Huh, all right. Trump style. Theres as we know, willie, Christmas Tree from comcast. Its all very moving. Always a tear or two in our eyes. But, you know, still, its something, yesterday, shock waves still over what happened in alabama with doug jones, people still talk to me about it. How it may same the election. You still got a tax bill thats up in the air. Donald trump, once again, strangely, embracing his, or actually his most reliable political allie Vladimir Putin. It was a twoway street yesterday. Vladimir putin gave that press conference, praising President Trump. He gave vlad sld a cal vladim putin a call. Dont fideutsche is with us. Senator at large lee gallagher, columnist and associate editor for the Washington Post David Ignacious and White House Reporter for usa today heidi pryzbilla. Mika has the morning you a. Joe, i want to go to a piece in the Washington Post titled newtonian physics. And joe, we have tim ryan, congressman tim ryan coming on in a few minutes. The Democratic Party is energized by what happened in virginia and now the other day if alabama. Well, you look at everything thats happening right now and it is a clear reaction to everything that donald trump and his republican enablers have done over the past year or two. And were talking about alabama. Were talking about virginia. You can talk about the fact that 7 republicans have lost 7 of their membership in terms of women, 5 overall, some people actually leaving the party. We always talked about state legislative seats lost under barack obama. Well, there had been 14 switches from democratic, from republican to democratic seats since donald trump was elected. Zero flips on the republican side. So i just thought it was fascinating and the reason i wrote the column is because you look at the story of the virginia governors race, which actually turned out much better for democrats than they expected. Its the women that we always talk about that were standing in long lines. They were going to vote against Donald Trumps endorsed candidate. In alabama, you have the same thing happening, where black voters who have felt pushed upon pushed back hard and were finding that not only is there an equal and opposite reaction, it seems the reaction from democrats the pushback is Even Stronger than what donald trump has given them, because Republican Voters are depressed and appear to be staying home. I mean, donny, if you look at what happens, we were down there in alabama the other day. We were in a room in mountain brooke, alabama, a group of voters, Republican Voters. They put on the stop sign. Those are Republican Voters. Democrats, african person voters in particular and women and africanamerican women, those groups pushed doug jones over the finish line and kept doug jones out full stop. Republicans dodged the bullet. Obviously, it was a win for the democrats. It was loselose for republicans. Had he won, two things, football one, youd be branned a democrat in the Republican Party the party of the pedophile the party of trump. They had be lining up to vote for 2018 now. As energized as the Democratic Party is now. Can you imagine it going the other way . It would be such panic, the energy level would go to another level. As much as it was a win,ed a moore won, it could have been more devastating for the republicans. Clearly this is an indictment on trump. You have to look at lee county, which is not as a democrat, its taken 45 since the civil rights act. It swung 41 points from a negative 24 to a positive 17 on the democratic side. Thats all you need to know. Thats young voters, joe, thats auburn university. Thats auburn university. The same ting you can say about the university of alabama. The reverse in Tuscaloosa County was huge. Again, these are not only young voters. These arent your normal college towns. Theyre not liberal left of center towns. These are very, very conservative areas. Not only were they conservative, they were trump counties, heidi, you look at again virginia, you look at alabama. You look at the numbers, you look at the generic ballot test, where republicans are getting destroyed like 51 to 36 . Thats one of the biggest gaps when you ask people, do you want a democrat or a republican to go for your district to congress. This is the pushback of what donald trump considers the other for hispanics, for blacks, for women, for people that wouldnt have been able get into perhaps his fathers 1950s country club or 1950s country clubs across the south and across the country. Thats his view of the world and it is plainly obvious when you just look at the people that he nominates. He nominates over 90 of the u. S. Attorneys are men and boy women have more of a reason to get out and vote today as do blacks, hispanics and others than ever before. They are actually doing it. You often wonder if the womens march really did precipitate something, joe, because you remember at the time so many people mocked that as a one day hiscy fit. We are seeing this manifest in so many ways, not just women running for congress but also a flip if party i. D. , potentially a new coalition forming. I have been going through the numbers, myself, here, not just in bam become but in virginia. What we are seeing is that flip in terms of Republican Party i. D. Dropping. Well, that is coming from collegeeducated white women. Some of them who even voted for trump. What we are seeing here, for example, in. Have a, in the suburbs of richmond, for the ft. Since 1961 that area voting for a democratic governor. My district, where republican barbara com stock won by 13 points there. The Democrat Ralph Northam carrying that area. So this is what the analysts, like charlie cook and others say is shaping into a wave. Because these people are fought just crossing over for a onetime vote. Theyre actually stopping to be identified with the Republican Party. They may have a couple things to sprinkle in as we think of this election in bam pam. Number one we have been saying all week, roy smore a uniquely terrible candidate a. Lot of people came out to vote against him and a credibly accused pedophile did not macnight the u. S. Senate. If you were vetting in all likelihood, the seat goes back to a republican, if the party nam nates a republican for the state of alabama. It may be a protest against moore, who is an outlier in our politics. But i do think when you look at alabama, combined with virginia, combined with the polling we are seeing the reassuring thing is that its telling us that the public facing an insurgent president. An insurgent strategy from steve bannon. A group of people that want to overturn the system as weve known it, thats beginning to draw a public weariness. My dad, now 97, likes to make an analogy to a top spinning on a table. Can you give a to be a real whack. But if the top is spinning fast if you have. It will wobble a little bit. Lit come back towards the center. I really hope thats what were seeing. Our top got a big knock from donald trump. The question was, wheres the rest of the country going to be after that disruption . And if these results are right, joes point about newtonian physics, there is a reaction. It comes back in the other direction. Well, well get back to alabama in a minute. We want to get back to russia now t. President Vladimir Putin praised President Trump in moscow for the u. S. Stockmarket gains and rejected the premise for the Justice Departments probe into russian meddling as quote spy hysteria. Hours later, President Trump and putin spoke by telephone. The staterun news agency disclosed details before the American Press learned about the call t. Kremlin statement said quote faye later followed up with a story of trump thanking putin. That came on the heels of the Washington Post report detailing how the president s refusal to accept the intelligence that russia meddled is interfering with the communication of National Security materials. Quote, current and former officials said that his daily intelligence update, phone as the president s daily brief or pdb is often structured to avoid unsettling him. Zplmplts so, joe, there is a lot to unpack there. Number one the very mention of russia apparently infuriates President Trump so they avoid it in the daily brief, something you presumed youd want to be in there. President trump speaking yesterday with Vladimir Putin after putin heaped praise upon him at that press conference. Yeah, willie, again the behavior towards russia, weve said it since december of 2015 is so bizarre. We said it sense he came on our show in december of 2015 and continued to say that slavladim putin was a better leader tan barack obama because he was a stronger leader. He basically brushed off the assassinations of journalists the killing of political rivals the invasions of countries. The shooting down of jets. Its one apology for russia after another and it just doesnt make sense. We all sigh it every day. David ignacious we saw it, of course, yesterday, Vladimir Putin flattering donald trump. Donald trump calling him up, sayingifies things about the stockmarket and whats so disturbing i would note, it has to be disturbing for the men and women that protect our company and the Intel Community, from the very beginning, donald trump has placed more trust in Vladimir Putin than he has our Intel Community. Now you have lackeys for donald trump running around saying that the fbi is turning into another kgb. Its, its a bizarre, bizarre world and youve got a column about this talking about the russian facts. Right there hiding in front of us. All right. I did, i wrote this morning, joe, about how you look at the evidence thats emerged thats mostly uncriticontradicted. It tells you a story from the beginning of this campaign, trump and his aides wanted russia to help, in particular, encouraged russia to do what it could to make available emails from the Clinton Campaign at a time we know that the russians were hacking democratic servers where those emails were kept. So i said, its known in the law if you got the facts, argue the fact, few dont have the fact, dont have the law, pound the table. Were seeing some pounding of the table in this agitation against special Counsel Robert Mueller and other comments from trump. On the trumpputin relationship, it is really remarkable that now for two years, the one issue on which trump really hasnt changed is his desire to have better relations with putin at a time of great tension between the u. S. And russia, nobody should dismiss the idea of there being more talks. But its just strange, this consistent, sometimes a bromance between the two, that the idea that putin was crediting donald trump for helping the stock market and trump was thanking him. Its just a strange feature of our international scene. Just a final thing. We do feed russian help on north korea. I think the fact that theyve talked about that, emphasized that, id probably underline that fact in yesterdays events. The reporting out of the white house about the call yesterday between President Trump and president putin, they led with the fact that the call was made in order for President Trump to say thank you to putin for mentioning the Great American economy. And yet, wall street so skittish about so many elements every, each and every day seems not to have reacted to an incredibly powerful indictment of policy making as appeared in the Washington Post yesterday what is going on there . I think its a great point, pike. I think that wall street right now is very focused on the tax cuts that are coming to them and wall street is in the middle of an enormous, bold year. When wall street gets upset its when things are uncertain, when there is massive geopolitical tumult can you with us events. Lately, its been focused on the domestic situation. I think thats a great point. I do think things are going great on wall street right now. Joe, there is something to me very scary on this specific russia thing. What the dynamic of you cant mention russia. There seems to be in the white house the mod us operandi is dont upset or throw trump off. I heard an anecdote fun mrkind funny, trump was working the room, a secret service guy came over to my friend, when you speak to the president. Be positive. Imagine its audience warmup for the president. Thats what the secret service is doing now. The entire being of the president ial circle is act managing his imbalance versus making decisions based on whats going on, thats kind of frightening. You know, donny, dan dresdner always has a recurring tweet it seems every week or two after somebody talks about how the staff is handling donald trump like a child. He says, ill say that donald trump is finally become president when his staff stops treating him like hes a child. Bob corker talked about adult day care, that it seems, there have you the Top Republican in Foreign Affairs saying the white house, it seems at times reverts to being nothing more than an adult day care center. You see it in the staff briefings. You see it in the press room, where you have people going out before microphones that are afraid to tell the truth because they know theyll upset their boss. Were not just talking about Sarah Huckaby sanders here. You look what sean had to do for the first nine months in his mind, what he had to do. You can never tell the truth about crowd sizes and its just bad for america and more importantly, its bad for the people that are holding these jobs. If you just want to look at sean and the people that lead this white house. Theyre not going to be able to go back and fit neatly into washington and work after subing themselves to the humiliation they had to. But it is disturbing, willie, you have secret Service People going around whispering saying, hey, be positive to the president. He cant handle it, i go es. The worst part to me is there are a lot of good people in that white house who know better. If you that you can to them privately, they rom their eyes or say, i know, i know. We got to management. Keep the bubble wrap around him. You shouldnt have to spend the presidency managing a president s feeling and talk about policy and hope hes doing the right thing. Unfortunately at this point thats where we are. We will get heidi and joe to explain the tax bill and why marco rubio is holding the fate of the tax bill in his hands. Big marco, willie. Big marco is running things. Marco is not so little with two ds anymore. Marco is capital b capital i capital g. He can hold this. I think its actually good that marco is doing this. Its actually good for marco. Its good for the Republican Party. Because hes actually concerned about working class americans. And i also, listen, every for wants to be president. I think its a good step forward for him to send a page, im not afraid to buck the entire system and make everything stop if i dont get what i want. I think thats a good development. He has been on this position, on this particular part of the bill since the beginning. So hes got a good leg to stand on and President Trump very proud. Coming up, senator Lindsey Graham gives the odds of trump attacking, if. We will bring in james stavride. W irons remarks felt like the invasion. As i mentioned, tim ryan joins our table, first, bill kearns has a look at the forecast. A good friday to you, willie a. Change in the forecast for millions of people from i95 down to washington, d. C. Snow is in your forecast this afternoon, early this evening. Keep that if mind for your evening compute. 