You agree with the proposal to increase these salaries based on inflation or not . In the name of god. I would also like to congratulate you on the blessed month of ramadan and the beginning of the year 9. And to my dear viewers, i say hello. In article 41 of the labor law, there are 2 debates. One debate is to look at the actual minimum inflation of each years inflation , it is not necessarily the same as the inflation, because in fact the composition of the councilors and. Is to make the right decision according to the times the same as in the year 401 above naq torn decided 414 , dont make a mistake that 574 was decided. In 402, in fact , circumcision was different and 27 was added that it is necessarily the same as inflation, the law did not say. Looking at inflation, banana is the first topic in the discussion. The second is that the issue of livelihood sabbath came up, he said that at least the position of the worker should be such that the household that the Statistics Center now declares the official authorities to provide the minimum needs of the household. That the friends of mr mir ghaffarims explanation mr. Doctor s explanation was the discussion that we had 9 expert meetings in the banana committee meeting, where i myself was in the meetings, in those meetings, when we talk about the minimum , we cannot, in fact, it is because everyone has his own expertise. He should defend it from the point of view and give his opinion anyway, it is recommended that it is under the opinion of the ministry of health, the Standard Center is actually the preparation of the basket of goods, the basket of livelihood , which he made to rozestani and officially notified, but in fact he also notified the official centers. That we announced in the mozdem Committee Meetings that we accept whatever the official moraze says discuss the basket with what number. Friends, in the meetings, the minimum basket and the desired basket were discussed. As a rule, according to the law , when we talk about the minimums, i avoid this to the statistics that the Statistics Center and the organization itself have exaggerated. According to the latest statistics, which is november , we have 110,000 people with compulsory insurance, and 11 of these insured people work in workshops with more than 10 people, and 89 in workshops with less than 10 people. They work scattered, we asked why which of these households and these workers are minimum wage workers, i said that the majority of scattered 22 53 of them are minimum wage earners , they get between 1 and 2 times the minimum, that is, the distribution of this is about 70 and 5 is in the 4th decile. This was the statistic that the temashtamai organization itself confirmed , according to the latest information of the welfare system of iranians. D4 of our Statistics Center is saying that there is a good basket for those who take the minimum amount, which has more calories than that, about 300 and a little more calories. It is a good basket. We are talking about this sabbath we are talking, of course, in the prices announced by the Statistics Center, two prices should be announced , and an average of the minimum prices should be scattered and available. Or the maximum prices , friends, come between the minimum and the maximum , take an average and put it in this basket, then the difference will be very large, at least it was actually obtained based on this form, i said that we did not obtain it because we have no dignity at all. The Statistics Center of the ministry of health and the ministry of economy itself i will tell you the number obtained in the meetings. We did not get a number ourselves, we participated in the meetings. We can have it, we cant have it, the desired consumption basket that was extracted in the meetings was a number of 15 million 200 thousand tomans. With the corrections that were made in the last meeting , it was 16,800,000 tomans, because a series of real numbers, a series of numbers that were needed, were corrected , 16,80,000 tomans, this was the number that was approved. The ministry of economy was the center of statistics, which was precisely the statistics and information given by mr. Mirghafari to the point mr. Javani mentioned. Please give your opinion on these two points. Yes, mr. Javani , they pointed out that it should meet the minimum needs , that is, the minimum wage should meet the minimum needs. One or two more, well , ill explain, from this point of view, they say the limits are against the law 89. You said that in dehak, where there are four working communities , i read the labor law, which clearly does not say anywhere about the minimum requirements, article 41, clause d, the minimum wage , without considering the physical and mental characteristics of the workers and the characteristics of the assigned work, should be equal to to ensure the life of a family whose average number is announced by official authorities. Do it, so nowhere did it say that it should meet the minimum needs, this is a misunderstanding of the law , which i hope will be corrected, it said no , read the first paragraph again, when the minimum is continued, if it was needed, it said that the minimum wage should be at least the needs were not met, at least he didnt provide, he said, at least no, it should be said, he is saying at least, well, what is going to happen in article 41 , at least from this point of view, we can go and have a different view there. This misinterpretation of this law causes friends to take out the items of the judicial basket when they read the judicial basket as if they are taking out the judicial basket for the people of the relief committee. Let me complete it , not for the labor force, dont forget, not for the labor force. A work whose age range is mainly between 30 and 60 years and the required calories