Of red tape and corruption for instance. For others. And it is perhaps going too fast especially when they point to be a widening gap between the haves and have nots. But the nations identity how its doing doesnt just boil down to how much you earn today in the fall spring kit so they wouldnt be looking at to identity identity playing a big role in politics these days and you cant help notice when you land here in delhi as well as an Election Campaign going on would it be going today in the false and get to the inside of the next superpower and set were doing it with them and you might remember as former number two to a coffee on a United Nations today. He is a state minister or member of palm and shush ito also of the writer of several books including humans act syndicate. Welcome to the shelf. Thank you to be with you. Do you just just to give our viewers a sense he spent a lot of years the United Nations twenty nine of the american nations and live and in politics and when you come when you come back to india after twenty nine years. I miss you go back and forth but is the same place. To which amanda from police on the new nine left in the same time of no fault of india was this time the sun can be on teaching them the cliche have always considered that cheney was bbling always enough system. Social change economic change political change. Because all is an odds and capricious democracy lot of these changes tend to be absorbed. Im changes which in other societies much and american revolutions become an oz as part of the ongoing evolution that people take in stride. Satan is quite interesting to see how much industry and said really. The fundamental respects a visibly of the appearances of the places the presence now foreign goods and foreign brands which were not bad and the protected economy of my dad growing up in india. Of the number of opportunities available to young people as they leave their schools and colleges. Other professions available that didnt exist alongside this the business change of his big change every minute of the trip to tuscany mean about it being a capricious to mock job faster its about a second bridge is capricious. With this as well. We welcome the new muscle to tom who also spent some time abroad you were a businesswoman a journalist and said you come back to india and youre a spokesperson for the Main Opposition Party the bjp. I guess. The question everyone must ask you this euro tumbled. What are you doing in a hindu nationalists. Im not trying. They agree with that and if a description of my puppy. It is open enough to spot the bcp. And oh yes i was so caught up in the distant window for assignments. But i was happy to come back. Im happy to get into politics the kind of poppy has given me a quarter of its recognition and space and today as ludicrous unthinkable for pompey have got to be read with your title glad to have the required as well. To welcome were busted and talia whose bestselling study of the impact of partition between india and pakistan to love upon the person experience of your family of the book is called the other side of silence. Well welcome to the show and of course you have left indeed youve stayed all along. Um that you think that there is this evolution not to. I just described the charge sheet or horror or do you think the scene disruptions and. I think of it and bolts leadership can i at the same candidate and i think it might be younger than me and its a bit but i also remember that what i do the best antidote to the zoo i also remember that dying when we were going up winning it was a bit different its not where you know there was this insult right in the pot of said reliance that he had chosen to follow. And if you visit a b any other post million followers to use all the difference with india a utility that the sudden notion of independence that india was trying to strike a pose subsequently so much has changed them. Im even though i have lived in indy on my tag buying a smaller two relating to the outside. I have seen the teaching them much more so that gradually we are happening. And i think one off b m areas in which the team has been a mom is in the position of women with it as being bored and had a kidney that cool. And radical that i will get back to appoint someone ask about that. Come one man whos not of the same generation of the rest of the paddle is russell guard reconsider thirty six years old the venue of the new venue you are straight out of school. You start. Itt start a new start another company than a third. And to you today. Have your own Business School and online Business School some stone and seven yuan. People offered you the chance to go work abroad that you decided to stay put yesterday that the oven i graduated top fifteen years back i thought. It is for the fall students that i am glad to see the events wouldnt do for me. I think come. It seems that ive seen is more to the eyes of young graduates. Tidy up high and be developed and graduates of my tops fifteen years. I keep going back to my school. At the guide to see a different guide read and even denied that delivers doctrine on practical fifteen years. And i think it excites me and it certainly seems lifeless starts his generation gap with the bidding for twenty oh one as a generation gap but the one after epiphany fits. So weve been asking people and that we went to the market yesterday here in delhi and nice we asked was that what you think is change happening too fast or too slow. It states of tuning of the late b its not too fussed when the other cool thing i didnt get beat up losing touch with adults. Off yet to be fast enough to keep in pace with what the midst of the ward is doing good to go to the back of the eighty s to hire them that of the teat the standard of living the facilities zealand amid the economic necessity. Now i feel more like an economic disconnect. Actually that respect its not going. If you have a stall due to civil code pink beaches in many trusts are definitely make an unbeaten as good as any other can go. Time stood still the woman was saying and in that report in her letters mom and todd and two more parts