Have doubt about his emotions, his feelings, his attitudes and the way in which he developed. Agree or disagree with the mayor . There is no doubt the president has been publically critical of america to the rest of the world. There have been times where america has shown arrogance and been dismissive. Americans are not your enemy. We sometimes make mistakes. We have not been perfect. I realize that americas critics will be quick to point out that at times we have failed to live up to our ideals, that america has plenty of problems within its own borders. This is true. Just before he took office then senator obama said this we are five days away from fundamentally transforming the United States of america. So is it fair to question why he would want to transform a country that he himself has said he loved . To quote reverend wright the chickens have come home to roost. I disagree with rudy in the sense that i do believe the president loves his country but he loves it in a different way. When we see america we see the best thing in the world. When he sees america he sees the worlds angry aunt with a shotgun. Part of the family but always causing problems. It is not dislike but patronizing superiority. He is saying we can do better he is saying be like me. Be like me because i am better. He always wishes that america would reflect his progressive ideology and be more like belgium or something more manageable and less aggressive and less arrogant than that angry aunt with the shot gun who is always showing up shooting at kids. He wants us to be likable and nice. That is why he brought up open change. You cant blame giuliani for having suspicion that perhaps he doesnt like us as much as previous president s. I would stop there. Lets continue. I think it is a good ending. Giuliani brought up the company that the president has kept. You get a sense in the measure of a person by the people they surround themselves with. The people we grow up with whether professionally or academically can help shape us. I think that is what people are responding to saying the president perhaps has a different view point. He doesnt seem to want to favor american exceptionalism. When you see the people he has been in company with like reverend wright. It does give you pause. Perhaps obama loves america and has a funny way of showing it. If you look at the words he said and the deeds he has taken he said it is not an exceptional nation. After americans were killed he went golfing and to fund raisers. He called half of the country bitter clingers. He didnt like the way the flags were after 9 11. A lot of the people that think the president doesnt like america there is a reason for that and gives ammunition to people. You look at these when you brought up reverend wright president obama sat in the front row when this man is preaching saying things like not God Bless America but god blank america. Take a look at him there. That is why people are upset. You say what are you even condoning and hanging out with someone like this if you love america. If america were a woman he would have kicked her out of bed by now. Its obvious. He does not love the country in its current state. He said he fundamentally wants to change the country. He overrides his military, his commanders in chief. He will not allow us to be the superpower that we are. He under mines every step of the way. He half steps everything. Thats not who we are. To me that shows that he does not love this country. Let me ask you this. Why do you think people are so reluctant to take the president of the United States for his word when he says things like this . He doesnt keep his word. He says he is going to do something and doesnt do it. Juan you are shaking your head. Your thoughts have been percolating. I am in awe of this kind of celebration of you know, insulting the president of the United States when no one is insulting him. Theres nothing wrong with being critical. When the left was this kind of critical and demeaning of president bush i called them out and i said you dont talk about the president of the United States in those terms. Now here you are talking about no one is calling let me finish. No one is calling the president any names here. We are doing an analysis of his own words. Giuliani says the president does not love america. It seems that violates patriotic good sense to talk about our president in that way to the world. It is over the line for liberals when attacking bush. How about president obama calling president bush unpatriotic . This is divisive and invites racial tension. This seems to me is wrong headed no one introduced the race card until you just did. You brought it up. You say one at a time. Let me tell you something. A minute ago it was said at this table he didnt grow up like the rest of us. If you dont grow up i guess i dont know where you are supposed to grow up and be exactly like this to be an american but different is not allowed. It doesnt have anything to do with race, juan. I know you have condemned things the right said about the left. I remember a long time ago a few years ago when the Obama Campaign arm said that romney murdered a woman with cancer. We have back and forth the one at a time. The left made a movie glamorizing the assassination of george w. Bush. Hostage takers during the debt ceiling crisis. Someone questions the president s patriotism. Let me make a point that perhaps when he said america he meant the actress. That is who he kicked out of bed. I want to agree with juan on a specific point about how to argue something. When giuliani says something does he confirm or does he convert anyone . There are three groups of people. There are people that agree with you that obama is a terrible president. There are people who dont agree with you who think he is doing a great job of a progressive leader and then people in the middle who are waiting to be convinced as