according to the same report institute of nutrition 2840 kcal per day means that this view should not be selective , it should be a complete and comprehensive view. Basically, we say that there should be a favorable basket that the labor force can meet its needs. In fact, there is someone more knowledgeable than you who is a lawmaker. If he were to say average or desirable, of course, he will bring the optimal in the law. When we decide on the minimum , you see, we, the Statistical Community, which i have, have statistics and the basis of statistics to provide you with a Statistical Center for you do not have a Statistical Community that is actually high at least he says that we dont have anything to do with it, which is actually other levels, there are other things , we dont have anything to do with it , we dont decide about the minimums, we dont decide about the maximums, we dont say that the maximum should be so limited, we dont decide about the averages, we decide about the minimum we decide, we want to say that the employer of your workshop should not pay less than this. Lets say in one place that our difference is that we dont want to talk populist and populist. In the past, maybe you are a workaholic. At least i have been in the council for 4 and 5 years. I was in various committees. I am asking you to come and face the facts to the people of the community. We make decisions for those who take the minimum. On the food and housing basket, this inflation that occurs causes the labor force to fall behind every year , the economic table becomes smaller. It can be said that when i cant actually provide for my livelihood basket, what does it mean that i can no longer reach my health, which means that my health goes to the next priorities of the discussion of education. Allow me, i came from south pars gas refinery, i came from the bottom of my society , i see that my colleague and i have to find a second or third job to meet our needs. They go to another workshop for daily wages , but the conditions of the workshop we are in are comparable. If i defend a worker, he is a populist, someone will talk the woman who comes says that salary has an effect on inflation, mr. Mir ghaffari, their view is that the minimum salary should be determined based on inflation. Is that correct . Now, mr. Jovani, if you can answer this , i dont know the table, whether your phone can show it or not. Look, the worker is not separate from the employer, can i leave my own human capital, which is the labor force, and not reach it, then we claimed that our workshop would progress, we do not accept this at all, no one, worker and worker are not the same in front of us, if we lag behind and talk about the basket why dont we tell the facts to the society . Why dont we say that . Livelihood basket 39 edible items are not edible 61 62 are nonedible items i will read this for you, maybe it will help you to see who is to blame here. There is housing, there is healthcare, there is treatment, there is transportation, we have nothing to do with the number, you see , there is clothing, there is communication, there is education in the constitution , it says Free Education in the timishmani law, it says free healthcare when i pay 30, i am a worker and i understand, as a rule, i should not be treated. In the constitution, it says that housing is not free, it says that the government should help the prices so that housing becomes affordable, the government has done its job. It all makes the worker imagine that we have come to have a 100 Salary Increase this year. How effective do you think it is . Maybe two or three months will have an effect so that this inflation or these costs that the government and the government should help and provide are not covered. The same view, the same view, you and the likes of your friends , lets see what the governments opinion is, mr. Raiti, you are with us, as well as hazrat ali. What is the representative of the government, deputy Labor Relations of the ministry of labor cooperation and social welfare . I will continue to talk to you i would like to say that we reached a framework for determining the livelihood basket with friends of workers and employers in the Supreme Labor Council. I think that every time we try to disrupt that framework by changing the people in the supreme council, it will definitely not be coherent and it will be much more difficult to make decisions. That we must emphasize that we are the workers of dahak. It says that it has nearly 700 Million Dollars per month, or it gives all kinds of subsidies to these seven deciles. Well, the working community is definitely a member of these seven deciles. I would like to tell you one more thing , mr. Javani, look at the government right now it is providing zero to 100 treatment costs for workers subject to the labor law who are insured for Social Security for free. Certainly, the government has many grants to provide housing for training on various issues to the Labor Community and the entire society , which the government considers itself to be the advocate of all society. Especially the weak class and the working class know what they are doing , this does not mean that the government. He wants to shrug off this issue or not to shoulder the burden of responsibility, no, the government really wants all the workshops to be able to turn around if we take action and make a decision that will cause an employer to become a worker. Let a worker be fired from the workshop, this is not for the benefit of the countrys Production Society and the countrys labor market. I have a request that we are right in our decision making, we should have some determination, we should study the right of the society, but at some point we must. Lets make a national decision, we should make a national decision, maybe we should also do