15 Million People are now under a Winter Weather advisory, including d. C. , baltimore, atlantic city. New york city not included in that. It doesnt require the issuance of a Winter Weather advisory. Heres the snowfall. Again, the timing of it this afternoon during the evening rush hour, one to two inches of snow, from d. C. To new york, through southern new england, a little higher totals there, maybe twotothree inches along the jersey shore. A pecky thomas fire t. Fourth biggest fire into california history flared up again last fight. New mandatory evacuation orders were issued. A red flag warning for central and Southern California, it will be windy, especially on sunday. Todays forecast, there is the snow in the northeast. No problems in the south, much of the west is calm, lets go outside, some rain out there in california t. Weekend outlook has snow in it. Heavy rain along the gulf coast. Thats about it for the weekend weather. The worst will be this afternoon, this evening, i95, washington, d. C. , right up to new york city. There is no sign for the snow yet. It will start around noon in our nations capital, the coating within an inch of that slippery white stuff. You are watching morning joe. Well be right back. A wealth of information. A wealth of perspective. A wealth of opportunities. Thats the clarity you get from fidelity wealth management. Straightforward advice, tailored recommendations, taxefficient investing strategies, and a dedicated advisor to help you grow and protect your wealth. Fidelity wealth management. To help you grow and protect your wealth. When youre clocking out. Im the one clocking in. Sensing your every move and automatically adjusting to help you stay effortlessly comfortable. I can even help with a silent night. Does your bed do that . I dont actually talk, but i can tell you how you slept. Im the new sleep number 360 smart bed. Lets meet at a sleep number store. Bp is taking safety to new heights. Using drones and robots offshore so engineers can stop potential problems before they start. Because safety is never being satisfied and always working to be better. We thats why at xfinityic. Weve been working hard to simplify your experiences with us. Now with instant text and email updates youll always be up to date. You can easily add premium channels so you dont miss your favorite show. And with just a single word, find all the answers youre looking for. Because getting what you need should be simple, fast, and easy. Download the xfinity my account app or go online today. This morning, the republican plan for tax reform is facing new uncertainty, Party Leaders are scrambling to lock down enough votes to pass the legislation before christmas. Key senators are withholding their support. Nbc news casey hunt has the details. Reporter senator marco rubio threatening to vote know, unless they agree to give American Families a bigger tax credit. Lets add it to the 1,100 figure i wont support the bill. Reporter for mike lee is undecided because of child tax credit. Senator bill corker is still a no on the bill. Balls they can only lose two votes that means republicans could be at risk of falling short of the 50 votes they need to pass the bill. The president is confident rubio will come around. Hes a great guy, very supportive. I think for rubio will be there for sure. Reporter but Vice President mike pence has had six tied votes this year delaying a critical trip to the middle east in case they need him in time. Also a concern, 80yearold thad cochran who has missed votes this week because of Health Reasons and senator mccain fighting brain cancer, hospitalized and absent from the senate this week. Its all about timing and managing absences in the senate. Reporter with time running out for the president and his party to make good on any Major Campaign promise be every the year is out. Heidi, its obviously very tight and postpeople consider right now what marco rubio is doing. Is he using leverage, that which he has the right to do. Again i personally think he should do it, using lever annual to get what he wants. But, corker is still a no what happens if john mccain cant show up to vote because of his health, does that derail it . It very well could, you have john mccain and thad cochran that missed votes this week because of his health. The bottom line is you can only lose two votes in this thing. You may have to delay it and a delay, of course, means who comes to the senate, doug jones, so i think whats happening with rubio is a manifestation is these senators, more moderate senators who jumped on board with the promise, they were given certain promises felt they got bad deals, look at susan collins, out there throwing an individual mandate repeal back in there. Not necessarily taking care of some of the extra funding that she wanted put back in. I think rubio is making a savvy political decision. I think in the end they will find a way to cut a deal for him. The politics at the moment are look at the polling on this bill. It does not have widespread support. As a matter of fact, it has widespread opposition. If you see the way that democrats are going to use this going into 2018, its playing into their broad values argument that theyre making, not just about everything that happened in alabama with roy moore but about the economics of how average families in this country are being affected. If i could, just for a moment, joe, you know this country was founded on a rebellion against monarchy. What is monarchy . Its inherited wealth . Whats happening with this bill is that its so tilted towards the upper income elements in this society. Its not just the estate tax repeal. Its the passthroughs. Its the fact that like marco rubio said, they found extra money to lower the top bracket. Theyre throwing 100 of trump change his way on the kyle tax credits. So this is a political moment for him and possibly other republicans to speak out and say, hey, at time when the top problem in this country is not jobs, its income and equality. How can we find extra money here to help working familys . Donny deutsche, i think thats why, if you look at again from branding and you have to look at it from branding, because, certainly, if youre a republican leader who sees how badly things are going for the gop, you have to wonder, how do we pass this bill after our attempt to repeal obamacare thats unpopular across america without getting hammered in the midterms. This will be one more thing thrown on top of the pile. That itself the first thing i want you to talk about. Secondly, though, as a businessman and an entrepreneur, you and your friends and a lot of people that drive the stockmarket have to just love what they hear on the macra level the top rate goes down to 37 and Corporate Taxes to 21 . Talk about both of those things. Well,a it was latter, if are you in a blue state, maybe not necessarily even all of our fancy wealthy friends, of course, that i will jump by about five or six points, from a big macro point of view and to heidis point, this is exacerbateing the number one part in this country wealth redistribution. Were redistributing it to wealthy guys t. One thing thats working right now in this country overall is the economy and a lot of our economists say this will have a negative infect. I cant wait joe no your first point as a brandon guy, id like to give my number on the air, theyre making it easy, beyond what we talked about in the first segment the party of moore and the party of trump and extremists. I can cut 20 commercials today basically saying the republicans have screwed you. The very thing that brought trump into office, the middle class white vote. Guess what, you are getting screwed on tax, on health care, sign me up right now, because its easy money, theyre walking you into a buzz saw, it is fundamentally so flawed from both a welfare point of view in this country to a strategic branding view what this tax plan is doing to get that w. That w is actually going to be on l. Democratic tim ryan of ohio is joining us here in new york. Lets stay on the Corporate Tax rate comes down, the Corporation Tax rate comes down for wealthiest americans, if it pass, congressmen can cobble this towing and get to 50 or 51 votes, what would it do in the short term to middle class family in youngstown, ohio, for example . Look, there is nothing worse than when someone makes a promise to you, you rely on that promise and they go back on that word. You feel in your gut, i have just been betrayed. People in youngstown feel betrayed because President Trump was saying, im going to tut your taxes during the campaign, im going to expand healthcare for you, im going to make life better for you, and everything hes done in the last year has either thrown someone off of health care or taken care of the wealthiest people in the country. So the person in youngstown over time is going to pay more in tacks. They may lose the child tax credit. You look at the groups against this teachers, aarp, veterans groups, catholic bishops, mr. Barnical, all against, not that you are a bishop. Far from it. In spirit. Hes a bishop. These groups are all against it because it is going to put the screws to the person in akron, ohio or youngstown, ohio, not to mention to pay for this entire ting. Wooer going to borrow 2 trillion from china and china is going to take our Interest Payments that were making on this money that we are borrowing. Theyre going to build high speed rail. Theyre going to move to batterypowered cars. Theyre going to continue to go down the road of Renewable Energy and all that, the benefits that come from that. They will build islands ift south coin sea and put military bases on them. They will build bases in africa. We are paying for china to move into a modern economy. You know, we are even seeing readers of our ceo daily fuse letter, which is written by our content officer alan purchase ray voiced their displeasure with this bill. We know the public is deeply acted with it. The concerns being it raisings the debt so much and it favors corporation. The Corporate Tax revenue as a percent of overall tax revenue was so small, its been getting smaller. So thats not, you know, most of the tax income comes from individuals, income tax, payroll tax, so thats whats going to feel the brunt of this. So, you know, theres widespread, even among, remember when gary cohen asked a group of ceos, who would hire . Nobody raised their hands. So the bill is an insult to common sense. Take me, drive me through your district and two aspects of this bill and other things going on in walk. The impact of basically the removal of obamacare, health care, that i assume many in your district and the impact of ignoring or not doing as much as we should do about the opioid crisis, which i assume is december stating in your district. Whats happening . We in ohio we will have hundreds of thousands of people thrown off their health care, many of these people, we do have an opioid crisis, many of these people are working class people, that are going to work every day, theyre playing by the rules, they have trouble making ends meet, they literally live pay check to paycheck. This was a lifeline for them to have Decent Health care, now the president is going to take that. Heres the other thing, if businesses wanted to hire people and we do them them. This, were not hostile to business. We want private investment in places like youngstown, who is going to hire our people . They have 4 trillion in corporate profits. If they want to hire somebody, they can hire them. If they see a good investment, they can make it notice. They dont need this tax cut. But you know whats not happening . When you drive through communities like mine and others across the country, there are thousands of blighted homes that need to come down. That needs to be a Public Investment we need to make. We need urban agriculture. We feed dream space. We need new we need to build few communities and right now, we dont have the money to do it. So these guys will run a 2 trillion hole in the deficit and borrow the money from china, mark my words, theyre starting to do it. We need money to take down dilapidated homes in youngstown to build roads, bridges, broadband and the new energy grid. They will say, you know what, we dont have the money. To your point earlier about branding, we came up with the commercial, its the President Trump tax plan. You see the guy, its the trump tax plan, the reason its the trump tax plan is he is saving billions and becomes of dollars, you know who is paying those becomes, putting them in his pocket, a thousand other people. You. You. The money is coming from your pock. 100 bucks at a time so that trumps grandson can save his becomes. He screwed you. Heres your commercial. The average people in youngstown, ohio will have 20,000 more in National Debt on to that family in youngstown because of this bill. Yeah, comeman, im sure you know, donald trump went to places like youngstown, they went to your district. He went to my district in pensacola, florida. He told working class americans and middle class americans all the things he was going to do for them and that he was going to go against the money interests, the political interests, against the International Interests and im sure you like me as donny is talking about branding and commercials, the most powerful thing you can do in a political ad is use somebodys own words against them. And my go, on health care, on taxes, on everything hes promised working class americans in youngstown an pensacola, hes gone back on those words, hasnt he . In dramatic, dramatic fashion. Yeah, no doubt about it. No doubt about. He is betraying the very workers that he was able to convince to come and vote for him. And look, these people were taking a chance. They were taking a chance on the blue collar billionaire, a chance on the guy who maybe had enough power and influence and money to be able to take on the money establishment in washington, d. C. , in the Centers Across the country. He hasnt done anything, really this tax cut is a missed opportunity. We did need tax reform. The tax system is too complicated. The Corporate Tax system is a mess. All of these things do need reform, but hes not doing anything to drive investment in pensacola or into youngstown, if you look at the fact that 80 of Venture Capital money goes to three states, to new york, california and massachusetts. And 90 of it goes to men, only 1 to africanamericans. If you reform the tax code, you look at the system and say, how can we get this wealth thats being created in the United States and get it to the communities left behind in the global economy. So hes betrayed these workers and come up with no plan to help them. Congressman tim ryan of ohio. Always good to see you. Coming up next. Admiral stavrides joins. And Lindsey Graham says time is running out. Morning joe is back in a momen moment. End sales event. What i want, youve got, but it might be hard to handle like the flame that burns the candle the candle feeds the flame topped steak twisted potatoes at applebees. Now thats eatin good in the neighborhood. You give us comfort. And we give you bare feet, backsweat, and gordos. Everything. I love you, but sometimes you stink. Soft surfaces trap odors. Febreze fabric refresher cleans them away for good. Because the things you love the most can stink. And plug in febreze to keep your whole room fresh for up to 45 days. Breathe happy with febreze. Were on a mission to show drip coffee drinkers, its time to wake up to keurig. Wakey wakey rise and shine oh my gosh how are you . Well watch this. I pop that in there. Press brew. Thats it. So rich. I love it. Thats why you should be a keurig man fullbodied. Are you sure youre describing the coffee and not me . Fullbodied. I d. Changed everything. You switched to the capital one quicksilver card. And how do you feel . [sighs] like a burdens been lifted. Those other cards made you sign up for bonus cash back. Then they change categories on you every few months. Then you had to keep signing up you. Deserve. Better. Now get out there and keep earning that 1. 