on msnbc. it's time for american voices with alecia menendez. >> thank you so much. hello everyone. we start with the release of 20 more hostages in gaza. 13 are israeli detainees and seven are foreign nationals. this is the second group of hostages to be released as a part of a cease-fire deal between hamas and israel. hamas delayed the release of this group for hours claiming israel violated the terms of the agreement. ey arrived in israel a short while ago. the alleged violations include continued attacks on civilians in gaza by israeli forces and mitions in aid from gaza. the white house has working with qatar, egypt and israel in implementation of the deal. the cease-fi is supposed to last for four days. the truth started yesterday after the four-day period, israel plans to resume ground attacks on gaza for at least the next two months. the health ministry in gaza said israel has already killed an estimated 14,500 civilians 5000 of which, were children. tell us how this deal nearly fell apart and what we know about how it was then put back together? >> this has been a nerve- racking evening here in israel, and in gaza, a couple of hours ago, hamas announced that it was delaying the release of the hostages, it was slamming on the rakes of this agreement, and they accused israel of breaching this deal in two ways, they said first of all israel is not allowing aid trucks to get it to the devastated regions of northern gaza where the fighting has been most intense, israel has been urging palestinian civilians to leave that area and it's not been allowing them to return during the course of the cease-fire and it doesn't want to do anything that would allow them to return home, so it's been reluctant to allow aid into the area. the second thing is, hamas saying israel failing to abide by a commitment to release palestinian prisoners by order of how long they have been in prison, hamas said the deal was, the longest-serving palestinian prisoners would be released first. now, we don't know the exact terms of this agreement. it is highly secret. we do know that yesterday israel released prisoners who had been serving for less time, the longest-serving prisoners remained inside prison. the israeli military tonight, flatly denying that it in any way breached the agreement and it fell once again to the qatari's, the mediators, who brokered this deal to salvage it because it did look like we might be on the verge of collapse. the foreign ministry saying that would help from egypt and help from the united states, they were able to bridge the gap and a few hours later, we saw the hostages being loaded into those white jeeps of the red cross in southern gaza. it's now a familiar choreography, they were taken through the rafah border crossing into egypt, crossing over . we now have an official list of those 13 israeli hostages, they range from toddlers to grandmothers and i'll tell you just about one family, the youngestages released tonight is three-year- old, she was released along with her eight-year-old brother and their mom, but their father remains a hostage of hamas. for all the joy and all the relief that their extended family will feel, her father is still inside gaza and there's no timeline for when he will be returned. >> absolutely was. i want to pull of the video we were just showing so we can show our audience what it is, it is video from the idf, the van that you see is hostages crossing over into israel. we talked about the hostages that have just been released. what more do we know about who it is that were in the fans? >> according to the israeli prime minister, today, hamas released 13 israeli hostages, as well as for high hostages. of the 13 israeli hostages, the majority of them are children, seven being released, the pictures that you are seeing were children, they also released an official list, identifying the names of the hostages, ranging in age from 3 to 67, they grouped this list by families. the weiss family, sherry weiss, 53 years old, the statement saying the israeli government together with all the security forces will accompany them and their families. now that they have crossed over into egypt, they will be taken to five distinct hospitals in israel for medical treatments, and then they will be reunited with their families. i can tell you, i have been in contact with thomas hand, he is the father, single father of emily hand, she's listed as eight years old but i know that she is now nine, she turned nine in captivity. on october 7th, when hamas militants told -- stormed their cupboards, she was at a sleepover with her best friend and she was kidnapped but days later, thomas was told that emily was dead. and it wasn't until weeks later that he was notified by israeli authorities that she was alive, believed to be a hostage and now, we are seeing images of him being reunited with family inside israel. it's a remarkable story but it's one of many. in terms for the process for tomorrow, we do not know the number of hostages or the timing, there's much we do not know but it is expected that the families, tomorrow, or today, rather, have received a phone call, the remaining hostages, letting them know if their loved ones will in fact be released tomorrow, if they are on the list. it's been described by families we've been talking today, as a harrowing weight, once they get the call, either way they say that each release gives them hope for the next release, and potentially the next release for as long as this goes. >> you hear many of the hostages saying that the hostages have become a family and a unit unto themselves. we have been reminded over and over again today how tenuous these deals are. one of the sticking points has been getting aid into gaza, humanitarian aid into gaza. where