Transcripts For CNNW Fareed Zakaria GPS 20191020 : compareme

Foreign policy. And British Parliament meets on a saturday for only the fourth time since world war ii to render a verdict on brexit. Ill talk about it all with two former National Security advisers for president george w. Bush. Then, americas elite colleges and universities have long been the envy of the world. But now they face a scandal about corruption. What went wrong with americas meritocracy . A preview of my new documentary, scheme and scandal inside the College Admissions crisis. But first, heres my take. Has there ever been a Foreign Policy move that has produced more crisis more quickly . Regardless of whether the current ceasefire holds, President Trump had allowed turkey no unleash its forces on syria, resulting in the abandonment of the syrian kurds and the empowerment of bashar al assad, vladimir putin, and the islamic public of iran. Trump was apparently seceding to turkeys wishes, but now he has also poisoned our relationship with that country. He has hit ankara with sanctions and threatened to totally destroy and obliterate its economy. The u. S. Military had to bomb its open weapon stockpiles to prevent them from falling into the wrong hands and airlifted troops as the forces of turkey, a nato ally, moved in. Trumps moves in syria are part of a middle eastern policy that martin indyk explains in foreign affairs, is in total arace. Indyk describes now in case after case, the trump administration, dispensed with regional experts, reversed longstanding policy and assume that its knowledgefree approach would yield Innovative New results. In fact, indyk writes, the administration understands so little about how the middle east actually works that its bungling efforts have been a failure across the board. As so often in the past, the cynical locals are manipulating a clueless outsider, advancing their personal agendas, at the naive americans expense. Indyk continues, almost three years into his term, trump has nothing to show for his efforts to counter iran or promote peace in the middle east. Instead, his policies have fueled the conflict between iran and israel, alienated the palestinians, supported an unending war, and a humanitarian crisis in yemen, and split the gulf cooperation counsel, possibly permanently. The policy towards syria does seem particularly unhinged, but its actually part of a pattern of erratic moves elsewhere. Remember, trumps initial approach to north korea was to dispatch three aircraft carriers close to its borders and threaten fire and fury, like the world has never seen. Within months, he was summiting with kim jongun, whom he praised lavishly and announced we fell in love. Since north korea never really offered policy solutions, the love affair seems on hold. The hallmark of trumps Foreign Policy is a disdain for professionals and a lack of interest in history or past policy. When asked during the campaign to name a few experts whom he consulted with on Foreign Policy, he replied, my primary consultant is myself. The policies we are witnessing from ukraine to the middle east are a direct consequence of the triumph of gut over brain. Of emotion over intelligence, and of personal admission over national interests. And some of the pushback in recent weeks has been the revolt of experts finally fed up with the mess. Watching the syria debacle, one cannot help but think of f. Scott fitzgeralds description of two rich, arrogant, and intellectually uncurious characters in the great gatsby. They were careless people, tom and daisy, he wrote. They smashed up things and creatures and then retreated back into their money or their vast carelessness or whatever it was that kept them together and let other people clean up the mess they had made. For more, go to cnn. Com fareed and read my Washington Post column this week. And lets get started. The u. S. Secretary of defense, mark esper, says the ceasefire that was put in place in syria on thursday generally seems to be holding. This despite the kurds claiming that turkey has violated it many times and the turks claiming the same about the kurds. Regardless, the ceasefire is set to end tuesday. What happens then . Let me bring in former defense secretary, ash carter, to talk more about the situation. Hes served in and out of government in many roles over the decades. Most recently, as president obamas secretary of defense. Ash, was this inevitable, this u. S. Withdrawal . What was it taking to maintain the structure in place where the turks and the kurds, in a sense, each respected their own zones, and peace was maintained . Well, it took very little. And it has taken very little from the beginning. When we first recruited the kurds, this is now back in 2015, fareed, when isis was, remember, trying to attack and kill our people. We had to protect ourselves. We had to destroy them. Not only in iraq, but we had to destroy them in syria. And we could have done it all ourselves. But a better way is not to have the u. S. Troops do the tough infantry, townbytown, buildingbybuilding fighting. Thats not our comparative advantage. Wed rather thats the enemys advantage. So we would rather vf grouhave forces that are local, who can speak the language and know the air. And then we bring down on top of them the great whirlwind of american and Coalition Military power. Air power, intelligence, logistics, advising. And that is the path that we set out in 2015 to take raqqah, which, remember, was the place they called the capital of the isis caliphate. And if we hadnt done that, our troops would have had to do it all by themselves, which they could have done, but then some of the local people probably wouldnt have joined us, but instead, fought against us, imagining we were somehow of occupiers. And then third, if we did it all by ourselves, wed be owning that territory now. And as you know, our experience occupying conquered territory in the middle east has been a challenge for us. So for all of those reasons, we worked with the ypg, and we knew the kurds wouldnt like it, but we said to the kurds, and i did personally, were going to have to agree to disagree about this. Well help you protect your interests, well keep the kurds that were supporting away from you, but we need to protect ourselves. This is an enemy of our people. And they need to go. That worked. For all the years i was there. That was the kind of balancing act. We did it every day. Everybody stayed in their lane, because they both needed us in their own way. Now, im afraid, fareed, that isis will come back. Victory will be sacrificed. Theyll come back and next time, well have to do it all by ourselves. How do you feel, ash, about the situation with the kurds . Because in a sense, you representing the United States, representing the department of defense, must have made certain assurances, whether they were ironclad, whether they were on paper or not, you, in a sense, gave them the word of the United States that we had their back. The kurds, as i understand it, destroyed some of their