To me. To speak my 1st question to the Prime Minister and no oncet given. I ask what proposals have been put to the European Union we asked yesterday many colleagues asked and the Prime Minister seems utterly incapable of answering any rational human being would assume therefore none have been port and there is no answer to that question. The Prime Minister and his cabinet colleagues have been saying hes making progress the chief negotiator. The chancellor of germany the tissue of all and say no proposals of yet been made by the u. K. If the Prime Minister thinks hes made progress will he publish those proposals hes put forward to replace the backstop right minister. Has the right honorable gentleman as i very well you dont negotiate in public and we are making was thank god but i owe it to a lot of Prime Minister face please forgive me interrupting there is a long way to go there are a lot of questions to be reached the questions must be heard and the responses from the Prime Minister