the new election comes up as which direction the country is going, questioning obamas patriotism isnt exactly the right way to convert people. You can be persuasive focusing on his academic background and focusing actions as they pertain to his past beliefs, the people he hung around with or professors that he had. You can get to the same conclusion i believe without saying other things. What giuliani says is great for talk television. You dont win converts but only confirm those with your assumptions. Seems like a divisive call attention to himself more so than a real valid criticism of the president. He started the sentence with i know this is going to be a terrible thing to say. You know you are in trouble the minute you start down that path. Addressing a group of people that were probably supporters of rudy. He is tailoring a speech and stands by his words. This is a bright man. One i dont think anybody doubts whether Rudy Giuliani loves america. I doubt if he loves the president. It is what it is. He knew he didnt love the president. You never heard Rudy Giuliani when wall street threatened americas Economic Foundation that these Hedge Fund Guys are greedy and acting in the best interest of themselves not america. No problem saying it. This is not i dont have a direct response from mr. Giulianis comments. I dont take joy or vindication or satisfaction from that. The only thing i feel is i feel sorry for Rudy Giuliani. You think Rudy Giuliani has lost it . I dont know. Those kind of hard hitting questions. Inappropriate response . I dont know. What are you going to do. This is a team sport. What is terrible about this story in a way is when you think about these two people how they can Work Together president obama and Rudy Giuliani are like a cop team in which one is the nice wimpy cop and the other gets crapped on. It is like l. A. Confidential. You put obama out there to appease your adversaries and then giuliani in the back waging war. I wish it was possible instead of the games we got something done on immigration on health care. I can go on. The media is really in the tank here to act like all outrage and then carry water for this guy. I remember when sarah palin was accused of having something to do with the shooting death of gabby giffords. We had so many insulting things said by the left. Biden republicans want to put you guys back in chains. All of a sudden some exmayor has beef. You are minimizing Rudy Giuliani. I dont know if this is good for your career. He is spoken for already. I think he is okay. I have to say i am saddened by this president because he had a chance to unite us in such a profound way being the first black president and instead did the exact opposite. I really dont think so. He did it or rudy did . The president. Its now obama. Lets blame obama. I was thinking about the race thing when you brought up the race. I didnt bring it up. You have to be raised in a certain way and that is who he is speaking to. There are three as a leader of the super power of the world you are the commander in chief. So you should be able to unite people of your country that you are leading. I think he does. Are you joking . Most polarizing president. When it comes to our military i dont think there is any president who expressed himself better than president obama in terms of support of military. You couldnt be more wrong. Greg . I think that when you talk about there has always been an issue with the idea of unity. One side said he is unified and others say he is most divisive ever. He is like a High School Coach who is also a teacher who has athletes in his class that he favors. So the athletes who are in his class can get away with more because he is also their coach. I think thats the problem. Wait a second who are the people he favors . I would say he favors what i would consider minority marginal classes that he thinks do not have power. He will always take the side of the powerless over the powerful. I think a lot of people would debate and say wall street is booming and look at the poverty rate in the country. There would be discussion about that. I think when you look at there we go. So she middle class is like on nutrisystem. Next on the five it isnt just hillarys Foreign Policy legacy that can hurt her. New revelations about her past that can be a major issue if she runs. Facebook friday. Post a question for us now on facebook. Com thefive. Ah come on lets hide in the attic. No. In the basement. Why cant we just get in the running car . Are you crazy . Lets hide behind the chainsaws. Smart. Yeah. Ok. If youre in a horror movie, you make poor decisions. Its what you do. This was a good idea. Shhhh. Be quiet. Im being quiet. Youre breathing on me if you want to save fifteen percent or more on Car Insurance you switch to geico. Its what you do. Head for the cemetery help northern china reduce its reliance on coal fire heating plants and prevent 60 million tons of co2 emissions . When emerson takes up the challenge its never been done before simply becomes consider it solved. Emerson. How did i set a new personal record today . I started with a test run. Then i got a solid nights rest in a great room. And before i hit the road, i hit the breakfast bar where i got my fuel for the next 26 miles. Great endings begin here. And now when you choose choice twice, get a night at no price at 1,500 hotels. Book now at choicehotels. Com the other Cable Networks ubsesz over Rudy Giulianis comments about obama they are barely covering a scandal. Giuliani has gotten almost 3,000 mentions over the last two days. The story about Hillary Clinton just 13. Wall street journal reports during clintons time as secretary of state she pushed government to sign deals and change policies to the advantage of Corporate Giants companies who donated millions to the Clinton Foundation and the charity is still taking money from foreign governments which