspaper publisher. Herbert hoover ozwas a mining tycoon. George h. W. Bush was an oilman. How would historians rate them . Its a weak list that you just read. And i think George Herbert walker bush was also the child of Prescott Bush who was already a u. S. Senator. And kind of had politics in the family blood. Our first president to graduate from annapolis as much as a business person. So the two youre looking at were failures. Warn hard Warren Harding a terrible failure. Herbert hoover a failure also. Trump is a showman and hes used media to present himself and make money. And a billionaire. There are connections to reagan. And perot seemed to me more real than a traditional doesbusinessman. On the other hand its kind of nice to think that donald trump could go to russia and sit down with Vladimir Putin and Vladimir Putin would respect his toughness and they would negotiate a deal. In that instance maybe donald trump would be effective. Id like to see how he would do in china. That would be very interesting. Where bluster does not work so well. On the other hand he does speak his mind. I think its interesting also to look at president s who have been successful. We always bash politicians and say how terrible the process is. Look at some of our stronger president s. Ronald reagan fdr. They were politicians they were both right . Its very much of a mixed bag. You have an actor politician. Fdr professional politician. Jfk, who came from nowhere. Barack obama who came from nowhere. Still to come in the newsroom Vladimir Putin burning mad about russian sanctions. Now hes cracking down on american food. It takes a lot of work. To run this business. But i really love it. Im on the move all day long. And sometimes, i just dont eat the way i should. So i drink boost® to get the nutrition that im missing. Boost complete nutritional drink has 26 essential vitamins and Minerals Including calcium and vitamin d to support strong bones and 10 grams of protein to help maintain muscle. All with a great taste. I dont plan on slowing down any time soon. Stay str i called for help as soon as i saw her. I found her wandering miles from home. When the phone rang at 5am i knew it was about mom. I see how hard its been on her at work and i want to help. For the 5 million americans living with alzheimers and millions more who feel its effects. Lets walk together to make an even bigger impact and end alzheimers for good. Find your walk near you at alz. Org walk. When i lay in my tempurpedic contour, then i slowly feel it start to kind of wrap itself around me. My mind just goes kind of blank and the next thing i know its morning. With tempurflex youve got the spring and bounce of a traditional mattress and it also adjusts to my body. My cloud feels so comfortable. It feels like somebodys hugging you. How can a bed do that . This is the best investment of your life because this is where dreams are made. vo theres a tempurpedic for everyone. Find the feel thats right for you. When broker chris hill stays at laquinta and fires up free wifi, with a network thats now up to 5 times faster than before you know what he can do . Lets see if hes ready. He can swim with the sharks book your next stay at lq. Com female announcer youre on the right track to save big during sleep trains triple choice sale. For a limited time you can choose up to 48 months interestfree financing on a huge selection of tempurpedic models. Or choose to save hundreds on Simmons Beautyrest mattress sets. You can even choose 300 in free gifts with sleep trains most popular Stearns Foster mattresses. The triple choice sale ends soon at sleep train. Sleep train your ticket to a better nights sleep during the 70s television saw a lot of big changes. It got real. The Worlds Largest antidisco rally. They had a disco demolition night. All of the disco records that you brought tonight, weve got them in a giant box. Were going to blow them up real good. It turned into this miniriot. It got really out of control. I would like to say disco did not suck. Disco was a revolutionary force. The 70s tv gets real, tonight right here on cnn. Lets talk about russia. Billions of dollars worth of food going up in flames simply because it comes from outside of russia. Putin ordered a crackdown of food imports from the United States canada and australia in response to western sanctions over ukraine. Reporter thats right. In fact the ban on those Food Products from the u. S. And other countries has been enforced now for more than a year. In any upscale russian supermarket you could still get foreign food. All thats now about to change because the kremlin is extremely irritated about the fact that shops are smukggling this food in. And theyre taking steps now to stop it and destroy the foozd they seize on the border. Its the start of a new crackdown on the import of foods russia has branded illegal. Bacon seized at the border and incinerated. It was produced in denmark, says this russian agricultural official. It was meant to be sold on the territory of ukraine, not russia. Theres outrage that at a time of Economic Hardship this perfectly good food will be destroyed. One online petition signed by tens of thousands of russians called for seized products to be distributed to the needy like pensioners or the unemployed. Its been more than a year now since the kremlin banned imports of some western foods in retaliation over sanctions imposed by the west over the ukraine. Products have been smuggled in and discreetly sold at high end supermarkets like this one. But with the new crackdown, that may no longer been tolerated. One group has been highlighting the violations raiding the stores still stocking the food. These nuts are on a list of banned products. This activist told the camera. Critics say the real danger might be enforcing the food ban so strictly with the risk of inflating russian food prices even higher. The russian public is of course sensitive to those inflating prices. And that petition i mentioned in that report its now been signed by 275,000 people in russia. Not exactly a revolution perhaps. But in a country where people are usually very supportive of the kremlin, it just shows how unpopular this move to burn the food is becoming. I was just going to ask you, is putins favorability rating still extraordinarily high . Reporter absolutely. According to the polls ive seen its somewhere in the region still of 86 . Absolutely incredible. Theres a sense in which, despite the sanctions imposed by the west on russia despite the other problems in the International Community, putin himself remains popular. But its exactly this kind of issue that threatens to derail that. So i expect the kremlin will be watching this petition and the fallout from this latest move very closely indeed. Still to come in the newsroom, the final show tonight for the man who dared to say out loud what the rest of america was thinking. What the [ bleep ] is going on here . [ cheers and applause ] the world is demonstrably worse than when i started. Have i caused this . We go live outside of his studio. Well take you there, next. High protein. I help you recharge with Nutritious Energy and strength. Ill take that. Yeeeeeah new ensure active high protein. 