It's a great book from a great reporter. I'm glad you had him on, chris. Agreed. Have a great weekend. You too. Okay, well, today started yet again with news of bomb threats in springfield, ohio. Yesterday two elementary schools, city hall, dmv and the county court facilities had to close because of bomb threats. Today two elementary schools were evacuated and a middle school had to close. Yesterday the mayor of springfield told nbc news he believes these bomb threats are directly connected to the baseless rumors spread online in the wake of viral social media posts claiming haitian migrants were abducting people's pets in springfield in order to eat them. I should note that the claims about haitian migrants eating pets in springfield are lies. There is no evidence to back up any of those claims. But that does not seem to matter. Here's the thing, a week ago today, on all of twitter, there were only about 1,000 posts mentioning haitians, migrants or immigrants eating animals. Twitter is a very big place. So this was truly a fringe conspiracy theory. During the presidential debate on tuesday night, trump used his microphone to bring that conspiracy theory to the 67 million people watching live. And now, kids are being pulled from elementary school classrooms and canine units are sweeping the city's buildings for bombs and right wing influencers from all over the country have descended on springfield to quote unquote report on this completely fabricated lie. You might be wondering how did this particular conspiracy theory get to donald trump in the first place. As it turns out it's actually really hard to say. Because trump has surrounded himself with so many toxic fringy advisors that the pool of potential conspiracy theorists is just too large. Just as an example, look at a few of the people trump surrounded himself with on the night of the debate. This is video of trump face timing in to what his campaign called its social media war room just before the debate. Among the army of maga internet trolls assembled was a woman known as libs of tiktok. Libs of tiktok is famous for pushing anti lgbt content that has led to the arrests. And you may remember how her tiktok led to bomb threats. It is quite a resume. The woman behind libs of tiktok was of course one of the people that trump had in his war debate room. And she was also the one who pushed the haitian dog eating. And someone who was trump backstage and who came with him into the spin room after the debate. Let's talk about laura loomer. You may know loomer from her attempt to prove that the school shooting that killed 15 people and injured 17 more was a hoax. Or when she handcuffed herself to twitter's headquarters wearing a yellow star of david on her chest. That was before elon musk took over, of course. Loomer and trump have been seemingly joined at the hip all this week. I mean, even though loomer is a 9/11 conspiracy theorist trump brought her to the 9/11 memorial this week. That's how buddy, buddy they've been. Loomer was one of those pushing the lie of the haitian pet eating conspiracy. Before spending this week with trump, a week ago today, laura loomer ate dog food on her show loomer unleashed. No pun intended. I think. Today for what is, whatever it's worth, trump tried to distance himself from laura loomer, sort of. Laura is a supporter, i don't control laura. Laura has to say what she wants. I know she's a big fan of the campaign but i really don't know. Is she an advisor. I would say that, well she brings a spirit to us that a lot of people have. We have very spirited people. Even if you ignore all the radicals and wierdos that trump has surrounded himself with and you look just at trump's presidential ticket, this conspiracy is still there. On monday, trump's running mate j. D. Vance himself was pushing this thing. From his social media to his social life to his professional inner circle, trump has surrounded himself with conspiracy theorists or at the very least people who are willing to push conspiracy theories in bad faith for personal or political gain. And because of the way the republican party is now structured. Once donald trump embraces something, well then everyone else does too. And trump is making sure his whole party feels welcome on this particular bandwagon. Even before trump said the lie about haitian immigrants on the debate stage he was posting memes about it online. As the new york times put it today, the memes over the top imagery gives him the feel of an inside joke. A just kidding is implied. Allowing political figures who have otherwise hesitated to circulate debunked particular to get in on it. And did they get in on it, they did. Even the official account of the republican house judicial economy got in on it. That's their tweet. The state's republican party brought the memes into the real world putting up 12 billboards around phoenix that read eat less kittens, vote republican. While trump and his supporters are all laughing on the meme based on this completely fake story. There are real human beings in springfield feeling the consequences. People who