On Instagram Stories, the "Crush" hitmaker said, "This is a tradition, right?" To which the "NCIS" actor responded, "It's a yearly tradition that Mandy and I take the horror of Halloween Horror Nights." But after dating, they encountered a few dramas. In a previous interview with Howard Stern in 2006, Wilmer Valderrama talked about intimacy with the "Princess Diaries" star, crudely saying that it was "good, but it wasn't like warm apple pie." That same year, the "A Walk to Remember" actress told Elle magazine that her ex's comments were "utterly tacky and not even true." She also noted how his remarks hurt her because she liked him.