defensive capacity against turkey in order to, you know, to make this operation work. And now they are at the mercy of turkey and the assad regime, two of their most bitter enemies. Well, we told them wed help them fight isis. We wouldnt help them fight turkey. And they kept their word and we kept our word. Now we havent kept our word on our side. And we dont have them in that same containment anymore. Fareed, im concerned also, elsewhere, within that region and around the world, of the ripple effects of this. If we can so quickly abandon a Security Partner thats been fighting a fight with us, that takes away one of the ways we force multiply ourselves. It selfisolates us, leaves us on our own. Now, weve got a great military and we can do a lot, but its better, we have fewer casualties, faster victory when we work through others. And this suggests that we are not capable of remembering and keeping track of who has helped us and who continues to help us. And as i said, well pay the price, im sorry to say, because isis will come back. We wont be able to fight them from right there with a partner. Were going to have to do it ourselves. And were going to have to do it, because this is a group that tries to kill americans. And the job of the department of defense, certainly my job, when i was secretary of defense, is above all, first and foremost, to protect our people, so you cant allow that. Talk a little bit more about your worries about isis, because the situation is one now that were sort of familiar with these ungoverned spaces in the middle east, where there are radicals, where there is a terrorist presence. Presumably, that is what exists now in parts of syria. The only problem is, were absent. The turks are there, the russians are there, in a sense. The iranians are there. The Syrian Government is there. But we are no longer there, right . Well, thats right. But remember where we were. We had u. S. Enabled forces that had taken mosul and taken raqqah, the ptwo principle citis of the socalled Islamic State caliphate. The state was destroyed for everyone to see, including the most deranged loser who might have gotten excited by it on the internet. And they were busy trying to stay alive. They said theyd fight to the death. And in some ways, i wish they had, because there are still some of them who are in detention and a few others who are drifting down the lower euphrates valley. But i was confident that we would keep them suppressed. So defeat was all but complete, really, early in 2017. And now they will, in the chaos that will ensue, as the turks and the kurds go at each other and the russians move in and assad moves in and the whole thing becomes much more scrambled in that environment, isis will return. Theyll also, therefore, have a base from which to operate and try to renew isis in iraq. And well have somewhere and some way, the same barbarians trying to set up their socalled Islamic State again. And when they threaten our people, with they do, thats part of their agenda, well have to defend ourselves. But next time. We wont have anybody go with us, im afraid to say. Ash carter, fascinating conversation. Thank you so much. Thanks for having me, fareed. Next on gps, the rest of the weeks developments, brexit, ukraine, senior National Security officials now speaking out against the president and his Foreign Policy with two top National Security advisers. Sleep this amazing . Thats a zzzquil pure zzzs sleep. Our liquid has a unique botanical blend, while an optimal melatonin level means no nextday grogginess. Zzzquil pure zzzs. Naturally superior sleep. And grew it tony 36 billion dollars. 986 in 2010, i signed the giving pledge to fund good causes. Then i left my business to combat climate change, fix our democracy, and hold President Trump accountable. Last year, we ran the largest youth Voter Mobilization in history helping double turnout and win back the house. Im tom steyer and i approve this message. Lets make change happen i am totally blind. And non24 can throw my days and nights out of sync, keeping me from the things i love to do. Talk to your doctor, and call 8442142424. Even after you clean, odors are still trapped in your fabrics. Febreze fabric eliminates those odors. And try Febreze Unstopables with twice the freshscent power. Tackle tough odors with irresistible freshness. La la la la la lets get deeper into what happens next with syria, iran, turkey, and american policy. Stephen hadley was president george w. Bushs National Security adviser in his second term. Hes now a principle of the Strategic Consulting firm, rice hadley gates. Megan osullivan with a deputy National Security adviser for president bush. Shes now a professor at Harvards Kennedy school. Megan, you handled the middle east a great deal. Let me ask you, what do you think this means at the end of the day . Because, you know, i hear people talk about russia and turkey, but it does seem like the principle beneficiary of all of this is iran. After all, iran has been the principle supporter of the assad regime. Assad is now in greater control of that country. They continue to have influence in iraq. How do you see it . Sure. Thank you, fareed. I would say that the middle east got even more dangerous in this very short period of time. Basically, if we look at the events in syria of the last week and we couple it with the attack on saudi arabia just last month, the fact that the United States has not or has been unwilling to use military force to protect two of its very direct interests, the saudis and the kurds, really sends the message to the rest of the region and the world that the u. S. Is unlikely to use military force to protect its interests. And that will invite more provocations. And i think the most likely invitee will be iran. But it will also encourage those to make provocations thinking that the u. S. Wont use any military force, when in some cases, the u. S. Will be forced to use military force. So i think theres an increased chance of provocations and theres an increased chance of very unwelcome and unwanted military conflict between the United States and some forces in the middle east and perhaps even elsewhere in the world. Steve hadley, what do you think this does to u. S. Relations with turkey. After all, those are also now pretty bad. And some of this is the turks, obviously, exercising their own kind of unilateralism. But they are a nato ally. The United States has, what, 50 Nuclear Weapons housed in that air base in turkey. Are you worried about this relationship . This has been a difficult relationship, really, for some time. And the strain of us being allied with the syrian kurds, who the turks view as affiliated with the pkk, a terrorist group that has killed tense of thousands of turks, it has been a problem for years. Ash carter talked about that. I think the best we can hope for out of this situation is that some kind of a deal gets worked out. The United States, i think, by giving achieving a period of ceasefire may be provide the context for a deal, whereby turkey