are now only sharing their stories anonymously because they are too scared for their lives to identify themselves. Their lives to identify themselves. [speaking global language ] ] but hey, jd vance says not to let the cry babies and the media desway you. So you know, keep the cat memes flowing. Joining me now is tim miller, writer at large at the bull work and political analyst. Tim, thank you for being here. To help us all figure out what exactly has happened. I just feel like the inherent nihilism of maga world and the trolls that surround it or are a part of its universe has led us to this moment, right. Where it's like all fun and games like a dark twisted sick game with decidedly real world consequences for a group of brown people who are here in the country. Let me just read you a quote from the new york times about how sort of this is a natural evolution of trumpism. Mr. Trump's mix of right wing politics, throwing and transgression during his 2016 campaign fit neatly with the discontent and prankish instincts of the wilder fringes. This is inevitable, what do you think tim. Yeah it was inevitable. We all saw this in 2016. As someone who was an anti trump republican back then. I was awash people sending sexual explicit memes, racial memes. It was stuff that was out there unfortunately or whatever but that trump elevated and brought into the mainstream back then. And we're really seeing this now, you know kind of evolve and grow offline as well. And so, you know i was thinking about how outrageous this all was and what i was going to say. While i was listening to your introthere. And i decided actually that there's somebody that said it better than i could. So i'm going to pull this up. Here's j. D. Vance october 9, 2016 when we were all seeing all of this. Trump makes people i care about afraid. Immigrants, muslims, because of this, i find him reprehensible. God wants better of us. So, everything that j. D. Vance said right then in 2016 is exactly right. It's irreprehensible. He persists in doing it plus encouraging others saying you're a patriot if you postthese racist cat memes shows a deep corrupting baddens of maga and of my party, my former party. And i see a difference between this dehumanization. It's this no cost cruelty. At least no cost in their eyes and the focus of it is immigrants, brown people. People they deem shouldn't be here. I mean, i guess we're now at the point where, that kind of nihilism. That kind of toxicity. That kind of dehumanization is something embraced by just regular old republicans in the party. Not even people that are in office. But everyone that jumps in. You see cruz' tweets. Migrants are eating cats, whatever he said. There isn't a dog whistle. It didn't a clever, it's not a joke. I guess it's a joke but it's a straight racist joke. And so, you know you can't imagine a scenario right where you know they were pushing something about ukrainian migrants or belgium immigrants who are coming here and who are like oh, these people are abducting your dogs and eating. They would never say that about, like you can't even imagine what that would sound like. Which reveals just how plainly racist it is. The fact that not only are many of the republicans getting in on it but nobody is saying, at least back in 2017, 2018. In the early years of trump. There would be some republicans in congress that would say, this grosses me out. I still like him for the policies. I don't like the meme tweets. You got at least that. The verbal acknowledgment that they knew it was wrong. You don't even get that now. Like there's no, the party is fully on board for the grossest like conspiracy mo new mongeri ng and racism. Now you see it's finding an intersack intersactum. The fact that loomer is on the trump plane and at the 9/11 memorial. Laura loomer said she would be fine being the press secretary if he wins. That might be a twisted parity, that's an actual prospect. I wonder what you make of marjory taylor green of all people and lindsey graham sounding notes of caution of trump getting too close to loomer. Marjory taylor green called loomers comments racists and lindsey graham has i think also cautioned trump to keep his distance though not in those words. Do you, first of all, how true do those words ring coming from someone like marjory taylor green and someone like lindsey graham who you have had, you know the history there between him and trump? i guess marjory taylor green is right on this one. Broken clocks and all. This whole thing and tom tillis, i've seen other people criticize her. The whole thing is absurd. That these congressional republicans like, oh there's a racist conspiracy monger on the trump plane. Like yeah, the person who's name is on the side of the plane fits that description. They can't criticize trump, right. So you have to criticize loomer. Loomer is extremely off the. You usually enjoy the local mayors or your best volunteer. Religious leader or something. This crazy internet troll is the person who gets invited with him to multiple stops is lunacy and it's not surprising that someone like that would be in the trump administration 2. 