All right. Welcome everyone to our rules committee of monday, december 12, 2016, im katie tang chair our clerk is derrick overview vonlz from sfgovtv thank you Nona Melkonian and Charles Kremenak to my left is commissioner coppel and joined by commissioner mar and to any far left is commissioner avalos like to point out supervisor avalos and mr. Clerk, any announcements . Yes. Electronic devices. Completed speaker cards and documents to be included should be submitted to the clerk. Items acted upon today will appear on the tuesday, january 12, 2016, board of supervisors agenda unless otherwise stated. All right. Thank you and joined by sxhafshg to let you know we have a lot before us today but commissioner cohens has a 1 30 Land Use Committee trying to get through that mr. Richie item one. 9 members for the february 2015 to the balboa Advisory Committee 9 seats and 10 applicants and our last rules committee on thursday we held a hearing and heard into some of the applicants and United States of america to supervisor avalos. Thank you yes, we heard from 4 applicant on friday and 9 names to be provided to the for our approval of the members of balboa park and reverend hope is up first. Thank you for this opportunity reverend glenn District Attorney hope represents the elderly in the area of balboa park and 80 yields myself the founder. Working with the cayuga an age in placeing network of residents in that area it is a multi Generational Program focused on the elderly and thank you for the opportunity to thank supervisor avalos and through the support in getting the cayuga Program Underway wouldnt have been possible without the you. Im a homeowner 2 1 2 blocks from the balboa park station for 40 years and taken Public Transportation for 46 years and still do im also the board president for the league of women voters were connected to walk sf and to vision zero so wellinformed about the things that need to happen in order to insure better the safety of pedestrians and while i have the microphone not exactly about the balboa park station but involved with in no new jails i urge you to vote no new jail we dont need this, please follow the recommendations of 2411 month seeking that is working hard to chart out alternatives to incarceration thank you and thank you for your desire to be on the committee im excited about our presence on there been important to have your voice and thank you for your service one of the projects the count i committee will be looking at the Affordable Housing the upper yard side that will be housing inform burglary thirty percent formally homeless families i know youve done a large record ever or of work with people in San Francisco and be a great voice to center on the project. Thank you. I awhile i was working in the tenderloin for 45 years we built Affordable Housing and rehabbed another site which is a confident location on ocean street transitional housing for single homeless women wanting to get out of evictions and prostitution ill familiar with the homeless and a member of i you go divided opinion about housing and other matters in the neighborhoods that im strongly supportive of most with Affordable Housing thank you. Thank you very much okay 09 questions from go on to the next applicant is here mr. Goodman. Good day im in district 11 area i was on the committee for two terms under families and children i think that is allowed under two i want to make sure that is understood we had on the bart representative and working hard as the cac to focus on the corridors and addressing some of the links and kefks from d7 and d11 to make sure the issues are addressed it is a key cac in terms of what is going on especially in the eastern area of the blood sample cac growth and efforts to look at the efforts of the People Living in the communities want to make sure those are addressed and the communities are heard in the district and help to to process for the communities involved submitted my seats for 6, 7 and 8 and 9 and looking at the transportation and a member of the San Francisco tomorrow with the advocacy in terms of transit working or working with orientation with the west of twin peaks and helped push forward legislation that look at the students and families in the area and an item that is going through on the transportation area that will be an improvement only the ocean avenue corridor with the my velocity for the seniors and children so thank you for considering my appointment again for a position. Is it true, mr. Goodman and mr. Fernandez is standing up please approach. Good morning. Im Jesse Fernandez an orientationer for the economic and environmental rights focus in the earnings and i myself my focus in indict r district 11 in neighborhoods district 11 and so this ive been with the organization for a year in 3 time i lead and served the Community Mapping process with various low income and grants and a nonnature speaker in the district Ground Troops for the demands and concerns around the ongoing and in coming concerns in district 11 laid act out a vision that builds on a part of lines communities announced for health and justice for multi ethic and intercoalition of generation that work in that district including 9 filipino and chinese affirmative