is allowed to establish this security zone in the northern ten miles of syria. The syrian troops come in and make sure it does not go further. There is some arrangement between the syrian kurds and the assad regime that gives them some kind of autonomy and hopefully allows the United States to continue to do what needs to do to ensure that isis does not come back. And at some point, the turks then move out of that Northern Security zone. I think thats the best that really can be achieved out of this situation. And hopefully the United States working with russia and turkey and the syrian kurds is trying to seek that kind of arrangement. But its a tough situation. Megan, what would you say to people who say, look, why the hell are we there in the first place. The United States is now producing enormous amounts of oil and natural gas. Why do we need to have any involvement with the middle east . Well, i think there are several responses to that. The first would be that our interest in the middle east are so much broader than oil. And when we look at syria in particular, syria was a modest producer and exporter of oil. Actually, their Oil Resources are in this kurdish area, but the influence of the United States and the interest of others in syria really has nothing to do with oil. It has much more to do with security interests. Whether its the turks being concerned about the kurds, the u. S. , and others being concerned about isis, or concerns about the assad regime. In the middle east, as a whole, however, we are producing more oil. Theres no question about that. So we dont have the same need to import middle eastern oil. But were all connected to a global market. And that means, if theres instability in that part of the world and something happens that takes the oil of the middle east offline, that is still going to affect the american consumer, who is tied to the global market, so Global Supply and demand meets in the place where global price is. Now, we have seen that oil markets havent really reacted to all of this instability very sharply in the last few weeks. And my personal sense is that the markets are really undervaluing the geopolitical risk here. And that we are at a risk of having a spike in price if something goes very badly awry in this region, as the chances of it have gone up pretty substantially in the last several weeks. Fascinating. Stay with me, both of you. Next up, what to make of a Foreign Policy that seems geared to a president s personal agenda. Where does that leave ukraine in the battle against russia . I will ask my two distinguished guests. Gh fiber. Chocolate would be good. Snacking should be sweet and simple. The delicious taste of glucerna gives you the sweetness you crave while helping you manage your blood sugar. Glucerna. Everyday progress. Doprevagen is the number oneild mempharmacistrecommendeding . Memory support brand. You can find it in the vitamin aisle in stores everywhere. Prevagen. Healthier brain. Better life. Nyquil severe gives you powerful relief for your worst cold and flu symptoms, on sunday night and every night. Nyquil severe. The nightime, sniffling, sneezing, coughing, aching, stuffy head, best sleep with a cold, medicine. Be right back. With moderate to severe Crohns Disease, i was there, just not always where i needed to be. Is she alright . I hope so. So i talked to my doctor about humira. I learned humira is for people who still have symptoms of British Parliament<\/a> meets on a saturday for only the fourth time since world war ii to render a verdict on brexit. Ill talk about it all with two former National Security<\/a> advisers for president george w. Bush. Then, americas elite colleges and universities have long been the envy of the world. But now they face a scandal about corruption. What went wrong with americas meritocracy . A preview of my new documentary, scheme and scandal inside the College Admissions<\/a> crisis. But first, heres my take. Has there ever been a Foreign Policy<\/a> move that has produced more crisis more quickly . Regardless of whether the current ceasefire holds, President Trump<\/a> had allowed turkey no unleash its forces on syria, resulting in the abandonment of the syrian kurds and the empowerment of bashar al assad, vladimir putin, and the islamic public of iran. Trump was apparently seceding to turkeys wishes, but now he has also poisoned our relationship with that country. He has hit ankara with sanctions and threatened to totally destroy and obliterate its economy. The u. S. Military had to bomb its open weapon stockpiles to prevent them from falling into the wrong hands and airlifted troops as the forces of turkey, a nato ally, moved in. Trumps moves in syria are part of a middle eastern policy that martin indyk explains in foreign affairs, is in total arace. Indyk describes now in case after case, the trump administration, dispensed with regional experts, reversed longstanding policy and assume that its knowledgefree approach would yield Innovative New<\/a> results. In fact, indyk writes, the administration understands so little about how the middle east actually works that its bungling efforts have been a failure across the board. As so often in the past, the cynical locals are manipulating a clueless outsider, advancing their personal agendas, at the naive americans expense. Indyk continues, almost three years into his term, trump has nothing to show for his efforts to counter iran or promote peace in the middle east. Instead, his policies have fueled the conflict between iran and israel, alienated the palestinians, supported an unending war, and a humanitarian crisis in yemen, and split the gulf cooperation counsel, possibly permanently. The policy towards syria does seem particularly unhinged, but its actually part of a pattern of erratic moves elsewhere. Remember, trumps initial approach to north korea was to dispatch three aircraft carriers close to its borders and threaten fire and fury, like the world has never seen. Within months, he was summiting with kim jongun, whom he praised lavishly and announced we fell in love. Since north korea never really offered policy solutions, the love affair seems on hold. The hallmark of trumps Foreign Policy<\/a> is a disdain for professionals and a lack of interest in history or past policy. When asked during the campaign to name a few experts whom he consulted with on Foreign Policy<\/a>, he replied, my primary consultant is myself. The policies we are witnessing from ukraine to the middle east are a direct consequence of the triumph of gut over brain. Of emotion over intelligence, and of personal admission over national interests. And some of the pushback in recent weeks has been the revolt of experts finally fed up with the mess. Watching the syria debacle, one cannot help but think of f. Scott fitzgeralds description of two rich, arrogant, and intellectually uncurious characters in the great gatsby. They were careless people, tom and daisy, he wrote. They smashed up things and creatures and then retreated back into their money or