16 grams of protein and 23 vitamins and minerals. Ensure. Take life in. Female announcer youre on the right track to save big during sleep trains triple choice sale. For a limited time you can choose up to 48 months interestfree financing on a huge selection of tempurpedic models. Or choose to save hundreds on Simmons Beautyrest mattress sets. You can even choose 300 in free gifts with sleep trains most popular Stearns Foster mattresses. The triple choice sale ends soon at sleep train. Sleep train your ticket to a better nights sleep checking some top stories for you at 52 minutes past. In new york the death toll is climbing following an outbreak of leekonaires disease. Eight people have died from the disease which has been described as a severe form of bacterial pneumonia. Health officials have traced the outbreak to the south bronx after five cooling towers tested positive for the bacteria. In all, 92 people have been hospitalized 48 of them treated and released. The persian gulf will be carrierfree for just a few months. U. S. Navy Officials Say needed maintenance and budget cuts mean they will not be able to keep an Aircraft Carrier in the gulf for much of the upcoming fall season. The gap is leaving the navy without a highprofile presence as a nuclear deal with iran is center stage. U. S. Military officials insist there will be no impact on operations there saying the air force can step in if needed. Take a look at this picture taken by the mars rover. The internet is abuzz over that Strange Object in the righthand corner. There it is. Is it a crab . An alien spider . Could it prove there is life on mars . Scientists say no, theyre chalking it up to the brains ability to see shapes out of random objects kind of like seeing pictures in the crowd. Ever since the first televised debate between Richard Nixon and john f. Kennedy weve been watching and waiting for those memorable moments. Reporter dont we tend to watch debates hoping to see a train wreck . Instead, were left with memorable moments, sarah palin winking. How long have i been at this . Like five weeks . Reporter Ronald Reagan demanding the sound system not be turned off. I am paying for this microphone. Reporter a line he picked up dont you shut me off. Reporter from Spencer Tracy in state of the union. Tv magnifyies everything from the sweat glistening on nixons chin he had to wipe out to al gores exaggerated thats what a governor gets to do. Reporter exasperated sighs. Recess nated edd edd by snl. There were some unforgettable forgetful moments. Commerce education, and the whats the third one there . Reporter rick perrys oops moments. Oops. Reporter and Arizona Governor jan brewerss brain freeze. That we could possibly do. Reporter and this was just her opening statement. You know what a televised debate isnt the time for . Checking the time as president george bush did. How has the National Debt reporter debates are a time for memorable zingers. Senator, youre no jack kennedy. Reporter and one liners for instance from a relatively unknown candidate for vice president. Who am i . Why am i here . Reporter and whatever you do candidates dont invade your opponents personal space. As Hillarys Senate rival once did. Would you give me stand up right now. Well shake on this i want your signature. Reporter or when al gore crept up on george bush. But can you get things done . And i believe i can. Reporter there is nothing like debatable behavior to liven up a debate. Theres differences. Youre likable enough hillary. Reporter jeanne moos cnn. Are we not doing the talent portion . Reporter new york. Oh, jon stewart signs off from the daily show tonight after 16 years of satire that skewers the high and mighty. Im going to miss watching you on this show but i think the most reliable way to take a good thing and make it go bad is to hold onto it too long. I think thats right. So you got to let it go and also its really time to go. If were being honest. Cnns Brian Stelter is outside the Comedy Central studio to tell us more. Good morning. Reporter hey, good morning. I dont think jon stewart is here yet but many many of his fans are, carol. Take a look at the line. Usually theres not lines out here until the afternoon but some folks were here at 2 00 a. M. Getting ready hoping to be in the audience for the final show. By the way, it doesnt tape until 6 00 p. M. Tonight. Of course it airs at 11 00. You will see theyre loading the gear in and out of the studio getting ready here preparing for the taping. Its interesting because trying to keep the actual plans for the finale a secret. I talked to the president of the Network Earlier this week and the president of the network said nope jon wants it this way. He doesnt want any announced guests. He wants it all to be a surprise for viewers. We do know its going to be an extra long episode. It will be about 50 minutes long. I have a feeling maybe there will be a little score settling by jon stewart, some final words for some of his foes. We know the producers reached out to some of the enemies, maybe bill oreilly, maybe donald trump. Obviously trump will be busy he will be at the debate stage in cleveland, but, you know, its possible well see some videotaped messages or Something Like that. So well find out for sure tonight. Trying to figure out whether its a good thing or a bad thing that jon stewarts last show airs on the same night as the first gop debate. Reporter its a very good point. If you think about it for liberals who tend to make up the core of stewarts audience they have two hours of ecstasy during the debate. They can laugh at the gop candidates and then an hour of agony as jon stewart signs off. Maybe for conservatives its the opposite because a lot of folks on the right are happy to see stewart going. They feel hes unfair. They think he skews very far to the left, but to the young people out here in this line, they say hes genuine source for context and perspective. Well see if thats still true when trevor noah takes over in september. But let me play a part of the program from last night. I think its notable that jon stewart has always said hes just a comedian. Hes always encouraged people not to take him seriously, and last night he was downplaying his effect on the world. Here is what he said. What the [ bleep ] is going on here the world is demonstrably worse than when i started have i caused this . Have have have my efforts all been for naught . Reporter hes always been very good about being selfeffacing and selfdeprecating but a lot of critics and Television Writers and commentators would say stewart actually has had a big impact in some ways a positive impact by showing people the power of video clips, by showing people the power of tough Interview Questions in otherwise comfortable settings and by pointing out hypocrisy and contradictions and misstatements both from politicians and occasionally from cable news anchors . Occasionally . How about often . Whether it was spot on or not. Fair point. Hes been a very effective media critic. I would say that. Sometimes he takes cheap shots, theres no doubt about it. Whenever my face would pop up i would have that flash of terror i got very nervous about what he was going to say, but i found myself agreeing with him more often than i found myself disagreeing when it came to the media critiques. Im the opposite. Brian stelter reporting live. Thanks so much. Reporter he always have to give him the raw material, didnt we . We did. The next hour of cnn newsroom starts now. Happening now in the newsroom, new plane debris. What malaysian searchers say they just discovered. Are we closer to solving the mystery of mh370. Plus if all of us were running we would owe voters an explain nation. 