parents were paid for it on the day of the shoot. kelly, apparently he has not had a problem with it until now, as andrew points out. ultimately, it will be up to the court to make a determination on that but shannon, we have to remember that he filed the complaint and has asserted not only federal statutory claims, but also asserted the fact that they didn t have his consent for the photo, and that is going to be key, because in order for someone to have the photo of him, a private photo that he contends they have to have some kind of consent for, and he is saying that they didn t sign any consent, his parent didn t consign any consent, so therefore it is not valid. shannon: andrew, take you to exhibit c, this is what he claimed happened because of this photo, one of the most iconic ever on an album, he says the permanent harm he has approximately suffered includes, not limited to extreme and permanent emotional distress, interference with his normal development and educational p