0. Trump had this box, remember he's sitting there in the box like king lear. The people that were in the box with him were a little less crazy than loomer but it was marjory taylor green, it was gates. The magiest, most online, most controversial members were around him sitting him in the box. It wasn't the lindsey grahams or tom tellicks. These are the people that would be around him if he won again. I will just say, in a dark note. Like the overton window shifted to the green and paulina luna and marjory taylor green are on the more normal end of the spectrum. That's how crazy things have gotten. I mean, i think it bares mentioning the left has memes too. Kamala harris had brat summer. The coconut tree thing. I think we have exampleless of examples of that. There was j. D vance on a couch. But couches are not people. They were not bomb threats being called in. There were not schools closing. I just wonder if it tells you something about the inherent nature of the republican party at this point. The toxicity and the poison around the internet is so sort of, it is so, segregated meme. You're making fun of the politician, right. You should have a little bit of leeway. When you're spoofing people in this country has a long history. To me that's within the normal downs of politics. Creating fake conspiracy narratives that target groups with just totally lies. Objective racist lies. You would never say that about other groups. It's totally due to their race and immigrant status. Yes that is only happening on one side of the aisle among one political party and there's no reason to try to pretend otherwise. Tim miller, it is always good to talk to you even when the subject matter. Kamala harris trys to woo voters in two pennsylvania counties that donald trump won in 2020. We're going to tell you all about that but first. Republican justices on the north carolina supreme court do donald trump a solid by removing a third party challenger from the ballot and voters are going to pay the price. We're going to explain, next. This is better. This is better. That's better. And that. Even this. Dupixent is an addon treatment for specific types of moderatetosevere asthma. It works with your asthma medicine to help improve lung function. That's pretty good! dupixent is not for sudden breathing problems. It's proven to help prevent asthma attacks. It can reduce or even eliminate oral steroids. And doesn't that make things better? dupixent can cause allergic reactions that can be severe. Tell your doctor right away if you have rash, chest pain, worsening shortness of breath, tingling or numbness in your limbs. Tell your doctor about new or worsening joint aches and pain or a parasitic infection. Don't change or stop asthma medicines including steroids, without talking to your doctor. When you can get more out of your lungs, you can du more with less asthma. And isn't that better? ask your doctor about dupixent, the most prescribed biologic in asthma. My life is full of questions. . . How do i clean an aioli stain? use tide. Do i need to pretreat guacamole? not with tide. Why do we even buy napkins? thankfully, tide's the answer to almost all of them. —do crabs have eyebrows? —except that one. For all of life's laundry questions. . . It's got to be tide. My little miracle is beckett. ♪ (a thousand years by christina perri) ♪ ♪ i have died every day waiting for you ♪ we wouldn't be where we are without saint jude. And in turn, we wouldn't be where we are without those people that have donated. (♪♪) it was supposed to be the first state in the nation to send out 2024 general election ballots but instead, early voting in north carolina is officially on hold. That's because the state's republican controlled supreme court has granted third party candidate robert f. Kennedy jr. His request to remove his name from the north carolina ballot. Now the republican justices on the board granted this request even after it came five days after the state's official deadline. As a result nearly 3 million ballots that were already printed must now be destroyed. That is forcing election officials to miss a key deadline mandated by the state and to scramble to meet another deadline mandated by federal law. The court decision will shorten the early voting period in north carolina which is going to affect thousands potentially millions of voters including those who attended kamala harris' massive rallies in the state yesterday. But there is someone who will likely benefit from this. Donald trump, who now know longer has a third party challenger on the ballot and who is currently tied with kamala harris. For harris, that alone is an achievement given that barack obama has been the only democratic presidential nominee to win north carolina in nearly 50 years. The harris campaign believes that it too has a chance to win the state but only if people can actually vote. Joining me now is mark joseph stern, senior writer covering courts for the law. His latest piece is called robert f. Kennedy jr. , a critical swing state. This piece is essential reading. I