17 gop candidates. Will any of them be able to get their message to voters. And we thought it was a scary movie. Police take down a man wielding an ax and a pellet gun at a nashville Movie Theater. Is it safe to see a movie . Lets talk live in the cnn newsroom. This is cnn breaking news. And good morning. Im carol costello. Thank you so much for joining me. We start with breaking news this morning. Investigators may have found new clues in the search for that missing malaysia Airlines Flight 370. The press secretary from malay malaysia malaysias transport ministry telling cnn a malaysian search team has found airplane window parts and aircraft seat cushions on reunion island in the west indian ocean. They say theyve also found aluminum material from an aircraft so lets talk about that. Lets head to toulouse, france, with more. Good morning. Reporter good morning, carol. Yes, we were expecting, of course when we first heard about that flaperon last thursday that more debris may turn up. A surprising admission from the Malaysian Transport Ministry because so far the teams down on reunion island that cnn has been told that there was nothing significant. Now the malaysians say they found plane parts which they say are like windowpanes, aluminum material and other parts that they say do relate to an aircraft. However, carol, they have said this that they do not say whethers that part of mh370. They say theyll be sending it here to france to this laboratory run by the ministry of defense which is already running investigations on that flaperon identified late yesterday evening, carol, as part of mh370. Carol . Sigh ma mow shin thanks so much. Reporting live this morning. Lets talk with cnn aviation analyst and former Inspector General of the department of inspection mary skichiavo. Good morning, mary. Good morning. Family members, they dont even believe that flaperon is the real deal even though malaysian Authorities Say it is. So should we believe them this time around when they say they found all of that debris on reunion island suddenly . Not without careful investigation and proof, and probably the best entity to do that is going to be boeing. For example, starting with the seat cushions they have to meet u. S. Aircraft seat flamability standards. Boeing will know whether or not these are seats from a 777. And since it was manufactured here it will meet our standards and they will be able to tell if this is an aircraft seat or not. Everything else would have to float. I did see online from reunion island somebody posted a picture of the window parts. It did look like it could be a window part but, again and theres just so much trash in the ocean, its difficult to know if that would be it for sure. It has to meet exacting specifications. Boeing engineers will know whether that is a part or not. It may not have a serial number on the window part. It could be whats called a standard part. So yes, they should be skeptical unless and until tested and fully vetted but if it is the parts from that part of the plane, that would mean that the fuselage was broken open and that probably should end speculation that if somebody did this intentionally, they settled it onto the ocean floor so no trace would be found. That would mean the plane was broken apart. Broken apart in the air before it landed you mean . No it could have hit the water at a high rate of speed and broken at impact but there was some speculation that someone scuttled it by landing it gently on the ocean and it sunk to the bottom without a trace. This would blow that assumption or that theory anyway out of the water. Do you think the flaperon came from flight 370 . Oh, without a doubt. I mean went so far as to check on online you can buy used parts and used aircraft parts. There was a shortage of 777 parts. You could not readily go buy a flaperon on the website, so if no other 777 had crashed in that part of the world and you cant readily get the parts, it just absolutely has to be mh370 and i think that the french investigators did a disservice by not just telling them why they said there are indications. In this case i think the malaysians should have just gone one step further and say, look we have the measurements, we have part numbers, we have this and we have that and just told them. The mystery is just painful and cruel to the families. Mary schiavo, thank you for quarter your insight. 17 candidates are descending onto cleveland. The 10 candidates deemed ready for prime time will be packed onto the debate stage, each given one minute per question to convince voters their vision for america is best. Biggest challenge may not be in messaging though but taking the spotlight away from donald trump. But for all the potential gop infighting, the head of the Republican National Committee Says all that attention is a good thing. Were probably going to have 12 or 15 Million People in this country tune in to a republicanonly debate in august and i think that in some ways it can be very helpful to our party. So will it be helpful to the gop . Lets talk about that. Im joined by the Communications Director for Mike Huckabee for president , alice stewart. Good morning, alice. Good morning, carol. Thanks for having me. Thanks for being here. Are you nervous for your candidate . Well theres more of a sense of excitement around the air in the past several weeks as we have been gearing up for the debate as it is for every debate hes ever participated in. And preparation like many others is to get together with injure staff and do debate prep thats going over material and potential questions and reviewing different scenarios on how the questions will be posed to you, but what governor huckabee has been doing is gearing up for this event tonight and having an opportunity on a National Stage to share his views on the issues and reinforce his record show a contrast between the other candidates but its something that hes very comfortable with doing. Hes got a long history as a debater, and this is a great forum. It will be tough though. There will be some tough questions and serious contenders. And you know donald trump is there which is different from every other debate because donald trump is a unique person. Has governor huckabee prepared differently for this debate than in past debates . Dumponald trump is his own man up there on the stage and he doesnt need anyone else to help talk about him. As you mentioned, carol, each candidate has one minute to answer these questions, and governor huckabee is going to talk about himself in the limited time they all have up there and theres no premeditated effort to go after donald trump or any of the candidates because the time is so short. Were going it use the time to get our message out there and speak to the american people. Do you think that the format of this debate is fair because the governor and the rest of the candidates will get very little time to respond to questions. They wont even get to rebut unless someone specifically asks calls out their name. Every debate has different rules and regulations. Your cnn debate coming up next months a different rules and regulations and thats part of the process. You go about each one looking at how you use your time wisely and you take your win to answer the question and you have a concise answer that addresses the issues and when you have the opportunity to rebut, you jump in there and do so. But all the debates are different. Every candidate up there is more than anything theyre thankful for the opportunity to get their message out. They have been campaigning across the country in iowa and New Hampshire and South Carolina talking about voters and talking with people about whats important to them. They will share it on the stage. It will be a much much larger audience. In governor huckabees mind who is the person to beat on that stage tonight . Its about him. Hes up there for himself to