transfers of w and obama. both led to ten years of no growth in the u.s., not one year of growth of 3% or higher. that is just unheard of in our history. this will make it even slower than that. we ve dropped the participation rate in the labor force way down already. it s going to go further down. this is a catastrophic bill that will hurt the u.s. for years and years to come. and there s there s bipartisan analysis making the very same point you did about the actual price tag of this being greater than the one that is being put forth that even joe manchin is taking issue with, a democrat who you just said that his as he stands firmly against the massive price tag. we have to consider that this takes us from an entitlement society to an entitlement society from a rewarding society are the words that he chose. let s take a moment and look at this and how this could change the way we operate as a country. he s totally right.