action and other organizations as well as that is that organization has produced a lot of observing that has impacted the balboa park station and the upper yard 100 Percent Development that is tavkd to a Development Team to help to steer the partnership with the Development Team as well as the supervisor avalos office weve been attending the ongoing merging with the mta and the various stakeholders that are shepherding for the redevelopment of the pedestrian changes that will be coming in that district and bart and other stakeholders folks at the carbarn station and other stakeholders as well with the schools to really Ground Troops and lift the demands less incorporated voices in the processed and lifting up the need for truly Affordable Housing ive submitted any application for the cac and feel i can add expertise and a lot outgoing sight and on top of i was serving on the human right commission our proposal for this year focused a Community Advisory in ways in which we can augment or improve the various stakeholders and increase representation for the projects moving forward in the city the cac is a vast ranging from specific Development Projects to large programs and statistic plans so a lot of the vigilant in the equity Advisory Committee has the thinking and proposals around the way the formations can better serve San Francisco as a whole and i think that trbtsdz greatly to the position that ive applied forfeiture any questions. Thank you supervisor mar. I want to thank Jesse Fernandez i know i have a full plate with the alliances but to step up for planning with the justice in this area really commendable thank you for that i think you joined other organizers on the balance a great balance and last week if tiffany from the Chinese Progressive Association they can how do you pronounce that. From the fac and walk sf and have raise your right hand glen District Attorney hope with the social just to bring the base seniors and others what a Green Committee with our expertise i want to thank you for doing that. Thank you very much. Thank you supervisor cowen. Thank you. Good morning question have you ever think attend any balboa park cac meetings. In particular but attend other cac for the battalion reservoir and also engaged the bart commissioners that are a stakeholder in the project area. So how do you know you having want to be part of cac if you havent attend meeting. This severs as a hub for the surrounding be neighborhoods next to persian ocean a heart of the the not kind of Ongoing Development but in the community that has impacted the livelihood of the next generation of people in the neighborhood. Hold on a twopart question here. So tell me what has the cac accomplished that you 5 mileanhour and tell me whatnot accomplished you, you offer a critique on. The coordination of the projects coming in into the battalilboa to step into thie to lend any voice and experience to the collective living to add a perspective that might not exist currently i think that seeing them so thats the first question the next question the things theyve not be able to do the cac kind of speaks to the projects in the project area in particular, the balboa reservoir and pubically owned sites yet followed different trajectories around the conversation and so i think that is without getting into the weeds one of the contradicts im interested in particular 2, 3, 4 addressing thank you. My final question whats our thought about the geneva bart schedule to get online with 2020 i think that is around that time. Ill i think that there is ample wanted to get ahead and understand how to meet the needs of folks that live here now and make the transit hub assessable to folks from the Outer Mission and Mission Terrace neighborhoods and so do that development in a way that will be really making in supporting transit ordered Development Rather than displacement those are some of my thoughts. Thank you, thank you all right. Thank you back to supervisor avalos i think one more applicant i dont know if shes here. Im not sure if raphael our last applicant is here shes not any other people that are interested in cac for the balboa station well go to Public Comment. Chair tilly chang having artists from the youth stage and others on the competent that is important as well as the Committee Organizes and social just people what a Great Committee for people that voluntarily help develop this station for the this incredibly important transit city of the city. Commissioner mar i believe she doesnt show up but defer to supervisor avalos. I have two cards for Public Comment and their two people that spoke so im not sure actually intended to speak at Public Comment. I would medication were seeking exist in a growing group not a full committee for a longterm and unfortunately, that about the balboa reservoir and transportation is a key for all of it i want to focus and with glad you talked about the geneva how it integrates the seattle to the southwest is key i greatly appreciate this comment and thought. Thank you. Im very, very excited about the group of people that are applying for the Advisory Committee i want to thank the folks to get them to apply weve been trying to get folks with the background of people that come at the