get his message out there. He doesnt look at any of the other candidates. Thats not a factor in how he prepares really . Absolutely. And thats the way he has always been. Hes been a debater for many many years. He goes out there, this is his opportunity to get his message out there. Thats how he prepared for it. Thats how he will go up on the stage and thats what we will see tonight at 9 00. All right. Alice stewart, thank you so much for being with me this morning. I appreciate it. Coming up in the newsroom, its the phone call everyone is talking about. Former president bill clinton gave donald trump a call right before trump decided to jump into the president ial race. Well talk about that next. With hotels. Com rewards i earn free nights that i can use at any type of hotel with no blackout dates. Which is why most of this legal copy is just instructions on how to win a free trip instructions actually written in this legal copy. Use your dvr to read them. This is the prerecorded voice of captain obvious. I am not a ventriloquist. Im caridee. Ive had moderate to Severe Plaque Psoriasis most of my life. But that hasnt stopped me from modeling. My doctor told me about stelara® it helps keep my skin clearer. With only 4 doses a year after 2 starter doses. Stelara® helps me be in season. Stelara® may lower your ability to fight infections and increase your risk of infections. Some serious infections require hospitalization. Before starting stelara® your doctor should test for tuberculosis. Stelara® may increase your risk of cancer. Always tell your doctor if you have any sign of infection have had cancer, or if you develop any new skin growths. Do not take stelara® if you are allergic to stelara® or any of its ingredients. Alert your doctor of new or worsening problems including headaches, seizures, confusion and vision problems. These may be signs of a rare potentially fatal brain condition. Serious allergic reactions can occur. Tell your doctor if you or anyone in your house needs or has recently received a vaccine. In a medical study most stelara® patients saw at least 75 clearer skin and the majority were rated as cleared or minimal at 12 weeks. Stelara® helps keep my skin clearer. Ask your doctor about stelara®. Youre driving along having a perfectly nice day, when out of nowhere a pickup truck slams into your brand new car. One second it wasnt there and the next second. Boom you had your first accident. Now you have to make your first claim. So you talk to your Insurance Company and. Boom youre blindsided for a second time. They wont give you enough money to replace your brand new car. Dont those people know youre already shaken up . Liberty mutuals new car replacement will pay for the entire value of your car, plus depreciation. Call and for drivers with accident forgiveness, Liberty Mutual wont raise your rates due to your first accident. Switch to Liberty Mutual insurance and you could save up to 509. Call Liberty Mutual for a free quote today at see Car Insurance in a whole new light. Liberty mutual insurance. A little political intrigue before the big debate. Guess who decided to call donald trump before he decided to run for president . Bill clinton. Yeah, that bill clinton whose wife was already in the 2016 race at the time. According to the Washington Post quote, the tone of the tall was informal and clinton never urged trump to run. Rather he was curious and told trump he was striking a chord with frustrating conservatives and was a rising force on the right. With me to talk about this cnn political commentator and jeb bush supporter ana navarro and political commentator errol lewis lewis. What do you make of this errol . I think its fascinating. Clearly bill clinton wanted to maybe get a little intel, sort of measure the waters. I think as one of the best sort of politicians of the last generation hes probably right, that there is some rising force of conservatism that trump represents or at least is in line with and that we would all do well to try to figure out what thats all about if we want to understand the dynamics of the debate tonight and the unfolding gop president ial campaign. Its interesting bill clinton gave that great piece of advice to donald trump, anna but hasnt seemed to communicate a great strategy to his wife since her Approval Ratings are going down. Well it seems maybe bill clinton is giving more advice to donald trump than to Hillary Clinton lately. Look im its intriguing its surprising its entertaining but lets remember that donald trump and the clintons have had a longtime relationship. Donald trump is one of the big donors to Hillary Clinton, also a big donor, six figures to the clinton foundation. The clintons were at the front pew of Donald Trumps last wedding, whatever it was, number three, number four and so, you know its a longstanding relationship. Its a new yorker thing i think, and if you know anything about bill clinton, you know the guy loves to talk politics so im, you know not surprised. If i were a conspiracy theorist maybe this is something that we can attribute to the vast clinton wing conspiracy, maybe trump is a double agent. Oh geez. Who knows. I want to talk about one of Donald Trumps advisers. His name is roger stone. Here he is on the cover of the Weekly Standard is richard in accordanceon nixon tattooed on his back. Some call him the professional lord of mystery. He reportedly fib lyly tipped off the fbi about he will yots spitters trip to a prostitute and most recently he had some choice words for you ana navarro. This is what he tweeted. Ana navarro the dumbest person on tv since cnn fired moron Roland Martin. Both quota hires. Ana, care to bite back . What can i tell you, carol . I really dont like to stoop to that level. You know i think that guy represents everything thats wrong with politics. A hatemonger, a twitter troll, but it tells you a lot about the kind of people donald trump is surrounding himself with. People that threaten others that just spew out venom against other people who may have a disagreement with them. You have seen he has fired at least two aides in the last few days over hateful comments on social media. So sometimes you have to wonder whether donald trump is running for president of the United States or president of twitter trolls. As far as, you know being a quota hire which is what roger stone i guess accuses me and Roland Martin of being, sorry, roger, i guess, you know, the quota for the weird bleach blond swinger was taken. Okay. I just want to ask one more question about stone and ill pose this question to you, errol. Stone told Jeffrey Toobin in 2008 politics is not about uniting people its about dividing people and the polls this time around certainly proves hes right, right . Well it suggests that you can win some things. You cant necessarily unify the country, move the country forward, and, frankly, youd probably lose about as many races as you try to win that way. But roger stone, i mean you say hes into political dirty tricks. He would be the first to acknowledge that. I interviewed him many many times. We have a friendly relationship. Hes actually quite good on mens fashion. Thats probably where you can get something out of him that wont offend anybody. Oh errol. But this is the politics of 50 plus one is what has really brought the country to a very low place in the last decade or so. This election like the last three, well ask ourselves are we ready to move beyond this . Could donald trump be such a person . As always we can only say we hope so. Can donald trump be the uniter when he hires a guy like this . Its not a promising start. If