Live Breaking News & Updates on Stone Soup Fallacy

Richard Borcherds is a British mathematician at Berkeley, who won the 1998 Fields Medal for the proof of the monstrous moonshine conjecture among many other contributions. A couple months ago, Borcherds posted on YouTube a
self-described “rant” about quantum computing, which was recently making the rounds on Facebook and which I found highly entertaining.
Borcherds points out that the term “quantum supremacy” means only that quantum computers can outperform existing classical computers on
some benchmark, which can be chosen to show maximum advantage for the quantum computer. He allows that BosonSampling could have some value, for example in calibrating quantum computers or in comparing one quantum computer to another, but he decries the popular conflation of quantum supremacy with the actual construction of a scalable quantum computer able (for example) to run Shor’s algorithm to break RSA. ....

United Kingdom , United States , Gil Kalai , Ernest Davis , Scott Aaronson , Ewin Tang , Des Smith , Sergio Boixo , Richard Borcherds , Radford Neal , James Gallagher , Terry Rudolph , Craig Gidney , Physics Stack Exchange , Stack Exchange , Extended Church Turing Thesis , John Horgan , Scientific American , Barak Says , Awbrey Says , Stone Soup Fallacy , Gidney Says , Neal Says , Zelinsky Says , Boixo Says , Gallagher Says ,