5 cash back on every purchase everywhere. Thanks, doc. Im not a doctor. What . [whispers] time to go. Whats in your wallet . To north korea now, north korea is saying that should the United States enforce a blockade, which has been alluded to, not officially proposedpy the administration the dprk would quote take merciless selfdefense measures against a violation of its sovereignty. That would consider to be quote an act of war. Meanwhile, senator Lindsey Graham is spending a lot of time golfing with the president and spending hours upon hours with the president of the occupation is talking about the possibility of war with north korea. In a recent interview, lindsay said there is a 30 chance that President Trump will decide to attack north korea first and there is a 70 chance that donald trump would attack north korea if they conduct a seventh nuclear tested. Graham said that this was discussed during his round of golf with the president at trumps golf course last sunday. Lets bring in now former nato supreme allied commander, now the dean of the Fletcher School of law and diplomacy at Tufts University Major General stavridis, the diplomacy analyst for nbc news and msnbc. Thank you so much for being with us, admiral. First i must ask you, what is your reaction to a member of the Armed Services committee who spends probably more time with the president of the United States right now than other members of the senate saying that we have a 70 chance of going to war if there is another test . It worries me a lot. Lets face it. Thats primary source information. Id probably put those percentages slightly differently and a little bit lower. Id say there is probably a 10 chance we end up in an all out wheels off war on the Korean Peninsula, i think there is a 20 chance we will end up exchanging ordinance with north korea at some point in a fairly scene of the accident way. About a 30 chance of war from where i sit right now. Personally, if there is an above ground Nuclear Detonation, i dont think well attack, but i think thats where you could get into a maritime block cade, which i think is the next logical step in this thing. So, admiral, this David Ignacious in washington, i just want to ask you, one of the scary things to me about what senator graham said is that if you begin preemptive action against north korea, youd have to go all the way. You dont know where all their missiles are hidden. You have to take out everything, have a worst case scenario, when you think about war on the Korean Peninsula, you have done that a lot in your career, youve had to. What do you think about in terms of the dangers of something really getting out of control of being devastating for the population there . Yeah, i think, david, i think its probably about a 10 chance that it all falls apart and we end up with Nuclear Detonation on the peninsula from king john eun. I disagree with the idea that we would have to go all the way the minute the first missile goes. I think you can do a lot going after the north american fleet, can you go after specific sites. The worry is kim jongun would respond with artillery on seoul, it ratchets up. Legitimate worry, i think there is room for negotiation here, i think if kim jongun launches one above ground, a nuclear debt nation, that will be the moment of peak tension. It will also be a moment of peak opportunity. Because, hopefully, at that point even china would step in with us and put a block cade around this guy par right time and on the land order with coin. That would choke off the economy and force him to the table. There is the question of iran, standing behind a backdrop, consisting of military equipment. Nuclear Ambassador Nikki Haley accused iran of violating u. N. Resolutions, offering up what the Administration Says is definitive proof. In this warehouse is concrete evidence of a legal iranian weapons proliferation, gathered from direct military attacks on our partners in the region. Behind me is an example of one of these attacks, these are the recovered pieces of a missile fired by houthi militants from yemen into saudi arabia. The missiles intended target was a civilian airport in riyadh. All of these weapons include parts paid in iran. Some by irans governmentrun defense industry. The evidence is undeniable. The weapons might as well have had made in iran stickers all over it. The nuclear deal has done nothing to moderate the regimes conduct in other areas. Where do we go from here . Well, i think the president made the first start by dessertfying the iran deal basically with congress, so that congress can start looking at these other things that eastern is doing. Yes, we have already started to talk to our partners in the Security Council. In a statement the iranian government says it categorically rejects it as unfounded, provocative, destructive, adding, quote the reported everyday is as much fabricated as the one presented on some other occasions as a part of an agenda and irans foreign minister tweeted, quote, when i was based at the u. N. , i saw this show and what it begat and showed a picture of colin power outlining the invasion of iraq. Admiral stavridis, she is laying the groundwork. What is it . She trying to hold together a Shaky Coalition of our european ourselves and with the sunni arabs so we can confront iran in all of these capitals, these proxy wars going on in yemen, in syria, in lebanon, and most importantly, i think, in iraq. So shes trying to hold that coalition together. I really disagree with the iranians on this one to try and say this as echoes of pollen powe colin powell. This is more substantive in terms of laying out the hardware. Its a little overly dramatic, perhaps, but i think it makes a pretty clear point, and i think iran is pushing on all these points and were going to have to stand against them. That does not mean we should walk away from the nuclear deal. We should keep the nuclear deal but built a front to prevent them. David, im wondering what insights you can give us from the nikki haley presentation yesterday and also with what the Trump Administration is trying to do here. Well, i think the Trump Administration has decided its time to step up the pressure on iran. Nikki haley was arguing iran is in violation of a u. N. Security Council Resolution passed in 2015 at the same time of the Iran Nuclear Deal and trying to rally members of the Security Council to address this and take it seriously. She has in that sense a Stronger International footing than we do, arguably, in dealing with north korea. I do think were in a period now where the u. S. Working with saudi arabia and the uae are going to take firmer steps to deal with iran, especially in yemeni. The saudis are nervous about the missiles that as haley says, the evidence pretty strong that they have been moving missiles into yes, maa yemen. Theres a feeling inside saudi arabia and the uae, were livering undliving under the gun. Theyre feeling the Trump Administration has their back. I think we are heading toward greater confrontation. Whats worry someis having confrontations on both sides of the world. North korea at the same time as the persian gulf with iran. But thats the moment were in right now. All right. David, stay with us. Admiral, thank you very much. Always good to have you on. Appreciate it. Coming up, trumps lies versus those told by obama. The big difference, obama stopped saying things checked by Fact Checkers. We have the list of trumps first year falsehoods, ahead on morning joe. Jerry . Just remember, its not a lie if you believe it. Liberty mutual saved us almost eight hundred dollars when we switched our auto and home insurance. With liberty, we could afford a real babysitter instead of your brother. Hey. Oh. Thats my robe. Is it . You could save seven hundred eighty two dollars when liberty stands with you. Liberty mutual insurance. They appear out of nowhere. My secret visitors. Appearing next to me in plain sight. Hallucinations and delusions. These are the unknown parts of living with parkinsons disease. What stories they tell. But for my ears only. What plots they unfold. But only in my mind. Over 50 of people with parkinsons will experience hallucinations or delusions during the course of their disease. And these can worsen over time, making things even more challenging. But there are advances that have led to Treatment Options that can help. If someone you love has parkinsons and is experiencing hallucinations or delusions, talk to your parkinsons specialist. Because theres more to parkinsons. My visitors should be the ones i want to see. Learn more at moretoparkinsons. Com the markets change. At t. Rowe price. Our disciplined approach remains. Global markets may be uncertain. But you can feel confident in our investment experience around the world. Call us or your advisor. T. Rowe price. Invest with confidence. You know, were covering a lot of ground this morning as we do every morning, but youre going to be on the hill today, and theres only going to be one topic, taxes. What do you expect to happen today . Well, i think that theyre going to be pressing hard on folks like marco rubio, susan collins, trying to get them in line, trying to maybe throw a little more money at rubio in the end so he can look like a hero and probably at the end of the day, theyre going to get this over the line, joe. But ive spent a lot of time on the phone lately with another group thats a holdout on the plan. Thats economists. And what theyre telling me is that there was a way to do this to make this a middle class tax plan. That was to give a payroll tax cut. Everybody pays the payroll tax cut. That would put money back into the hands who buy washing machines and cars. But in this case, what you have here is primarily a Corporate Tax cut. And guess what. There was a way to do that, to give a lower corporate rate which a lot of economists agree with. And that was to do a revenue neutral plan by closing loopholes. So we dont have either of these things in this plan. Thats why it will have no democratic support, but in the end, i think theyre going to get people like rubio. Okay. Heidi, thank you. We appreciate you being with us today. Stick around, because coming up at the top of the hour, were going to be talking about russia, north korea, the fallout from alabama, and were going to have peggy newnan. Well be right back. If youre not content to remain where you are, why should your teeth be . Invisalign clear aligners can shape your smile up to 50 faster. Dont let anything slow you down. More people shop online for the holidays than ever before. And the United States Postal Service delivers more of those purchases to homes than anyone else in the country. Because we know, even the smallest things are sometimes the biggest. Zbljtds t the stock markets is hitting a all time high record. How theyve grown. Economic. Investors show. Consumer confidence. In the American Economy. Surged to 3. 3 . They have trust in what president is doing. Its all psychological and whats that creates greatness. With all due respect. They call themselves the resistance. You ever see the signs . You know, all of this has been invented. And these fake people back here. Made up. But i tell you what. Willie, that is message discipline. Youve got to really respect those two guys. Just for no other reason to have the sort of message discipline. Its so jarring. Were going to be introducing peggy newnan in a second. For those of us who grew up as conservative republicans during the height of the cold war, it really is jarring to see donald trump in a mind meld with a man who runs a country that invades other countries, that shoots down passenger planes, that assassinates journalists. That assassinates political leaders. Its pretty jarring, but hes doing it, and as David Ignatius says, the facts are hiding in broad daylight. And putin knows exactly how to play President Trump. He says exactly what he needs. Donald trump will respond. And he got a phone call from President Trump yesterday. Donny deutsche and Mike Barnicle are here along with l lee gallagher, peggy newnan, David Ignatius, julie pace, and former chief of staff at the cia and department of defense now at nbc news National Security analyst, jeremy bash. Mika has the morning off. Joe . So, peggy wrote a column this morning in the Washington Post talking about the laws of physics apparently apply to politics in the age of trump because for every action, there is an opposite and equal reaction except in this case it appears that the reaction to donald trump pushing back on the rights of women, pushing back on the rights of minorities, it appears that the pushback in alabama and virginia and across america seems to be Even Stronger than the push that donald trump and republicans are providing. Republicans are just losing across the board. Yeah. Virginia was followed by alabama. Somebody said the other day the actual fact here if you just reduce it down to its essentials is that democrats hate donald trump more than republicans love him. And i think there may be something to that. I do think that this alabama setback might reorient some thinking in the white house about the fact that the president has failed in the year since the election to expand his core of supporters. Its still a core. Its still there. But your job when you come into the past si with a limited core is expand the edges. Keep persuading. Keep bringing people in. Do this with an air of personal moderation and political moderation at this moment a sort of soft populism. He hasnt been able to do that. Peggy, you and i were both in tuscaloosa, alabama. Hold on here, 33 years ago, in 1984. It was my First Political rally. It really was. Your First Political rally, and i remember you reading about it, reading about what youd written about it, but its hard to believe that in that state, in that conservative state that republicans actually lost the senate seat for the first time in a quarter century, but doesnt that really speak to just how bad things have gotten for republicans under donald trump, that perhaps it is alabama, ironically, it is alabama, the state that trump has always bragged is his number one state . That maybe its the state where the fever of trumpism finally broke . Yeah. You know, donald trump won alabama in the 2016 president ial election by i think with i think 62 of the vote. Hillary clinton got 34 . Its a 28point spread. Thats a big a spread as you get in the natural political universe. So one of the things you see is that one of the things that caught my eye in the exit polls after the alabama voting was that the president s approval, disapproval numbers were 48 48. So it used to be 64. You know . Now its kind of 48. So thats not so good. But that, you know, alabama once was on fire with a kind of i think beautiful, modern ascendant conservatism, and sometimes things turn into a racket. I think in the case of roy moore, there was a bad candidate who seemed not who was kind of easily detected by a number of people to seem not essentially wellmeaning, and then he is charged with these bad crimes having to do with teenage girls. So i dont know. I guess i thought alabama, the outcome in alabama had to do with a return or a reassertion of political standards of what we will accept and what we will not accept. This is too about political standards but not about alabama. This is about the phrase preserve, protect, and defend the constitution. And it is about an amazing piece in the Washington Post yesterday having to do with President Trump being briefed on all sorts of situations. The president ial deal. He briefed my vague familiarity with the president ial daily brief is that the cia director is in the oval office along with a professional career briefer. But why dont you talk about your reaction