Live Breaking News & Updates on Wayne Hsieh|Page 6
Stay updated with breaking news from Wayne hsieh. Get real-time updates on events, politics, business, and more. Visit us for reliable news and exclusive interviews.
change. dr. gelles, i am here from the government and i m here to help you. is that not true? just could not true. host: why not? guest: because most social government programs designed to help people don t help. in some instances it is little more, i hate saying this, but the do-gooder full employment act that provides lots of jobs to people who would like to help, but at the end of the day if you look at whether the needle has been moved and people have been helped by substantial government programs and substantial amounts of money, the bottom line is very rarely are people helped. that was a story worth telling. the idea came to me as i was being smuggled into the back door of the statehouse in the state of hawaii from meeting with the secretary, the speaker of the house. hawaii was spending half a billion dollars on education. part that was subsidized by the federal government under the dividuals with disabilities education act. the rest is the taxpayers of haw ....
widely divergent cadet some older and younger. to this day, west point is still the father of west point because he s the one who puts it on much sounder and more systematic and that s very important because that s the army that will produce the generals of the civil war. that institution at west point will be where all these most of the more generous with their initial professional experience. host: the titleist west pointers in the civil war. who have regarded that were generous in the civil war? guest: in all honesty, most of the famous. sherman, grant, lee, hood. to give you a harder number, there are a few fitness, wade hampton for example. to get the sense of the numbers, two thirds of major generals involved are veterans of the regular army. the regular army is dominated by west point. the west point is about it not only must officers of the regular army graduate was going, it s just a focal point of much of the army s professionalism. when they do, for e ....
it s 50 minutes. as you know, the topic of the class is robert e. lee. not just to talk about his life and career but to assess his generalship, assess his command. so the first thing obviously when you need to do something like this and we will do this with grant on friday, and, remember, the reason i have the class structured this way is because as we will probably talk about later in this class, if you criticize or defend lee, a lot of times it ends up being in comparison to grant. all right. you probably noticed that, for example, in the weigly reading. but before we get to grant, let me start with lee. a lot of this comes down to, if we re going to assess the commander s abilities, mr. wayne, come in. the question then becomes what s the criteria one uses for that. now, does anyone in your readings think that lee has no merits as a general whatsoever? does anyone say lee is terrible to everything? it s a rhetorical question. no. so what is the consensus even an ....
the first thing obviously when you needed to do something like this and we ll do this with grant on friday. the reason i have the class structured this way is because as we ll probably talk about later in this class, if you criticize or defend a lot of times it ends up being in comparison to grant and you probably notice that for example especially in the weigley reading. before we get to grant, why don t we start with lee and a lot of this comes down to if we re going to talk about how we assess the general and a commander s abilities, if i can come in, the question then becomes what is the criteria one uses for that. now, does anyone in your readings think that lee has no merit as a journal whatsoever? does anyone say lee is terrible to everything? it is a rhetorical question. okay. what is the question and many your readings who is the critic? butch guy, historian, i have you read it for monday, remember? is gallagher a critic of lee. no. he gives you all the cri ....
this week u.s. naval ankd history professor wayne hsieh looks at the generalship of robert e. lee, part of a course called the american way of war. it is 50 minutes. as you know, the topic of a class is robert e. lee and not just to talk about lee s life and career but to sort of assess his generalship, assess his command. the first thing obviously when you needed to do something like this and we ll do this with grant on friday. the reason i have the class structured this way is because as we ll probably talk about later in this class, if you criticize or defend a lot of times it ends up being in comparison to grant and you probably notice that for example especially in the widely reading. before we get to grant, why don t we start with lee and a lot of this comes down to if we re going to talk about how we assess the general and a commander s abilities, if i can come in, the question then becomes what is the criteria one uses for that. now, does anyone in your readin ....