George bush sr. Signed the americans with disabilities act. The bill passed the house and the senate with only 34 legislate34legislators total opposing it. Yet today 38 republican senators voted no on the u. N. Treaty that would extend the ada to the rest of the world. Inclusion six who had voted yay on the bill in 19 ott. This was sufficient to block it. The treaty was adopted by the United Nations six years ago and has since been ratified by 126 countries, just not the United States. Even a lastminute appeal by former senator bob dole himself a disabled veteran, as well as every major Veterans Group and even the chamber of commerce could not sway Senate Republicans. But this is what has become of the Republican Party. A party whose views often dissend to the lowest common denominator and defined by paranoid fears of the u. N. That are devoid of any fact whatsoever. So one could understand harry reids frustration in trying to negotiate with republicans when he vented, and i quote, its difficult to engage in rational negotiation when one side holds wellknown facts and proven truths in such low esteem. Senator reid is spot on or more on what it means for the Disabilities Community im met with the ceo how shocked are you that it could not be ratified by the United States senate. When it comes down to it, i was floored. There is no reason in this day and age when a treaty that is focused on a quality for people with disabilities abroad cant pass the u. S. Senate. It was really ridiculous and ultimately a sad day for america that we couldnt get it through. This treaty would have allowed the United States to really export things that we just hold dear you know, some of our fundamental values about equality freedom and true human dignity. When americans are traveling abroad whether its to study to work, or as part of a family contingent going to one of our bases overseas, they will not have the same protection as folks with disabilities here in the United States under the ada. George w. Bush, he was the one who passed the ada. This treaty was the brainchild of his son right . George Herbert Walker bush was the brainchild and george w. Bush was the brainchild of this treaty. Eliot that is what is astonishing, the heritage of the act and the treatry are in the Republican Party. It is actually perhaps the last vestige of the Republican Party as a voice for Civil Liberties and civil rights. You have both bush signing it, drafting it, and then it is astonishing that these nativist voices, the fear of the United Nations this paranoid sensibility that captures a few votes in the Republican Party prevent it from passing the senate that is supposed to be a batian of reason. You worked in the obama white house, does it shock you when Lindsey Graham stands up and votes against this. Hes somewhat a respected member of the senate. Nothing shocks me any more. The Republican Party has been moving away from disability for some time. When you look at other things that the congress has focused on medicaid, healthcare, the Affordable Care act, even looking at whats going on with the fiscal cliff right . Are we going to balance our budget by lessoning lessening the support to those with disability or focus on those at the top 1 . This trend is ongoing and i hope it doesnt continue. The bipartisan tradition around disability is longstanding, and i think its mourn. Its one of those few issues that traditionally both republicans and democrats can agree on, and i hope we can get back to that point. A lot of work need to be done in the Republican Party for us to get there. Eliot your point is so well taken. There should be no disagreement about extending rights to those with disabilities. This is not a partisan issue. It has not been historically a partisan issue. Whom will you call . Where will you begin when you go and reach out to the Republican Party and say guys, go back to your roots. You just lost an election because of the narrowness of your vision. Expand it. Who will you talk to . You know what . I will talk to everyone and anyone who will listen. We work he very closely with former senator dole, and i couldnt believe as he was sitting there in the senate, and republican after republican voted against something that was so important so near and dear to his heart with former Governor Dick thornberg who is an amazing ally to folks with disabilities. I had dinner with dora bush another person who is passionate about making the world a better place for those with disabilities. The voices are there we just need to figure out how to get those voices to be a more powerful voice for the power. Eliot each of those voices were a voice from the past. Thats indicative of the unfortunate transportation transformation. Mark perrierllop thank you for joining us. We served from different states way back a couple of years ago. Senator, were you shocked as many of us when this treaty was not approved by the United States senate . I was absolutely astonished, shocked and surprised especially given the presence of former senator dole in the well of the chamber, present physically there, even in somewhat weakened state, but a reminder, as you put it very well, the roots of the Republican Party, and the bipartisanship that should surround this issue. So it was a very poignant, and truly sad moment for i think all of us to see the 307 plus republican senators who voted against it despite the instincts of bob dole and others in the party. Eliot my sense is, and tell me if im wrong this extends principles of law that is all right existent in the United States. It does not alter