to the post story, the nuts and bolts of the story, and actually how the briefing takes place . Yeah. Two things, mike. First, in terms of the morning intelligence briefing for the president and his senior team, that is usually led by a career professional cia analyst or an analyst from another intelligence agency. And they are putting forward a consensus intelligence product. When you have an intelligence briefing for a president where they are shading the truth, leaving out intelligence, changing the order so as not to offend him, thats not an intelligence briefing. That is story time. That is fiction. That is basically telling the president something he wants to hear, and i cant think of anything more dangerous during a time when we have crises in asia and the middle east, all around the world. The president needs the truth and emblazoned on the wall of the original cias Head Quarters building is know the truth and the truth shall set you free. Thats the motto of the intelligence briefer. For the president to receive anything less is a disservice the Intelligence Community is doing for him and the nation. Its a dangerous precedent. If you read the piece the thrust is the people giving the briefing danced around any questions of russia and russian interference so as not to outrage President Trump. Meanwhile the russian president praised President Trump yesterday speaking to reporters at his end of the Year Press Conference in moscow. He praised trump for the u. S. Stock market and rejected the premise for the probe into russian meddling at spy mistear ya. Hours later they spoke by telephone. The staterun Russian News Agency disclosed details of the conversation before the American Press learned about the call. The kremlins statement said, quote, acute issues of bilat relations as well as the situation in crisis hot spots worldwide for discussed with an emphasis placed on the issue. President trump thanked president putin for acknowledging americas strong Economic Performance in his annual press conference. They discussed working together to resolve the dangerous situation in north korea. Later there was a story about President Trump thanking putin. Julie pace, what was the sort of order of this . Was the phone call from President Trump to putin a reaction to the praise that day at the press conference or was it already planned . Well, its hard to say exactly what the order was but the fact that putin was in russia and was praising the president caught trumps attention, and its clear that putin has learned a lesson that i have heard diplomats in washington, lawmakers, Business Executives talk about when it comes to their own dealings with the president and thats that flattery is everything. If you want something from this president , the best way to get his attention, the best way to butter him up is to praise him. And in this case its the economy. You hear trump talk about this frequently. He doesnt think hes getting enough attention for the way the stock market is rising. He doesnt think the Strong Economy hes getting enough credit for the Strong Economy. Putin clearly has been briefed on that. He clearly knows thats the way to flatter this president , and then get into whatever else he wants whether its in north korea or syria. Its a lesson that has been learned across the board. It ties into is there anybody in the white house who can talk to the president about expanding his base . Right now theres really not because people in the white house tend to be focussed on flattering this president. He doesnt have a lot of people around him who often will tell him difficult truths because this strategy of flattery has become so pervasive. On the question of flatter i, back to the president s trip to the middle east where they projected his image and face on to the side of the hotel and had his face on flags on the route he traveled. People around the world, and especially Vladimir Putin know exactly what to say to butter up donald trump. Thats right. The whole game for foreign leaders is trying to figure out how to play our president , how to make him feel important, how to make him feel bigger than he is. And its, again, dangerous, because it shows that other countries are able to ma nip you la manipulate us. The fact that the president has been opposing sanctions and other measures to get tough on russia, this isnt merely his insecure about the election. Its gone beyond the election and predated his election victory. Its gone back as you and joe and mika have talked about since the beginning since december of 2015 since the president has been beholden to russia. Its almost like the borrower and the indebtedness. The president of the United States has put American Foreign policy of collateral, and putin has the leverage. David ignatius, also, lets just talk about this relationship with the Intel Community, fraught with pitfalls from day one. From even before donald trump became president , he spent a great deal of time attacking the Intel Community. Now the Intel Community is coming to donald trump whitewashing the briefing so as not to upset him. You have Donald Trumps allies on the hill starting to bash the fbi, trash the federal bureau of investigation. Some people on cable news comparing the fbi to the kgb, and then strange things happening at the Justice Department. The Text Messages being improperly late because now the Justice Department admitting that actually everyone inside there has the right to hold their own political opinions. So long as it doesnt interfere with the investigations. The Intel Community right now is obviously going around in circles trying to figure out how to deal with this president. Whats your take away from what weve heard over the past 24, 48 hours . Joe, i think the Intelligence Community feels like a punching bag sometimes with this president. There were two important pushback moments this week. One was wen chris ray, the fbi director chosen by donald trump defended the fbis professionalism. That was actually last week, but it was a key message. He said the fbi isnt in tatters. The bureau i represent is doing the job of the American People. I thought it was also important this week that the Deputy Attorney general Rod Rosenstein appointed by trump stood up for the Justice Department for special counsel bob mueller, his investigation. He said the investigation is not tainted by the political views by people who work for mueller. He didnt see any reason to fire him. I thought those things were all important. I would note one thing on this question of President Trumps ability to absorb reality about Foreign Policy. The biggest worry i would have this week is if he doesnt understand just how danger the situation with north korea is, and the fact that he talked with his pal Vladimir Putin about getting russian help on north korea to avoid getting in a military conflict to get additional russian pressure, i think trump is realizing china alone isnt going to do it. That was their strategy. I dont think theyre getting there with that strategy. If hes reaching out to putin and saying you need to help us convince kim jongun to stop this Nuclear Program before we get into much more dangerous territory, i think that actually is a useful development. Lee, with all this going on on the Foreign Policy front, president has a few days to get a win on tax reform. A win. He wants to get something done by the end of the year to have a legislative achievement. Rubio is Holding Things up in regard to the child tax credit. The margin is raiser thin. Bob corker is a no. If they dont bring rubio around, theres trouble. Susan collins, we dont know. Theres a lot in the air still. Thats right. If this does pass and they can cobble this coalition together, what it will mean for the American Economy . Well, look, business will sing and celebrate. The stock market will go up. It should be noted that business already pays basically 18 to 20 . When you factor in the loopholes and everything. Its not like this has been so desperately needed as everyone would have you believe. But i think we will see theres so much public disaffection with the bill. I think that will be even more reflected. Theres been picketing. My father is very active in local politics, and very active in the resist movement. You guys talk a lot about Nicole Wallaces father, my father is the counterpart. He was at the picket lines last week in delaware county, pennsylvania. Its a place joe brings up a lot. And they had trump tax scam carols last week, and i brought them just to show them here. We wish for a better tax bill. Youre a mean one mr. Trump. My father thinks this is too silly and diminishes the real point here, but i think were going to see an incredible movement, the dissatisfaction will deepen. I wonder what will happen among trumps base. We havent really talked about how are they going to feel about this tax bill . Its i mean, theyre the ones who are going to be the most affected. President trump promised in his live presentation yesterday with people saying they will benefit from the tax bill, citizens, et cetera, he said you are going to see, you regular americans are going to see a lowering of your taxes by february. I think he meant on your february payroll tax. If the economy, the proof is in the pudding. If after this has passed and im not certain it will be, but lets say its passed, if the economy goes up, the stock market goes up and people feel they have a few extra bucks, when theyre being paid, that will be fairly popular, but i think theres a real argument to be made that this doesnt really serve the president s base so directly. I think marco rubio is onto something when he says whoa, dont worry as much about the tax rate. Worry about the deduction for parents who have kids. You know . We love parents. We like kids. America is actually in a birth dearth. We need more kids. Have a baby. Lets try to make it easier. Theres another thing i want to say. The Corporate Tax thing, i am a conservative, so i like to cut taxes. I think its a good thing. I dont know all of the things you know about the Corporate Tax rate. In other words, thats its functionally 18 and 20 or not 30 , but i know if they benefit corporations and appear to be benefitting, and they do not translate those benefits into expansion, development, jobs for people, if instead they just hold the benefits to themselves, pay off their debt or whatever they do with their money, that will be a scandal. That will be a real shame. Speaking of scandals just a scandal, and sometimes i think corporate chiefs, koreas, wall street, they have to remember they are citizens too. They have a stake in this thing. Theyve got to create jobs. Theyve got to help young people entering the market who arent fully whats the word, trained . What happen with all the mergers and acquisitions . Ill tell you what happens. People get laid off. Any benefits of that will happen with the big disney thing. Trump university. Thats whats happening here. Through his base, its the same thing. Pulls people in with a promise. Nothing happens. He gets rich. We are living through trump university. Well, we also, lee, you can speak to this. Everybody keeps comparing this to the reagan tax cuts. Things are different today than they were in 1981. The highest tax rates i think were up in the 70s or 39 now. We may get a couple off of that. We had an economy that was struggling back in 1981. Right now we have an economy that is for the past several years improving every single month. So thats one part of it that doesnt make sense. But also the entire way corporations work. In 1981 if you gave a corporation a tax cut, chances are good they could have to reinvest into the production which would mean Assembly Lines and more americans getting more jobs and that being spread out. Now explain. If the Corporation Makes more money, chances are good theyre not going to hire more people. In fact, its more likely than not they wont hire more americans to work. They will buy back more shares of their own company. Thats true, joe. Theyll do that. They may make some mergers and acquisitions, the results are very really depend on each case. Even jamie diamond said this week you might not see it for a while if there is a benefit to corporations. But youre making great point here. And the other thing that economists pointed out is that just by adding this massive bill to the debt, Interest Rates are going to go up which could wash away a lot of the benefit you could see from the theory that the cut will spur growth. Theres a lot of issues that you raise. And also our tax policy, it incentivizes people and corporations to avoid, to find ways to park the money. Its flawed in many ways. Those things are not addressed by this bill. As you talk to people inside the white house, whats the level of desperation or choose a better word of getting tax reform passed after having lost the promise to repeal and replace obama care earlier in the year, what does it mean to lose on this Campaign Promise . I think desperation is a good word. They are facing the prospect of ending the year with no significant achievements. This president made a lot of lofty promises. And he continues to talk about this year in a really lofty way. He talks about historic achievements, but we have a poll coming out later today and one of the questions we asked people was do you believe that the president made good on his promises. I wont give away the full number, but its a pretty low percentage of americans who believe he did. When i talked to a lot of americans who did the survey for us, their takeaway from the year is that trump talks a big game but there isnt a lot to back it up, and if they know anything about the tax bill, its that it benefits the wealthy. One gentleman said the one thing i know for sure is if this passes, it will benefit President Trump and his wealthy friends. Even if this passes, i think the white house has a big hurdle in front of them, republicans as well, a big hurdle in front of them to try to prove to americans that this wasnt just a package for the wealthy, for business leaders. This will help the middle class, and based on estimates from economists, the impact on the middle class doesnt seem as great as for the higher income earners and businesses. Well find out if it passes before the end of the year. Julie, thank you. Still ahead on morning joe, well bring in one of the reporters who had washington abuzz about paul ryans future. Tim alberta is next whith what hes hearing about ryans possible exit strategy from congress. Youre watching morning joe. Liberty mutual stood with me when this guy got a flat tire in the middle of the night, so he got home safe. Yeah, my dad says our insurance doesnt have that. What . you can leave worry behind when liberty stands with you™. Liberty mutual insurance. If yor crohns symptoms are holding you back, and your Current Treatment hasnt worked well enough, it may be time for a change. Ask your doctor about entyvio, the only biologic developed and approved just for uc and crohns. Entyvio works at the site of inflammation in the gi tract and is clinically proven to help many patients achieve both symptom relief and remission. Infusion and serious allergic reactions can happen during or after treatment. Entyvio may increase risk of infection, which can be serious. Pml, a rare, serious, potentially fatal brain infection caused by a virus may be possible. This condition has not been reported with entyvio. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, experience frequent infections or have flulike symptoms or sores. Liver problems can occur with entyvio. If your uc or crohns treatment isnt working for you, ask your gastroenterologist about entyvio. Entyvio. Relief and remission within reach. But can also loweresterol, your bodys natural coq10. Qunol helps restore this hearthealthy nutrient with 3x better absorption. Qunol has the 1 cardiologist recommended form of coq10 qunol, the better coq10. [ mouse clicks, keyboard clacking ] [ mouse clicking ] [ keyboard clacking ] [ mouse clicking ] [ keyboard clacking ] good questions lead to good answers. Our advisors can help you find both. Talk to one today and see why were bullish on the future. Yours. The president did speak to the speaker not too long ago and made sure the speaker knew very clearly and in no Uncertain Terms if the news but true he was unhappy with it. The speaker said they were not accurate reports and they look forward to working together for a long time. Thank you very much. I appreciate it. That was House Speaker paul ryan. And before that press secretary Sarah Huckabee sanders reacting to our next guest reporting yesterday that ryan is eyeing an exit from congress in 2018. Joining us now is tim alberta. Tim, if i understand it correctly, you had three dozen sources, 36 sources that said paul ryan in no Uncertain Terms was planning his exit around the 2018 midterm election. Those denials yesterday from the white house and from paul ryan, how do you react . Well, willie, i think its important to realize why paul ryan cant afford to look like a lame duck. Hes the most prolific fundraiser. And on the one hand they need his continued financial might, on the other hand, he loses all of his negotiating leverage with democrats, with his own conference if he looks like a lame duck. When john boehner left, the night before his spokesman came out and said he wasnt going anywhere, and 12 hours later he was. Thats how these things work. Why now . Still a young man to step away. I think its important to understand sort of the context of his career arc here. Ryan when he came back from the 2012 campaign trail when he was the Vice President ial nominee almost left congress. He made clear he was ready to go home. John boehner twisted his arm to bring him back. When he was there, ryan realized at that point he wanted to chair the ways and means committee, hope to rewrite the tax code and pass it into the law with the help of a republican president. If he could accomplish that, he was going to go home. He told friends and family that at the time. Then he becomes speaker reluctantly, but he told john boehner and others this was a shortterm proposition. This is my last job in politics and i dont want the job to begin with. Now fast forward, hes looking at the landscape and says look, i have tax reform in my back pocket. Im going to use next year to try to get entitlement reform. His children are in their teenage years. He has never lived at home with them. He would like to. Hes made it clear to people close to him. People have picked up the message. Hes told his inner circle about this and its spread. And you know have Steve Scalise and Kevin Mccarthy, his two most likely successors jockeying behind the scenes. They understand the writing is on the wall and at some point in the next year, there will be a leadership shakeup. Tim, youre touching on the point of curiosity to me. What will your report, and the reports that the speaker will leave in after 2018, what will that set off . What is it going to look like in the congress . Youll have scalise and mccarthy. We have a bunch of other possible candidates for the job. Whats it going to look like . Well, i think its going to be a bit of a mess, frankly. Kevin mccarthy had the opportunity to become speaker several years ago when john boehner left, and Kevin Mccarthy didnt have the votes to get the job. And others were uncomfortable with him taking over. His cal cue louse this time is because hes a strong ally of President Trumps, the white house will help to get him over the top. There are deep concerns about that in the halls of congress. So Kevin Mccarthy is going to take another crack. Hes made it clear to his allies if he does not have the numbers, then Steve Scalise will jump at the job and try to become speaker. Whats important to realize is the Freedom Caucus has all the leverage. They view themselves as the king makers of the next speaker. What theyre looking for, its important, they want significant process reforms in exchange for their votes. That means specifically restructuring the Steering Committee so there is a more dispersed way of selecting Committee Chairman and handing out Committee Assignments and potentially creating another leadership position where there would be another leadership official who would be almost e in power to the majority power. Theres almost a triangle. These are the things theyre discussing behind the scenes. Dpl. Tim, the Freedom Caucus. On a day today basis, the weight of angst that paul ryan must feel from people like the guy from no coat from ohio, mark d meado meadows, the entire freedom caucca cauc caucus. How is it theyve tormented leadership for eight to ten years, this group . I think it boils down to strength in numbers. There are about three dozen, as of right now, 35 members of the Freedom Caucus. Paul ryan can only afford to lose a certain number at any time. And nancy pelosi is loathed to have any break in her ranks to help ryan pass anything. Freedom caucus members realize they hold the critical margin on anything anything the Republican Leadership wants to do. Now, if, in fact, republicans lose seats in 2018, the members who are most endangered are swing district mostly suburban center right establishment friendly moderate republicans. Freedom caucus districts are almost entirely off the board for democrats. If the republican majority shrinks next november, which we expect it to, then the margin for error paul ryan has is smaller and the lerch the Freedom Caucus has is greater. I think thats factoring into hisalculations. He understands the map. He realizes that if republicans hold the house next november, that theres going to be a much smaller majority that hes working with and these folk who have made his life so difficult will have an even bigger role to play in the process. Its a fascinating piece. Speaker ryan denies hes living but in recent interviews, not a Single Person believes hes still in congress past 2018. Check out the piece if you havent read it at politico yet. Tim, thank you. Good to see you. Thank you. Coming up, hes been called Vladimir Putins public enemy one. When asked if he knew anything about the russian lawyer that met at trump tower, our next guest responded i know a lot about her. Bill brouder joins us next. It can detect a threat using ai, and respond 60 times faster. It lets you know where your data lives, down to the very server. It keeps your insights from prying eyes, so theyre used by no one else but you. It. Is. The cloud. The ibm cloud. The cloud thats designed for your data. Ai ready. Secure to the core. The ibm cloud is the cloud for business. Yours. The market. Redict but through good times and bad. At t. Rowe price. Weve helped our investors stay confident for over 75 years. Call us or your advisor. T. Rowe price. Invest with confidence. Or a little internet machine . It makes you wonder shouldnt we get our phones and internet from the same company . Thats why Xfinity Mobile comes with your internet. You get up to 5 lines of talk and text at no extra cost. So all you pay for is data. See how much you can save. Choose by the gig or unlimited. Xfinity mobile. A new kind of network designed to save you money. Call, visit, or go to xfinitymobile. Com. Welcome back to morning joe. Joining us is bill browder, the man who inspired a bill that singled out a number of putin allies and denied them u. S. Visas. Because of that hes been called putin enemy number one. Jeremy bash is back with us. Hes former chief of staff at the cia and department of defense. Bill, good to see you. I want to back up and explain that you were the largest foreign investor in russia for a time or one of them. Your attorney exposed some tax fraud that was happening in russia. He was jailed and killed in jail. And you continue to fight the putin regime every day. Why do you fight so hard against russia and putin . My lawyer was killed, i should say tortured to death in a russian prison in 2009 for uncovering a massive putin russian government corruption scheme. They killed him effectively as my proxy. They killed him because he worked for me, and thats a big responsibility. He was 37 years old. He left a wife and two children after being tortured to death. And so on the day when i learned of his murder, the day after they killed hip, i made a vow to his memory and his family and myself to make sure i would go after the people who did it. Ive spent eight years doing that which resulted in legislation making asset freezes. So against people of the putin regime involved in this and who do other terrible things in russia and putin went crazy. Give the scale so people understand, if you were assigned a dollar amount to the affect of putins oligarchs, the money he controls, were talking the hundreds of billions of dollars here . I believe that putin is the richest man in the world. I believe that he personally is worth 200 billion. And i believe that people around him, lets say the top 1,000 officials in russia, are worth a trillion dollars. Theres so much money at stake here. This is such an important issue. I should point out this money is not kept in russia. As easily as they stole it from other people, it could be stolen from them. They keep it in the west, in the United States and london. To draw a line back to trump where he was to anxious to get rid of this, to lift this act to get rid of the sanctions, draw the line back to trump. Whats his incentive . We dont know trumps position on the sanctions. Putins position is he wants the sanctions lifted as his number one Foreign Policy priority. We know he got this agent, the famous russian lawyer, he got her to go to trump tower when trump was just nominated to go on a quest to donald trump junior, Paul Manafort and Jared Kushner to repeal the act. We dont know the trump camps reaction to that. And so were sort of sitting here, and its an important month. This is the month more names get added to the list. Trump will either do that as scheduled in the law or not. And this is a significant moment. You mentioned the russian lawyer, the woman who was in the june 2016 meeting at trump tower. Youve known her for some time. Is there any chance that she was not acting on behalf of Vladimir Putin and the russian government . In other words, could she have been freelancing . Theres no chance. We have multiple pieces of evidence that she was acting as an agent for Vladimir Putin. We have the evidence she was working closely with the general prosecuter of russia, the equivalent of the attorney general who is putins main enforcer. And many other things as well. She was an agent for Vladimir Putin showing up in trump tower. Thats for sure. And what she was asking for is also for sure which is repeal of the act. What we do not know is the reaction to her request. Bill, jeremy bash has a question for you. Jeremy . Bill, im going to put you on the spot here. Have you been interviewed by Robert Mueller or the intelligence committees investigating the money trail between Vladimir Putin and the Trump Organization . I can only talk about what ive done publicly. I have been interviewed by the Senate Judiciary committee. I cannot talk about any Law Enforcement interactions ihad. Fair enough. We respect that. Talk about the money trail for a moment. Do you believe you reference Vladimir Putinens personal wealth and the wealth around him. Do you believe that some of that money that was leaving russia in the 80s and the 90s actually went to trump and the Trump Organization . Did they use russian money either through offshore accounts or Shell Companies to fund trump business projects . Im not an expert on trump finances or russians connections to trump finances. What i do know is Many Russians bought condominiums in various different projects in florida and elsewhere. And that may not be too different than other developers, but we know that for sure. Were skeffectively arm share investigators. Theres 1,000 times more information than that us. They have subpoena powers. They can get people to become witnesses. Well find out in due course if theres anything else and if there is, what it is. And finally, bill, can you quickly explain the connection between the act which was named after your lawyer and russian interference in the election . What were they trying to do in interfering from your perspective . The way i put the pieces of the puzzle together is putin says he doesnt like the act. It upsets him personally. He wants to get it repealed. He sent in people to meet with the trump camp to try to repeal it, and for some reason or another, and putin, maybe thats the reason putin decided trump was his favorite candidate in the u. S. Elections. We know as well that putin went in with various types of techniques to hack, to influence the outcome of the elections, et cetera. What we do not know for sure is whether trump participated or if putin was just expressing his interest in the sidelines. The assets in london, paris, chicago, how do they hide them . How do they wash them . Putin doesnt keep any money in his own name. He keeps all money in the name of oligarchs. When you see a rich spectacularly rich russian and you see their name on the forbes list, multiply it by 50 . The other half of the money is putins. They keep their money, or he keeps his money through oligarchs in hedge funds and private equity funds and trophy property in the United States and all these other places you named. And given the scope and the reach of Vladimir Putin in the west, and in the world, do you fear for your own personal safety . Um, well, two questions. Am i living in fear . The answer is no. Im out there campaigning every day to old putin to account. Am i at risk of being killed . The answer is yes, a high risk. Theyve threatened to kill me, kidnap me. Theyve tried going to interpoll to have me arrested . They threatened to kill you . What form does that take . For example, the Prime Minister of russia was at the World Economic forum in davos and was asked by a group of journalists, what do you think of mag knit ski, he said its a shame hes dead and bill browder is still alive and running around. Let me ask you a question. As you think about the whole trump magnitski act, do you get a sense President Trump then candidate trump was an unwitting mark or someone who was a witting mark, somebody who didnt understand white what was going on who didnt understand what was going on or someone who got it . Its impossible for me. Im slowly looking at the pieces of the puzzle being put together. I know for sure what the russians wanted, and i do not know how the trump camp reacted. But we will know, and quite soon, i think. Its great to have you here. Great courage. Youve been speaking about that at great risk to your own safety. Thank you for being here. He has a book called red notice if you want to see how the pieces of the puzzle come together. A new poll finds most americans say President Trump has done something illegal or at least unethical when it comes to russia. Well dig into it when we come back. Online u. S. Equity trades. You realize the smartest investing idea, isnt just what you invest in, but who you invest with. What comes to mind . Your next getaway . Connecting with family and friends . A big night out . Or maybe your everyday shopping. Whatever it is, aarp member advantages can help save you time and money along the way. So when you get there, you can enjoy it all the more. For less. Surround yourself with savings at aarp advantages dot com. Difficult opened in theaters. The preview expected to