does the effort stand tonight? >> it remains the case that even while there are hundreds of eight trucks now crossing over from egypt into gaza, it is just a fraction, an absolute fraction of what people in gaza need, for 49 days, they have been under intense israeli bombardment in retaliation for the october 7th hamas attack. they have been besieged, there has been only an absolute trickle of the basic necessities coming in, most of gaza, still without electricity. many places without running water, and one of the big questions is how does this situation in the north work? we have seen crowds of palestinians gathering on main roads in gaza, during the cease- fire, and they want to go back to their homes in gaza city, in the refugee camp, in the northern areas, they want to see for starters, if their homes are still standing because the un says about half of all the homes in gaza have been destroyed. and they want to go back and get things that they weren't able to carry when they fled in the first place. and the israeli military is for for bidding that. they have effectively do -- divided gaza, we've heard reports of them firing into the air, to, at least two palestinians were killed by israeli fire, after the cease- fire began in one of those confrontations at the checkpoints, and while the cease-fire is holding in the big picture sense that we are not seeing israeli forces exchanging fire with either hamas or palestinian islamic jihad, there's a lot of concern about these crowds of palestinians and the possibility that israeli forces really use live fire to keep them back. >> thank you both. i like to bring in whitehurst -- white house correspondent allie raffa. >> reporter: we've seen that credit even by israeli and qatari officials who credit the president's direct involvement, his continued pressure, for sealing this deal and we know that engagement continue today, before, during and after this hours long caused by hamas in the releasing of these hostages. we know that president biden spoke with qatari leaders about this cause and what obstacles needed to be overcome to continue the release of these hostages, according to an official white house readout, the leaders agreed to remain in close contact, to ensure that this deal is fully implemented according to its terms. we know the security officials were in touch all day with their counterparts, on what needed to be accomplished to be able to see what we are seeing now with the release of these hostages back into israel, and they say it was around 1:30 p.m., eastern time that qatari officials let them know that this deal was back on and the international red cross was in route to pick up these hostages, and bring them back into israel, they say the president continues to be updated on the latest there. but the last few hours, just underscoring how incredibly fluid and delicate these negotiations, this deal in general, has been, that something we heard the president and white house officials say in the weeks following this war, how incredibly fragile it is and how every single piece of this moving puzzle has to fit perfectly for the successes to continue. the president thing yesterday that he continues to be in touch with his counterparts in egypt and qatar, and as the deal has come to fruition, it still not over, they're hoping americans are among the next patches of hostages being released. >> what are you hearing about the american hostages? >> reporter: we know, obviously, that americans were not among the hostages released today, but the president said he continues to be hopeful that at least three, two american women as well as a four-year- old girl, are among the hostages released in the coming days. so the next two days that the cease-fire is set to be in place, the president, in just the last hour, asked by reporters in nantucket, when we could expect to see more hostages released and he said hopefully we will see something soon but at least they were learning tonight from u.s. officials, that tell nbc that there is concern that hamas may be waiting until potentially the fourth and final day to release american hostages, so that the u.s. continues to pressure israel to keep the cease-fire in place. so more aid will be able to flow into gaza but these officials say they don't have an independent official assessment to be able to confirm that. so right now, we continue to hear from the president as well as officials that they are hopeful that they will be released and so far, there's no indication, letting them know that there is less of a chance that they will be released considering the first two hostages released by hamas two weeks after the war began work in american mother and daughter. >> thank you. new developments in donald trump civil trial, after hundreds of thousands of threatening email's are sent to the judge and his court. as trump's trials drag on, will his water carriers step in on his behalf. later, elon musk goes after media matters for its reporting. the company's president is here to respond. first, richard louis with the other big stories we are tracking this hour, richard? >> before minneapolis police officer convicted of murdering george floyd was stabbed in a federal prison friday. jerry derek chauvin is in stable condition in the hospital. the attorney general's office that he is expected to survive. ukraine officials say russia launched its largest drone attack in kyiv, since the start of the war. at least five people were hurt and many buildings damaged in the attack on saturday. ukraine's air force chief said they were able to down 71 of the 75 drones launched in different districts. and actress tiffany haddix was arrested friday on suspicion of driving under the influence in beverly hills. police say they