Answer me or indeed many others. Can i put you in a question i was sent by [shouting] mr. Speaker, at may be very amusing to members opposite, but [shouting] i was sent this question by karen, and she, i quote, what is the Prime Minister punishing working families . I work fulltime and earns a living wage within the public sector. That tax credit cuts will push me and my family into hardship. Can he give a castiron guarantee, to karen come and to all the other families who are very worried what is going to happen next april to the income, how are they going to make ends meet . He could give them the after today. I hope you will. I ask them for the sixth time, please give us an answer to a very straightforward, very simple question. What i would say to karen is this. If she is on the living wage working in the public sector, next year in april she will benefit from been able to earn 11,000 pounds before she pays any income tax at all. It was about 6000 pounds when i became Prime Minister. If she is sure she will benefit from 30 hours of childcare every week. That is something that has happened under this government. But above all she will benefit because with a growing economy, because we have zero inflation, because with 2 million more people in work, because we had to drink 3 billion apprentices in this parliament and that is the fact. The reason the labour party lost the last election is ever completely untrusted on the deficit come on debt, and on a stable economy. And sense of in the deficit deniers have taken over the labour party. That is what happened when you look at their plans, borrowing forever, printing money, hiking up taxes come it is working people like karen that would pay the price. [shouting] david morris. Thank you, mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, in my constituency unemployment has fallen by 30 since 2010. This government has delivered the link road after six years which will create even more jobs in my area when it is completed. Does my friend the Prime Minister agreed that the conservatives are ensuring that it is back open for business the . I well remember visiting my honorable friends constituency a look at the road works that were being put in place a going to open up the port, that will help would bring for new Nuclear Power station and all the steps he wants to see. I can tell in the longterm use claimant count in his constituency has fallen by 30 in the last year. Those are all young people not able to work, able to benefit from our growing economy. Sir angus robertson. We associate ourselves with the condolences of our been expressed by the Prime Minister and leader of the opposite. Last week i asked about the tragic circumstances of a man from north london to a disabled man who took his own life after an assessment by the department of work and pensions. We know 60 investigations have taken place into suicides following the cancellation of benefits, but the findings have been published. The Prime Minister said to me last week that he would look very carefully at the specific question about publication. Will the Prime Minister confirm windows findings will be published . I will write to him about this but my memory for looking into his question afterwards is the are very good reasons why we cant publish this specific report that he talks about because it has, it has personal and medical data in it which would not be appropriate for publication. If ive got that wrong on the right to them but that is my clear memory of looking this question after last week. Thank you very much. Will a man in the West Midlands was 53 when he took his life. The corner wrote a major factor in his death was a statement had greatly reduce leaving almost destitute. His sister said its a double of a deal for going to be affected the worst. The dwp need to publish these reviews. The Prime Minister says that he is concerned by the views of the families involved. The families say the findings should be published. Will be published the findings . 3 Million Pounds are going to have their Child Tax Credits cancel. We need the answer to these questions. First of all let me just correct him on his last point. Under the proposals we put forward, those people on the lowest levels as they were protected because of the National Living wage and those people on the lowest incomes were protected because we were protecting the basic award of the Child Tax Credit at 2780 pounds. I think the other part of the question is the bit ive already answered which is my understanding but i will send him about if ive got it wrong come is there were too many personal and medical details for that to be published. I think that is an important consideration in whether deciding whether to publish something. Thank you, mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, id like to ask the Prime Minister about ruby your ruby is one of my youngest constituents, she is just one month old. Why should ruby face the prospect of spending her entire working life paying off the debt thats been built up by visit generation . I think ruby is absolutely right to care about ruby when we became the government, one in four pounds spent by the government was borrowed money. We had one of the biggest budget deficits anywhere in the world, and its always easier for people to say put off the difficult decisions, dont make any spending reductions. But what theyre doing is burdening future generations with debt. What i would take to the labour front bench, that is not generosity. That is selfishness. Will thank you, mr. Speaker. Thank you, mr. Speaker. [shouting] i think the honorable lady must have misheard. Innocent. Mrs. Sharon hutchins center. We all know about Prime Minister is open promise on tax credits but will