pull in 45 million, second only to the force awakens. Numbers are expected this morning. Willie, this sunday, big interview connected. That guy right that, adam driver, the guys who play kilo wren. Adam driver, fascinating guy, joined the United States marine corps after 9 11, served the country, came out, started acting a little bit. Did only stage work. Best known early on for his role on girls, that lena dunham series, played her boyfriend and got this part that turned him into an International Star when he did the force awakens. Kyle low wren this sunday on nbc. Couldnt get chewbacca . No, chewy doesnt do press. The reviews on the movie have been incredible. University good. I was a teenager when it came out, i never bit. Its like christmas if youre jewish, you feel like youre not part of whats going on. You can skip three. Peggy, where are you coming out on star wars . I was never into it. On when it came out and it was a phenomenon and everybody saw it, its just not my cup of tea. Its never too late. I think youll like this one. I love him. I love that actor. Hes really impressive. He has extraordinary presence. Thats what they say about Mike Barnicle. Adam driver. Every president tells untruths. A new list from the New York Times puts President Trump in a category all his own. Well break that down ahead. Plus President Trump spoke to Vladimir Putin yesterday by phone hours after putin praised trump and sided with him in the russia vaks. Plus, the republican plan for tax reform suddenly on shaky ground this morning. Senator marco rubio is threatening a no vote and other key republicans on the fence. Morning joe is coming right back on a busy friday morning. Heres the story of Green Mountain Coffee Roasters sumatra reserve told in the time it takes to brew your cup. Lets go to sumatra. Wheres sumatra . Good question. This is win. And thats wins goat, adi. The coffee here is amazing. Because the volcanic soil is amazing. Making the coffee erupt with flavor. So we give farmers like win more plants. To grow more delicious coffee. That erupts with even more flavor. Which helps provide for wins family. And adi the goats family too. Because his kids eat a lot. All, for a smoother tasting cup of coffee. Green mountain Coffee Roasters. Packed with goodness. Republicans are still working on their tax bill and paul ryan even tweeted out his own version of twas the night before christmas and changed the word to make it about taxes. Trump just released his own version. Twas the night before christmas in washington, d. C. , and not a person was working and especially not me. When all of a sudden there came a loud bing, bing, bong, and i went to go outside to see what was wrong. And there was st. Nicolas who started to say Merry Christmas to all and god bless the United States. [ laughter ]. All right. Merry christmas, trump style. As we know, willie, the commerce Christmas Tree from comcast. Its all very moving. Again, always a tear or two in our eyes. Still its something. Yesterday shockwaves over what happened in alabama with doug jones, people still talking about it and how it may shape the election. Youve still got a tax bill thats up in the air and donald trump, once again, strangely embracing his actually his most reliable political ally, Vladimir Putin. It was a twoway street yesterday. Vladimir putin gave the press conference praising the achievements in the first year of President Trump, President Trump gave Vladimir Putin a call yesterday. Well get into all that and a lot more. Veteran columnist and msnbc contributor Mike Barnicle. Donny deutsch at the table. Senior editor at large for fortune lee gallagher, from the Washington Post David Ignatius and White House Reporter for u. S. A. Today heidi przybilla. Joe, i want to go to newtonian physics will crush the gop. I didnt know you were such a physicist. The laws of physics apparently apply to politics. Newtons third law that every action has an equal an opposite reaction explains much about the Democratic Partys resurgence. Physics professors teaches that force always comes in pairs. The harder trump and his republican allies push in gains made by women and minorities, the harder these same americans push against trump and his republican enablers. The political reaction likely to result from this newtonian cycle is a complete collapse of the grand old party. Joe, the Democratic Party is energized, both by what happened in virginia and now the other day in alabama. You look at everything thats happening right now, and it is a clear reaction to everything that donald trump and his republican enablers have done over the past year or two. Were talking about alabama, talking about virginia. You can talk about the fact that 7 republicans have lost 7 of membership in terms of women, 5 overall from people actually leaving the party. We always talk about state legislative seats lost under barack obama. There have been 14 switches from republican to democratic seats since donald trump was elected. Zero flips on the republican side. I just thought it was fascina fascinati fascinating. The reason i wrote the column is because you look at the story of the virginia gov ernors race which turned out much better for democrats than they expected. Its the women that we always talk about that were standing in long lines. They were going to vote against Donald Trumps endorsed candidate. In alabama you have the same thing happening where black voters who have felt pushed upon pushed back hard. Were finding that, not only is there an equal and opposite reaction, it seems the reaction from democrats, the pushback is Even Stronger than what donald trump has given them because Republican Voters are depressed and appear to be staying home. Donny, if you look at what happened we were in alabama the other day with a group of voters who were Republican Voters. But they ran the stop sign. Those are Republican Voters. Democrats, africanamerican voters in particular and women, africanamerican women, those groups pushed doug jones over the finish line and kept roy moore out of the senate. And the republicans dodged a bullet. Obviously it was a win for the democrats, but it was loselose for republicans. Had he won, two things. Number one, youd be branding the Republican Party as the party of the pedophile. Theyd be lining up to vote for 2018 now. Can you imagine it going the other way . There would be such panic, the energy would even go to another level. As much as it was a win, strangely enough, from the long ball point of view, had moore won, it could have been more devastating for the republicans. Clearly this is an indictment on trump. Lee county, no democrat has taken more than 45 since the civil rights act. It swung 41 points in 13 months. 41 points from a negative 24 to a positive 17 on the democratic side. Thats all you need to know. Thats young voters, joe. Thats auburn university. Thats auburn university. The same thing you can say about the university of alabama, the reverse in Tuscaloosa County was huge. Again, these are not only young voters, these arent your normal college towns. Theyre not liberal leftofcenter college towns. These are very conservative areas. Not only conservative, they were trump counties. Heidi, you look at again virginia, alabama, look at the numbers. You look at the generic ballot tests where republicans are getting destroyed like 51 to 36 , thats one of the biggest gaps when you ask people do you want a democrat or a republican to go in your district to congress, this is the pushback of what donald trump considers the others for hispanics, for blacks, for women, for people that wouldnt have been able to fit into perhaps his fathers 1950s country club or 1950s country clubs across the south and across the country. Thats his view of the world. Its plainly obvious when you look at the people he nominates for judge. Nominates over 90 of the u. S. Attorney attorneys, are men. Boy, women have more of a reason to get out and vote today as do blacks, hispanics and others than ever before. Theyre actually doing it. You have to wonder if the womens march really did precipitate something. Joe, remember at the time so many people mocked that as just a oneday hissy fit. Were seeing this manifest in so many ways, not just women running for congress, but also a flip in party id, potentially new coalition forming. Ive been going through the numbers myself here, not just in alabama but in virginia. What were seeing is that flip in terms of Republican Party id dropping, that is coming from College Educated white women. Some of them who even voted for trump. What were seeing here, for example, in virginia, in the suburbs of richmond, for the First Time Since 1961, that area voting for a democratic governor. My district where republican Barbara Comstock won by 13 points, the democrat ralph northah carrying that area. This is what analysts like charley cook and others say is shaping into a wave. These people are not just crossing over for a onetime vote. Theyre actually starting to be identified. A couple things to sprinkle in. Number one, something weve been saying all week is roy moore is a uniquely terrible candidate. A lot of people came out to vote against him and make sure a credibly accused pedophile didnt make it into the United States senate. The other thing is, if youre betting in three years the seat goes back to a republican p the party nominates the right kind of republican for the state of alabama. Maybe just really a protest against moore who is an outlier in our politics, but i do think when you look at alabama combined with virginia, combined with the polling that were seeing, the reassuring thing is that its telling us that the public facing an insurgent president , an insurgent strategy from steve bannon. A group of people who really want to overturn the system as weve known it, thats beginning to draw public wariness. My dad, who is now 97, likes to make an analogy to a top spinning on a table. You give a top a real whack, but if the top is spinning fast enough, it will wobble a little bit but then come back toward the center. I really hope thats part of what were seeing. Our top got a big knock from donald trump. The question was where is the rest of the country going to be after that disruption . If these results are right, joes point about newtonian pha physics, there is a reaction. It comes back in the other direction. Well get back to alabama in a minute. We want to get back to russia now. President Vladimir Putin praised President Trump yesterday speaking to reporters at his end of the Year Press Conference in moscow. He praised trump for the u. S. Stock market gains and rejected the premise for the Justice Departments probe into russian meddling as, quote, spy hysteria. Hours later putin and trump spoke by phone. Disclosed details of the conversation before the American Public learned about the call. Acute issues of bilateral relations as well as the situation in crisis hot spots worldwide were discussed with an emphasis placed onseting the Korean Peninsula nuclear issue. The white house statement said, quote, President Trump thanked putin for acknowledging americas strong Economic Performance in his annual press conference. The two president s also discussed working together to resolve the very dangerous situation in north korea. Later a story about trump thanking putin. That call came of the heels of yesterdays wide ranging Washington Post report, detailing how the president s refusal to accept the intelligence that russia meddled is interfering with the communication of National Security materials. Quote, current and former officials said that his daily intelligence update known as the president s daily brief or pdb is structured to avoid upsetting him. Russia related intelligence that might draw trumps iers included only in the written assessment and not raised orlando li said a Senior Intelligence official familiar with the matter. A veteran cia analyst adjusts the order of his presentation and text aiming to soften the impact. A second former u. S. Senior intelligence official said, quote, if you talk about russia, meddling, interference, that takes the pdb off the rails. A lot to unpack there. The very mention of russia infuriates President Trump, so they avoid it in the daily brief which is something youd want to be in there. And President Trump speaking yesterday with Vladimir Putin after putin heaped praise upon him at that press conference. Willie, again, the behavior towards russia, weve said it since december of 2015 is so bizarre. Weve said it since he came on our shore in december of 2015 and continued to say that Vladimir Putin was a better leader than barack obama because he was a stronger leader. He basically brushed off the assassination of journalists, the kelg of political rivals, the invasion of countries, the shooting down of jets. Its one apology for russia after another, and it just doesnt make sense. We all see it every day. David ignatius, we saw it, of course, yesterday, Vladimir Putin flattering donald trump. Donald trump calling him up, thanking him for saying nice things about the stock market. Whats so disturbing, i would know it has to be disturbing for the men and women who protect our country, the Intel Community. From the very beginning donald trump has playsed more trust in Vladimir Putin than our intel committee. Now you have lackeys for donald trump running around saying the fbi istu turning echt another k. You have a column about this talking about the russian facts are right there hiding in front of us. I did write the morning, joe, about how you look at the evidence thats emerged, mostly uncontradicted, the tweets, events that are acknowledged. And it does tell you a story from the beginning of this campaign, trump and his aides wanted russia to help and in particular encouraged russia to do what it could to make available emails from a Clinton Company at a time we know the russians were hacking democratic servers, where those emails were kept. So i said, its known in the law, if youve got the facts, argue the facts. If you dont have the facts, pound the table. Were seeing some pounding of the table in this agitation against special Counsel Robert Mueller and other comments from trump. On the trumpputin relationship, it is remarkable now that for two years the one issue on which trump really hasnt changed is his desire to have better relations with putin at a time of great tension between the u. S. And russia, nobody should dismiss the idea of there being more talks. Its just strange, this consistent we sometimes call it a bromance between the two, the idea that putin was crediting donald trump for helping the stock market and trump was thanking him, its a strange feature of our international scene. A final thing, we do need russian help on north korea. I think the fact they talked about that and emphasized that is probably id upped line that fact in yesterdays events. Still ahead on morning joe, the republican tax plan seemed to be going full speed ahead. That is until it hit a few bumps yesterday. Well tell you where things stand right now. This week President Trump became the only twotime winner of politifacts lie of the year, seeing how trumps lies stack up to those of president obama. Bill kaerns has a check on the forecast. Good friday morning. A little surprise on yei 95. Well have an inch of snow on the ground for the evening rush hour could make things dicy. 15 Million People in wenter weather advisories. Again, this is not a big huge beal. You can see how light the snow is here in the white. This is about win bench. It does go all along i 95. Unfortunately, if you heard the tragic news yesterday of the firefighter from san diego that was up there fighting the thomas fire, perished in the blaze yesterday. The first firefighter