What they think is right. Norways government has approved a controversial plan for a mine that environmentalists warn may damage the fjords fish stocks. Fishermen, like elliv erdal, rely on the regions fish for their livelihoods, but all of that may soon change. Eiliv fears the plans wont just kill the fish but end his way of life. Todays catch is pretty good. Plenty of monkfish, cod, and tusk. Eiliv erdal has been fishing the waters of the forde fjord for many years. After a short career in the military, he decided hed rather work and live surrounded by the great outdoors. On a Beautiful Day like this, it is quite impossible to understand that somebody thinks it is a good idea to destroy this beautiful scenery. I think the only natural thing to do is to live here and enjoy the nature as the people here do or is that tourists. The fishermen here are under pressure from a Mining Company that wants to begin extracting a rare mineral found in the cliffs of the fjord. Erdal fears that if the miners are allowed to get to work, the days of plenty here in the fjord are numbered. By the time the operations are in full swing, he says, hell probably be out of a job. Theyre going to take the top off the mountain, and then theyre going to quarr it out. Then they start tunnelling in. The worst part is that the waste from the production will go into the fjord, and they will fill it up 150 metres to 200 metres and destroy the local life in the fjord. Nordic mining is after the mineral rutile. Its used as a pigment for example to make the brilliant white in toothpaste. The Company Wants to extract it for the next 40 years, which would create 250 million tons of slurry. So the whole area around us here is going to end up a waste ground. Erdal is also worried that toxic sludge could be carried out into the open waters of the north atlantic. Many people here rely on the fjord for their subsistence. Around half of erdals income comes from either tourism or fishing. It means a lot to me. I grew up locally. I caught my first salmon when i was four. Now im 47, and im also really looking forward to catching salmon this year. The family also runs a cafe right on the water of the fjord. Guests come here to enjoy the breathtaking nature and homestyle norwegian food traditional baked goods and, of course, lots of fish. The Mining Company claims that fishing is little more than a hobby for the people here. That accusation makes the fishermen angry. Its a selling point that its a clean fish. So to say it is a hobby is quite interesting. It is more people working in jobs regarding nature in this area here than nordic mining s providing. Many of the families in the area that will be impacted most by the mine are refusing to accept the governments decision. Hundreds of demonstrators have blocked streets leading to the site. Some have been hit with stiff fines. Erdal is happy that his problem is now a topic all over norway. Despite the opposition, nordic mining has been pushing ahead. Tracks like these left by digging equipment are fresh. The boreholes help illustrate exactly how deep the Company Plans to go. Its a long way to the bottom. Its quite deep, i guess. I hope this is the biggest hole theyre going to make. Eiliv erdal hopes that the high cost of the project will lead to it being abandoned. He dreams one day of opening a hotel overlooking the forde fjord one with a restaurant that would, of course, serve fish. Michelle while over the year we have covered conflicts throughout europe as well as the impact wars in other parts of the world have had on the continent a story we did in ukraine reminds us how experiencing such traumas can effect someone throughout their entire life. Raisa maistrenko survived babin yar, one of world war iis most notorious massacres, when over 30,000 jews were murdered on the outskirts of kiev. Although she was just three years old when she first witnessed the misery of war, she remembers. Raisa maistrenko did not walk this road to babi yar for many decades, but after the monument for the murdered children was erected, the dance instructor has come here repeatedly with her pupils. My words are always, this monument could have been for me, but i survived. In the early autumn of 1941, nazi germanys army, the wehrmacht, captured kiev. Soon after, some bombs exploded in the center of the city, killing german soldiers. Special units have been ordered to fight the fires and secure the strategic roads. The ss and german and Ukrainian Police ordered all the citys jews to assemble on september 29th and to bring only essential belongings. A kilometerlong line of people was marched off, including the threeyearold raisa and her family. Raisa i saw the grownups legs. I called them white grandpas. They only had underwear on, longjohns and undershirts stained with blood. All around were the germans and their local helpers. The people on the sidelines were screaming, theyre taking these people to be shot. Dont protest, or theyll shoot us, too. There is no film documentation of the mass executions, but a german soldier took a few photos that show the waiting jews and the clothing of the victims. More than three decades after the atrocity, the soviet union finally erected a monument to the victims in babi yar. And it was a long time before raisa was able to face her past. Raisa my grandmother never talked about it. She was silent for fear of traumatizing me. She didnt say what happened here, and thats why i didnt start dealing with it until 50 years later. She started thinking about the massacre long after she had a family and headed a dance school. And she visited the memorial site. Then raisa wrote the choreography for babi yar. It helped her overcome her trauma, but each performance is still a tightrope walk. Raisa its an ambivalent feeling. On the one hand, as a professional, i make sure my pupils do everything right. But if they do everything right, then im overcome with emotion. Today the babi yar ravine is overgrown with vegetation. The place where almost 34,000 people were shot dead in just two days is hardly recognizable. Raisa escaped the murders because her ukrainian grandmother pulled her out of the line of the doomed. Raisa we just ran away, to the cemetery over there. My grandma ran