found the emmy and grammy award winner slumped over her car while it was still running. she was arrested for a similar incident in atlanta, last year. more american voices after this break. as someone living with type 2 diabetes, i want to keep it real and talk about some risks. with type 2 diabetes you have up to 4 times greater risk of stroke, heart attack, or death. even at your a1c goal, you're still at risk ...which if ignored could bring you here... ...may put you in one of those... ...or even worse. too much? that's the point. get real about your risks and do something about it. talk to your health care provider about ways to lower your risk of stroke, heart attack, or death. learn more at getrealaboutdiabetes.com in order for small businesses to thrive, they need to be smart, efficient, savvy. making the most of every opportunity. that's why comcast business is introducing the small business bonus. for a limited time you can get up to a $1000 prepaid card with qualifying internet. yep, $1000. so switch to business internet from the company with the largest fastest reliable network and that powers more businesses than anyone else. learn how you can get $1000 back for your business today. comcast business. powering possibilities. this week, republican new york congressman elise stefanik is once again declaring victory after a court paused a guy order barring trump and his legal team from attacking the judge and staff. you will require desperate recall she filed, claiming bias, friday she tweeted in part, the site doesn't end here, and antiquated the lifted gag order to fighting for all americans first amendment rights. nevermind that trump so-called free speech has led to hundreds of serious and credible threats against the people he's been targeting, and i think giving post he once again bashed da will willis and others, robert garcia serves on the house oversight committee. so much to get to but this weaponization of the first amendment. the way that stefanik would like people to understand the first amendment, the way donald trump would like people to understand the first amendment, it seems like the bases they are forming for his reelection? >> 100%. look, i think , will do whatever it takes to get picked and his vice presidential running mate and so she's going to spend all of her time defending donald trump, doing whatever she can to intimidate the courtroom, as well as she's been doing already within the house to try to get his agenda enacted, so they have no regard for the process, this should be in serious process and trump is out there attacking this judge and all court officials, every single day, the things that you say are beneath any person, let alone a major candidate for the presidency. so the first amendment is one thing, but you can't also put people in danger and what his words are doing is actually putting people in danger, he is setting up something very dangerous if he got reelected president. i think he is basically telling us that he's going to go after his enemies and needs the justices to do so. >> the ethics complaint that elise stefanik filed has nothing in actually to do with the pause on this gag order. we've seen just how dangerous he can be. he has ramped up tax on the judge in the case, meanwhile you've got house speaker johnson recently visiting trump in mar-a-lago even though we could be barreling toward another government shutdown without any specific packages past, the statement of priority seems pretty clear. >> i mean mike johnson, i don't even think he knows what he's doing. he had to go down to mar-a-lago to get his marching orders from trump. he is fully in the pocket like elise stefanik from donald trump, that's what the goal is to try and damage and hurt biden in any way they can and ensure that he is reelected, that's why they are there, that is why trump supported his election to speaker, and he's done everything he can, to align himself from these extreme voices in the party. mike johnson also has no plan, of course we have acr which by the way, democrats are the one that got that across the finish line, he can't control his own caucus, they are already rebelling against him and the main thing on his agenda this week is going to be the expulsion of george santos. so he really has nothing in front of the american people, so we are going to continue to work hard every day and push back but i think like johnson has a lot to answer for. how is he going to solve the budget crisis and save american jobs, how will he save the american economy and what is his position going to be on the expulsion of george santos that will be up this week? a lot of folks are ready to listen. >> that start where you ended because yes, part of this is seeing where the speaker is on the expulsion of punishment santos, there's also just a question as you and i have talked about before of the map, do you feel you now have the numbers? >> i think we do. in fact, besides all democrats that will be united i'm sure, many democrats have voted not to expel him for a variety of different reasons, they have all said they were going to, we've seen an avalanche of republicans come through, particularly the ones that said they would not expel him, they are now saying that they would. george santos himself has said even as early as last night that he thinks he is going to be expelled, and he's right. and what i told him last night, we were on a twitter space together and i told him look, you should do the right thing right now, and resign, why are you putting yourself through this horrible idea but more important, why are you putting your constituents and the american people through this? he owes everyone a huge apology. he should do the right thing tonight and resign. if he does not