he wants to bring the country together this is not a promising start. On the other hand people do change. People do change their political style, their political philosophy and the political outcomes that we want, you know its really up to us. We cant always look to the candidates. We will have the final say about who succeeds and who does not and those who want unity, those who want a different tone a different direction, the time to get involved is right now. Errol luis and ana navarro, i reach out to you often and ask for advice so i think youre one fantastic, incredibly brilliant person and im glad youre employed by cnn. Ana navarro and errol luisieu louis thanks so much. A manhunt is under way after a Shreveport Police officer was killed. He was responding to a call about a prowler. Six dozen police units are combing the area and a helicopter is assisting in the search. Bill cosby going on the record later this year. A california judge is ordering the comedian to give a sworn deposition in a civil suit against him. Judith said she was 15 when cosby molested her at the playboy mansion. This is first time hes been forced to testify in ten years. More than two dozen women have come forward accusing him of rape. Still to come in the newsroom, another Movie Theater attack this time at the hands of a young man with a history of mental illness. So is it safe to go to a movie . Well talk about that next. Hows it progressing with the prisoner . Hell tell us everything he knows very shortly, sir. Playboy mansion. So is it safe to go to a movie . Where were we . 13 serving 14 service if your boss stops by, you act like youre working. Its what you do. If you want to save fifteen percent or more on Car Insurance, you switch to geico. Its what you do. If you want a paint thats more than just easy to scrub. If you want a paint that actually repels dirt and grime. If you want a paint that stands up to lifes wear and tear. Only this can. Regal select from benjamin moore. Paint like no other. I sure had a lot on my mind when i got out of the hospital after a dvt blood clot. What about my family . My lil buddy . And what if this happened again . I was given warfarin in the hospital but i wondered if this was the right treatment for me. Then my doctor told me about eliquis. Eliquis treats dvt and pe blood clots and reduces the risk of them happening again. Not only does eliquis treat dvt and pe blood clots but eliquis also had significantly less major bleeding than the standard treatment. Knowing eliquis had both. Turned around my thinking. Dont stop eliquis unless your doctor tells you to. Eliquis can cause serious and in rare cases fatal bleeding. Dont take eliquis if you have an artificial heart valve or abnormal bleeding. If you had a spinal injection while on eliquis call your doctor right away if you have tingling numbness, or muscle weakness. While taking eliquis, you may bruise more easily. And it may take longer than usual for bleeding to stop. Seek immediate medical care for sudden signs of bleeding, like unusual bruising. Eliquis may increase your bleeding risk if you take certain medicines. Tell your doctor about all planned medical or dental procedures. Eliquis treats dvt pe blood clots. Plus had less major bleeding. Both made switching to eliquis right for me. Ask your doctor if its right for you. While every business is unique everyone is looking for ways to cut expenses. And thats where pg es Online Business Energy Checkup tool can really help. You can use it to track your Actual Energy use. Find rebates that make equipment upgrades more affordable. Even develop a Customized Energy plan for your company. Think of it as a way to take more control over your operating costs. And yet another Energy Saving opportunity from pg e. Find new ways to save energy and money with pg es Business Energy checkup. Female announcer right now at sleep train get up to 48 months interestfree financing on tempurpedic. Save hundreds on beautyrest. Or choose 300 in free gifts with Stearns Foster. The triple choice sale ends soon at sleep train. We turn now to that hoff riff horrific attack in a nashville area movie ve tiertheater. Within minutes the man would be shot to death by police. Vincente David Montano pointed that weapon at them. It was a pellet gun but it looked like a real weapon. Montanos mother said he had a long history with mental illness. The man he struck with a hatchet offering this prayer moments after he was attacked. Im eternally grateful excuse me for metro Police Department for their Fast Response today and the fact that no one else got injured other than the person who did this. I would ask anyone to pray for his family because he obviously has some mental problems or something else. Nick valencia is in nashville this morning with more. Good morning. Reporter good morning, carol. Police in nashville being prased ed raised for their actions in preventing an incident that could have been much worse. The suspect identified as 29yearold vincente David Montano came into this Movie Theater. He purchased a ticket and then he proceeded to carry out his attack. He was armed with a pellet gun, an ax and wearing a surgical mask presumably to protect himself from the pepper spray he used to douse the patrons inside inside. Some of those frantic moments captured on 911 audio tape. I was in the Movie Theater a minute or two ago and this guy, this shady looking guy stood up with like two bags and he walked towards the back of the theater and he pulled out like a hatchet and started attacking this family and then he pulled out a gun and we all ran out of the theater. Reporter according to police montano has a lengthy history of Mental Health issues being committed in Mental Health institutions. He has a record of being checked in at the National Homeless institute but no record of him staying overnight. On monday his mother filed a missing persons report telling police he was a diagnosed schizophrenic and had a hard time taking care of himself. Nick valencia thank you. It does make you wonder is it safe to go to a movie. It happened on the heels of what happened in lafayette, louisiana. Here to talk about it is matthew, a former Police Officer. Should we be afraid to go to the movie . I dont think we should be afraid to go to the movies, but we should be aware of the current climate. As Security Professionals and practitioners, its our job to assess vulnerabilityies and make security plans that make sense to the public. Thats what you do for a living right now. So how do you do that in a Movie Theater . Remember security is a very touchy business. Its something Everyone Wants but someone has to fund and i dont know if america is ready for magnetometers as you go to Movie Theaters ready for screening processes. I dont know. Most Movie Theaters have Police Officers that work friday saturday sundays, high volume times. A lot of Movie Theaters employ the use of private security but right now i think america is going to take a good hard look at strengthening these soft targets. Yeah. Well is a way to strengthen a soft target to have somebody serve your bag . I cant even imagine that but should Movie Theaters do that . If you think about that look how far weve come since 9 11. Could we have ever imagined taking off our shoes and belts before we go through security checkpoints at airports . It very well may be the answer at some point. We have to reconsider our security and also remember this as we change our targets from soft to hard it leaves other soft targets vulnerable for things just like this. Okay. So there has been a suggestion that maybe people