of india that has been significant progress in changing room and get to disrupt travel that status above are the same time of being simply havent conquered or the problems of that of many parts of the window where religious system of electrified with the roads us the most decent condition. Whered up opportunities for jobs and decent work on mon to the daily available and those or tell them to a book of the biggest and most visible change the ending is in the city thats where cade has been dramatic an entire new citizens from the book values to be a sleepy town too but i was at university here and in the oven no one would think up of looking into the living dead or living in beta but that w its become almost an extended some of this. Its become a gaming spanking for the first of three said they would show up. Which no one wouldve imagined with god so youve seen changes like that in the villages of disappeared by becoming part of obamas pro. So that has changed but yes we still have Serious Problems we need to overcome. Pop over to the bond of development. But progress has been made of that theres no doubt is the change to slow or too fat and in some sectors the status of costco cost now and some of those the us had me he is not given much of that scene. I would hope honestly think weve lost book fifteen year scene comes to picking bill. If you want to get the stupid can get tickets to one goal. But the footage of the rest of the us of india. Life in charting said sufficiency in some balance to strike put into practice. Im as it ascends to the you find that the coupons up to ninety one im not anti the support of all everything that comes in the name of who built this nation but still after that this accounts for baking didnt want to know to do this alone the item will stick this baby of being given back to the spinster well. You see progress. But governance and governments to make it. Given the lessons and all the excess insufficient and that the cities and White Asbestos riddled since you have an altar piece with which people talk and effectively as yet and that this could be because of administration and covenants. Still not catching up with the times. Over estimates are that he thinking beings. Recognize themselves in all this change i think yes. The giant but i think they both told me i roasted a confused about who the eye. In the midst of all of this change because that means some reason that the dt with which the changes happening and the leaves and reached the outside word has opened up to india in the night just as them religions are getting swallowed up in the sixties so the source of the cd is seeping into the bin in sch and theres a lot of in migration into cds from the biggest of those toy and boundaries between the belief in the cpi. These are living in some ways of getting meninga solo so india and its International Connections im making for another team so i think weak and in many ways need to recognize us and to the menu is known to be confused of what will be on and with the updates a case of confused as of nursing at the top there is an Election Campaign going on i noticed the time. How do you identify politically than as a result of a foetus is or is it is the conversation about this issue worse than conversation about Something Else for now the Eviction Campaign sent me from the point of real people earn very often be identified in terms of identity is as a particular costa group as a particular the eye. Localized rule or even as a group of women. Im the open court on that basis and the election meeting is also often on that basis what say in the place like danny now but its awfully late the election is imminent. You do have all the parties addressing people as citizens of haiti. Its not so much divided up on those questions of identity as it is on the show citizenship which is a much broader issue than the specific plot get that specific identity. Your greenhouse to tom that identity is perhaps less of an issue in the city more so in rural areas. I think identities in a shul. Up to an extent in one part these are all pretence of a mentor it would definitely have an impact on the wii that we could to keep up his tools the candidates chose to have it the pacific. In the distance and communities and pretence. But after that it shows up quite good not to. And like me wanted to switch back and give it the day. So to an extent i can pee pee is critical because you need to pursue it but dr that it is a question of what to do the best jacinto your thoughts on the rare pleasure to be with him but i guess the thing that has been abuzz rights one thing that i do see the liver is that it was a politics of color and simple identity where appeals were made to boltons only on the basis of identity of god is giving we as in the last twenty years or so. Rivers in the given lead to a politics of hope for us. That is where people are normal and its no dumb enough to sit with me because they are the same cost or isnt it time that People Like Us one of the kind of appeal was recently made to ma for the long ago. The people have to say we give you roads are given at the cd will give you what to what we have given you these things will the government has failed to give you these things. Choose a performance on the much much more sympathy the middle of a steel cement when she spoke about citizenship. When we took him up and addiction in a statement daily because of a woman in the oven the issues of governance of the fall months off all from the kinds of things that citizens are concerned about irrespective of cost identity become far more important. In another state to state that it is good but not with is also an election that already the first balloting is already taken place. You do find other aspects coming and perhaps more fundamental issue the development of both left wing violence off up the rights of the tribal people of health cost issues and salt in a bigger scale than youve seen in the baby and a stint as a new boss country. Very difficult to generalize across the board and cracked a bit feisty its going to the pores in each of them is a different political reality. But