is said to be a clear conflict of interest if he is going to run in 2016. Because of the perception. No way you should have someone thinking about running for president taking money from Foreign Countries. What is it they are expecting for that money . A couple of countries support terrorism. She is on record saying they support terrorism and yet she is taking money from them. I dont get it. Hillary is taking this secretive dark arab world money and a lot of countries have spotty track records when it comes to terrorism and a lot cant drive. Human rights abuses. This doesnt look good. The Clinton Foundation has become kind of a slush fund. And they dont have to disclose any information, not as much as regular superpack. How damaging do you think this is to hillary . I think if you are predisposed you cant wait to use that point with all your neighbors that are on the fence or completely in the bag for hillary. But its legal. You were able to get donations they are not breaking the law. Whether or not you find it to be morally or ethically. Some people might say ethically dubious. I say this is ethically wrong. This is not good. This is insider access to american politicians. And they know its wrong because remember when she was secretary of state the foundation stopped taking money from folks. Why is it okay now . She says she is not official officially a candidate. Of course she is going to be the candidate. So people are going to pay so they can say we gave money and get access. You can see this with American Companies and also with Foreign Countries not supposed to make contributions to our politicians. They can do it through this back door. I think this is influence. You talk about republicans going to attack her. Democrats. Because it is just wrong. You cant do that. This is what they have been doing for years. We had the white water, we had secretive chinese money pouring in. A lot of money secrets. They were basically running out of the white house with silverware and furniture. What is it with the clintons with this money grubbing and ethical boundary violations . They are like bank robbers. It just shows what a hypocrit she is. I think its good for us. You think its good . Gutfield, the Clinton Foundation has about 1. 6 billion. Or maybe isnt that im not certain that hillary made billions but all of her pant suits are 100 spotted oil. Now when she throws a lamp at bill its tiffany. Thats good. Who knew she was such a fan of capitalism. My beef is that im totally okay with whatever you do. Im okay with you getting rich. Dont condemn the rest of us for doing the same thing or trying to do the same thing. The progressive left, they love the rich as long as those who are rich prevent others from doing the same thing. That is whey you have so many left wing billionaires clamping down at everybody else. It is a hypocrisy of it all. It makes me sick to my stomach. Somebody bring in the pepcid ac. Isnt this how government works, juan . People get into office. They convince foreign governments for these contracts for multinationals and then get a kick back when they run for reelection . You are such a cynic. I just think its rotten that she thinks that everybody else is just blind to this reality. By the way, they werent trying to hide it. You can go on the website and then tell you about this money coming in. I think they thought no big deal. Its not about the rich. I dont know that the rich have such foundation. From the democratic side people are worried about Hillary Clintons relationship to wall street all these years that she is too much in the company and in supportive of big corporations and wall street. This is food not just for republicans but for Elizabeth Warren to say as a populous what are we doing with a candidate in bed with all big Money Companies in the United States as well as everybody else. She is in bed with the companies and bill is in bed with the company. But stacy is kicking them out of bed. That is obama. Thank you very much. Still ahead facebook friday. Looking forward to answering questions up next. For all the takes on the hip hop community, is he right . Well debate. Meet the worlds newest Energy Superpower. Surprised . In fact, america is now the worlds number one natural gas producer. And we could soon become number one in oil. Because Hydraulic Fracturing Technology is safely recovering lots more oil and natural gas. Supporting millions of new jobs. Billions in tax revenue. And a new century of American Energy security. The new Energy Superpower . Its red, white and blue. Log on to learn more. I said it before and i will say it again. Rappers like jayz, snoop dogg and others are hurting the black community by promotesing a hip hop culture that is dysfunctional. Geraldo rivera made a similar comment. Hip hop has done more damage to black or brown people than racism in the last ten years. I love russell simmons. I admire his business acumen. At some point they have to come to the fact that encouraging this culture that is removed from the mainstream they have encouraged people to be so different from the mainstream that they cant participate other than you know the entry level jobs. I lament it. Lament it . It makes me cry geraldo. You have exactly spoken the truth and put yourself at risk for all those clowns out there who say geraldo went against hip hop so he is not hip and happening. Here is what is hip and happening. In hip hop culture you can play to the worst racial stereotypes of black people and say you are celebrating black culture. You can make black men out to be nothing but sexual deviants. You can say black women are nothing but [ bleep ] and then say im keeping it real. All you are doing is playing to young people often times coming from broken families and instead they are looking at someone like snoop dogg and snoop dogg is talking about can you control and it is all right to slap your [ bleep