resign, we are going to expel him next week. >> i want to pull a thread through all of these stories because i think it's easy to see them as bird stories but you and i know there's a through line and we talk about someone like elise stefanik carrying water , when you talk about the santos expulsion and the fact that the speaker is not clear on where he stands on that. all of it is happening along the backdrop of the fact that what everyone should be doing is focusing on governing, should be focusing on permanently funding our government so as we look ahead, putting aside all of that nonsense, if you think the party currently in charge of the house of representatives is going to be able to carry it over the finish line? >> absolutely not, the truth is, our government is largely broken today because of the attacks, relentless attacks on our institution by donald trump. we have george santos today because of donald trump. elise stefanik who used to have a broader worldview of how to help improve the government has completely gone off the deep end as an extremist even within her own party of the one thing that kind of ties all this together is donald trump's grip on his party, on his base, and he has destroyed much of our faith in government, our faith in media. we have to do everything we can to ensure that he does not become president again. his marching orders that he's giving to johnson and those in congress, we will try and fight back every single time. we've got to get a budget passed and into this whole charade of different budget deals passing that will never pass the senate. >> thank you for taking the time to be with us. next, we will breakdown the other recent twist and turns in donald trump's legal sagas plus hamas releases more hostages after threatening to delay the deal. new video of their release, details, straight ahead. and everything ships free! plus, pay your way with the wayfair credit card. shop wayfair's lowest prices of the year during black friday now through nov 27th. ♪ wayfair, you've got just what i need ♪ sleep more deeply. and wake up rejuvenated. purple mattresses exclusive gel flex grid draws away heat. relives pressure and instantly adapts. sleep better live purple. right now save up to $900 dollars off mattress sets during purple's black friday sale. visit purple.com or a store near you today. my most important kitchen tool? my brain. so i choose new neuriva ultra. unlike some others, it supports 7 brain health indicators, including mental alertness from one serving. to help keep me sharp. try new neuriva ultra. think bigger. we're travelling all across america, talking to people about their hearts. wh-who wants to talk about their heart! how's the heart? how's your heart? how's your heart? it's good. is it? aah, i don't know. it's okay. it's okay! yeah. good. you sure? i think so. how do you know? it doesn't come with a manual, and you like ooh, i got the 20,000-day checkup, right? let me show you something. put two fingers right on those pads. look at that! that's your heart! that is pretty awesome. with kardiamobile, you can take a medical-grade ekg in just 30 seconds, from anywhere. kardiamobile is proven to detect atrial fibrillation, one of the leading causes of stroke. and it's the only personal ekg that's fda-cleared to detect normal heart rhythm, bradycardia and tachycardia. how much do you think this costs? probably in the hundreds. $79. oh wow! that could be cheaper than a tank of gas. cyber monday starts today. kardiamobile is now just $69, our lowest price ever. get it for yourself or a loved one at kardia.com or amazon. [♪♪] we come from people we can be proud of. [♪♪] seeing all the places i come from, i know, if it's a serrano it's something to be proud of. give the gift of family heritage with ancestry. joining the fight over donald trump's, the court system. court officials warning trump's comments have created a serious security risk with the fbi and dhs force to protect the judge in the case. they also say the clerk is dealing with a dailies of threats since trump singled her out including hundreds of anti- semitic calls and text to her personal phone. trump's gag order is positive until monday and that's when an appeals panel is set to meet in new york. jill is a cohost of the sisters in law podcast and author of the watergate girl. also with us is analyst david jolly. it's good to see you both. i've got to know, how much do you expect the filing to sway the new york appeals court on trump's gag order or do you think it was already pretty baked? >> i think there was already enough evidence of what he does when there is in a gag order, and how he confuses his rights as a criminal defendant with his rights as a political candidate. and it's not unusual for criminal defendants to have limitations on their speech put in place, especially, when there is a nexus between their speech and threats to the people they are speaking about. and that is what is happening in new york. the evidence of the number of threats that came in, to judge engoron's clerk as a result of trump's speaking ill of her is enough reason to stop him because even the first amendment for a political candidate does not allow that candidate to do something like yell fire in a theater or to use words that will lead his followers to take action. we've seen plenty of conduct that is action based on his speech. so i think the gag order should be put back in place, and enforced. >> to that point, david, trump posted his first thanksgiving message online at 2:00 a.m., apparently turkey has the opposite effect on him then it doesn't most of us, mostly a rant about the attorney general, the judge, what is that signal to you about his reelection campaign that this is where he is spending his time, his