think a lot of people had no idea what was happening in north carolina and indeed there are some developments tonight. But let's just first rewind to the outset of all of this. Rfk jr. Wants to get off the ballot in the state. You know transparently partisan maneuver to help the guy he's endorsed. Donald trumps and the courts decide hey why not. Can you talk a little bit about the process this happened? rfk jr. Waited days after the deadline in north carolina to remove his name from the ballots then he filed this overdue request. The election board said hey, we actually can't accommodate this. We've already printed millions of ballots. We've designed more than 2,300 ballots for every individual county and locality. We have to send them out under state law by september 6th. It will take us like 23 days at least to do this. So we just can't accommodate what you're asking of us. He went to court and secured a 32 decision by the north carolina supreme court. That is a court by elected republicans who issued i think a lawless and rather shameless decision accusing the election board and the state's very hard working and under paid election officials of engaging in misconduct. Of attempting to undermine rfks request because they somehow didn't read his mind and anticipate earlier that he would seek to withdraw his name from the ballot. State supreme court ordered the state elections and every county board of elections to violate the law. To violate state law which requires these ballots start going out by september 6th to destroy 3 million ballots. To redesign more than 3,400 ballots and to try to do all of this before the federal deadline of september 21st which congress has said, at which point these ballots have to go out to overseas and military voters. Tonight the state board elections is saying they have raced to accommodate this order. That they have purchased special printers and stationed them around the state to reprint millions of ballots. That they will spend probably millions of dollars in order to try to get these ballots out by september 24th to the general public that means the ballots will start going out more than two weeks after they were required to. They're still encouraging people to do all this as fast as possible because they don't know if they'll be able to run this election as smoothly as they had hoped. All of this to accommodate r. F. K. Jr. 's attack. That's the key part of it right. I believe wake county it's going to cost $60,000. Election workers are going to have to work through the weekend to accommodate rfk jr. A proxy for trump. How disturbed are you by the decision of the state supreme court and like how much do you read into that in terms of any future election related concerns or lawsuits? so i'm really disturbed and i just want to get into the weeds a little. Because the north carolina supreme court had years ago ruled that, the state constitution has this provision that guaranteed free elections. It says all elections shall be free. The north carolina supreme court says that restricts gerrymandering. They got the free elections clause and said this is a meaningless clause and there's no real guarantee for free elections. But when rfk went to the north carolina supreme court and said he wanted to be removed from the ballot. Those same republican justices sited the free elections clause in the state constitution as the reason why he could be removed from the ballot and why the entire early voting process had to be abridged and thrown into chaos. It's sheer partisan hackery for judges that were elected on partisan line. It tells me these guys are very much putting their thumb on the scale for trump in this election. We know more republicans vote early and vote by mail. It seems these justices are doing everything they can to cause chaos, wreak havoc, make it more difficult for democrats especially to cast their votes in 2024, to try to help trump prevent kamala harris from making this the tipping vote state. All states matter, right. The freedom and the fairness of our elections is of utmost concern to our representative of democracy. The fact of the matter is, kamala harris did two events in north carolina yesterday. The campaign believes this as you said could be the tipping point for a potential victory. And it's not the only state where this kind of chicanory which is probably being optimistic is under way. Do you have thoughts on the efforts going on in nevada or pennsylvania? two other crucially important states. In pennsylvania republicans are fighting hard to require the nullification of mail ballots. That are dated incorrectly. A minor error that shouldn't really matter. The state supreme court today said we're not going to decide that issue yet. That leaves it as a bomb under the table if that election is close. In nevada, one of trump's own lawyers is representing jill stine, asking the u. S. Supreme court to put her back on the nevada ballot after she was kicked off. No big mystery alex why a trump attorney would be representing jill stein here. Chicanary is the right word. This is all to ensure that in