right at him. they asked scott to come down to the police deparment again. and without telling him where they got it, they showed him a fax of a photo of himself with amber frey at the christmas party. and of course he lies when he s confronted. reporter: prosecutor birgit fladager. he sees the picture of himself with amber and he says, that s not me. was it clearly him? it was. reporter: if scott suspected the detectives had somehow found out about amber, he didn t let on. and he kept calling her, and she kept recording. but he started testing her with questions. did you see that news on paris? no, i didn t actually. there was a bomb that exploded. and i was like, what bombing? there was another time he had asked if i had seen the article on the monarch butterflies that are in pismo, and i said, no. i gathered right away he was asking because these were in fact something that was in the paper possibly. right.
prosecutor. he sees the picture of him and amber and says that s not me. was it clearly him? it was. if scott suspected the detectives had somehow found out about amber, he didn t let on, and he kept calling her and she kept recording. but he started testing her with questions. did you see the news on paris? no, i didn t, actually. there s a bomb that exploded. and i was like, uh, what bombing? there was another time he had asked if i had seen the article on the monarch butterflies that are in pismo, and i said, no. i gathered right away he was asking because these were, in fact, something that was in the paper, possibly. right. if i was looking at the news. to find out, in other words, if she knew about laci. and then, on january 6th, 13 days after laci disappeared, scott told amber himself.
the police department again. and without telling him where they got it, they showed him a fax of a photo of himself with amber frey at the christmas party. and of course he lies when he s confronted. reporter: prosecutor birgit fladager. he sees the picture of himself with amber and he says, that s not me. was it clearly him? it was. reporter: if scott suspected the detectives had somehow found out about amber, he didn t let on. and he kept calling her, and she kept recording. but he started testing her with questions. did you see that news on paris? no, i didn t actually. there was a bomb that exploded. and i was like, what bombing? there was another time he had asked if i had seen the article on the monarch butterflies that are in pismo, and i said, no. i gathered right away he was
it felt like we were family, felt like we were one one heartbeat. you know, our hearts were intertwined together like i can t describe. indescribable love, never loved someone so intensely in my life. their children were soon in on the secret. katelynn was beguiled by rachel. you could be talking to her, like we re talking, and she would make you feel like the most important human being on this earth. how did that make you feel? special. loved. i could open up to her. if todd suspected anything, he didn t let on. but rachel s dad, don, began to get a queasy feeling during his visits to the airpark. tell me what you thought about him, at the time. he came across as this christian guy. and he you know, he s helping rachel.
police were convinced the missing hiker meredith emerson was under the control of gary hilton somewhere in north georgia. the more they learned about the survivalist odds ball who was the person of interest in two murders in national forests elsewhere, the more they feared for her. a friend of meredith s family appealed directly to hilton. i hope that if he realized that this would be helpful, that his heart would be softened and turned to come forward with information. so, please, please have the courage to come forward. we need you. their next lead, the big one, came from an unlikely source, the suspect himself. three days into meredith s disappearance, gary hilton called his old boss tabor. i answered my cell phone, and i heard his voice. couldn t believe it. he pretended acted as if nothing was wrong. he didn t let on that he was the subject of a man hunt?