effort, his energy. >> fascinating, look, in past years, his holiday messages have attacked socialists and democrats and the deep state and this was an unhinged screen against prosecutors and judges and it gives you a little bit in terms of his state of mind and we continue to step closer and closer to donald trump possibly losing his own liberty either because of pretrial behaviors and attacks on prosecutors and judges or a conviction, and we have not seen what donald trump ultimately does in that environment, so what's the political analysis? i think we've seen it does not change the calculus for his election. i don't think he has a lead over biden like the polls show because when people see his behavior, his behavior, they are reminding that he is an unstable, unhinged man, who should not be returning to the white house and that is enough to protect joe biden's lead going into a matchup. >> to remind everyone, we are talking about multiple gag orders, we just talked about the new york gag order so david's point about being unhinged, let's talk about the fact that they have a panel of d.c. judges still weighing whether to impose trump's federal gag order. it would seem that they are considering narrowing the restrictions on trump. i wonder if you agree with that analysis and if you could sort of explain why that is? >> the reason they are considering it, is because he does have some rights as a political candidate that need to be protected. we need to be able to hear his views and to vote taste on what he says, versus what president biden says. the narrowing depends on what exactly the details are. if, as they seem to be leaning, that they will narrow it, slightly, to make it very clear what he can say versus what he can't, it's really more for clarification then to narrow it so much. it's as if there was some vagueness that was alleged, and wasn't ridiculous in what was alleged, so they may clarify exactly you know, can he say this, can you not say that, and i think that is fair enough. i wouldn't be upset about that. if they eliminate a gag order, that would concern me because all criminal defendants, first of all, we the people have a right to a fair trial, just as much as the defendant has a right to a fair trial and if his language is something that is going to hurt our right to a fair trial by intimidating jurors, by intimidating witnesses, by intimidating codefendants, then, it must be stopped. >> as a reminder, we are part of the trial, too, as american citizens. david, when you step back, all of this is about the ways that he has undermined institutions, democracy written large. you and i have the conversation many times about the role that republican electives would need to place why thought this interesting article, take a listen to one of the founders. >> we believe that the legal profession is uniquely positioned and uniquely obligated to support and defend american democracy and the rule of law. at this particular moment in our history. >> i've got about a minute left but as a recovering attorney and recovering republican, i wonder what you make of that take? >> i welcome it. the legal apparatus has largely survived the threats of trump. it's the political actors that we risk seeing topol the entire thing. so if there are conservative jurisprudence to get out there and say, we are going to be on this message of protecting the constitution and they can survive donald trump, great, because they will be in partnership with others trying to protect the constitution. my concern went to my the folks like elise stefanik, were willing to use the political leadership and their leverage to fundamentally change and destroy the constitution. that is the danger of this moment going into next year. >> as always, thank you both so much. coming up, more on the hostage deal that almost wasn't. new details on the former hostages who are now on their way back to their families and elon musk files suit against media matters for reporting on him. stay with us. (ella) fashion moves fast. (jen) so we partner with verizon to take our operations to the next level. (marquis) with a custom private 5g network. (ella) we get more control of production, efficiencies, and greater agility. (jen) that's enterprise intelligence. (vo) it's your vision, it's your verizon. somedays, i cover up because of my moderate to severe plaque psoriasis. now i feel free to bare my skin, thanks to skyrizi. ♪(uplifting music)♪ ♪nothing is everything♪ i'm celebrating my clearer skin... my way. with skyrizi, 3 out of 4 people achieved 90% clearer skin at 4 months. in another study, most people had 90% clearer skin, even at 5 years. and skyrizi is just 4 doses a year, after 2 starter doses. serious allergic reactions and an increased risk of infections or a lower ability to fight them may occur. tell your doctor if you have an infection or symptoms, had a vaccine, or plan to. thanks to clearer skin with skyrizi - this is my moment. there's nothing on my skin and that means everything! ♪nothing is everything♪ now's the time. ask your doctor about skyrizi, the #1 dermatologist-prescribed biologic in psoriasis. learn how abbvie could help you save. [coughing] copd hasn't been pretty. it's tough to breathe and tough to keep wondering if this is as good as it gets. but trelegy has shown me that there's still beauty and breath to be had. because with three medicines in one inhaler, trelegy keeps my airways open and prevents future flare-ups. and with one dose a day, trelegy improves lung function so i can breathe more freely all day and night. trelegy won't replace a rescue inhaler for sudden breathing problems. tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high blood pressure before taking it. do not take trelegy more than