something about the past. It is also possible that the members of the target community themselves are involved in this decision they are involved in decisionmaking and decisionmaking and can help in this matter. I have a request only regarding the issue of the sabbath, one of the duties of the supreme council. Our minimum wage, in order to help us reach the minimum wage in the past years, it was agreed that the livelihood basket should be defined , the livelihood basket should be clearly announced, i request that we help, definitely the demand of the working community the societys demands are fraudulent, the employer is fraudulent because he wants to turn his workshop around and keep his workshop active , he needs manpower, and there is also an important point in the Supreme Labor Council, we determine the floor. We also in the mozdi departments, which are announced by the honorable minister of labor every year, after the decision made in the Supreme Labor Council, in article 6 of that part of the mozdi letter, we announce that the higher numbers between the workers the employer can agree that a skilled worker will give himself a higher number. We determine the blasphemy , just as mr. Javani said, we determine the minimum for the 20 of dear workers who are on the minimum wage in the country, which is about 1,200,000 people. Can definitely work. A skilled worker who has more productivity with a Work Agreement we can pay him more, and i would like to tell you one more thing. If you could show us this table, it would be great. 88 of these workshops have less than 10 people and 13 and a half percent of workshops have more than 10 people. And the number of workers is proportional. If we dont make the right decision and reach a consensus, we will definitely get into trouble. I have a tip for you. 57 of our workshops are after their activities, then there are services. I have a request that we must take this matter up with the world health organization, and then, and even in a way, the world organization, then the family. They are considered equivalent. We still refer to the size of the house that the iranian Statistics Center announced in 2015 according to the census of the Housing Population to be 3. 3 tenths, while the research and field estimates of the iranian Statistics Center now show the size of the house in urban areas to be around 3. 1 tenth says that in rural areas, it says about 3 shares, which means that after khan , it is less. One and two tenths of family members are employed. It means that there is not only one person in the family, it is the whole family, generally, we have one or two tenths of the people who are employed, and if we consider the material dimension, the amount of calories that one person needs as the head of the family or family worker. According to the scientific and Detailed Research conducted by irans nutrition , there are 2,386 calories, which if we count the second person as seven tenths of the wife and half of the children , they are almost a picture with us, mr. Zoharian. Wages or in other words determining these minimum hands in there is next year. Some people believe that this minimum wage should be announced based on the current inflation. Some people who are against this argument say that the same increase based on the inflation rate will cause a further increase in inflation in the next year. Azalis view as an expert what is economic . In the name of allah, the most merciful, the most merciful. Hello, i would like to serve you, dear viewers and guests of your program. I would like to point out one thing that we are not talking about the increase , our issue is the stabilization of workers rights. The main issue is that money and. When it comes to money. Talking money is not a commodity, it is a credit, that is, the value of money is not in its nominal value, it is in the amount of purchasing power that it gives to the person who owns it, and for this reason, when we look , especially from 2016 onwards, the policies that are against the policies of the regime. There have been salaries, which has actually caused us to decrease the purchasing power of both the workers that you are talking about in the program today and the Government Employees, who are also government workers in a way. Inflation means that if we take the base year in 2016, we can now lets go back, ill take 2016 so that we have a stable year, what happened is the growth rate of salaries compared to 2016. 5. It was equal to one hundredth. But in the field of inflation, it is 781, and this means that one of our workers has had his salary reduced by 28 in these 5 years. Basically, we are not talking about an increase. The salary that a worker received in 1996 is now talking about workers rights regarding the employees salary. The weight between these two years is even worse. Inflation has been lower than the rate that has been increased in the labor law. Now we have this problem with the employees, mr. Zahorian, because our time is very limited, the solution of his highness is to stabilize the price according to your order or determine the minimum salary. I said what should happen in 1403 , at least if we take 96 as the base year , even a small increase. The salaries should be higher than the inflation rate so that we can gradually return to the salaries that a worker or employee of ours received in 2016, and this is only from an angle. Based on the inflation rate, we want to increase it, but that increase itself will lead to a further increase in inflation. How do you reject this . The term is not significant. I mentioned that there are both domestic studies and studies abroad that show that this increase is not a significant increase in inflation. Secondly, lets look at the issue from the other side. The increase in total demand means the increase in production