should be allowed to take guns into Movie Theaters . That is absolutely not the answer in my view. Just because you have a gun doesnt mean youre trained to use a gun. And its a dark theater and lets face it if somebody attacks somebody its difficult to get your bearings right . Youre watching a movie. It is absolutely difficult. If you look at what happened yesterday, the nashville metro Police Department responded but they train for incidents just like this. Theyre a fulltime team. They know what to do. They have the process down. If you look at the way that scene developed yesterday, it developed flawlessly. The Police Officers did exactly what they were trained to do and what they were supposed to do. They corralled him in a certain area and then there was a gunfight although we later find out this guys gun wasnt real which was strange. The whole thing is strange. Its strange but its coming out he may have had some mental issues. We were here two weeks ago and two weeks before that too little too late is becoming too often. Matthew horace thank you so much for stopping by. Have a great day. And good morning. Im carol costello. Thank you so much for joining me. This just in to cnn. One of the main negotiators of the Iran Nuclear Deal is leaving the state department. Wendy sherman will become a fellow at the Harvard Institute of politics. She will join the institute in early october. The u. S. Senate will take up that nuclear deal september 8th right after the august recess. A big concern for lawmakers, new satellite imagery suggesting the iranians are attempting to clean up a site ahead of international inspections. President obama warned that if Congress Rejects this deal though it could set the stage for another war in the middle east. That provoked some back and forth on twitter between the white house and congressional leaders. Steve scalise complained about the secret side deals, and the president fired back important detail there are no secret deals. My staff can brief you on any question about any part of the deal. Thats what the president tweeted. Here is cnns chief National Security correspondent jim sciutto. I am stating a fact. Reporter today the president made an impassioned, even Defiant Defense of the Iran Nuclear Deal attempting to dissuade skeptical lawmakers from blocking the agreement. I have had to make a lot of tough calls as president , but whether or not this deal is good for American Security is not one of those calls. Its not even close. Reporter but the skeptics got new ammunition today. Cnn has learned that the u. S. Intelligence community believes iran is attempting to clean up one of the most sensitive suspected nuclear sites. The military installation after satellite imagery showed heavy Construction Equipment including bulldozers. The president dismissed activity that iran can hide nuclear activity. Nuclear material isnt something you hide in the closet. It can leave a trace for years. The bottom line is if iran cheats we can catch them and we will. Reporter a Senior Intelligence official familiar with the imagery in question tells cnn that the iaea the International Agency responsible for inspecting Irans Nuclear sites, is, quote, familiar with sanitization efforts and the International Community has confidence in the iaess technical experience. Many lawmakers arent convinced. They take particular issue with the fact that theed a ed aadministration has not released details of agreements with iran and the iaea and wont confirm if u. S. Officials even read them. Why now will you not give us the documents that exist that are so important to all of us relative to the integrity of this why not . We dont have the documents in the first instance. We dont have them. So we dont have them to give to you. I didnt see the final documents. I saw the provisional documents as did my experts. Reporter for the president however, the choice remains clear. Lets not mince words. The choice we face is ultimately between diplomacy or some form of war. Maybe not tomorrow maybe not three months from now, but soon. Reporter jim sciutto, cnn, washington. A News Conference going on right now in shreveport louisiana, where a manhunt is under way after a Police Officer was shot and killed. He was responding to a call about a prowler when he was shot several times. Police are actively searching this area. A helicopter is assisting. Of course well monitor this News Conference and bring you any new information that comes our way. Still ahead in the newsroom, gop president ial candidate Rick Santorum did not make it into the prime time debate because his poll numbers were too low, but he says that should not matter. You wouldnt do half of your daily routine. So why treat your mouth any differently. Brushing alone does less than half the job leaving behind millions of germs. Complete the job with listerine®. Kill up to 99 percent of germs. And prevent plaque early gum disease and bad breath. Complete the job with listerine®. Power to your mouth™ also try listerine® pocket packs to kill bad breath germs on the go. Staying in rhythm. Its how i try to live. How i stay active. So i need nutrition. That wont weigh me down. For the nutrition you want without the calories you dont. Introducing boost 100 calories. Each delicious snack size drink gives you. 25 vitamins and minerals and 10 grams of protein. So its big in nutrition and small in calories. Im not about to swim in the slow lane. Stay strong. Stay active with boost®. Before i had the shooting, burning, pinsandneedles of diabetic nerve pain, these feet grew up in a family of boys. Married my high school sweetheart. And pursued a degree in education. But i couldnt bear my diabetic nerve pain any longer. So i talked to my doctor and she prescribed lyrica. Nerve damage from diabetes causes diabetic nerve pain. Lyrica is fdaapproved to treat this pain. Lyrica may cause serious allergic reactions or suicidal thoughts or actions. Tell your doctor right away if you have these, new, or worsening depression or unusual changes in mood or behavior. Or swelling, trouble breathing rash, hives, blisters, muscle pain with fever, tired feeling, or blurry vision. Common side effects are dizziness, sleepiness, weight gain and swelling of hands, legs and feet. Dont drink alcohol while taking lyrica. Dont drive or use machinery until you know how lyrica affects you. Those who have had a drug or alcohol problem may be more likely to misuse lyrica. Now i have less diabetic nerve pain. And i love helping first graders put their best foot forward. Ask your doctor about lyrica. You pay your Car Insurance premium like clockwork. Month after month. Year after year. Then one night, you hydroplane into a ditch. Yeah. Surprise. Your Insurance Company tells you to pay up again. Why pay for insurance if you have to pay even more for using it . If you have Liberty Mutual deductible fund™ you could pay no deductible at all. Sign up to immediately lower your deductible by 100. And keep lowering it 100 annually, until its gone. Then continue to earn that 100 every year. Theres no limit to how much you can earn and this savings applies to every vehicle on your policy. Call to learn more. Switch to Liberty Mutual and you could save up to 509. Call Liberty Mutual for a free quote today at see Car Insurance in a whole new light. Liberty mutual insurance. Hi, im Henry Winkler and im here to tell homeowners that are sixtytwo and older about a great way to live a better retirement. Its called a reverse mortgage. Call right now to receive your free dvd and booklet with no obligation. It answers questions like. How a reverse Mortgage