prescribed. trelegy may increase your risk of thrush, pneumonia, and osteoporosis. call your doctor if worsened breathing, chest pain, mouth or tongue swelling, problems urinating, vision changes, or eye pain occur. ♪ what a wonderful world ♪ ask your doctor about once-daily trelegy for copd because breathing should be beautiful. ♪ we're building a better postal service. with easy, more affordable ways to ship. so you can deliver even more holiday joy. the united states postal service. delivering for america. breaking news in the isreal- hamas war, after an hours long delay, the second release of hostages from gaza went ahead as planned. routine is rarely hostages and for thai nationals were released. the idf released this video of the hostages crossing into israel. you see it right there. hamas delayed the exchange earlier over a dispute about the terms. meanwhile the isreal-hamas war is continuing to stoke divisions here at home. antonio hinton traveled to cornell for a closer look. >> the campus of cornell may look the same as always but it feels different here. students are on edge and have been since the war began and a student was arrested for making violent anti-semitic threats. >> how would you describe the climate right now? >> we are getting threats on campus. it's like how can you mourn? >> i'm numb, i feel like i'm desensitized. >> we asked students for justice in palestine and students from the, both declined to meet together. >> it's not an intellectual exercise to debate and discuss. >> jewish students zoe and simone. >> my cousin is a paratrooper in the idf, he's 20 and within the first day of the war, 20 of his friends were killed or taken hostage. >> malarkey is palestinian and has family in gaza. she said her grandparents were forced out of their homes in 1943. >> at one point, the tension was so high at cornell, classes were canceled. in this form of education is now investigating alleged harassment complaints at cornell and other schools. >> i've noticed a lot more stairs, a lot or and ease just around me being around. >> it's been challenging for people on this campus. i'm seeing seeing my peers march down the street chanting things like from the river to the sea which we have seen as a call for the ethnic cleansing of jewish people. >> many muslim students say it's a call for equal rights. >> assess from the river from the sea, palestine will be free. the question is where is it from the river to the sea palestinians should not feel safe. let's look at the map and say i palestinians to be free and jewish folks to be free, everywhere from the river to the sea. >> my problem is with that slogan whatever message people think they are sharing, because hamas has used it. it's been appropriated by a terrorist organization. >> cornell has increased security and promised new programs to file -- fight anti- semitism. >> our coalition, our organizations came together and condemned anti-semitism. >> what would it take to maybe just slightly open the door to either healthier dialogue or more dialogue here on campus. >> for no one on this campus for no one to use that slogan, i think it's just too painful for jewish students to hear. >> until i can be seen as a human and until my humanity of being a muslim and palestinian is seen first, then it's hard to have a conversation. >> for now, neither side believes the other can see their humanity. >> our thanks for that report. next, billionaire elon musk, facing blowback for anti-semitic comments and advertising is, the president of media matters which musk is suing, joins us next. follow us across social media. follow us, we will be right back. right back when my doctor gave me breztri for my copd things changed for me. breztri gave me better breathing, symptom improvement, and reduced flare-ups. breztri won't replace a rescue inhaler for sudden breathing problems. it is not for asthma. tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high blood pressure before taking it. don't take breztri more than prescribed. breztri may increase your risk of thrush, pneumonia, and osteoporosis. call your doctor if worsened breathing, chest pain, mouth or tongue swelling, problems urinating, vision changes, or eye pain occur. ask your doctor about breztri. stolen elon musk recently announced a lawsuit against media matters in response to research published by the organization showing ads for prominent trends routinely appeared next to anti-semitic post. media matters published their findings, numerous companies rethinking their spending on x formerly known as twitter. the lawsuit alleges that media matters is trying to sabotage the plat forms relationship with its advertisers and demands they take the article off its website. it also claims the juxtaposed images were manufactured and not what users typically saw on the platform. in a statement, media matters president called the lawsuit frivolous and an attempt to bully critics into silence. angela, i've been wanting to talk with you about this all week. what did i miss? >> i think the thing that is important to know is he is certainly not suing us for anything that it is false, the complaint acknowledges that everything we reported was accurate, the things are. exactly the way they said. as we are running alongside that content but i would emphasize, this is one report of many that we've been publishing over months, and it also illustrates the same issue , they promised a suite of new ad tools that were supposed to prevent these things from happening so they've given up on the idea that the platform is going to be a safe haven for nazis, they've been telling advertisers, don't worry, even though the toxicity has gotten worse, we have special tools that will make sure that you never get embarrassed and so