their vast carelessness or whatever it was that kept them together and let other people clean up the mess they had made. For more, go to cnn. Com fareed and read my Washington Post<\/a> column this week. And lets get started. The u. S. Secretary of defense, mark esper, says the ceasefire that was put in place in syria on thursday generally seems to be holding. This despite the kurds claiming that turkey has violated it many times and the turks claiming the same about the kurds. Regardless, the ceasefire is set to end tuesday. What happens then . Let me bring in former defense secretary, ash carter, to talk more about the situation. Hes served in and out of government in many roles over the decades. Most recently, as president obamas secretary of defense. Ash, was this inevitable, this u. S. Withdrawal . What was it taking to maintain the structure in place where the turks and the kurds, in a sense, each respected their own zones, and peace was maintained . Well, it took very little. And it has taken very little from the beginning. When we first recruited the kurds, this is now back in 2015, fareed, when isis was, remember, trying to attack and kill our people. We had to protect ourselves. We had to destroy them. Not only in iraq, but we had to destroy them in syria. And we could have done it all ourselves. But a better way is not to have the u. S. Troops do the tough infantry, townbytown, buildingbybuilding fighting. Thats not our comparative advantage. Wed rather thats the enemys advantage. So we would rather vf grouhave forces that are local, who can speak the language and know the air. And then we bring down on top of them the great whirlwind of american and Coalition Military<\/a> power. Air power, intelligence, logistics, advising. And that is the path that we set out in 2015 to take raqqah, which, remember, was the place they called the capital of the isis caliphate. And if we hadnt done that, our troops would have had to do it all by themselves, which they could have done, but then some of the local people probably wouldnt have joined us, but instead, fought against us, imagining we were somehow of occupiers. And then third, if we did it all by ourselves, wed be owning that territory now. And as you know, our experience occupying conquered territory in the middle east has been a challenge for us. So for all of those reasons, we worked with the ypg, and we knew the kurds wouldnt like it, but we said to the kurds, and i did personally, were going to have to agree to disagree about this. Well help you protect your interests, well keep the kurds that were supporting away from you, but we need to protect ourselves. This is an enemy of our people. And they need to go. That worked. For all the years i was there. That was the kind of balancing act. We did it every day. Everybody stayed in their lane, because they both needed us in their own way. Now, im afraid, fareed, that isis will come back. Victory will be sacrificed. Theyll come back and next time, well have to do it all by ourselves. How do you feel, ash, about the situation with the kurds . Because in a sense, you representing the United States<\/a>, representing the department of defense, must have made certain assurances, whether they were ironclad, whether they were on paper or not, you, in a sense, gave them the word of the United States<\/a> that we had their back. The kurds, as i understand it, destroyed some of their defensive capacity against turkey in order to, you know, to make this operation work. And now they are at the mercy of turkey and the assad regime, two of their most bitter enemies. Well, we told them wed help them fight isis. We wouldnt help them fight turkey. And they kept their word and we kept our word. Now we havent kept our word on our side. And we dont have them in that same containment anymore. Fareed, im concerned also, elsewhere, within that region and around the world, of the ripple effects of this. If we can so quickly abandon a Security Partner<\/a> thats been fighting a fight with us, that takes away one of the ways we force multiply ourselves. It selfisolates us, leaves us on our own. Now, weve got a great military and we can do a lot, but its better, we have fewer casualties, faster victory when we work through others. And this suggests that we are not capable of remembering and keeping track of who has helped us and who continues to help us. And as i said, well pay the price, im sorry to say, because isis will come back. We wont be able to fight them from right there with a partner. Were going to have to do it ourselves. And were going to have to do it, because this is a group that tries to kill americans. And the job of the department of defense, certainly my job, when i was secretary of defense, is above all, first and foremost, to protect our people, so you cant allow that. Talk a little bit more about your worries about isis, because the situation is one now that were sort of familiar with these ungoverned spaces in the middle east, where there are radicals, where there is a terrorist presence. Presumably, that is what exists now in parts of syria. The only problem is, were absent. The turks are there, the russians are there, in a sense. The iranians are there. The Syrian Government<\/a> is there. But we are no longer there, right . Well, thats right. But remember where we were. We had u. S. Enabled forces that had taken mosul and taken raqqah, the ptwo principle citis of the socalled Islamic State<\/a> caliphate. The state was destroyed for everyone to see, including the most deranged loser who might have gotten excited by it on the internet. And they were busy trying to stay alive. They said theyd fight to the death. And in some ways, i wish they had, because there are still some of them who are in detention and a few others who are drifting down the lower euphrates valley. But i was confident that we would keep them suppressed. So defeat was all but complete, really, early in 2017. And now they will, in the chaos that will ensue, as the turks and the kurds go at each other and the russians move in and assad moves in and the whole thing becomes much more scrambled in that environment, isis will return. Theyll also, therefore, have a base from which to operate and try to renew isis in iraq. And well have somewhere and some way, the same barbarians trying to set up their socalled Islamic State<\/a> again. And when they threaten our people, with they do, thats part of their agenda, well have to defend ourselves. But next time. We wont have anybody go with us, im afraid to say. Ash carter, fascinating conversation. Thank you so much. Thanks for having me, fareed. Next on gps, the rest of the weeks developments, brexit, ukraine, senior National Security<\/a> officials now speaking out against the president and his Foreign Policy<\/a> with two top National Security<\/a> advisers. Sleep this amazing . Thats a zzzquil pure zzzs sleep. Our liquid has a unique botanical blend, while an optimal melatonin level means no nextday grogginess. Zzzquil pure zzzs. Naturally superior sleep. And grew it tony 36 billion dollars. 