a close election, they can either flip it toward trump or if it still goes toward harris to claim there was fraud or wrong doing and deny the legitimate of the results. Are you telling me trump doesn't just want to have a system where voters gets their issues heard. You need to know what's happening at the state level as we head into november. Thanks for your writing, mark. Thanks, alex. Donald trump gets another small win in court but the clock is still ticking. And kamala harris went to the republican country but she might just find some willing to listen to her. We're going to talk about that sales pitch, next. Es as a pain, blistering rash that can last for weeks. And it could wake at any time. Think you're not at risk for shingles? it's time to wake up. Because shingles could wake up in you. If you're over 50, talk to your doctor or pharmacist about shingles prevention. [audience laughing] worried you'll laugh so hard you'll leak? well always discreet can hold your biggest gushes with up to zero leaks and odor. So you're not just dry. You're laugh until you cry dry. We've got you, always. Always discreet. Psst psst! aaaah! with flonase, allergies don't have to be scary. Spray flonase sensimist daily, for nondrowsy, longlasting relief. . . In a scentfree, fine mist. Psst psst! flonase. All good. Bombas makes absurdly comfortable underwear. Made to move with you, not on you. Because your basic things should be your best things. One purchased equals one donated. Visit bombas. Com and get 20% off your first order. Hayden: the fact st. Jude will take care of all this, this is what's keeping my baby girl alive. Chelsea: it's everything for us. We wouldn't know what to do. We couldn't afford for our little girl to survive. And st. Jude gives us that. [music playing] known for following your dreams. Known for keeping with tradition. Known for discovering new places. No one wants to be known for cancer, but a treatment can be. Keytruda is known to treat cancer. Fdaapproved for 17 types of cancer, including certain earlystage and advanced cancers. One of those cancers is earlystage nonsmall cell lung cancer. Keytruda may be used with certain chemotherapies before surgery when you have earlystage lung cancer, which can be removed by surgery, and then continued alone after surgery to help prevent your lung cancer from coming back. Keytruda can cause your immune system to attack healthy parts of your body during or after treatment. This may be severe and lead to death. See your doctor right away if you have cough, shortness of breath, chest pain, diarrhea, severe stomach pain, severe nausea or vomiting, headache, light sensitivity, eye problems, irregular heartbeat, extreme tiredness, constipation, dizziness or fainting, changes in appetite, thirst, or urine, confusion, memory problems, muscle pain or weakness, fever, rash, itching, or flushing. There may be other side effects. Tell your doctor about all your medical conditions, including immune system problems, if you've had or plan to have an organ, tissue, or stem cell transplant, received chest radiation or have a nervous system problem. Keytruda is an immunotherapy and is also being studied in hundreds of clinical trials exploring ways to treat even more types of cancer. It's tru. Keytruda from merck. See all the types of cancer keytruda is known for at keytruda. Com and ask your doctor if keytruda could be right for you. Ours is a fight for freedom. Like the fundamental freedom of a woman to make decisions about her own body. And not have her government telling her what to do. Vice president kamala harris was in johnstown and pennsylvania today. Both of which happened to be in counties that donald trump won by significant numbers in 2020. Republicans see a reproductive freedoms as critical. That's why donald trump made a garbled explanation of what he called fertilization but probably meant invitro fertilization. There is health care that will impact families that will impact communities. Joining me now is alexis miguel johnson, ceo of the parent election fund. Thank you for joining me. I'm really interested in the choice that vice president harris made today to campaign two counties, luzern county and cambria county which are decidedly republican counties. Biden got 42% and in cambria trump got 68% of the vote. Biden only got 30. 8. Now, i know abortion is an issue that motivates voters. It sort of seems toutful that they would win that seems doubtful that they would win this county. Can you talk a little bit about how you see abortion target the sort of center of the electorate. First of all let me be clear. The vice president has connected the dots on all of these issues. She understands that the fundamental right to control your own body, as it relates to abortion is also related to contraception. It's also related to ivf, it is also related to our democracy and i think she's been doing a beautiful job, out on the campaign trail. Helping voters understand really getting into the granular of what that will mean in people's practical lives right. In telling the stories as she has done incredibly