Works how much you qualify for the ways to receive your money. And more. Plus, when you call now, youll get this magnifier with led light absolutely free when you call the experts at one reverse mortgage today, youll learn the benefits of a governmentinsured reverse mortgage. It will eliminate your monthly mortgage payments and give you taxfree cash from the equity in your home and heres the best part. You still own your home. Take control of your retirement today its been called the happy hour debate and the under card. Im talking about the Candidate Forum featuring seven republican president ial hopefuls who did not score well enough to the polls to get a spot in tonights prime time faceoff. One of the them is Rick Santorum. Hes pushing back on that format and the idea that poll results this early should have been a deciding factor. Here is what he told chris cuomo this morning. You can complain about how the rnc is doing it how fox is doing it in this first debate, but at the end of the day the polls do matter and youre not doing that well in the polls and neither is the group thats at 5 00 instead of at 9 00 and shouldnt that be relevant in deciding who is on and when if at all. Well chris, if two weeks before the Iowa Caucuses i was at 2 in the National Polls and i won the Iowa Caucuses and went on to win ten other states. Its not a predictor of anything. Its not a national race. Its a statebystate race. Again, thats what im focused on. Joining me now from cleveland, john brabender, a senior vis for Rick Santorums 2012 campaign and a republican political consultant. Glad to see you. Glad youre here. Glad i can be here. Thank you for having me on. Thanks for being here. So i heard what Rick Santorum said. On the other hand donald trump is not part of the happy hour debate and that means maybe people will actually listen to what the candidates have to say. Well i look at it a little bit differently. I look at that 5 00 debate and here is what i know. Were all talking about the iran deal maybe the most important issue facing america, and the two people tonight in a debate that have far more Foreign Policy experience than anybody else is Rick Santorum and lindsey graham. Were talking about job creation. The governor that probably has the best Success Story is rick perry in the early debate and Carly Fiorina is the only one in either debates thats run a fortune 50 company. You can always watch donald trump on reruns on the apprentice. I think the more substantial debate will probably be the 5 00 debate. I tend to agree with you because the candidates will also have a little more time to give their answers, right . Absolutely and i think it will be less confrontational. I think what will happen in the later debate somebody is going to be smart enough whose name is not donald trump to engage donald trump knowing thats whats going to be played over and over again tomorrow and the next day and the next day to do that to get their name in the news. It becomes a Reality Tv Show almost environment. I think in the first debate it will be more cooperative, more of a spirit of being together in this thing, but they will point out differences and i think it will be a very very insightful debate. Do you think this prime time debate will be ultimately bad for the president ial race and the gop . No i dont think so but i do think its so early. You know look four years ago at this time the leading people that were centering the debates were Michele Bachmann herman cain and tim pawlenty. Two of them didnt even make it to the iowa caucus and one didnt make it past the iowa caucus. It is really early, but i will say this i do think somebody like a donald trump who is way ahead who people know very little about needs to started being vetted and i think today is tonight will be the first process of that. What do you mean start being vetted . You mean by voters by who . You know, i made a joke on cnn the other night that if will ferrell got on the republican race tomorrow he might start at 10 because nobody knows anything other than hes a funny comedian. And, you know, in some sense, donald trump, the character, is running for president , but nobody has vetted him under the lens do we really want this person in the white house making decisions on trade, on manufacturing, on social issues on our National Defense . You know hes shown nothing in his history to show on many of those issues that hes capable and i think we have to find out. So when do you think donald trump will flame out . Well you know i dont know if flame out will be the word. I think you will find this hard core group of people who are mad at washington as mad as they can be and are willing to have a protest vet and say until we do something drastic like voting for donald trump were not getting anybodys attention. I think you will find he will always have a certain 10 or something in the polls, which will keep him credible all the way through. I also think what hes doing is hes motivating a certain republican voter who hopefully will stay engaged all the way through november of 2016. Well see. John brabender, thank you so much for being with me this morning. I appreciate it. Thank you. Yemoure welcome. New york city has it all, however knowing what to do or where to go can be a real dilemma. I step away from the anchor desk to show you some hidden gems. Welcome to Hells Kitchen new york. Its real. Im the unpretentious sort i like working class people. There are all kinds of characters here there are great restaurants including this one, the best Mexican Restaurant anywhere. Whats the secret to our success . My secret is i do it with love. You make the customer feel like family. Yeah. Thats the main point for us. This is one of my very Favorite Places in new york city. This is central park but its way up north away from the maddening crowds. This is one of the water falls in the park and when i sit here and listen to it i can imagine myself anywhere in the world. Another one of my Favorite Places in new york city Grand Central terminal. If you want to know why just look up at the ceiling, at the october sky full of 2,500 stars. This terminal covers 49 acres in midtown manhattan. This is the Worlds Largest and every single day 750,000 people come through here which is the entire population of alaska, san francisco, but on top of that information booth, that fourfaced clock valued at 10 million to 20 million. Every face of that clock is made out of one solid piece of precious opal. Youre kidding. Little do they know that is a fortune. Thanks for tagging along. Now come on and visit new york city. I have to catch my train. When account lead craig wilson books at laquinta. Com. He gets a ready for you alert the second his room is ready. So he knows exactly when he can settle in and practice his big pitch. And when craig gets his pitch down pat, do you know what he becomes . Great proposal lets talk more over golf great. Better yet, how about over tennis . Even better. A game changer your 2 oclock is here. Oops, hold your horses. No problem. La quinta inns suites is ready for you, so youll be ready for business. The ready for you alert, only at lq. Com. Laquinta the kids are asleep. Look what i got. Oh my froot loops [sniffs] lets do this . Get up get up get up get up loop me bring back the awesome yeah yeah yeah with the great taste of Kelloggs Froot loops. Follow your nose no students ever photographed mean ms. Colegrove. But your dell 2in1 laptop gives you the spunk for an unsanctioned selfie. Thats that new gear feeling. Get this High Performance laptop bundle for only 399. Office depot