before and after. if you want to go further out, there was one study that says millionaires from 2003 to 2006, their tax burden went up to 274 billion-dollar from $137 billion. a will the of people benefited from the bush tax cuts, including this country. i think it was obvious in jobs, gdp and tax receipts to the treasury. >> the speaker's premises is if you raise taxes on the rich, you lower the deficit, also, by cutting taxes on the rich, we inaccuracied the dest. you re-elect both. >> absolutely. the problem is the deficit problem began in the last couple years and had nothing to do with taxing the rich. that's not the solution. >> now i have to nail you down. are we or are we not going into a double dip. >> we're going there. >> likely? >> 40/60. >> going on no a recession, 60 not. >> yeah. part of that is my rose colored