during the debate. I think to go into the belly of the beast as she is doing right now in pennsylvania, counties that are rich in support for trump is actually really testing the assumption of what we know. Right. That the majority of american support access to reproductive freedom. And she's going to go find those voters and make the case to them that you know, it's one thing to support and stand in reproductive freedom and it's also critically important to elect champions for reproductive freedom if you want to ensure that a state like pennsylvania which currently you know has access to abortion does not actually end up with a national abortion ban under donald trump, effectively. You know what i think is so striking and the argument she's making to those voters. For the first time we have a national candidate for president, a woman who is able to tell the stories of the women who have been affected by the trump. Basically stun them into their senses. And i think the right is understanding that. John mcabie reacted in disbelief. Can someone track down the women kamala harris says are bleeding out in parking lots because roe v. Wade was overturned. Don't hold your breath. As it comes, rolling stone was able to track down the woman. Unlike the stories about people eating pets. Can you talk a little bit about sort of the evolution on this. I mean, look, it has been heartbreaking. We have heard numerous stories, public stories of women who have been sent to hospital parking lots to wait until they are just a little bit more in danger of their lives in order for a doctor to justify the treatment. It is, it is literally the first time i heard that story, one of those stories was during sb 8 in texas a year before dobbs as they were testing what it would look like to push such a ban through. And now we are here hearing more of them. I mean it is astonishing to me that you know, that they would be questioned. I think that, we are also at a moment where, people shouldn't have to tell their stories in such a, in such a challenging way. Like they're privacy. We're asking them to share the most intimate parts of their lives and their experiences and prove that. And, and also very appreciative because story telling is actually what helps us break down the stigma. But i think what the president is doing and what many of us are out there in terms of educating people about the, you know the very, very deep impact is trying to make it plain to folks that this is not a game. This is people's lives. This is, this is what when you don't have access to health care, people experience and when you put limitations on what doctors could do to support their patients, you ask them to call lawyers before they provide care. These are the kind of things that can happen. So i think that disruption that's happening in health care is coming through these stories is the best way to kind of put a name and a face on the data, right. That almost all of all women are living in a state with an abortion ban. More than half of black women are living in a state with an abortion ban. They're incredibly brave for those who are sharing it with us right now. As a matter of strategy to react to those stories with disbelief and skepticism and say prove it does not seem like the right response. Alexis miguel johnson with planned parent parent haoád. Parenthood, thank you for joining us. Thank you. And trump talks about his i election interference cases. Stay with us. ♪ as you go with ♪ austedo xr significantly reduced kate's td movements. Some people saw a response as early as 2 weeks. With austedo xr, kate can stay on her mental health meds— (kate) aww! hi buddy! (vo) austedo xr can cause depression, suicidal thoughts, or actions in patients with huntington's disease. Pay close attention to and call your doctor if you become depressed, have sudden changes in mood, or have suicidal thoughts. Don't take if you have liver problems, are taking reserpine, tetrabenazine, or valbenazine. Austedo xr may cause irregular or fast heartbeat, or abnormal movements. Seek help for fever, stiff muscles, problems thinking, or sweating. Common side effects include inflammation of the nose and throat, insomnia and sleepiness. ♪ as you go with austedo ♪ ask your doctor for austedo xr. ♪ austedo xr ♪ arearn: saint jude they gave it 110% every time. And for kenadie to get treatment here without having to pay anything was amazing. ♪ ♪ have you always had trouble losing weight and keeping it off? same. Discover the power of wegovy®. ♪ ♪ with wegovy®, i lost 35 pounds. And some lost over 46 pounds. ♪ ♪ and i'm keeping the weight off. Wegovy® helps you lose weight and keep it off. I'm reducing my risk. Wegovy® is the only fdaapproved weightmanagement medicine that's proven to reduce risk of major cardiovascular events in adults with known heart disease and with either obesity or overweight. Wegovy® shouldn't be used with semaglutide or glp1 medicines. Don't take wegovy® if you or your family had medullary thyroid cancer, multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2, or if allergic to it. Stop wegovy® and