Director john houston and the battle of san pietro a 32 minute film depicting the 1943 battle which destroyed the town of san pietro, italy. Praised for a realistic portray portrayal of a battle that killed over 1,000 americans the film was composed almost entirely of reenacted scenes. Before showing the film we speak with film historian mark harris. The book is titled five came back a story of hollywood and the Second World War and joining us from new york is mark harris. As we look at some of the leading directors from this time period including john houston. What can you tell us about him . Well houston was a really fascinating, larger than life figure. His career in hollywood was just starting when the war broke out. He had had a kind of neerdowell adolescence, and early 20s, he had been involved in a few car crashes. He fled to paris at one point. His reputation was really not great. And then he came back to hollywood, started to build a reputation as a screenwriter, particularly with the help of william wyler, who was something of a mentor, and very good friend to him. And then just before pearl harbor, had his breakthrough success with the first movie he directed, the maltese falcon. And you know he had a chance to make about one and twothirds more movies. He had to leave for the war and his service in the war before completing a movie he was making, which reunited the cast of the maltese falcon called across the pacific. So much focusing on the post Traumatic Stress of those who returned from vietnam or more recently in iraq and afghanistan, i want to ask you about one of two films that he put together, this one from 1945, let there be light. What did he bring to the american audience about this condition, and these servicemen, mostly men, who returned from world war ii and what they faced . Well, let there be light is a remarkable documentary. It huston was asked about making what the army felt would be a propaganda film about psychologically scarred veterans in an Army Hospital after the war. The propaganda element of this was that the movie was intended to show that these men could recover incredibly quickly. And the film was specifically intended to be aimed at american small and midsized businesses who needed to be told that it was safe in fact to hire returning veterans. That it would be easy to reintegrate them into society. Houston took that assignment eagerly, and in fact wanted to make that movie. And the last twothirds of let there be light, which focuses very heavily andon miracle cures. Youre back here now. Youve forgotten it. But you remember who you are now. Who are you . Dully, thats right. Full name now. Dominic dully. Thats right. He really did the propaganda job in that movie, but the first portion of let there be light is an absolutely searing and nonpropaganda portrait of just how shattered these men were by their war experiences. You see these young men in their intake interviews with army psychiatrists, and theyre just devastated, empty voice, hollow eyed. Do you feel conscious . Are you aware of the fact that youre not the same boy as you went over . Do you feel changed . Yes, sir. How long were you overseas . 11 months. Were you in any combat at all . Six months. This would have been the most vivid and by far the most honest look that any american audience had ever gotten at the psychological trauma caused by war. I say would have been because the army suppressed the film. After houston completed it the army did everything in its power to prevent its release. The movie was not shown publicly until 1981. Houston spent decades after the war trying to get it shown and finally only succeeded thanks to the intervention of walter mondell. That 35year period of the censorship that he faced was that unusual for directors in this time period . Let there be light is the only movie to have been suppressed from the war over a very, very long term. While they were making films for the army these directors constantly battled restrictions, accusations from the War Department that they were going off message, that they couldnt include footage, for instance of american bodies. They that had to always show american soldiers as brave and confident. Confident. Were going to show the movie the battle of san pietro which came out in the 1940s. What can you tell us about this one . It was shot by john huston in italy. It was intended to be a document commissioned by frank capra of the successful u. S. Effort to free small ancient village with told to go to italy in search of a town that could provide images like joyful and grateful villagers emerging from their hiding places with rounds of cheese and loaves of bread and casts of wine to greet the victorious americans. Huston got to italy and found the right town but the battle was already over. The town had been retaken. There were no villagers in sight and it was mined german traps. So what he did with the full knowledge and enthusiastic cooperation of the army, was to restage the battle. The battle of san pietro, this film is fake. Its all reenactments. Reenactments done on that location and with actual u. S. Soldiers, but none of it was real. It was very successfully passed off to the American Public as predominately actual battle footage. The army put out press releases who say huston and his men were so brave that they actually preceded the army men on the front so that they could turn around and film the soldiers approaching which is one way that you know that a documentary has been faked because film makers dont go first. Whats interesting is that even though it is a big fakery, only a minute or two is real footage. It also helped make a vocabulary for what battlefield realism looked like. Huston didnt fake the movie because he wanted to put something over on the American Public. He faked the movie because it was the only way how to convey what he understood of the realities of Ground Combat and Ground Troops advancing, which is something that had not been successfully shown in an american documentary before. So even though what youre watching isnt real, what huston is going for in the movie is, in fact, a kind of realism. It turned