Stay updated with breaking news from Donald virelli. Get real-time updates on events, politics, business, and more. Visit us for reliable news and exclusive interviews.
Purchase health insurance a tax? since it was enforced with a tax penalty that will be assessed on any individual tax returns on people who do not comply with the government mandate to purchase health insurance. solicitor general donald virelli representing the obama administration ran in to trouble on that question. if they don t pay the tax, they violated a federal law. as long as they have paid the penalty. they paid the tax they are in compliance with the law. why do you keep saying tax? if they paid the tax penalty they are in compliance with the law. thank you. the penalty. the problem is if the supreme court views the mandate as a tax they might decide they cannot decide this case until mb somebody actually has to pay the tax in 2015. on the other hand, claiming the mandate is a tax will help in tomorrow s argument when they discuss the constitutionality of ....
Comfort the supreme court will uphold as constitutional every provision of what even the white house is now calling obamacare. today was day one of the three-day historic argument in front of the supreme court and the question of the day was, is the individual mandate the to purchase health insurance a tax? since it was enforced with a tax penalty that will be assessed on any individual tax returns on people who do not comply with the government mandate to purchase health insurance. solicitor general donald virelli representing the obama administration ran in to trouble on that question. if they don t pay the tax, they violated a federal law. as long as they have paid the penalty. they paid the tax they are in compliance with the law. why do you keep saying tax? if they paid the tax penalty they are in compliance with the law. thank you. the penalty. the problem is if the supreme ....
Act. no, justice alito. joining me is dr. sikh iman wul, the department of the department of medical ethics and msnbc distributor he helped to craft the affordable care act and was inside of the supreme court. i m so jealous of you getting one of those precious seats in the court today. i m jealous of myself, too. i would have loved every second. it sounded like it wasn t going so good for the solicitor general. no, it went fine for the solicitor general. it was quite clear that most of the justices were hostile to the argument that this was a tax and thought they could get pass it easily. they had to bring in a lawyer in because the government and other side thought the anti-injunction act didn t apply. so the buzz in the court going out the building today looks like as of day one the issue that was at risk today is maybe they can t even decide this case right now. it looks like they have cleared that threshold and now, for the ....
And was inside of the supreme court. i m so jealous of you getting one of those precious seats in the court today. i m jealous of myself, too. i would have loved every second. it sounded like it wasn t going so good for the solicitor general. no, it went fine for the solicitor general. it was quite clear that most of the justices were hostile to the argument that this was a tax and thought they could get pass it easily. they had to bring in a lawyer in because the government and other side thought the anti-injunction act didn t apply. so the buzz in the court going out the building today looks like as of day one the issue that was at risk today is maybe they can t even decide this case right now. it looks like they have cleared that threshold and now, for the rest of the argument, it will be about what the supreme court is going to decide in relation to this. right. ....
it may be the most critical supreme court case since the justices ruled on the 2000 presidential election, but out in obama administration s health care reform law is under close scrutiny. in a dramatic hearing today the court appeared deeply split. conservative justices are showing deep skepticism about the individual mandate which would require people to buy health insurance. cnn s congressional correspondent kate bolduan and jeffrey toobin were both inside the court today for the hearing. kate, let s start with you. is the health care law in serious jeopardy right now? reporter: i ll tell you, wolf, you never know how much the oral arguments in the courtroom will in the end reflect the final opinion of the court, but straight out of the gate today the lawyer for the obama administration was the one on the defensive and while the justices can and do surprise us, quite frankly, from being in the courtroom today, it does appear that the key provision of the health car ....