just as any other excursion, while you are venturing out into nature, you wavered letting you know you are assuming a risk. i wouldn t wish this on anybody, however, i don t think the liability traces away at the carnival. shannon: okay exhibit b, motion to dismiss by royal caribbean says the open and obvious risk of volcanic activity and related injury taken by passengers voluntarily with one of the world s most active volcanoes. the cruise line no duty to warn the plaintiffs of such open and obvious risk. do you connect this to robert s point? well, the supreme court ruled 1959 that there is reasonable care under the circumstances old by a shipowner to the passengers. there has been subsequent case law that shows when they sell these excursions, there is still liability potential there for the cruise line. what i think this case will