986 in 2010, i signed the giving pledge to fund good causes. Then i left my business to combat climate change, fix our democracy, and hold President Trump<\/a> accountable. Last year, we ran the largest youth Voter Mobilization<\/a> in history helping double turnout and win back the house. Im tom steyer and i approve this message. Lets make change happen i am totally blind. And non24 can throw my days and nights out of sync, keeping me from the things i love to do. Talk to your doctor, and call 8442142424. Even after you clean, odors are still trapped in your fabrics. Febreze fabric eliminates those odors. And try Febreze Unstopables<\/a> with twice the freshscent power. Tackle tough odors with irresistible freshness. La la la la la lets get deeper into what happens next with syria, iran, turkey, and american policy. Stephen hadley was president george w. Bushs National Security<\/a> adviser in his second term. Hes now a principle of the Strategic Consulting<\/a> firm, rice hadley gates. Megan osullivan with a deputy National Security<\/a> adviser for president bush. Shes now a professor at Harvards Kennedy<\/a> school. Megan, you handled the middle east a great deal. Let me ask you, what do you think this means at the end of the day . Because, you know, i hear people talk about russia and turkey, but it does seem like the principle beneficiary of all of this is iran. After all, iran has been the principle supporter of the assad regime. Assad is now in greater control of that country. They continue to have influence in iraq. How do you see it . Sure. Thank you, fareed. I would say that the middle east got even more dangerous in this very short period of time. Basically, if we look at the events in syria of the last week and we couple it with the attack on saudi arabia just last month, the fact that the United States<\/a> has not or has been unwilling to use military force to protect two of its very direct interests, the saudis and the kurds, really sends the message to the rest of the region and the world that the u. S. Is unlikely to use military force to protect its interests. And that will invite more provocations. And i think the most likely invitee will be iran. But it will also encourage those to make provocations thinking that the u. S. Wont use any military force, when in some cases, the u. S. Will be forced to use military force. So i think theres an increased chance of provocations and theres an increased chance of very unwelcome and unwanted military conflict between the United States<\/a> and some forces in the middle east and perhaps even elsewhere in the world. Steve hadley, what do you think this does to u. S. Relations with turkey. After all, those are also now pretty bad. And some of this is the turks, obviously, exercising their own kind of unilateralism. But they are a nato ally. The United States<\/a> has, what, 50 Nuclear Weapons<\/a> housed in that air base in turkey. Are you worried about this relationship . This has been a difficult relationship, really, for some time. And the strain of us being allied with the syrian kurds, who the turks view as affiliated with the pkk, a terrorist group that has killed tense of thousands of turks, it has been a problem for years. Ash carter talked about that. I think the best we can hope for out of this situation is that some kind of a deal gets worked out. The United States<\/a>, i think, by giving achieving a period of ceasefire may be provide the context for a deal, whereby turkey is allowed to establish this security zone in the northern ten miles of syria. The syrian troops come in and make sure it does not go further. There is some arrangement between the syrian kurds and the assad regime that gives them some kind of autonomy and hopefully allows the United States<\/a> to continue to do what needs to do to ensure that isis does not come back. And at some point, the turks then move out of that Northern Security<\/a> zone. I think thats the best that really can be achieved out of this situation. And hopefully the United States<\/a> working with russia and turkey and the syrian kurds is trying to seek that kind of arrangement. But its a tough situation. Megan, what would you say to people who say, look, why the hell are we there in the first place. The United States<\/a> is now producing enormous amounts of oil and natural gas. Why do we need to have any involvement with the middle east . Well, i think there are several responses to that. The first would be that our interest in the middle east are so much broader than oil. And when we look at syria in particular, syria was a modest producer and exporter of oil. Actually, their Oil Resources<\/a> are in this kurdish area, but the influence of the United States<\/a> and the interest of others in syria really has nothing to do with oil. It has much more to do with security interests. Whether its the turks being concerned about the kurds, the u. S. , and others being concerned about isis, or concerns about the assad regime. In the middle east, as a whole, however, we are producing more oil. Theres no question about that. So we dont have the same need to import middle eastern oil. But were all connected to a global market. And that means, if theres instability in that part of the world and something happens that takes the oil of the middle east offline, that is still going to affect the american consumer, who is tied to the global market, so Global Supply<\/a> and demand meets in the place where global price is. Now, we have seen that oil markets havent really reacted to all of this instability very sharply in the last few weeks. And my personal sense is that the markets are really undervaluing the geopolitical risk here. And that we are at a risk of having a spike in price if something goes very badly awry in this region, as the chances of it have gone up pretty substantially in the last several weeks. Fascinating. Stay with me, both of you. Next up, what to make of a Foreign Policy<\/a> that seems geared to a president s personal agenda. Where does that leave ukraine in the battle against russia . I will ask my two distinguished guests. Gh fiber. Chocolate would be good. Snacking should be sweet and simple. The delicious taste of glucerna gives you the sweetness you crave while helping you manage your blood sugar. Glucerna. Everyday progress. Doprevagen is the number oneild mempharmacistrecommendeding . Memory support brand. You can find it in the vitamin aisle in stores everywhere. Prevagen. Healthier brain. Better life. Nyquil severe gives you powerful relief for your worst cold and flu symptoms, on sunday night and every night. Nyquil severe. The nightime, sniffling, sneezing, coughing, aching, stuffy head, best sleep with a cold, medicine. Be right back. With moderate to severe Crohns Disease<\/a>, i was there, just not always where i needed to be. Is she alright . I hope so. So i talked to my doctor about humira. I learned humira is for people who still have symptoms of Crohns Disease<\/a> after trying other medications. And