get medical help right away if you get a lump or swelling in your neck, severe stomach pain, or an allergic reaction. Serious side effects may happen, including pancreatitis and gallbladder problems. Wegovy® may cause low blood sugar in people with diabetes, especially if you take medicines to treat diabetes. Tell your provider about vision problems or changes, or if you feel your heart racing while at rest. Depression or thoughts of suicide may occur. Call your provider right away if you have any mental changes. Common side effects like nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea may lead to dehydration, which may cause kidney problems. With wegovy®, i'm losing weight, i'm keeping it off. And i'm lowering my cv risk. That's the power of we. ♪ ♪ check your cost and coverage before talking to your health care professional about wegovy®. Ok limu! you set it, and as i spike it, i'll tell them how liberty mutual customizes car insurance, so they only pay for what they need. Got it? [squawks] did you get that? only pay for what you need. ♪liberty, liberty,♪ ♪liberty, liberty. ♪ more judges would dropped yesterday in atlanta, georgia. It's all politically inspired. It's all against their political opponent. We won the case, the big case they won, they said the big case, the big case. I completely won that case, the documents case in florida. The case was thrown out. With deranged jack smith, deranged prosecutor. That was former president and convicted felon donald trump. There is no question that trump's legal strategy of delay and then delay some more appears to be paying off at least for now. Joining me to discuss all that is mary mccord, form earl acting assistant general and cohost of the indispensable podcast prosecuting donald trump. Mary it has been a moment but that does not mean things have not been happening in our justice system as it pertains to donald trump. Yesterday jack mcaffy dismissed two counts. But still eight felony counts remain. I do wonder, the supreme court's immunity decision and what that does to these ongoing cases. Do you think the georgia case survives in the wake of the supreme court's immunity decision. Because judge mcaffey has not ruled on that yet. I think that judge mcaffey will have to take briefing and go through any kind of allegations of official acts and do if kind of parsing that judge is doing right now. That is not what happened in his ruling yesterday. In fact, he makes it very clear in a footnote, my ruling here is not based on the immunity decision, it has not been briefed, it was not argued. I'm not even considering it. His ruling was based on arguments that frankly the entire indictment should be dismissed based on the supremacy clause. And an argument that basically the federal government is the only place where these kind of charges could be brought. Which is of course interesting, because in federal court, of course donald trump's lawyers are saying none of this could be brought in federal court either. And what judge mcaffey did is he relied on an 1890s case, not kidding. 1890 that stands for the principle that when you have perjury in a federal court, and there is a federal perjury statute that applies to it. Then there's not a state interest in also prosecuting that conduct. So the three charges that he dismissed were charges that involved one the complaint that donald trump and john eastman had filed in federal court that contained false statements. He said that's something that federal charges could take care of so we don't have a state interest. And then also, the transmission of false statements, the electoral, the fraudulent electoral college to the federal court in georgia. Which is one of the many destinations that electors have to submit. Those could be prosecuted in federal court under federal law therefor the state doesn't have an interest. He denied the motion to dismiss the entire indictment. There's plenty of other false statement charges that remain. Including the fraudulent e lek tores creating these documents themselves and transmitting them to the archivist. To everyone. It is a change in the indictment. There are still many many counts that remain including the rico count against donald trump. Yeah, don't tell donald trump that, because in his mind it's all going away. I do have to ask on the note. As we talk about charges that are going away and cases that are effected. Tonya duncan in dc there's thinks going on. Trump's response is due on the 17th and the government's reply to donald trump is due october 29th. So these are briefings on a number of topics including immunity. My question to you is, there's a fairly narrow question. Are we going as the public to get any of this? are we going to hear any of the arguments. I mean hear, are we going to see any of the filings. Do you think we'll see any of the evidence right now. Some of it is under seal. Do you think it will remain under seal. If there's more evidence brought up about trump's potential election interference that's a bomb shell for the political climate that we now exist in. It's unclear. Because her