Councillor Maria Suarez's alternate motion to delay the decision was defeated.
Here is how each councillor voted:
Vote: Against Cr Suarez and Cr Hungerford's motions, signalled support for officer's recommendation.
Cr Jamieson was supportive of a user pays system in favour of charging ratepayers for construction.
It was estimated a charge of $18 a year would apply to every ratepayer annually for 20 years if the carpark was free to use.
Vote: Against Cr Suarez and Cr Hungerford's motions, signalled support for officer's recommendation.
The deputy mayor said he did not have the same "imagination" as other councillors who were against paid parking.