the final nail in the coffin of compassionate conservatism be hammered home if you were to scrap universal Infantry School meals in the review, taking hot healthy meals out of the mouth of innocent, blameless infant children . Will be guaranteed now not to scrap the universal infant preschool meals [shouting] im immensely proud that it was a government i lead that introduced this policy. [shouting] thirteen years, 13 years of labour government. Did they ever do that . No speed and do we remember the infant new builds on the labour party . Im proud of what we have done and we will be keeping at. [shouting] stephen phillips. Thank you very much, mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, my right honorable friend has demonstrated considerable leadership enjoyed a britain is the second largest donor of bilateral aid in series you. But there is another crisis going on which the world has largely forgotten about. In yemen there is an ongoing war. 1. 4 many people have been forced to flee their homes, 3 billion faced starvation, half a million children are ever some lifethreatening malnutrition malnutrition under president of the International Red cross has said in yemen after five months we are in the same position as we are in serious after five years. Please, can we do more . My honorable friend is right to raise this and we have been involved in trying to help in this situation right from the start as in syria we are a major contributor in terms of humanitarian aid. Weve made clear all of yemeni party should engage without preconditions and in good faith in piece talks to allow yemen to move towards a sustainable piece and that needs to be a piece based on the fact that all people in yemen need proper representation by their government. To our similarities with syria which is on a government on behalf of one part of the country is never going to be a sustainable solution. Cristy blackmon. Mr. Speaker, how dare anyone in this house are in a 74 a year till families that their combined income of 25,000 pounds is too much affinity give it some of the back to bounce the economy . Try to do the Prime Minister refused to put this in his manifesto because he knew he wouldnt be a lack of . Let me remind the honorable lady about the situation we inherited. When i became Prime Minister nine out of 10 families were getting tax credits including members of parliament. That is a crazy this is a we inherited. We reduce that during the last parliament, pose that is of course by labour and the snp to 610 families. Our proposals would take it down to five out of 10 families but these are not proposals on their own. They are accompanied by National Living wage for the first time. They are accompanied by allowing people to earn 11,000 pounds before paying tax for the first time. Those sorts of measures while the short family that she talks about. Michel donovan. The Prime Minister spoke movingly at conference at the plight of young people. Cant be answered, what with the government actually did improve the life chances of these young disadvantaged children and give them opportunities as they move forward in their lives . I think but are open for her question for the most important think we can do is to speed up the adoption system so that more children get a copy at what weve seen since ive been partnership is an increase in adoptions but then because of what one or two judgments its slipped backwards a bit and we did work very hard to make sure more children get up out of. Up for those who cant be adopted we need to make sure or Residential Homes are doing the best possible job they cant and that is why today i can as i passed the former chief executive who is an excellent Public Servant who worked with wins at the home office to conduct an independent review of childrens residential care, reporting to the education secretary and myself so we can take every possible step to give these children the best start in life. Thank you, mr. Speaker. Redundant steelworkers such as those in wrexham Pay National Insurance contributions and play by the rules. Why then is this government limiting mortgage interest support for them in the future and making them pay twice, once for National Insurance and wants to paying back a loan . Is a that type of action and a responsible government like is should not be pursuing, and isnt it an example of compassionate conservatism dying . Actually what he refers to as a temporary recession measure on mortgage payments that was continued for five years, but he does give me the opportunity to say as i promised i would last night to update the house on what were doing to help this evening and she which i know is important as constituency. And on energy costs i can announce today we will refund the Energy Intensive industries for the full amount of the policy cost they face as soon as we get the state is a judgment froms brussels. Payment will be making elite and that payment will be made throughout this parliament. Far more generous than what is been proposed by the party office at. [shouting] mr. Grimm abends. Thank you, mr. Speaker. Ive had hundreds of emails from constituents regarding the Northern Powerhouse and i have just chosen one. John emailed me to tell me [shouting] cannot listen to leader of the opposition with his strategy of higher spending, higher barbara, more debt, but instead to stick your longterm economic plan for higher wage, lower welfare, low tax society. Does the Prime Minister agree with john . I do agree. John estimates and more sense in his email and the leader of the opposition did in at least six questions to the point i would make is not only have we seen an economy that is growing, 2 million more people in work, inflation that is low so Living Standards are