fatality. That fire flared up overnight. New mandatory evacuations ordered. Still red flag warnings. They cant catch a break. They need rain desperately in california. In some places it hasnt raenin in over 250 days. Red flag conditions continue tod today. Sunday looks to be a dangerous, winds gusting 50 to 70 miles per hour. The weekend forecast, today, light snow and rain in new orleans. Tampa possibly a shower. Seattle, damp weather for you. A little lakeeffect snow on saturday. Well watch this rain storm in texas on saturday, spreading saturday night. By sunday, heavier downpours in new orleans. Raen any, gloomy weather. Were in the 50s and 40s. No ice on the map. Travel or Holiday Shopping plans or Holiday Weekend plans, it will be a little wet. This is the glaring thing on sunday. Watching Southern California in that fire threat. New york city is one of the spots that will see about an inch of snow later today. Doesnt look like it now. Not even a cloud in the sky. Youre watching morning joe. Well be right back. To do whatever it takes, use every possible resource. To fight cancer. And never lose sight of the patients were fighting for. Our Cancer Treatment specialists share the same vision. Experts from all over the world, working closely together to deliver truly personalized cancer care. And these are the specialists were proud to call our own. Expert medicine works here. Learn more at cancercenter. Com Appointments Available now. hard exhalation honey . Can we do this tomorrow . grunts of effort can we do this tomorrow . If you have Heart Failure symptoms, your risk of hospitalization could increase, making tomorrow uncertain. But entresto is a medicine that was proven, in the largest Heart Failure study ever, to help more people stay alive and out of the hospital than a leading Heart Failure medicine. Women who are pregnant must not take entresto. It can cause harm or death to an unborn baby. Dont take entresto with an ace inhibitor or aliskiren. If youve had angioedema while taking an ace or arb medicine, dont take entresto. The most serious side effects are angioedema, low blood pressure, kidney problems, or high potassium in your blood. Tomorrow, tomorrow. When can we do this again, grandpa . Well, how about tomorrow . Ask your doctor about entresto and help make tomorrow possible. The ford yearend sales event is in full swing. you are going to be a big surprise. whining aww, i see a big puppy. I see a biig puuppy. Hey greg thats ford, americas bestselling brand. Now get exclusive holiday offers, with 0 financing for 72 months across a full line up. For a limited time, get an additional 1,000 cash back on top of 0 financing for 72 months. Get these exclusive offers during the ford year end sales event. This morning the republican plan for tax reform is facing new uncertainty. Party leaders are scrambling to lock down enough votes to pass the legislation before christmas, but key senators are withholding their support. Nbcs casey hunt has details. Reporter senator marco rubio now threatening to vote no unless Republican Leaders agree to give American Families a bigger tax credit. Unless they can figure out a way to add to the 1,100 figure i wont support the bill. Because they can only lose two votes, that means republican could be at risk of falling short. The president confident rubio will come around. Hes been a great guy, very supportive, i think senator rubio will be there. Reporter Vice President mike pence who has already had to cast six tiebreaking votes this year. The senate being equally divided, the Vice President votes in the affirmative. Reporter delaying a critical trip to the mieft. Also in concern, 80yearold thad cochran who missed votes for Health Reasons. Senator john mccain fighting brain cancer. Doing just fine. Reporter now hospitalized and absent from the senate. Its all about timing and managing absences in the senate. Reporter with time running out for the president and his party to make good on any Major Campaign promise before the year is out. Heidi, its obviously very tight. Most people consider right now what marco rubio is doing, using leverage which he has the right to do and personally i think he should do it, using the leverage to get what he wants. But corker is still a no. What happens if john mccain cant show up to vote because of his health . Does that derail it . It very well could. Youve got not only john mccain but thad cochran who missed votes this week because of his health. The bottom line is you can only lose two votes. Might have to delay it. A delay, of course, means who comes to the senate . Doug jones. I think whats happening here with rubio is just a manifestation of the fact that so many of these senators, more moderate republican senators who jumped on board with the promise they were given certain promises felt like they got kind of bad deals. Look at susan collins. Now theyre throwing the individual mandate repeal back in there and not necessarily taking care of some of the extra funding that she wanted put back in. I just think rubio is actually making a very savvy political decision here to put himself out there. I do think in the end theyll find some way to cut a deal for him. But the politics of the moment are look at the polling on this bill. It does not have widespread support. As a matter of fact, it has widespread opposition. If you see the way democrats are going to use this going into 2018, its playing into their broad values argument that theyre making, not just about everything that happened in alabama with roy moore, but about the economics of how average families in this country are being affected. If i could just for a moment, joe, this country was founded on a rebellion against monarchy. Whats monarchy . Its inherited wealth. Whats happening with this bill is that its so tilted towards the upper income elements in this society, not just the estate tax repeal. Its the passthroughs, the fact that like marco rubio said, they found extra money to lower the top bracket and theyre throwing 100 of chump change his way on the child tax credit. This is a political moment for him and possibly other republicans to speak out and say, hey, at a time when the top problem in this country is not jobs, its income inequality, how can we not find the extra money here to help working families . And Donny Deutsch, i think thats why if you just look at this from branding, and you have to look at it from branding, because certainly if youre a republican leader who sees how badly things are going for the gop, you have to wonder how do you pass this bill after an attempt to repeal obamacare care thats unpopular across america without getting hammered in the midterms . It will be one more thing thrown on top of the pile. Thats the first thing i want you to talk about. Secondly, though, as a businessman and a entrepreneur, you and your friends and a lot of people that drive the stock market have to just love what they hear on the macro level, that the top rate goes down to 37 and Corporate Taxes go down to 21 . Talk about both of those things. As far as the latter, if youre in a blue state, not even necessarily our fancy wealthy friends, because theyll jump by five or six points. From a macro point of view and to heidis point, yes, this is exacerbating the number one problem in this country which is wealth distribution. Were redistributing it to the rich guys. Its insanity. Also, the bizarre thing is, the one thing thats working right now in this country overall is the economy. A lot of economists are going to say its going to have a negative effect and well walk into inflation. Your first point, joe, as a branding guy, id like to give my number to any democrat running in 18. I could cut 20 commercials today basically saying the republicans have screwed you, the very thing that brought trump into office, the middle class white vote. Guess what . Youre getting screwed on taxes, on health care. Sign me up. Its easy money. Theyre walking echt a buzz saw. Its fundamentally so flawed because of a well their point of view but strategic branding view for the Republican Party, just to get the w, the w will actually be an l. The New York Times has tried the impossible, to count every time President Trump has told a lie. Thats next on morning joe. [ keyboard clacking ] [ click ] [ keyboard clacking ] [ clacking continues ] good questions lead to good answers. Our advisors can help you find both. Talk to one today and see why were bullish on the future. Yours. Talk to one today and see why were bullish on the future. Bps natural gas teams use smart App Technology to share data from any well instantly. So they can analyze trends and stop potential problems in their tracks. Because safety is never being satisfied and always working to be better. I love you, droolius caesar, but sometimes you stink. Febreze car vent clip cleans away odors for up to 30 days. Because the things you love can stink. one is the only number that youll ever need staying ahead isnt about waiting for a chance. Because one is. Its about the one bold choice you make that moves you forward. That you ever need the one and only Cadillac Escalade. Come in for our seasons best offers and drive out with the perfect 2017 Cadillac Escalade for you. Get this low mileage lease from around 899 per month. we are the driven. From around 899 per month. The dedicated. The overachievers. We know our best investment is in ourselves. We dont take no for an answer. We fight for what we want. Even for the things that were once a given. Going to college. Buying a home. And not being in debt for it for the rest of our lives. But were only as strong as our community. Who inspires and pushes us to go further than we could ever go alone. Sofi. Get there sooner. Welcome back to morning joe. Senate republicans set a new record confirming the 12th Circuit Court judge, giving trump the record for the most Circuit Court judges confirmed in a president s first year, outpacing john f. Kennedy and Richard Nixon who previously shared that record. There are still 143 judicial vacancies left to be filled. A no, maam know had trouble answering a series of basic questions. In an exchange with john kennedy it became apparent that matthew s. Peterson nominated for the District Of Columbia doesnt have a lot of the experience typically expected of a federal judge. Have any of you not tried a case to verdict in a courtroom . Have you ever tried a jury trial . I have not. Civil . No. Criminal . No. Bench . No. State or federal court 1234. I have not. Have you ever argued a motion in state court . I have not. Have you argued a motion in federal court . No. Just for the record, do you know what a motion in limine is . I would probably not be able to give you a good definition right here at the table. Do you know what the younger abstention doctrine is . Ive heard of it. But again how about the pullman abstention doctrine . Youll see that a lot in federal court. I think that was unfair. 57 of President Trumps nominees have been reviewed by the american bar association. Four of them deemed not qualified. One of those nominees was confirmed to the eighth circuit earlier this week. Joining us, commentary editor for the Washington Examiner tim carney and opinion ed for. Off the clip we saw of peterson, on the fec, federal election commission, hasnt tried a case. You heard the litany of things he hasnt done. Does that trouble you hearing that exchange . Yeah. I think the drain the swamp mentality has a lot of virtues to it that washington, d. C. Has a lot of bakedin kind of crust where youve got libbyists and lawmakers enter tangled and a bureaucracy that is not responsive. Theres a lot of good things, but it goes too far in the Trump Administration where they take people who dont have qualifications for the relevant job. So i think thats what it is. This distrust of expertise that can come if you take drain the swamp too far. Weve seen in other places, too, look at ben carson at hud or epa or fda, all these people that are not particularly familiar with the areas where they have the most significant and prominent job. I would distinguish from one liberal critique of trump which is that hes nominating people that oppose the purpose of the agency. I actually think we need people like that in the agency, not if theyre going to sabotage it, but to say when i was a lawmaker i didnt think there should be a department of energy. Talking about scott pruitt. The exportimport nominees. Having somebody like that as a kep tick, i think as a conservative thats good. Having somebody that doesnt have the skill set and experience like we sae see in some of these nominations, thats upsetting. Peggy, what do you make watching that exchange . I think senator kennedy is a new person on the national scene, a smart guy. Every time i see him showing up on tv or radio, hes saying something smart. He was the questioner there. I agree with tim, it is good when you have fresh and skeptical eyes come into an agency and say why do we do it this way and find out the answer is not really so good. And better ways of doing things could be dreamed up. Outsiders have their place. David, in watching that clip, its one thing as tim pointed out, not necessarily the unhealthy thing to get people into agencies who are a bit sen cal, perhaps, and take a fresh look at the agency. Yet, its quite another to put Forward Nominees who are like six eggs short of a dozen which often happens. In the case when it does happen, the president , more often than not, has gone on to defend his appointments with a series of well, we have to label it, untruths about their credentials. You have been charged with the incredible task of cataloguing the number of untruths this president has trotted out thus far only in 11 months of his presidency. Hows it going, david . We actually need a whole team of people to do it. Its not just me and it takes a lot of time. As you know, all these Fact Checkers out there and totaled up and said trump has said a thousand untrue things. We said it needs to be demonstrably and blatantly untrue. We didnt count his general story about general pershing or when he gets Commission Statistics off a little bit. Weve counted 103 distinct untruths, falsehoods, lies hes told in his first ten month in office. There are a lot of them. Give us an example of your criteria, your top three that fall into the category pants on fire lie versus all the other subtle untruths or misappropriations of the truth. A lot of these we know. A blatant lie about the inauguration size crowd, the more substantive stuff. The stuff saying we have the highest taxes in the world which we clearly do not. We try to take the most favorable interpretation. We say is there any way we can justify this and say its a matter of political debate. If the answer is no, we count it. What we just did is we compared it at the request of trump supporters, compared it to obamas pace of telling falsehoods. Ted, you sat down and wrote a rebuttal to the New York Times piece. I did. I did not question the premise of the piece. Donald trump is an exceptional, extraordinary liar even among politicians and certainly compared to barack obama, but i dont think its a proper use of Data Journalism to say were going to count up the lies. Why . Because i dont think theyre actually counting the lies. I looked at the New York Times list, the short list of obama lies and searched for my favorite. He said we have excluded lobbyists from policy making jobs which is one of his Campaign Promises. There were 36 including a Goldman Sachs lobbyist as a chief of stof at treasury. That was a lie, a blatant falsehood that didnt make the New York Times list. You look at this, if you like your doctor, you can keep your doctor counted as one lie even though he said it at least 30 times as