corbin. i think it s not simply a matter both parties are divided and that s why we re stuck, but we ve got an absence of strategy on the part of both of the leaders. the problem is a more fundamental one. and the divisions that she s referred to are part of the open closed question. since the financial crisis the industrialized economies have struggled to give a real offer to their middle classes and that s at the heart of the issue. i m afraid europe is the handle on it. put this in broader perspective for us in the subyournen context. you look at europe now. britain is this chaos you so well described. macron is crippled in france. italy remains on the verge of a