Barri bumgarner we had several suspects. John short i just thought his behavior reeked of guilt. An innocent man doesnt act like that. Keith morrison he lied, lied and lied and lied. About sex, sex, and sex. Libby sullivan there are a lot of people that cheat. It doesnt make them a murderer. Morley swingle all of a sudden, this puzzle all came together. Patrick rogers at The End of the day, No One Else had a motive. Libby sullivan steves on the phone, and hes got a gun. He was crying. I said, fight this. This is crazy. Keith Morrison Voiceover a College Student is murdered. And detectives discover a Trail Leading uncomfortably close to home. John short oh, my god. Its going to look bad. Keith Morrison Voiceover he could have been sunbathing here in the grass. Naked, but for a pair of blue shorts. His face turned up toward the june sky. Was beautiful. It was afternoon by the time someone noticed him, though hed been lying here still, silent since before daylight. Here, among the old roo
Things happened so fast. We need to find her. So her body was found right in here. Why would anyone do this . Motives were thrown out, like jealousy, some kind of Love Triangle. Did you keep getting new tips in all the time . Tips were coming in. But kept hitting dead ends. Hitting dead ends. A massive Law Enforcement Project that had gone on over 25 years. God, could you give us a little something here . We just got to keep going. For the first time, we had a face to put with the boogeyman. What are you thinking . I took a big, Deep Breath, and my mind began racing. Your jaw must have dropped. To say the least. I picked up a rose, and i put a card on it. It just said, lisa, its done. [theme music] Andrea Canning Voiceover its a pretty little thing, whimsical, frivolous. But three decades ago, this Music Box became Something Else a symbol of deadly intent. Did that give you chills, seeing that Music Box . Absolutely. Andrea Canning Voiceover a gift from an evil soul. He had bought the
Man quite honestly, is it possible she is alive . Annie he was watching her and following her. Deeply creepy stuff. Criminal acts that hed recorded. Yes. Thats his favorite thing. Collecting women. My heart just sunk. How many other times has he done this . How many other women has he done this to . Narrator a young nurse vanishes in a mystery stained with evil. He brought us to the back. Man and we all looked down. We just gasped. Narrator the front range of colorado, the vast Grasslands East of the Rocky Mountains offers plenty of places to conceal the body of a 97 pound woman. This woman, Tina Sandoval. But the question that gets set for the next two decades. Where are you, tina . And then the searches begin. Yeah. Where are you . Brad goldschmidt yeah. And we searched, oh gosh, probably over 50 different locations. Narrator officially she was a missing person. Had been for more than 20 years. But the authorities, like then detective Brad Goldschmidt, couldnt accept that she was a r
Caller on clip my wife and my son, theyre both shot. Miles Tucker Nichole had been shot in the back of the head. Taylor had been shot in the face. This is a murdersuicide. Detective do you think taylor shot himself . No. I waited and waited and waited for somebody to be arrested for this. Detective did you have anything to do with this . Did you have anything to do with killing your wife . You got to be out of your mind. Jason payne On Recording you have three tapes. I want you to tear those up. Faye payne On Recording i can do that. I thought, theyre going to come kill us. Niece On Recording so to threaten the lady, you know, you need to do this, or were going to hurt your child. Faye payne On Recording yes, yes. Remington payne they said that i was so young that i couldnt have remembered anything. Something like that doesnt go away. I saw what i saw. [no audio] hello, and welcome to dateline. When jason and Nichole Payne first met, the attraction was instant. Soon, the bachelor and s
Anything for christian to be Here. Reporter the whole world ahead of them. He grabs my chin and pulls me up and he gives me this magical kiss. Reporter their secret romance will be to something shattering when christian vanished. My young life went Out the window. It was tense and we were nervous. We were scared. Am starting to believe tHere may be more to this than just a missing person. Reporter wHere was he . Did someone have something to hide. A lovers triangle. A circle of friends. Was one of the May Killer . This was Planned in on purpose. How could do do something so horrific . Welcome to dateline. High schoolers Erika Friman, Pedro Bravo and Christian Aguilar who likes 3piece in a pod after graduation , the even picked colleges in the same city. Then one of them went missing. Last seen in a dangerous area of town. As the hours passed, the ministry deepened. Then investigators uncovered a hidden truth. One they believed might be a motive for murder. Here is Dennis Murphy with ci