twice. if you look at the actual vote study cast, he supported the biden agenda and votes cast so far 100 percent. so, the democratic party, i think, really the party that has to saved american democracy here. and the big stuff is going to be remembered, you re not gonna remember in 20 years if it was a 3.5 bill or 2.5 bill. you will remember if it 2024 was the last election that resembled anything close to democracy. i think this party needs to embrace people like joe manchin, they ought to be able to elect joe manchin instate cycle iowa. i think that that diversity, is difficult but i think it s really important. look, other than having a democrat like joe manchin representing joe west virginia thank you for name checking, nostalgically so.