means the activation of empty capacity it is the factories, and he is engaged in the concept of employment from that side, that is, through. The creation of overcash and its own production will affect the reduction of inflation, and vice versa, if wages are suppressed in the country, the suppression of investment will be proven, the stagnation in the field of production and the Economic Growth of rome will be affected in the long term, and from that side, it is only a problem. The problem is not purchasing power, it is the disruptions it creates in the labor and labor system, and it creates in the government systems, in the Human Resources systems, which is now the deputy minister of employment, who says that there is work, not labor. In our eight provinces, the problem is basically workers. An important issue of this work and worker ratio means that a society that has already experienced a level of purchasing power is not ready to work in the government with low salaries and lower purchasing power, especially in hard industrial jobs that are currently having problems with providing labor. We have a problem due to the wage suppression that happened in the Civil Service law. In our recruitment exams, especially in good fields, basically, good people do not enter, and in the long run, the quality of the governments malaba system can be greatly affected. Mr. Zorian, very briefly, just give me one number. Economic expert, what is the percentage for next year . My suggestion is that we return to the rate of 1996 in a 5year period. In a short period of time, that means if we want to return, we must add 28 inflation rates this year to return to the same rate. Thank you for that. You have given us your time, mr. Javani, we would like to hear your opinion regarding the conversation of our loved ones. We also have a minute to summarize. Let me give an explanation. Look at the issue of purchasing power and inflation in the society. I showed my table only with the increase in wages. A country has come and said that it is new in the labor law and says that by looking at the inflation rate in the Civil Service law , it says that the salaries of Government Employees should be increased at the same rate of inflation. In any case, the economic requirements of the government and there are discussions, it has insisted that it must not happen in the case of Government Employees. I think 20 has been added, but we are not talking about the governments decision and about its own employees in the tripartite work. Sometimes i dont read shavalis regulations kar said that the slogan of work is formed with the presence of 6 members, there must be two members of the labor group , two members of the Employer Group and two members. The government does not mean that in fact decisions can be made even without the presence of friends, it is true that decisions are made by majority, but at least i tried to make it by consensus for several years , which means that there has been no year without the signature of three parties. Very well, god willing, we will be able to make a good decision. Which is needed by the labor and Production Community , what percentage is your opinion, tomorrow there is a serious discussion and we will discuss the percentages, you give your opinion as the representative of the employer, we are the opposite, friends. Workers , we are trying not to create inflammation in the society , not to create expectations, god willing, tomorrow we will try to decide what percentage will be unexpected for our friends. I can announce the percentage. Excuse me, lets hear a short explanation from mr. Raiti. As the closing speech , we will have one minute of hazrat alis jambandi. Mr. President , mr. Moderators, i would like to tell you something. Look, what is the cause of the inflation that we have in Society Today . Is it because of the lack of Economic Growth in the 90s . The negative growth we had in the 90s is now our legacy. We have a bankrupt economy in the 1990s, whose inflation today may have affected both the worker and the employer. I will show you a table. Just look at this table. In 1400 , the minimum income of workers was 2 million 600. Today we have we are talking to you , the minimum salary of the workers is 5 million 30. In these two years, we have tried to help the livelihood of the workers. It means exactly twice all these decisions it has been taken for the past two years and efforts have been made to really take into account the livelihood of the worker and the worker s table. I have a request that we really let the Supreme Labor Council reach a good decision in a tripartite manner in the expert environment without grudges, so that the labor and Production Community will benefit and we we will be able to make up for these delays, god willing. God willing, you will also announce the percentage of the proposal that you are considering. As i am the secretary of the Supreme Labor Council, and definitely the members of the Supreme Labor Council should have an opinion on this issue. There is a government, the government doesnt have any special mentality, it should definitely be discussed my friends, the time is too short, 30 seconds, one minute, so let me talk a lot, i will at least give an answer, the removal of the preferential width was done in this government , and the inflation affected the working community. More than 70 , 70, 70 of our workshops have more than 10, 10 people. So, please tell me the number of workers , or the debate that other parts of the world discuss about workshops, that most of them are Service Workshops. There are no Service Workshops in other parts of the world, only in iran. Our Service Workshop is now from armenia its a small part, because last years livelihood basket was their own, which was 1390 , by which standard they announced this number