the majority of people on humira saw significant symptom relief and many achieved remission in as little as 4 weeks. Humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. Serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened; as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. Before treatment, get tested for tb. Tell your doctor if youve been to areas where certain fungal infections are common, and if youve had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flulike symptoms or sores. Dont start humira if you have an infection. Be there for you, and them. Ask your gastroenterologist about humira. With humira, remission is possible. What do we wburger. Inner . I want a sugar cookie. Wait. I want a bucket of chicken. I want. Its the easiest because its the cheesiest. Kraft. For the win win. Here, hello starts with hi mple. How can i help . A data plan for everyone. Everyone . Everyone. Lets send to everyone [ camera clicking ] wifi up there . Ahhh. Sure, why not . Howd he get out . a camera might figure it out. That was easy glad i could help. At xfinity, were here to make life simple. Easy. Awesome. So come ask, shop, discover at your xfinity store today. And we are back with Stephen Hadley<\/a> and megan osullivan. Steve, i want to ask you something, and i think its very important that you convey to americans and to the world what the reality and the history has been here. Mick mulvaney says, we do it all the time, we use pressure on Foreign Government<\/a>s to get them to do what we want. But the what we want has traditionally been american Foreign Policy<\/a> goals, not personal political advantage for the president. Theres a story about george bush sr. , for whom you also worked in a very senior capacity, when republican congressman came in and suggested that jim baker, the secretary of state, ask russia to help get some dirt on bill clinton, and it was actually just factual, not even dirt, but clinton had visited russia, soviet union, and essentially baker threw him out of the office, he thought it was such an inappropriate demand. Have you ever, in the administrations youve worked with, applied foreign pressure pressure on a Foreign Government<\/a> to try to provide political information or advantage for your president . You know, in the two president s i served, both president george h. W. Bush and president george w. Bush, their mantra was, were going to keep domestic politics out of Foreign Policy<\/a>. I remember, when karl rove wanted to attend the nsc meetings on Foreign Policy<\/a> matters, i thought it was fine. President bush, george w. Bush said, absolutely not. I want to make it absolutely clear to the American People<\/a> that domestic politics dont intrude on Foreign Policy<\/a>. So this is something that shouldnt have been done. It is not the norm. It was a mistake. You know, the house of representatives in the senate will have to decide whether it is an Impeachable Offense<\/a> or not. But the kind of things that should have been done. And i think the administration and the president are rightly paying a political price for it. Megan, when you use the state department machinery, these ambassadors, Deputy Assistant<\/a> secretaries of state, what does it do to american diplomacy . What does it do not moral of the Foreign Service<\/a> officers . Well, certainly, the firing of the u. S. Ambassador to ukraine or her removal over these kinds of disputes is very demoralizing to our diplomatic core. And especially when youre reading the transcript of President Trump<\/a>s conversation with ukrainian president , where our president actually criticizes his own ambassador, saying that shes bad news, and that shes going to have to go through some things. This is unheard of, in my mind. This ambassador, and all ambassadors around the world, get their power, their influence, their ability to do their jobs by projecting the power of the president. And by having his back on any occasion. And i think this not only degrades our relationship with ukraine, but i think it calls into question how effective our ambassadors can be around the world. Now, both of you are republicans. Steve, i want to ask you, the larger question here, it seems to me, is that President Trump<\/a> is pursuing a Foreign Policy<\/a> that while is raising some eyebrows in congress among traditional republican Foreign Policy<\/a> hands, like yourself, it does seem popular with his base. The idea of just, get out of the middle east, get out of the world, really. I think thats right, fareed. And we have to put this in context. President trump was elected in 2016, in large part by a group of people who felt victimized by globalization and threatened by immigration. Abandoned by their politicians, and betrayed by Foreign Policy<\/a> elites. And President Trump<\/a> is reflecting that view during the campaign and after, when he has said that we shouldnt have been in the middle east, weve got to get out of these endless wars and bring our people home. I disagree with that. But he is reflecting a view in the American People<\/a> and the process, if you will, for three years has kept President Trump<\/a> from actually implementing that policy with respect to syria, iraq, and afghanistan. But finally, when president erdogan said, im going in to northern syria, the president finally had had enough. And he decided the u. S. Troops should come out of syria. So, you know, elections have consequences. And again, while i disagree with the policy, it is very much a result, i think, of what happened in the election in 2016. Stephen hadley, megan osullivan, pleasure to have you both on. Thank you. Nice to be with you. Thank you. Next on gps, organizers say about a Million People<\/a> marched in london yesterday. Chants of no brexit were heard as the protesters made their way to parliament. Did the politicians inside heed their words . What actually happened on saturday . We will explain with the editor in chief of the economist when we come back. Call, not long ago we would walk on the sidewalk all around the wind blows we would only hold on to let go blow a kiss into the sun we need someone to lean on blow a kiss into the sun we needed somebody to lean on all we need is someone to lean on introducing new Vicks Vapopatch<\/a> easy to wear, with soothing vicks vapors for her, for you, for the whole family. New Vicks Vapopatch<\/a>. Breathe easy. You see clear skin. Cosentyx can help people with moderate to Severe Plaque Psoriasis<\/a> find clear skin that can last. Dont use if youre allergic to cosentyx. Before starting, get checked for tuberculosis. An increased risk of infections and lowered ability to fight them may occur. Tell your doctor about an infection or symptoms, if your inflammatory bowel disease symptoms develop or worsen, or if youve had a vaccine or plan to. Serious allergic reactions may occur. How sexy are these elbows . Ask your dermatologist about cosentyx. Yesterday, the British Parliament<\/a> met on a saturday for only the fourth time since world war ii. Many believed that