u. S. Law. It does not change u. S. Law in any way. What was the opposition of the Republican Party . I struggled all day to find a rational opposition, a rational argument. Well, there were all kinds of very very unfounded charges made about this law. Youre absolutely right. It does not in any way enhance or extend United States law. What it does is extend it to other countries. Extend those standards that enable people with disabilities to enjoy in other countries the same law and Legal Protections access fair and just treatment that they are accorded here. You asked the really one of the key questions here where to go now . Because it will be brought back in the 113th congress. My hope is that veterans will carry the day here. Veterans organizations very strongly supported this law and the treaty, and my hope is that they will carry the day. Eliot you refer to the fact you were there. Senator dole in the well of the senate saying to his fellow republicans, please vote for this. He is, of course, a wounded veteran for whom this was an important statute. The chamber of commerce was for this on the theory it would expand exports and the power of capitalism, and the chamber of commerce being a conservative voice. It was astonishing to see Lindsey Graham, that he opposed this. Thats why im somewhat astonished about the depth of the 38 votes, that they would get into opposition. Interestingly talking about veterans, john mccain supported it. Another veteran. Truly distinguished and a claimed veteran supported not just by his vote, but also testified in favor of it before the Foreign Relations relation committee. So there is a group presently serving men and women who supported this law. We dont have to go back to the bob doles or the former president bushes, and with all due respect to them, youve asked the right question. What do we do in the here and now, the present. I think there is a real potential body of strength to work outward and maybe recruit some of those senators who voted against it, and well have new senators who are not yet on record. Eliot i and many others certainly hope when you turn the corner in january i heard senator kerry say there could be hearings shine a spotlight on how flawed the arguments in opposition to the treaty were. The questions remains is this systemic of a larger problem with the Republican Party . It seems to grasp at arguments that we discount and are lacking in Factual Foundation to hold up meaningful and important legislation and is the Republican Party moving more to the right or is it moving more to the center. What is your sense on that . Here is my sense. This issue has been widely misunderstood and misinterpreted. The arguments are based on fears and falsehoods, disabilities and protection of people with disabilities, fair access to education and justice and transportation, all of the services that are essential and guaranteed by our constitution should be part of who we are. Nonpartisan bipartisan, the argument that it would undermine United States sovereignty promote abortion, undermine care of children by their own parents, all completely unfounded. I hope that this may sound naive, once more of the truth is known by more of the people who can mobilize those Veterans Groups, more of the natural constituencies of both parties that we can prevail. Eliot look, one thing i know you are not from dealing with you as a lawyer, senator, naive, you are not. I think youre exactly right. Lets hope that the light is shaneed on how fella cius their arguments are. Senator, continue the fight as you always do. You never quit. Senator dick blumenthal. Thank you for joining us. Eliot will john boehner and Mitch Mcconnell actually leave this time . Coming up next. Ice breakers mints. Break the ice. Question why are ice breakers mints called mints . Answer in a moment. Fruit just got cooler. Fruit on one side, cool on the other. Ice breakers duo. A fruity, cool way to break the ice. Brought to you by ice breakers mints. Break the ice. [ singing Christmas Carols in background ] aunt sallys singing again. Its a tradition honey. [ singing Christmas Carols ] mmmm. [ female announcer ] make new traditions with pillsbury grands cinnamon rolls. [ female announcer ] what would you call an ordinary breakfast pastry thats been wrapped in a flaky crust stuffed with a gooey center toasted up all golden brown then given a delicious design . A toaster strudel. Pillsbury toaster strudel. So delicious. So fun. Eliot one of the reasons cited by Senate Republicans to ratify an u. N. Treaty providing protection to people with disabilities they didnt believe Big Decisions should be made by a lame duck congress, really . These are the same folks who were supposed to be in serious negotiations about the impending fiscal cliff. Even Mitch Mcconnell should acknowledge the hypocrisy in that one. Over the fiscal cliff negotiations one thing has become crystal clear. The schisms are becoming more and more pronounce. There are three distinct groups, theological warriors who want to impose their views on the country. Tee Party Zealots and remnant of the pro business moderates while their fiscal views are the last Reasonable Voice in the Republican Party. Its this last group who are willing to compromise and combine their ideologies with governing. It is this group bit by bit who are peeling away the extreme views of the rest of the party. The most important question remains are there enough of them to make a deal and reign in the g. O. P. Circus. Joining me now charles pierce, writer to esquire and author and host of ring of fire and majority