all of these reports basically illustrate one thing. the mechanisms that they say exist, to prevent apps from running alongside that content, are not working the way they claim and that's the important thing here. fundamentally, and they acknowledge it, the ads did run and so have other ads in the same way as you seem reporting not just from us. nbc has made the same reports. >> you will understand the spirit in which i asked this question, which is, if you don't care about media matters and you don't really care about x, why should you care about what is unfolding? >> i think the thing that's worth considering is number 1, the way in which, where they filed the lawsuit, they chose a jurisdiction that would be beneficial for them, which i understand but when you consider this lawsuit is part of a series of things that they are doing at the same time, so taking up stephen miller's recommendation to enlist republican attorney generals to run parallel to the lawsuit, investigations of other attempts to criminally publish media matters for reporting the thing that was accurate about x in retaliation, that's when you have to worry about, what does this mean for the future because elon musk took the call from stephen miller, put a bunch of money into the litigation but then said who would do this and a few of them started running with ease. why should people court care? because it's a small window into the future where you can basically punish media outlets for reporting accurate things, simply because you don't like them and not only with those outlets suffer, the real effect is that most places are going to stop doing things that might get them in trouble like this, because they just don't want to deal with the consequences or it has a chilling effect. that's why people should care because it's the nest -- next iteration. >> do you think that the exodus of advertisers holds? >> i think so. and i think a big factor to that is that musk's only behavior, he didn't just engage with an anti-semitic conspiracy theory that somehow, and america are funding mass immigration, he responded by saying the actual truth, it's very hard to say oh i was just misinterpreting it, i think his own conduct, helps reinforce why the advertiser exodus state because it shows is a lens through which they can think through all the things happening on x. why does it seem like there's much more nazi content, why does it seem like the tools they are promising us, the safety tools are not working the way they should. it's because when you look at it through the lens of the key decision-maker there, he doesn't really see a problem or at least seemingly, with a lot of this content because it's also a reflection of his own worldview. so if you are a business person or advertiser you are saying, this isn't worth the brand risk to be associated with something where the rot goes all the way to the top. >> i to ask you angelo, everything you are saying about the platform itself, about the role that gop attorneys general are paying in carrying musk's water, why it matters when you are 11 months out from an increasingly consequential presidential election? >> that is the key factor. you know x and twitter, all the social media platforms play a role in our information ecosystem. even though x has had a diminished presence since elon musk took it over, it still provides at this point a safe haven for extremists, it's algorithms allow for connecting power on the fringes, and that ties in with the republican strategy which is to build power, political power on what used to be on the set of the fringes. if you can turn those tools to facilitate and support that ideology, to help build power, that's where the consequences really start to become magnified. it's far beyond x, it provides a launchpad for disinformation for extremism that will be tied into not just peoples civic participation in elections but the aftermath. and we saw how consequential that was last election site. >> as always, thank you for joining us. coming up, an update on the hostages hamas just release. we have brand-new video. new developments over the holiday on donald trump including the possible reinstatement of the gag order. later, a party in shambles, blindly following an accused felon, jasmine crockett talks to us about the mess that is the modern gop. modern gop like carpal tunnel syndrome, shortness of breath, and irregular heartbeat could be something more serious called attr-cm, a rare, underdiagnosed disease that worsens over time. sound like you? call your cardiologist, and ask about attr-cm. liberty mutual customized my car insurance and i saved hundreds. with the money i saved, i started a dog walking business. i was a bit nervous at first but then i figured it's just walking, right? [dog barks] oh. no it's just a bunny! calm down taco. sit duchess. stop! sesame no no. archie! walter don't, no, ahhhh. ahhhhh! you're lucky you're so cute. only pay for what you need. ♪liberty. liberty. liberty. liberty.♪ sometimes jonah wrestles with falling asleep... ...so he takes zzzquil. the world's #1 sleep aid brand. and wakes up feeling like himself. get the rest to be your best with non-habit forming zzzquil. ♪ ♪ we're travelling all across america, talking to people about their hearts. how's the heart? good. you sure? i think so. how do you know? let me show you something. put two fingers right on those pads. look at that! that's your heart! that is pretty awesome. with kardiamobile, you can take a medical-grade ekg in just 30 seconds, from anywhere. kardiamobile is proven to detect atrial fibrillation, one of the leading causes of stroke. cyber monday starts today. kardiamobile is now just $69, our lowest price ever. get it for yourself or a loved one at kardia.com or amazon.