Boris Johnson<\/a> had the votes to pass his new brexit deal. That did not happen. I want to bring in zanny minton b bedaows to explain what did happen. She joins us from london. Were all so very tired of this, but we have to explain it. Im going to very briefly characterize what i think happened and you tell me why it happened. It seems what parliament passed was an amendment that says, were not going to give you Carte Blanche<\/a> to just do brexit. You have to bring us details. Were going to pass each individual piece of it and then well decide whether or not were going to do it. Clearly a blow to Boris Johnson<\/a>. But i guess the big question everyone is asking is, does this make brexit more or less likely . Well, youre light. It was another cliffhanger, another twist in the endless soap opera that is brexit, and a soap opera, as you say, that everyone is heartily sick of. But what it did, in short, the reason people passed this amendment yesterday, there were a coalition of different types that came together. But one group wants extra time for parliament to scrutinize the Boris Johnson<\/a> deal. To make sure that they agree with it. And perhaps even some of them want to attach riders to it, like asking for a second referendum. Another group just wanted to make absolutely sure that there was no way that Boris Johnson<\/a>s government could crash out of the European Union<\/a> without a deal on the 31st of october. And the reason that they worried about that was was that current law right now in the uk said that if there had been no meaningful note by the 19th of october, ie, by saturday, the Prime Minister<\/a> had to send a letter to the European Union<\/a>, requesting an extension. And he duly did, last night, send a letter. But he didnt sign that letter, and he sent another letter, saying he thought it was a very bad idea to have an extension. But right now, i think we have several possibilities. One is, and i wouldnt count this out. One is that the Prime Minister<\/a> gets through his deal formally, by the 31st of october and we leave with the Prime Minister<\/a>s deal. The second is that it takes longer and we have to have an extension and perhaps even the people who want a second referendum are hoping that a rider, an amendment will be attached calling for a second referendum. The third possibility is that we could still crash out, if the europeans dont give us an extension. Though i think the odds of that are probably extreme lly small. So give us the odds on the first two . Whats the most likely outcome . You know, right now, as you said, it looked yesterday as if the Prime Minister<\/a> had the votes to get the meaningful vote through. And it still looks as though he has the votes to get his vote through. But the longer people look at this deal, the more scrutiny it is under, the more people may waiver, particularly those rebels in the labor party who are going to vote with him yesterday. And its worth remembering that right now everyone is impatient to get a deal done. But nobody has really had time to scrutinize this deal. And the Boris Johnson<\/a> deal is significantly different to the deal that theresa may tried three times to get tlhrough the houses of parliament and failed. It involves a kind of harder brexit than theresa mays deal. The impact on the uk economy would be a bigger hit than with theresa mays deal. And secondly, and i think perhaps even more importantly, the changes that Boris Johnson<\/a> made, which were basically to agree to a border, a Customs Border<\/a> across irish sea, when Northern Ireland<\/a> is legally in the same legal status as the rest of great britain, but practically is in the Customs Union<\/a> with the eu, that to me makes down the road a unified ireland much more likely. And thats why the unionists didnt vote for it. Why they have been they feel theyve been sold down the river. And the other thing that i think people have paid less attention to is that scotland, which voted to stay in the European Union<\/a>, which is very proremain, is now being effectively under boris deal, dragged into a harder brexit than it would want by being part of the united kingdom. So i think the momentum for Scottish Independence<\/a> will increase. And recent polls suggest that 50 of scotts will be in favor of independence. So this deal, if it goes through, is likely to involve a harder brexit than even theresa mays deal did. So worse for the economy. And its also putting the union at risk. So this is a big deal. And frankly, therefore, more scrutiny over it. Fed up as we all are with brexit, we all want it to be over with. More scrutiny of it is important. Because as you and i have discussed before on this program, even once a deal is passed, there are still going to be months and years of negotiating what the longterm arrangement looks like. So while i would love this soap opera to be over, i fear that brexit is going to be on the agenda in this country and dominating politics for quite some time. Zanny, we have a minute, but i want to ask you about the political dynamic here, because it is reminiscent of something going on in the United States<\/a>. You have Boris Johnson<\/a> presenting this kind of rightwing populism brexit. And while its not super popular, there is still the reality that it is, in some ways helped by the unpopularity of a very farleft labor leader. How much is the fact that labor is not represented by somebody who is, you know, popular, attractive, and has a clear proeuropean position helping Boris Johnson<\/a> . Oh, hugely. If we had a different Labor Party Leader<\/a> and a different labor party, the last three years would have looked completely different. But i think a bigger political question is when will the next election be . And it looks increasingly likely that it will be before the end of the year. Because if Boris Johnson<\/a> gets this deal through, he is doing extremely well in the polls. The labor party is doing very badly. He will want an election as soon as possible to try to get a much bigger majority and then govern for the rest of his agenda. And if he is forced to have this extension, then he may want to go to the polls in order to get a bigger majority for his brexit deal, because he is actually reasonably popular. And a lot of britons, even if they were remainers, just want to get this stuff behind them. Zanny minton beddoes, a pleasure to have you on. And we will be back. I get it all the time. Have you lost weight . Of course i have ever since i started renting from national. Because national lets me lose the wait at the counter. And choose any car in the aisle. And i dont wait when i return, thanks to drop go. At national, i can lose the wait. And keep it off. Looking good, patrick. I know. vo go national. Go like a pro. Woman 1 i had no symptoms of hepatitis c. Man 1 mine. Man 1 . Caused liver damage. Vo epclusa treats all main types of chronic hep c. Vo whatever your type, ask your doctor if epclusa is your kind of cure. Woman 2 i had the common type. Man 2 mine was rare. Vo epclusa has a 98 