was and is an experienced policeman. he s been on the force for 18 years. so what about that milky white substance he says the sheriff told him was found in jennifer s body, which was at the heart of pat s suggestion that jennifer s death could have been caused by some inappropriate sexual event involving tom? how does he know? by coincidence, he writes this script where he s bringing ice cream to the murder scene. and lo and behold, the detective has this milky white substance in the vagina. reporter: but aren t you taking two and two and coming up with five? no, i don t think so. reporter: he s fictionally writing about him being there with ice cream. and you think it s a coincidence that he shows up in his script that he places himself at the murder scene minutes before his sister s murder and he s bringing a substance that after fire could be melted down and be a milky white substance? do you think that s a coincidence? i don t. reporter: why would it be white? maybe it
underneath her bed and doused those with gasoline in addition to dousing her body. i spoke with the florence county coroner and discussed these items. he indicated to me that he did not remember telling tom morgan any of these facts. reporter: and that s about the point pat s theorys took a turn toward something way out there, something no one else had even imagined, some sort of sexual dysfunction between tom and his sister. in the one telephone conversation i had with the florence county detective, he informed me that after jennifer morgan was murdered, there was an unknown milky white substance in her vagina. reporter: what set it off was that phrase. pat recalled that the florence county investigator, kenny boone, told him that an unidentified substance may have been found in jennifer s body. was this milky white substance placed there as a result of an assault, including oral sex? reporter: what could that substance have been? well, how about ice cream?
have helped cover up the murder by dousing her body in gasoline and setting it on fire. all these years, pat suggested, jennifer s whole family may have been involved in a massive cover-up. the documentary ended with what pat intended as the climactic interview. i m on your side, but there s people out there that have been telling me stuff. reporter: here tom has no idea that a microphone and two cameras are placed in the room. pat is moving in for the kill. for what he hopes will be tom s confession. tom, i know you re at your sister s accident, jen s accident. no, i wasn t. tom i know you were. i know for two years you ve been telling me things that put you at your sister s accident. tom listen to me what i m telling you, i was not at i
premiere, pat admits he never did check out the alibi. were you able to verify any of his so-called alibis? well, the last well, the last alibi, i did not. at that point it just seemed like i d be chasing another one of his lies anyway. reporter: you set up a high tech sting operation yes, i did. in this hotel room. yes. because you wanted to trap him and because you wanted to get him to confess to you that he had killed his sister. and you were terribly upset when he didn t confess to it. when he said, no you ve got it all wrong. you ve got it all wrong. i was disappointed that we didn t get to the bottom of the matter. reporter: but remember one of pat s insinuations went beyond all the others. and that was this. based on nothing more than his own analysis of a fictionalized story, pat surmised in his very
pat moug, the livonia, michigan, acting cop looked like a cross between mr. clean and kojak. a big friendly bundle of gung ho. and moug had already done it. he had made an independent film, directed and starred in it himself, a movie called the ugly one. you always said i should start fighting again. in a ring with gloves and rules. the fact that moug was a detective was a bonus, tom figured. i ve been a police officer for 18 years. another experienced set of eyes to consider the evidence. i felt that being a police officer, someone that was a detective in sex crimes, i thought i d be able to bring something to jennifer s story that other filmmakers might not be able to do. plus, moug had a great idea. why not make a promotional video about tom s project? in 2002 i met tom morgan. tom morgan had written a screenplay called brothers. neither one of them had the money to make tom s movie.