rising but we can see their art 680,000 fewer workers households and 480,000 fewer children and workers workers households. If you want to measure the real difference, think of those children, think of those households and think of the dignity of work. Mr. Speaker, last weekend was the First Anniversary of the death from Cervical Cancer of my constituent age 23 put in june 2013 should been concerned enough to ask for an early test but she was refused because she was under 20 [inaudible] her family have written an open letter to the Prime Minister. Can i ask you not to offer here a reflex repeat of the rationale for current screening age policy, but to reflect on the questions raised about how this translates into refusing smear tests the young women . And to consider the agerelated data since the screening age was increased in 20 2004 speak with he raises a tragic case and our thoughts go to her family and her friends. He raises an important case because of course the uk National ScreeningCommittee Said the age at 25 to understand is the reason for that is not a resources based decision to its because of the potential perverse medical consequences of carrying out screening routinely below that age that would be a number potential false positives because of actually anatomical changes that go on at that age. Its not a resource decision. What has he says it is worth looking at those people who fear they have a Family History and ask for a test and i will write to on that specific issue. Thank you, mr. Speaker. Yesterday the eu said we can no longer have dealt with on the internet to protect our children from indecent images. I want to know what the Prime Minister is going to do to make sure that our children remain protected. Like her i think it is absolutely vital important we enable parents to have that protection for their children from this that you on the internet. Probably like i a wonder bread y get email this morning i splattered on my complex because we worked hard to put in place these filters. But i can reassure her, i can reassure her because we actually security and opt out yesterday so we can keep our familyfriendly filters to protect children. And i can tell the house that we will legislate to put out agreement with Internet Companies on this issue into the law of the land so that our children will be protected. Mr. Speaker, could associate myself with the Prime Ministers earlier remarks about the late Michael Meacher who is a decent man, they could constituent mp and an extreme effective environment secretary. Yesterday i visited the refugee camps, and there i met families that were inspirational and desperate. Alongside with the British Charity workers that i found, i am frankly ashamed we will not offer to help a single one of those refugee families. May i ask this question, with the agreed with save the children that we take as a country 3000 vulnerable unaccompanied children in europe some of whom are as young as six . Lasslast the last. Confirm to our partners and the british people that no option is off the table or british options will be considered including the option of a relationship such as that of norway if it is negativable and in our negotiable. No options are off the table. If they dont get what we need in our renegotiation i rule absolutely nothing out. But it is important we have the debate in this nation were firm about the fact as figures. Some are arguing britain to leave the european union. Not all people, some people particularly pointed to position of norway saying saying that isd outcome. I would guide very against that. Norway pays as much per head to the e. U. As we do. They take as twice as many migrants as we do in this country. They have no seat at table, no ability to negotiate. Im not arguing that all those who want to leave the e. U. Say they want to borrow the norwegian path but some do. Very important in the debate were absolutely clear about the consequences of these consequences. Join me in congratulating myself toneyearold constituent jesse mcabe on 3800 name petition First Time Ever to accept women composers on the syllabus. Will you tell us is a [inaudible] if feminism means we should treat people equally, yes absolutely. Absolutely. Im proud of the fact that i have got sitting around the cabinet table, a third of women sitting around cabinet table and something we promised and something we delivered. But can i congratulate her above all, can i congratulate her for her achievement in terms of this epetition and constituents and her have done a good job. Mr. Turner. Sir, the nhs england, nhs england knows that the aisle the White Commission group is outlyer in relation to the outpatient partners. Can my right honourable friend confirm that progress is being made to identify factors affecting the island . Will we benefit from amendments to the new ccg formula. What i can say to my honourable friend it is right that decisions on allocations are made independent of ghost and not by government. So that is how the formula is reached. I can also tell them that there is an independent review of the funding formula underway we expect to see its recommendations later this year but these things should be done in a fair and transparent way. Mary cray. Mr. Speaker, remember meeting my constituent neil shepherd and sharon wood nine years ago this week. They took their two children, christie age seven, and bobby age six on holiday. The children tragically died of carb carb poison Carbon Monoxide poisoning. They wish that other people not suffer the tragedy they endured. In the European Parliament on recommendation that the commission bring forward on legislation to improve Carbon Monoxide safety and fire safety for tourism premises in the e. U. Can i ask the <