until she couldnt run any more. Then she fell to the ground. We huddled between the gravestones all night. Raisa survived hiding in cellars until the nazis were defeated. Many years ago, she encountered a german tour guide at another memorial site in poland. Raisa i looked at him and i could see he had taken the whole burden of the german nations guilt upon himself. You understand . And thats when i reconciled with germany. Before that, of course, i was embittered. Today, raisas husband is buried in the cemetery where she escaped the murderers. And one day, the place where she was rescued will be her final resting place. Michelle raisa somehow found a way to come to terms with her past and forgive those who murdered her family. Our reporter, gunnar koehne, has lived and worked in turkey for over 20 years. In the last few years, he has witnessed first hand how the climate for those who are critical of the government from academics to journalists has deteriorated. And after the coup, things only got worse. Many newspapers, magazines, and tv stations were closed. Several journalists were taken into custody, including one of gunnars friends. We follow gunnar as he tries to find out what happened to him. Gunnar they came for him in the early hours of the morning. Aydin engin was led from his home by the police. Hes not the first turkish journalist to be arrested in this way. Aydin abi, as the 75yearold newspaperman is respectfully called, is a good friend and conversation partner for us german journalists in istanbul. Im very worried about him. He has never tired of explaining and commenting on turkish politics for us, like he did this july after the failed coup. And always with a touch of humor. Aydin this is the first coup that hasnt landed me in jail. Gunnar on november 1st aydin engins column in the turkish daily newspaper cumhuriyet was blank. The Public Prosecutor claims that engins writings support terrorism. Weve only ever heard him call for peace and reconciliation in turkey. [chanting] gunnar i encounter an angry crowd in front of cumhuriyets building. Engin was one of 13 leading journalists for the paper who were arrested. Every day, innocent people are thrown in jail. Enough is enough gunnar cumhuriyet is one of the last turkish newspapers that criticizes erdogans government. Supporters guard the entrance, day and night, to discourage the police from arresting even more of the staff. This is the office where engin writes his columns. He has been writing for cumhuriyet for 25 years though there have been some interruptions. The remaining Editorial Staff is working on a new edition in the next room. The mood is glum, and the police are waiting outside. Not far away, i meet up with engins wife, oya baydar, and we wonder what we can do for him. She is known beyond turkeys boundaries as an author. Her novels have been translated into german and english. We browse through the bookshelves. Oya im currently working on a novel but im so preoccupied , with worry that i cant write a single line. Gunnar the couple has braved hard times together. After the military coup of 1980, baydar and engin had to flee turkey. They lived in exile in germany for 12 years. Engin drove a taxi to support the family. She says the political situation in turkey is similar to the way in it was back then. Oya i have german as well as turkish citizenship. But go into exile again . At our age, wed rather go to prison. Gunnar life on the streets of istanbul goes on as usual. But the country is being put to the test. Engin has repeatedly warned about the danger of civil war. That angered the erdogan government. Even after three days, none of us is permitted to speak to him. This is the Notorious Police headquarters of istanbul. Engin and his colleagues are being held here in the antiterrorism section. Finally, after five days, we get good news. Engin is being released under restrictions due to his age and the state of his health. Aydin i was treated decently, but ive never seen such a trumped up indictment. We will not bow to this pressure. [applause] gunnar i meet with engin at cumhuriyets office the next morning. He has to stand in for editorinchief murat sabuncu, who still in jail. Aydin im doing okay, but my heart is with my colleagues who are still in prison. We dont know whether cumhuriyet will survive. But i told my young colleagues, dont ask what tomorrow brings produce a good paper today. Its our newspaper. Gunnar thats all the time he has for me. Tomorrows edition has to be planned. Even if it should turn out to be the last issue of cumhuriyet. Since our brother aydin has returned, we feel stronger again. Were happy. Now well produce a good newspaper. Gunnar aydin engin once said that in 50 years, he has survived three coups and three prison stays. One thing is clear, he has no intention of giving up. Michelle gunnar told us that despite about a dozen employees at the paper being arrested, it defiantly published the headline, we do not give up. Another group of people who refused to give up are fishermen in britain. When the British Government held a referendum in june, asking the public to decide whether to leave or remain in the european union, the countrys fishermen voted overwhelmingly to leave. They feel that they have suffered the most from eu policies namely one that limited their access to their own waters. Our reporter went to a small town in cornwall, on englands southwest coast, to ask if they had any regrets. Cornwall isnt far from europe, but most of the people here dont want to have anything to with the european union. Nearly 60 of cornwall residents voted to leave the eu. In the harbor town of newlyn, the fishermen in particular resent brussels. They regard the eu fishing quotas as pure harassment. They say the french steal their fish, and now they finally have their sea back. Bye, bye, brussels. Now well be able to spend our own money on what we want to. And well stop giving money to waste on all the things brussels wastes their money on, the french farming industry. And we havent seen anything out of it. No benefit. Im surprised at how many did vote for it. And it worked. What happens from now on, nobody knows it. Its early days. Well see how it goes. It cant be any