officemax. Gear up for school. Gear up for great. I called for help as soon as i saw her. I found her wandering miles from home. When the phone rang at 5am i knew it was about mom. I see how hard its been on her at work and i want to help. For the 5 million americans living with alzheimers and millions more who feel its effects. Lets walk together to make an even bigger impact and end alzheimers for good. Find your walk near you at alz. Org walk. Whoa what are you doing . Putting on a movie. Im trying to watch the game here. Look i need this right now ok . Come on i dont want to watch that. Too bad this is happening. Fine, what if i just put up the x1 sports app right here. Ah jeez its so close. He just loves her so much. Do it. Come on. Do it. Come on yes awww, yes that is what im talking about. Baby. Call and upgrade to get x1 today. It was a sickening scene inside a florida home. Three people found dead, beat with a hammer. Their throats slashed. Police say the gruesome murders could be tied to witchcraft and tied to last weeks blue moon. Alina machado has more. The elements of this case are odd at best. Reporter the violent deaths of an elderly woman and her two adult sons inside this escambia county, florida, home may be tied to witchcraft. The method of the murder Blunt Force Trauma slit throats, positions of bodies and then our person of interest has some ties to a faith and or religion that is indicative of that. Reporter the victims identified as 77yearold vansiel smith and 49yearold Richard Thomas smith. They were killed with a claw hammer they had their throats slit. Richard thomas also had a gunshot wound to the head. The crime scene was very complex and took several days to work. Reporter investigators have been talking to neighbors who say the family was very reclusive. Richard thomas smith worked for the department of homeland security. His position is not believed to be the reason why the family was targeted. There was a sizable amount of cash found at the house inside a safe that was not taken. So we believe that we can safely rule out robbery as the primary motive. Reporter so authorities are turning their attention to the possibility that what happened inside this house was part of a ritualistic killing and its not the first time weve heard of a case like this. Last year in houston a 15yearold girl was kidnapped and murdered. Her killers reportedly committed the crime during a satanic ritual. Authorities in florida meanwhile arent offering specifics on the type of beliefs or religion that could be behind the triple homicide but experts say ritualistic killings have very specific characters. The person has to be killed in a particular way, you know. Certain kind of injury has to be inflicted on each person. The buddies have to be put together in a particular way. Thats the nature of ritual. If you deviate from that formula, it ceases to be effective. Reporter authorities believe the victims were killed sometime last week on tuesday. Their bodies though werent found until friday. The timing they say coincides with last weeks blue moon but authorities have not said how. Also worth noting the sheriff says there were no signs of forced entry and that nothing appears to have been taken from the home. Authorities are asking anyone with information on this case to please come forward. Carol . Unbelievable. Alina machoado reporting live for us. Still to come jon stewarts last night in hosting the daily show hours away. Well take a look back at some of his greatest hits next. Have have big day . Ah, the usual. Moved some new cars. Hauled a bunch of steel. Kept the supermarket shelves stocked. Made sure everyone got their latest gadgets. Whats up for the next shift . Ah, nothing much. Just keeping the lights on. laugh nice. Doing the big things that move an economy. See you tomorrow, mac. See you tomorrow, sam. Just another day at norfolk southern. Can a business have a mind . A subconscious. A knack for predicting the future. Reflexes faster than the speed of thought. Can a business have a spirit . Can a business have a soul . Can a business be. Alive . [ female announcer ] when youre serious about fighting wrinkles, turn to roc® retinol correxion®. One week fine lines appear to fade. One month deep wrinkles look smoother. After one year, skin looks ageless. High performance skincare™ only from roc®. When laquinta. Com sends craig wilson a ready for you alert the second his room is ready ya know what he becomes . Great proposal lets talk more over golf. Great. How about over tennis . Even better. A game changer the ready for you alert, only at lq. Com. My name is mark amann. Im a gas service rep for pg e in san jose. As a gas service rep we are basically the ambassador of the company. We make the most contact with the customers on a daily basis. I work handinhand with crews to make sure our gas pipes are safe. My wife and i are both from san jose. My kids and their friends live in this community. Every time i go to a customers house, their children could be friends with my children so its important to me. One of the most rewarding parts of this job is after you help a customer seeing a smile on their face. Together, were building a better california. After 16 years of lampooning the news media and turning the days headlines into jokes, john stewart make his final appearance as host of the daily show tonight. Brian stelter looks back at some of stewarts most memorable moments. Reporter more than 15 years after he took charge of the daily show, jon stewart is stepping down. Before trevor noah steps down we wanted to look back at some of stewarts best and most memorable moments starting with indecision 2000. The 2000 election that started in november and didnt end until middecember was perfect fodder for stewart. Jon, please address me as protect carrel. What . Im assuming the presidency. You cant do that . Bush did. Reporter but hes not just about laughs. Are you okay and we pray that you are and that your family are. Reporter while difficult to watch it is remembered as stewarts most heartfelt moments. More often he was a prankster, a jokester. [ bleep ]. Reporter spoking fun at political i haddiot si and sometimes making people think. He and Stephen Colbert brought thousands of people to washington for a rally. They see no ones humanity but their own. Reporter but his criticisms were not just limbed to the right wing. The recurring Guantanamo Bay watch segment took aim on president obama. And stewart tried to hold the news media accountable, too. He critiqued us here at cnn too. Giant floor maps big fake airplanes. Little fake airplanes. Holographic airplanes. No airplane detail left unspoken. Reporter the only channel he mocked more often was fox news. President obama and the Entitlement Society that he enables. This is the core of [ bleep ]. Reporter this time well let jon stewart have the last word. Brian stelter, cnn money, new york. Thank you so much for being with me today. Im carol costello. At the hour with berman and bolduan starts now. New plane debris found on the island where a piece of flight 370 is believed to have washed up. Window parts, seat cushions. That is the word from malaysian officials, but a frank question this morning, can they be trusted . And another attack against innocent people families simply enjoying a movie. The new calls now to change security at theaters across the country. And the x files meets a telephone meets donald trump. The secret phone call between bill clinton and donald trump just before trump announced for president. Conspiracy theory. Is trump a clinton plant . The truth is out there