order did not say anything about filing under seal. And at the argument last week, there was no mention by the government or mr. Trump's attorneys or the judge of filing under seal. Now i do think, that there are protective orders about confidential. There are things that the special office would submit in their briefings that they might think might need to be under seal in which case they might file under seal and then the judge would probably order them to redact only those things that needed to be kept under seal and filed a private document that may be redacted. What we expect to see and i do think some of this will be publicly available is exactly what the special counsel said he would do. Outline their reasoning for why the superceding indictment does not include the pressure on state legislators, the speech on january 6th that incited a mob. And they will also try to accomplish why the conversations with mike pence, the pressure i should say on mike pence to refuse to count the legitimate electoral ballots from the swing states. They will argue that, that official act presumption of immunity with respect to that is, rebutted. Because that was not the president acting in his official, you know acting with respect to something that he has anything authority over. That's going to be a very explosive series of arguments to, regardless of whether we actually hear about them. Mike pence and his conversations with donald trump is something that i think everybody wants to know more about. Mary mccormick it's great to have your level of expertise with us on a friday night. Thanks for your time. Thank you. Coming up a programming note you do not want to miss. We will be right back. Upset stomach iberogast indigestion iberogast bloating iberogast thanks to a unique combination of herbs, iberogast helps relieve six digestive symptoms to help you feel better. Six digestive symptoms. The power of nature. Iberogast. A test or approve a medication. We didn't have to worry about any of those things thanks to the donations. And our family is forever grateful because it's completely changed our lives. ♪(voya)♪ there are some things that work better together. Like your workplace benefits and retirement savings. Voya helps you choose the right amounts without over or under investing. So you can feel confident in your financial choices voya, well planned, well invested, well protected. A bend with a bump in your erection might be painful, embarassing, difficult to talk about, and could be peyronie's disease or pd, a real medical condition that urologists can diagnose and have been treating for more than 8 years with xiaflex®, the only fdaapproved nonsurgical treatment for appropriate men with pd. Along with daily gentle penile stretching and straightening exercises, xiaflex has been proven to help gradually reduce the bend. Don't receive if the treatment area involves your urethra; or if you're allergic to any of the ingredients. May cause serious side effects, including: penile fracture or other serious injury during an erection and severe allergic reactions, including anaphylaxis. Seek help if you have any of these symptoms. Do not have any sexual activity during and for at least 4 weeks after each treatment cycle. Sudden back pain reactions and fainting can happen after treatment. Tell your doctor if you have a bleeding condition or take blood thinners as risk of bleeding or bruising at the treatment site is increased. Join the tens of thousands of men who've been prescribed xiaflex. Make an appointment with a xiaflextrained urologist. Visit bentcarrot. Com to find one today. ♪ upbeat music ♪ ♪♪ ♪♪ is it possible to count on my internet like my customers count on me? it is with comcast business. Keeping you up and running with our 99. 9% network reliability. And security that helps outsmart threats to your data. Moaire dida twoo? your data, too. There's even roundthe clock customer support. So you can be there for your customers. With comcast business, reliability isn't just possible. It's happening. Switch to reliable comcast business internet with security and get started for $49. 99 a month. Plus ask how to get up to a $500 prepaid card. Call today! c1 msnbc colleagues and i came together for a very special event that connected us and the hosts with you the viewer, the person. Here is some of our conversation we had at that fan fest with my coworker and friend joy reed. We have to talk about kamala debby harris y'all. We have to talk about her. Yes, yes. Listen, she has stepped and basically, right, right. People want to question what her background is. Basically she's alex plus me, okay. You're welcome. Just look at the stage. Get it in your mind. Caribbean american lady. Our moms noticed. Our moms noticed. Our moms did not not notice. If you weren't able to make it the brooklyn last weekend and you still want in on the action. Tomorrow night is your night. You can catch more of my conversation with joy during msnbc live, democracy 2024. A special two hour presentation of our premier fan event. You can get a behind the scenes look, plus discussions with