report sam seder. Do you feel sorry for john boehner who has all these circus folks with him . I dont. Eliot shocking to me. Look, he hashes trying to maintain his caucus, and you know, at the end of the day i dont really invest too heavily about the actual persons of these politicians. The fact that you were talking about Lindsey Graham who pressureperceived eliot i was setting him up to tear him down. The point is hes facing reelection. The republican electorate that the republicans have nurtured and grown. They have created frankenstein, ive said it before on this program, and basically theyre at the mercy of these people. They created this monster and they cant put it back in the bottle. Eliot would you agree with sam, they are now the victims of their own creation. They cannot escape the tea party fringe who has knocked out the more moderate voices of the Establishment Party so theyre left with only the fear of the far rate. Shame on them. I dont mean to put too fine of a point on it, the Republican Party of this party is demented. I wrote a book on alzheimers disease. I know what it looks like. They have sensory and auditory hallucination. Their place in the world has been completely blown. What mike reese said about this disability treaty, any more off the wall than the fairytales that Ronald Reagan used to tell about welfare moms . As sam pointed out this has been the ongoing slide into dementia that began in 1980 when they adopted supply side economic which was the ultimate koolaid. Getting back to Lindsey Graham, wasnt he the leader in effort to impeach a president in a lame duck session . Did i sleep will you that year. Eliot the hobgoblin of little minds. You cannot look for consistency. Just mere hypocrisy made on the other side whether its the refusal to ratify the treaties e tending u. N. Treaty about disability or what theyre saying by the fiscal cliff. Were seeing an important shift in their strategy. I think at the end of the day john boehner is going to decide it makes more sense to pass the senate bill, extending the tax cut to 98 saying to the public at large were not going to deny you that but were not going to pass the debt ceiling increase. On that theyll hang tougher seeking to extract something from the white house. I agree with half of that. I think theyre going to wait for the debt ceiling crisis that theyre going to create with their leverage. But it seems to me that they have more incentive to blame the democrats for rising taxes on everybody, and then come back and pass that middle class tax cut. I think were going to see the sun setting of the bush tax cuts. I just dont see how the tea partyers essentially can do a preemptive basically pre preemptive before the taxes go back up. Eliot charles, do you agree with sam . Once the tax cuts have expired maybe they pass the tax cut for 98 but then use their leverage to negotiate the tax cuts entime entitlement cuts. Im not sure that they wont fold on the tax cuts. Once again you have to step back from the observation of whats going on in washington now, and remember were fighting whether or not the top marginal rates should be in the low 30s or not. We should roll back the reagan tax cut but i dont believe in miracles. Eliot charles, what youre Say Something critically important. Were all in a way falling prey to this issue as if theyre big issues when theyre not. The fact that the rate would go from 35 to 39. 6, it used to be in the 90s and 70s and 60s, and Capital Gains will be taxed at below the rate of ordinary income. Were dealing with the most minimal of shifts and changes yet were being sucked into the notion that this is dramatic. Its not. You divided the republicans in three separate camps. I would say that the difference between the theological theocrats and the tee tea party is minimal. To a certain extent the policies that plays out with the theocrats is economics. Four republicans have become identity politics. They have no idea what theyre talking about. There is plenty of data to show that people dont even know what the fiscal cliff is. It shrinks rather than expands it. You dont spend. Antikeynesian has become the same politician involved in marriage and eliot i distinguish between the two, the theological strand of the party is more of the social, samesex marriage. I dont think there is as much distinction as you think there is. Eliot the second category, the tea part i began as economic empowerment. Youre right. Folks who say get government out of medicare, there is no logic to what theyre saying. Do youdo you buy it, but boehner is trying to harness and hold together that is fraught with inconsistencies. Well, first of all i agree with sam. I think eliot am i outvoted . Im not sure that i like this. Its a distinction without a difference in the first two groups, and i dont think there is a third group left not with any power. Do i think boehner is trying to rein in his caucus by sending a couple of rookie pitchers down to aa . If john boehner wanted control of his caucus he could discipline paul ryan whose crazy economic inside are ideas are the hill that theyre willing to die on. If john boehner wants to discipline somebody, let him get paul ryan out of the negotiation. Eliot i agree with you. I dont think thats likely to happen. Only a few seconds left. Dick army leaving Freedom Works with a mere 8 million self republicans pay. Hes getting paid 400,000 year for the next 20 years for not coming in to work. His salary was 500,000 a year. So hes getting fourfifths of his salary just not to show up. I think there is Something Else going on. Eliot