out to be a kind of realism that was very influential on many filmmakers after the war in terms of creating an understanding for us of how to shoot battle footage that looks like real battle footage. Mark harris, thanks for that explanation. And here is that film from the mid 1940s by director john huston, the battle of san pietro. In 1943 it was one of our strategic aims to draw as many germans away from the front and french coastal areas and to contain them on the italian peninsula while liberating as much of italy as might be possible with the means at our disposal. As the bulk of our supplies was directed to england for the forthcoming invasion, operations in italy had to be conducted on an extremely limited scale. Thus, it came about during the winter months, the number of allied divisions in italy was greatly reduced. Yet so determined was their effort that they succeeded in holding in italy a very large number of german divisions. During the preinvasion period. San pietro in the fifth army sector was the key to the leery valley. We knew it and the enemy knew. We had to take it even though the immediate cost would be high. We took it and the cost in relation to the later advance was not excessive. By its very nature, this success worked bitter hardships upon each individual soldier calling for the full measure of his courage and devotion. The response of our fifth army troops providing an inspiring page in our military history. To these individuals living and dead, and to those who now continue in their tradition, this picture is dedicated. Leery valley lies in the italian midland, some 60 miles northwest of naples to some 40 miles southeast of rome. A wild flat corridor enclosed between four walls of mountains. In winter, the highest peeks of the leery range ascend into the snows but the valley floor with its olive groves and ancient vines. Its crops of wheat and corn is green the year around. Italians in normal times. Last year was a bad year for grapes and olives. The fall planting was late. Many fields lay fallow. There are two ways from the south end of the valley. One a narrow pass, it the other a high scenic road over the mountains. They converge from the sight of the ancient village san pietro. Where 700 years it has stood on the shoulder of the valley, welcoming the travelers. The stones of its walls were queried out of the apparent hills. Population 1,412 at the last census. A farming community. Patron saint peter. Point of interest saint peters. 1438. Note, interesting treatment of chansal. From the end of october 1943 until the middle of san pietro had seen some of the bitterest fighting in the army front. They entered the second phase to push forward again after a static period brought on by heavy seasonal rains. Our battle lines were as haphazard as the rains itself. Each river seemed like five. And where there was no river to cross, a mountain blocked us. Each meter ahead being a few higher so each new peak had to be fought for the hard way with the enemy looking down our throats. They had time to fortify their ammunitions. No amount of artillery fire could force them to withdraw. That was for the infantry to do, it was up to the man with the rifle. The man under fire from all weapons. The man whose way all our weapons land, air and sea serve only to prepare. It was up to the foot soldier to attack a hidden enemy over ground that was sown with mines. The antipersonnel s mines that fly up and explode beneath the groin. Nowhere along the entire front were enemy preparations more elaborate than the san pietro area. For san pete pietro stands at the threshold of leery valley and through leery valley wide and level runs the most highly prized length of groves south of rome. By early december we were taking and holding high ground. The hill mass being last to fall. An italian brigade under a live command made a grave attempt to capture mount luvo. The italians were all but annihilated. In a few of their excessive losses, further operations against mount luno were abandoned. And it was decided to make a direct frontal assault on enemy positions in and around san pietro. Elements of the 36 Texas Infantry Division were rotated from position to position overlooking the valley so that troops might study the terrain ahead by various viewpoints. Patrol activity was continuous. Day and night units went out on the ground to draw fire, take prisoners, thus adding to the sum of our information about the enemy. High points. Mount lungo was 351 and Mount Sammucro, all manned and force. The town itself was strongly garrisoned, with numerous mortar, machine gun and heavy weapon in placements. Four enemy battalions were dug in place that ended from the base of mount lungo northeast across the the valley floor to the base of Mount Sammucro. Another battalion was organized to defend the high ground northwest of san pietro. Areas before these positions were heavily mined and held a confusion of barbed wire and booby traps. On the afternoon before, dday and hr were communicated to the italian commanders. December 8th, at 0620 hours. The First Battalion of the 143rd infantry regimen to attack the summit of 1205 having moved up the mountain under cover of darkness and having achieved its objective to attack a ridge to the northwest of san pietro. The third range of a battalion likewise to attack 950. Another feature of the Mount Sammucro hill mass. The second battalion of the 143rd to attack near the olive orchards northeast of san pietro. The third battalion acting in support to follow the second at 400 yards. Of the original force to establish, the 143rd had since spent all but a fortnight under action in extremely bitter weather conditions. At the crossing, it would take mortal punishment. The task ahead promised no less bloodshed, yet it was undertaken in good spirits and high confidence. The First Battalion began the long rugged climb up the mount. Sammucro. As night fell, our artillery opened up and throughout the night hours, intense fire was laid down onb6b the enemys main line of resistance. Tjp it had rained most of the night and it was raining at 8 hours when the second and third battalion lines