last couple of meetings to be honest tofu to beth and everyone that is coming forward to do this important work this is a part of San Francisco that is overlooked for me, the way this body can be effective if members will be really terrify and advocates for transportation, housing, Pedestrian Safety it is key and all that k5u9 with the advocates decisions in my recommendation is seats one through 9 i dont have is seat for. Shall we close Public Comment on item one all right. Thank you supervisor avalos. So we have applicant for all the seats equip the city college and our backward having people not with the background that one is still open but wanted low income and supposedly that tiffany takes this spot and two seat a anna that was not able to make it shes with the Youth Challenge and senior is glen District Attorney hope and we have one serving on the committee and seat 6 for pedestrian bike is also with walk sf the residents asset proposing Aaron Goodman and the Small Business will be louis who is with the ocean Avenue Association and working closely with dan weaver another person that applied and the nonprofit for Jesse Fernandez ive worked with jesse often the cac and so h he has a lot of bay bridge the areas of the Housing Needs and the Transportation Needs which which come up in that committee thats where im hoping the committee can adopt and hopefully have our support. Thank you supervisor avalos and that would be in the form of a motion. I cant make that motion. Would any of the Committee Members last week to make the motion. I dont catch the numbers but move the recommendations of our district 11 supervisor avalos. I have those here and as a Committee Report for tuesday. Yes. Test december. Theres no further business. For the full board without objection. All right. Congratulations all right. Were now joined by supervisor president london breed as well and mr. Clerk going to item 2. The hearing for one mbe member term ending to the Police Commission we now have madam chair one seat and 3 applicants as robert and michael have withdrawn their applications. Thank you very much and we did hear from one of the applicant from thursday so at this time unless opening questions and comments jump to the presentation the next is john. Good morning, supervisors supervisor president london breed and commissioner eric mar and madam chair and supervisor cowen on december 2nd, 201 on december 2nd, 2015, mario woods two bullets ripped through his young body with it in the streets of San Francisco mario died a victim of that mentally ill the following day i received a call from a young woman looking for help a young africanamerican was sitting next to her but were Department Staff stated to get on the phone the friend was on looker who watched mario woods died the friend of the member of the community as mario two fearful to come forward but angle africanamerican young person on their way to work captured evidence of a Police Killing was two faired to share the forgotten and offer their testimony this is the world i live in every single day i work in the same courthouses and with the police that arrest my clients ive spent a lot of time in the jail request the Police Integration good, bad, and ugly some of my clients are skewed of doing terrible things im a credible defense attorney and prepared to be inform next Police Commissioner our community cant wait your decision will have life and death consequences for San Francisco the burden will be borne by young brown and black men the mentally ill and those struggling with Substance Abuse and those who struggle with justice afraid to call the police bus of the mandarin and chains speaking officer ive been reviewing the police work since laurel and a law clerk for the Public Defenders Office everyday i ask did 9 Police Follow the law did they violate the fourth and fifth and 6 amendments were my clients allowed to walk the streets free were their statements taken in mri if my clients were wrong i seek to hold 9 officers accountable i treat the officers that do their job with professionalism and integrity with respect i want to be clear in Police Reform no ups and downs we have to come together to heal what is broken as my friend who lost a sister to a Police Killing remind me we have to do that with compassionate and love our hearts must be open for change what ive discovered over the course that most Police Officers wake up evidence and put on the your mind and try to fulfill their duties to serve and protect the community having that desire is not right watt without 9 accountability and transparency weve let our officers done by not lagging the the President Task force on 21st century and the doj Police Services but we also have to acknowledge other officers that cant accept our diversity of our state officer with racism, violation and hatred in insurance hearts they disgrace the uniform everyday they put that on and we have to hold those officers accountable i want to give one illustration of the challenge and why this is important to center age expert in the position i recently had a client the department believed was a bad guy one officer came into the courtroom that my client shot at another person that was a person in prison after 3 years of