with one thing in common than four of them the bjp and the congress of the principal rivals and thats whats perhaps given that the trappings of some of the kind of Media Attention that you will be talking about. Russell guards your father was not an entrepreneur he was a Civil Servant is a retelling of labor inspector for. With the factories. The dome against the people of his generation. The thing to define way when they go to the polls from the people of your generation. To think very differently. The Great Depression so i think of the citys that seems is to fox and acting in the tier two cities the changes to spill it goes i think kelvin and appeared in the amended to my friends and people its very hard to relate to one periods the end of the from freezing temps of sensible that the contents of gods arrogance of aspirations is a fiction sometimes i think that the median family system is due to his neck and hands i think that is the fiction even for standard doesnt suffer some notes of people dont have the job for sure you deliver that you know of but the button so the dumb self ideal disease deaths of principles arent the complex a sentiment i command you know the face of this people want peace more. It is a bit different something in them so from then on my fathers generation. And and my privates am at seaman mine and you know fifteen years as people got to be difficult so i think james is very rapid. Let the guy go back to get us off of the city tonight to abandon qb. You know they use to be the number of cholera toxin is going up now its been hours since the kids a sense from this but its not still eight hours to stay balanced and i wouldve predicted fifteen years back that wouldve been fixed and fifteen is a case in identity politics in the tub and india by the way its up its religion its ethnic its cap. Its a lot of things and hes saying that it is another aspect to it and you mentioned at the outset which is gender in the whole world watch this horrible case of this the twenty year old student from delhi was raped and gang raped and murdered a turning point that incident. Back to the incident. This tool is that yes it was a turning point are a variety of reasons. In the sense that one made to allow a few which protests on the issue of gender and protests in which they were not only women because as you know india is no stranger to protest and the Womens Movement has been protesting. When does human making different to moms of the state and expressing their anger over certain things but this particular protest because i did it to be raising a young just as the urban elites. This incident isnt it beyond just the opening heat that possibility day he was in many other places. And poppy that also has to do with the media and between that immediately to sound. And i think the other interesting thing about this was the international station did go to india. We chose and bought some ways but in some ways back but its oh so instead of calling the bluff off the indian shining in history because how can you have a shining india stony a copy of occupation is subjected to the was kind of islands and therefore need for scott government into action in some ways much more rapidly than they would have done this. I made opened up the show which has not yet disappeared off the agenda soaking in all of those since as i think it was a significant moment in the history of the struggle for womens rights in this country which is still an incomplete history. And which has some very fantastic stories attached it with them they need everyone to swim all right were going to pick up on that one becomes back. Stay with us much more to come where incidentally this is a special edition of the falls and gets great. I want to let got of course when you dont. Twenty four seven one of the on going to offer you the gift of insight the national bank. Dont i sea. I can use in time for a quick play at our top stories im very complex and increasingly angry six days out that ive been high and hit the philippines many of the expected still havent received any case having the operation is against the new ramos shes now in the sun which was taken at the head. Getting reports of gunshots that this is residents complained about security of. Inner peace negotiators resigned this in protest at its grey plastic filled moments that you are such that in the West Bank Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas says that on a sticky beak and then the negotiations to come back for form and the dedication labels a path to take legal action if it is ousted by the attention on the gospel his spokesman announced that yet. And youve read the messages has been at the disgraced president is on Crop Production is like in the killing of testers lost it he said domenici kidnapping him one day before they announce this stuff politicians from all sides contend that week they briscoe has just this mistake this tend to be brought to a monkey that has prosecuted as i didnt take any inquiry into the offending had dined at the request of the french Prime Minister. The three people charged in the two thousand and two sinking of the prestige. Well time to be in it quits it as disappointing say in crime and tests. It was strange was that the environmental consultant thousands of miles of coastline was a bit second up from the instrument and its actually a false lead to capture the special cafe in the welcome back. This is a special edition of the false been kept in states where in india where the kids enforcement that has Just Launched in the new delhi area in english and were presented to have with us hes that the minister for Human Development and member of parliament should she tell more of the Congress Party also with its near bala center it on spokesperson for the opposition to the party shes the author of the other side of some stills from partition were bought for much of the telly a welcome back and welcome back as well to brush tool guard entrepreneur. Young guide to suspend beginning of our discussion of the church it or mention as an example from the city of gold doll. Which is this sort of sprung up out of nowhere. He ca