worse. Turbot, mackerel, and cod. In newlyn, everything revolves around fishing, as if there were no other issues in europe. Even though the new iceflaking machine was paid for with eu subsidies, the workers here are relieved at the result of the referendum. They think the only ones who will be hurt are the bankers and bosses in london. Ryan a lot of londoners and major cities want to stay in europe, but its obviously the fringe counties away from the major cities that want out. Were the ones that are struggling worse and they seem , to be getting everything, you know . It should be a lot better for cornwall, for definite, and especially for newlyn. Others are less optimistic. Alex lake is bewildered. For more than 15 years, she has supervised eu projects in cornwall. In that time, the eu has poured about a billion euros in subsidies into the region to fuel new economic fields like handicrafts, media, and the digital industry. Now alex is worried about more than her own job. She sees the Rural Regions whole structural transformation endangered. Alex if the u. K. Is out of europe, remote regions like this will remain insignificant. There are bigger priorities to our u. K. Government and the politicians in our u. K. Government than a small region with a small population at the end of the country. Most people in newlyn dont see this danger. They are deeply embedded in their traditional way of life. Jamie maclean is a cook in his own restaurant. He voted for the brexit because he expected that, without eu fishing quotas and regulations, fish would become cheaper. But now hes not so certain. Jamie to be honest, it came as a shock. I mean, i voted out, but i thought id be in a minority. So for me personally, you know, i was actually quite shocked by the out vote. I didnt think it would happen. I wouldnt describe myself as particularly happy about it. Theres a lot of uncertainty. So now the hard work really begins, you know. I dont think its something to celebrate. Its something to think about and to start working towards the future. Its clear what cornwalls fishermen plan to do work harder, so they can export more fish to france and spain, without interference from brussels. Bill well, just hopefully everythings looked at a little bit clearer and a bit more fairly. Its actually somebody in our country making the rules instead of somebody in another country, you know . Somebody making the rules about the waters they know nothing about. See what happens from here. But the brexit already has a down side for the fishermen. Newlyns harbor was going to be modernized with eu funding. That wont be happening now. Michelle the swiss government has built what is considered the worlds longest and deepest railway tunnel through the alps. It is a technological feat that allows the transport of more freight faster. But as with so many of the conveniences of modern life, the tunnel came at a cost. Six workers died, and several houses had to be demolished. While most residents were resettled, one chose to be left behind. Vairner vullker refused to embrace the rapid pace of change around him and stayed in his lifelong home. That is, until he caught site of the bulldozers approaching. The new Gotthard Tunnel has changed Werner Walkers life. Ten years ago he still worked as a hill farmer. Now he spends most of his time sitting on a plastic chair with a cigarillo, watching the traffic go by. The 84yearold has come to terms with his lot. In any case, he says grumbling is not his thing. Werner there are lots of trucks that honk and wave. Does he wave back . Werner oh, yeah. Hes a man of few words. He lives alone in his caravan, surviving on canned vegetables, lemonade, and tea. Theres no television, no internet, or telephone. The folk music on the radio is quite sufficient he says. He doesnt feel lonely, but he is having difficulty walking now. Werner good health is what counts. I dont need anything else. Nothing else matters. Will put his money if you are sick what the is money if you are sick . Possessions mean nothing to him. Perhaps thats how he was able to bear losing everything he held dear for the first 75 years of his life. His house in rynacht was bulldozed to make way for the tunnel. It was where he grew up and worked as a farmer. He had eight cows and worked hard to eke out a living. But he was happy. It was only when the diggers moved in that he finally left his home and bought the caravan. Now ten years after his house was torn down, hes come back for the first time to see his former property. Theres an Information Center there, a soulless building from the alptransit company that built the tunnel. Its clearly not easy for Werner Walker. There are so many memories attached to this place, but he wont say anything negative about the tunnel. Complaining is pointless, he says, you cant turn the clock back. Did he know this was here . Werner yes. What does he think . Werner its ok. Doesnt it make him emotional to be back here . Its forgotten. Pushed away . Yeah. Less than 100 meters away, trains will be thundering at record speeds. The journey from zurich to lugano will take two hours thats a reduction of 45 minutes. Up to 65 passenger trains and 260 freight trains will pass through here daily. Twenty minutes later, the passengers then emerge in the south. Its a new railway age thats quite foreign to Werner Walker. All his life hes never left the canton of uri. He doesnt feel like celebrating, even though the eyes of the world were on the local town of erstfeld because of the tunnel. All he wants is to get back to his caravan. Werner i cant live in a village full of people. I need to be out in nature. Even if that nature is sliced through by a busy highway. Still, walker has got quite used to it all, and despite everything, perhaps he is indeed happy with his lot in his old age. Michelle Werner Walker was able to make peace with his situation, but for many others 2016 has been a year of division and polarisation. So, wed like to toast to the new year and to a greater understanding of each other. Thank you for watching. Happy 2017. [captioning performed by the national captioning institute, which is responsible for its caption content and accuracy. Visit ncicap. Org]
comparemela.com © 2020. All Rights Reserved.