president. In my rebuttal blog post i found the first three that came to my mind, only one of those, if you like your plan, you can keep it, showed up in those. I think counting lies and charting them and doing this is a silly thing because youre not going to catch it. You did not have the New York Times, david lean hart and your team of journalists didnt go through every statement the president made and you missed a bunch of obamas lies. I agree trump is a much bigger liar, much more falsehoods, accidental and intentional, than obama. But why didnt you have in there, we have excluded lobbyists from policy making jobs. Wasnt that a significantly clearly false statement . You want us to apply a different standard to obama and trump. We applied the same standard. Thats a great example of what we didnt include. We said under the most generous interpretation, we took all those out for trump and said were not going to give obama a different standard than trump. When you do it, you end up seeing obama definitely said untrue things. The fact he said if you like your Health Insurance plan, you can keep it. Thats false. He said falls things about the High School Dropout rate. When you compare the same standards for the two, you end up seeing theyre not close at all. I think you dont have a standard. Trump tells many, many more untruths than obama does. I agree with that, but i dont think you have a standard for obama if when he says we have excluded lobbyists, that counts as true because there were some lobbyists who didnt get hired. Thats the persing that the Obama White House gave me when i asked them about it eight years ago, seven years ago. If you could find ones we excluded from trump that were similar than that or included, i would agree that would be fair. There are dozens of them just like the lobbyist one for trump, the crazy story like general pershing, we didnt include it. We did the same standard for obama and trump. You can see these ten things about trump you should have included and the ten about obama you should have included. But when you do it, you see theres no comparison. Tim, to underline, you can see donald trump examining rates more than president obama. More than any other president ive seen in my life. Off the top of my head, i cant think number of trump lies versus alabama, i bet trump wins. But has strum trump had an impact in terms of policy impact and implications, if you like your doctor, you can keep your doctor. If you like your plan, you can keep your plan. That strikes me as the biggest political lie of the past ten years or so. How about the tax bill. It has president passed yet. Peggy brings up an obvious point. Obviously trump wins the volume battle. If you say lies that cause harm, a major piece of legislation that was his defining piece of legislation was built on she brings up a good point. The central critique, one of the central critiques of romney in the 2012 campaign, remember the motto from the baem campaign, Osama Bin Laden is dead and General Motors is alive. He said in one of the debates i want to get the exact quote to prove it was a lie by any standard, he said obama said the federal government romney said the federal government should provide guarantees for post bankruptcy financing and assure car buyers that their warrantees are not at risk. Obama then said youre very clear you would not provide government assistance to the u. S. Auto Companies Even if they underwent bankruptcy. Put those two statements side by side, its clear romney said we should have government guarantees. Obama said you said there wont be government guarantees. That was at the heart of obamas criticism along with, if you like your plan, you can keep it, was the single biggest defense of the central piece of legislation. I can make the argument that the heart of obamas campaign was built on standard political lies. Trump is still a much bigger lie. We said that. Obama told falsehoods, bush told falsehoods. Trump tells falsehoods about everything. He lies about the crime rate, about immigration, about where barack obama was born, lies about how taxed we are as a nation, lies about what his Health Care Bill would do. I dont think trumps lies are the offthecuff funny stuff. They are very much about policy and central to his strategy. When george w. Bush was made aware of thing he said wasnt true, he stopped saying it. When barack obama was made aware, he stopped saying it. Blatant untruths, they stopped. What trump does, he tries to discredit the people pointing out the falsehoods, whether theyre fbi agents, cia agents, federal judges, scientists, you name it. Thats dangerous to our democratic culture. Undermining the behavior of truth in general. His administration started out with a fight over the crowd size. David lean hart, thank you very much. Tim carney, a good back and forth. You guys should go out to lunch, keep the fight going. President trump was big on symbolism, cutting red tape to represent his administrations slash on regulations. Morning joe is coming right back. Eras. Theyre defined by accomplishments. By victories. By those with the resourcefulness, the ingenuity, and the grit to help ensure the next energy to power our dreams, will be american energy. The fcc voted to roll back Net Neutrality rolls in a Party Line Vote yesterday eliminating regulations that required internet providers to treat all site traffic and speeds equally. We have cnbcs dominic chu with us. Dom, ive read online this means everything from free at last to locusts descending from the heavens and tearing the flesh from our bones. Tell me, is it somewhere in the middle or are we all really doomed . Its probably at least for right now somewhere in the middle. There are other steps that will be taken at some point possibly to talk about what the future of these regulations are. In essence what it means, joe, is companies that provide Broadband Internet service are going to have that ability to control the economics. Thats going to be the big deal here. What they could do is charge more for some companies to use their en from structure like the pipes, the highway that we all use over the internet or maybe control the speeds like you said. The argument for nut neutrality right now is no one person or group or company or otherwise should be denied any kind of equal access to the internet, the most profound commune cases and commerce tool of our modern era. But there are a lot of points on the other side of the debate. One of the key issues right now is how the internet infrastructure in the future is going to be funded and paid for. Broadband Companies Say it takes a lot of money to build, to maintain, to improve Internet Technology and it needs to be looked at from that economic perspective. Thats the reason why its such a big deal right now and the reason why a lot of people are curious about how its going to proceed. We could see a Congressional Review Act coming up. Thats the next step possibly. Thats what the American Civil Liberties union is asking for. Well see how that goes. The other major story here is that mega merger between disney and pretty much buying up all of 21st century fox, 52. 5 billion of disney stock to get everything in that fox empire. The things theyre not going to get are the fox broadcast network, fox news networks, the fox tv stations and the Sports Networks like fox sports 1 and 2. But what disney does get is pretty much everything else, nat geo, the movie studios and everything else. By the way, guys, at the end of this deal, fox shareholders will own about 25 of disney. A big deal in the media space. Back to you. That is a big deal. Cnbcs dominic chu. Thank you very much. Up next, democrat congressman john delaney is making an early push for the 2020 president ial bid. Hes already all in in iowa. Hell be on our political roundtable coming up next on morning joe. We come into this world needing others. Then we are told its braver to go it alone. That independence is the way to accomplish. But there is another way to live. A way that sees the only path to fulfillment is through others. That our time here can be deep beyond measure. No one who chose interdependence ever found despair. Because what the world taught as weakness, is in fact our greatest virtue. With us now, weve got a member of the House Committee on financial services, democratic congressman from maryland, and the first person to declare their candidacy for the 2020 president ial election john delaney. Congressman, thank you so much for being with us. First question, your take on what happened this past week in alabama . Well, you know, obviously it was a big victory for the citizens of alabama and in many ways for the citizens of the country. And, you know, to me it wasnt expected. I thought they would come up with these results. But listen, people clearly came up, spoke in alabama. Roy moore is one of the worst candidates in modern political history. Really a big win for the state of alabama. Whats the democratic message for america, not for the coasts the democrats dominate but for middle america, for places like alabama, oklahoma, nebraska . Whats that message . So i think the message should be jobs, pay and opportunity for their kids. I also think what the Democratic Party should stand for is civility, confidence and restoring respect for the profession of public service. I think thats what the American People are desperately looking for. Right. They want the fighting to end. They want us to move into some kind of a post hyper partisanship world. Were always going to be a partisan country. That kind of partisan debate is ultimately healthy. But theyd like us to move to a world where we can actually start getting things done. The way you do that, is you have to have some measure of civility. And i think, you know, the American People want to see their faith that theyve always had in their government restored to some level. We have an unusual connection with our government here. When its failing, were kind of failing. I think theyd like to see some restoration of the faith and the pride they used to have in their government. And thats what the democrat let me get your yeah, let me get your take on the debate thats been roiling since the 2016 election and red state america, is there a place for congressional candidates who, lets say, are pro Second Amendment and also support, like, for instance, a ban on abortion after 20 weeks . Prolife candidates that want some limits to abortion . So look, i think the Second Amendment we question i think is easy. Most democrats including myself believe in the Second Amendment and support the Second Amendment. We dont ness say lir interpret that to mean there cant be some commonsense limitations. But as relates to the womens reproductive freedom, i think clearly the Democratic Party platform should embrace and support womens reproductive freedom. I also think we need to be a bigtime party. If theres candidates that overwhelmingly align with our values on some big economic issues, some of the kind of priorities were debating in the tax bill, if they align with our value and fundamentally look at this issue differently, probably from their own religious perspective, i think we should be embracing of those candidates. So following up on what joe was just getting to and what you were getting to in your answer i think, i think youd have to admit that the two leading candidates right now potentially for democrat candidate for president would be Elizabeth Warren and bernie sanders. Their view of American Life is to pull the democratic priority more to the left. Youve been out there. Youve been in iowa and new hampshire. What sort of sense do you have of the electorate out there . They want to go left . Where are they according to your eyes . I think they want us to get something done. To understand that the cost of doing nothing is not nothing. And for decades hyper partisan politics has prevented us from getting some of the basic things we needed to do in this country to both prepare our country for the changes of the last several decades based on globalization and then importantly to prepare ourselves for the future which is going to change as profoundly for different reasons. Technology, innovation, automation. I think what the American People understand deeply is their government has failed them. It stopped doing things. And that theyre paying the price. Right . So i think thats actually what they care about more than some of these kind of rallying party battle cries if you will. So do you think of yourself as a political figure, as someone more comfortable on the left than say on the middle and how do you feel personally . I know you want a big tent, lots of different opinions on some very difficult issues but where are you on late term abortion . Personally, my wife and i would follow the teachings of our church. Were active catholics. The decision i make personally is different than the decision i should be implying for citizens of this country, so thats kind of how i think about that issue. So you would not be for a ban against late term . It all depends how you define it, right, the science is moving. As relates to your first question, i do think of myself as a different kind of democrat, right, i think my policies, which ive laid out a broad policy agenda at this point, seek to accomplish goals the Progressive Movement has been fighting for for a long time. I do think Market Forces really work. I do think the private economy of the United States is an amazing innovation machine. What we should be doing is trying to find ways where the government and the private sector Work Together to achieve the goals that are really important for all americans. So that sounds a little like centrist and i want to return to your sure. Because im a maryland catholic like yourself. Yeah. But i think your answer of implies falsely that the Catholic Church just prescribes how you ought to behave on abortion. The Catholic Church and the catechism and papal documents says clearly that abortion should be illegal and that this is a clear teaching of the Catholic Church. Do you agree with that . How do you square the fact that youre saying abortion ought to be legal with the fact that the church says abortion is always an evil and that politicians may not allow it to be legal . So listen, you know, i love my church and i support my church which doesnt mean i agree with every specific doctrine of my church. My church has evolved across time just as all religions have. And, you know, i think i line up largely you rejecting the Catholic Churchs teaching on the legality of abortion . I dont think listen, i respect the law of the land of the United States of america and support womens reproductive freedoms so that does conflict with some of the things my church advocates for as relates to the law of the land so yeah, i have a conflict with them on that. So congressman delaney, were out of time unfortunately. We always make sure we ask the existential questions with 15 seconds left. I also notice here as the only baptist on the panel that ive unwittingly surrounded you by three catholics and then Donny Deutsch who makes up his own faith i didnt think i was walking into vatican 3 here my lawyers a jew. Listen, were going to invite you back and ask you questions that do not pertain to abortion. Its a big, big world out there. We thank you so much for being with us. All right. Lets go now to Stephanie Ruhle. She picks up coverage right now. Have a great weekend. Thanks much, joe. Good morning. Im Stephanie Ruhle with a lot to cover today, starting with filing for an extension. The fate of the gop tax bill is uncertain. As a not so little republican says hes a no. Unless they can figure out a way to add to the
comparemela.com © 2020. All Rights Reserved.