since the taliban talks have started to break down things have gotten much much much worse for the civilians for instance i was asking them because they've done a lot of research in the eastern province and there are i asked them i said in the year and a half the tree years that they studied her this report how many instances took place in the province of harmless of 3 instances and in those 3 instances i least 30 civilians were killed right now in that entire report which is the 9 provinces they documented 50 civilian casualties and at least 30 are from a single problems now what's really interesting is that the report that this wretch organization did took place in taliban controlled areas and and of course you have people there sympathetic to the taliban who choose to collaborate with them but the event you also have a poor farmer who might not have a lot of sympathy with the taliban but if they show up with guns into the village you kind of have no choice but to collaborate with them and yet you have the c.i.