crossed the departure. Some 200 yards forward they encountered mines and automatic fire from pill boxes. Artillery was deadly accurate by reason of excellent enemy observation over mount lungo, overlooking our advance, which continued another 200 to 400 yards. Many men gave their lives in attempts to reach pill boxes and throw hand grenades through the narrow gun openings. The third battalion was committed. But the advance never got more than 600 yards past the line of departure. Our initial assault on san pietro had been repulsed edd with heavy casualties. The attack on hill 1205 however was a brilliant success. Leading elements of the First Battalion had gained the objective before a strongly entrenched enemy knew that an assault was in progress. To the right of 1205, the third range of italian had also captured its objective but only after excessive attacks and costly casualties. For 950 the enemy was not taken unaware. Counterattacks would be expected on both 1205 and 950. They were not long developing. The first was launched during the early Daylight Hours and even as it was beaten off, another took form. Day and night they followed. Unremitting violence. The toll of enemy dead mounted with each new attempt. The german prisoners captured on 1205 and 950 said theyd been ordered to retake those positions at all costs. In addition to defending hill 1205, the hill battalion obedient to the field order undertook the reduction of enemy defenses which were organized running west. On the 12th of december, the u the First Battalion was reinforced by the parachute battalion which took over the defenses of 1205 and 950, thereby enabling the First Battalion to throw its entire remaining strength into the assault along the ridge. But the first strength had dwindled and shrunk in the five days past and there was now a question as to whether its existing numbers was sufficient to prevail. Reports during the night of the 14th of december stated that the enemy was offering bitter resistance and that the issue was in grave doubt. Meanwhile on the olive terraces below, the second and third battalions had twice again attempted to reach their objectives. Both times they came up to a wall of automatic weapons mortar and artillery fire. Volunteer patrols made desperate attempts to reach enemy positions and reduce strong points. Not a Single Member of any such patrol ever came back alive. Our attacking forces were finished with excellent ariel cover by live fighter patrols but now and then enemy planes were able to slip through and to bomb our posi6gfis, which to all purposes had remained unchanged since the first day. To break the deadlock, ordered were given for a coordinated divisional attack. The second and third battalions. 143rd were to proceed in the execution of the original orders. Acting in conjunction company a of the 753rd tank battalion were to attack san pietro from the east. One was to attack over the flat valley floor. After nightfall on dday, the 142nd infantry regimen to attack mount lungo. The earlier decision not to attack those strategic points having been reversed in view of the present critical situation. In preparation for the attack all fifth Army Artillery within range, including tanks and oil tracks was directed against san pietro and the surrounding area. Each hour, 1200 hours, dday, the 15th of december. The 141st infantry advance some yards against departure to be held down powerless under the weight of the enemy fire. The second and third battalions of the 143rd advanced some 100 yards beyond their former positions to a point almost directly before forward enemy defenses. For the third time they were quaking earth could offer. And the tanks. Orders were for them to enter the town to locate and destroy the heavy weapons there which were levelled against our attacking foot soldiers. The high road in the san pietro is a narrow mountain road, and from the beginning of winding dissent in the the leery valley, it was under direct enemy observation. 16 tanks started down that road. Three reached the outskirts of the town. Of these, two were destroyed and one was missing. Five tanks were immobilized behind enemy lines, their crews having to abandon them. Five tanks hit enemy mines within our lines and were thereupon destroyed by enemy gun fire. Four tanks returned to the vivoak area. After dark, two companies, one in the second battalion and one from the third finally succeeded in penetrating enemy positions. But receiving both frontal and flanking fire, they were forced to retire. Company e having been reduced in strength to a handful of riflemen and company l fairing little better on the ridge, the First Battalion fought its way within a few hundred yards the objective. But the ground gain at a man a yard and did not have strength to carry the fight any further forward. On mount lungo however, despite bitter resistance battalions of 142nd in successive waves kept pushing upwards until in the early Daylight Hours of the 16th of december, the foot soldiers had gained the summit and were wiping up what remained of a stubborn enemy and that proved to be a key position in enemy defense, for even as mount lungo fell, the enemy throughout the san pietro area made preparations to withdraw. Almost invariably, the enemy will counterattack to cover a withdrawal. The first violent thrust was delivered within a few hours. Thereafter, counterattacks came in waves. The roar of the last mingling with the russian fury of the next to break. Many countries lost all their officers. Enlisted4ron men came forward as inspirational leaders to rally their battered companies and resist yet one more onslaught. Our own artillery was brought to fall within a hundred yards of our front line elements. After five hours, during which the earth never ceased to tremble, counterattacks ended, indicating the withdrawal of the enemys main body had commenced. In an effort to maintain contact with the enemy, our patrols immediately pushed ahead. Ba6q entering the town, they discovered that san pietro was ours for the taking. The second and third battalions less than a Rifle Company in strength, weary to death, who were alive, stumbl