overall cure rate. Man 3 i just found out about my hepatitis c. Woman 3 i knew for years. Vo epclusa is only one pill, once a day, taken with or without food for 12 weeks. Vo before starting epclusa, your doctor will test if you have had hepatitis b, which may flare up, and could cause serious liver problems during and after treatment. Vo tell your doctor if you have had hepatitis b, other liver or kidney problems, hiv, or other medical conditions. Vo . And all medicines you take, including herbal supplements. Vo taking amiodarone with epclusa may cause a serious slowing of your heart rate. Vo common side effects include headache and tiredness. Vo ask your doctor today, if epclusa is your kind of cure. Americas colleges are among the finest in the world. Names like yale, stanford, and georgetown are famous for offering outstanding educations. But now each of these schools and many more are wrapped up in a scandal. Can admissions at these universities really be bought . Whenever happened to the idea of a meritocracy . Of the smartest outshining the wealthiest. These are some of the issues i explore in my most recent documentary that airs tonight at 9 00 p. M. Eastern. Its called scheme and scandal inside the College Admissions<\/a> crisis. Heres a preview. What do you want to say to your former players . Do you have any remorse, mr. Meredith . Your former player who is trusted you. Yale soccer coach took over 400,000. John van der walt pleaded guilty to taking hundreds of thousands in bribes. Sanfords sailing coach agreed to take over 600,000 for the sailing team. The fbi believes that the uc tennis head coach was paid more than 90,000. In all, ten coaches and athletic officials were accused in rick singers scheme. Five have pleaded guilty and five not guilty. Of all the students that were cheated out of this fund. Kept out of schools because of what you did. Theres no coincidence that College Sports<\/a> is at the heart of the biggest College Admissions<\/a> scandal in history. Singer worked with the parents to fabricate impressive athletic profiles for their kids. Singer knew that the recruitment of the athletes was a weak link in the admissions process. The students athletic credentials had been fabricated. Charges documents say ernst accepted millions of dollars in bribes. Coaches had enormous power to choose their recruits. What made you want to plead guilty . It was tough to bribe a whole committee, but you could bribe one person. Schools say theyre addressing the problem, stressing that they were victims in rick singers scheme. But the system they created lives on, where some kids get huge advantages in admissions through the side door of athletics. They werent the victims. I mean, thats ludicrous. They set up a system that favors wealthy people and that made this scandal possible. When people think of College Sports<\/a>, they often think of allamerican favorites like football and basketball. Sports with lots of publicity and many lowincome and minority students. But there is also rowing and la crosse and water polo and other sports that a lot of rich white kids play. And that many College Applicants<\/a> cant afford. The elite colleges reserve a huge number of slots for all athletes. More than 30 of the class in some schools. And they dramatically lower admission standards to let the athletes in. From all the preferences, the preference for recruited athletes is the biggest in terms of how much it helps candidates. Take harvard, for example. Every applicants academic record is ranked on a scale from one to six, one being the highest. Those who scored a four, who were not athletes, got in less than 1 of the time. But the athletes who scored a four got in around 70 of the time. Harvard claims that no one is admitted based on one single trait. Still, admissions at elite schools for athletes like la crosse players is often effectively affirmative action for rich, white kids. You cant play this absurd game where you have affirmative Action Program<\/a> for rich, white people, because you have a back door for these sports. Rich parents spend loads of money to help their kids become recruitworthy athletes. Paying hefty sums for coaching and camps. Meanwhile, of course, many Public School<\/a> kids dont even have access to posh sports like golf and sailing. Theres only certain families that can afford to have their kids play some of these sports. Scheme and scandal inside the College Admissions<\/a> crisis airs tonight at 9 00 p. M. Eastern. Dont miss it. And we will be back. I am totally blind. And non24 can make me show up too early. Or too late. Or make me feel like im not really there. Talk to your doctor, and call 8442342424. Nyquil severe gives you powerful relief for your worst cold and flu symptoms, on sunday night and every night. Nyquil severe. The nightime, sniffling, sneezing, coughing, aching, stuffy head, best sleep with a cold, medicine. On the stage at the democratic debates this week, candidates took a break from bashing donald trump to debate how taxation can help ease inequality. Meanwhile, new Census Bureau<\/a> data finds that the countrys Median Household Income<\/a> in recent years was higher than ever before. That brings me to my question. What was the approximate Median Income<\/a> for an American Household<\/a> in 2018 . Was it 41,000, 63,000, 83,000, or 90,000. Stay tuned and well tell you the correct answer. My book of the week is impeachment an American History<\/a>. With impeachment on everyones mind, this is a clear and intelligent account of the three previous examples in American History<\/a> and of course the current one, by jon meacham, tim naftali, peter baker, and jeffrey engle. It will help you make up your own mind as you watch the news unfold. Th gps challenge this week is b, the combined income of all adults in the median American Household<\/a> was 63,179 in 2018. This means that half of the households in the United States<\/a> earned more than that number and half earned less. But this single number hides how much income disparity there is across the country. For example, the medianation household earns over 87,000, while for black individuals, that number is just around 41,000. The average income is much higher hat 90,000, because incomes at the top in america are skyhigh. The report reveals that inequality in america in 2018 is the highest recorded in history year. Thanks to all of you for being part of my program this week. I will see you next week. With moderate to severe Crohns Disease<\/a>, i was there, just not always where i needed to be. Is she alright . I hope so. So i talked to my doctor about humira. I learned humira is for people who still have symptoms of Crohns Disease<\/a> after trying other medications. And the majority of people on humira saw significant symptom relief and many achieved remission in as little as 4 weeks. Humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. Serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened; as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. Before treatment, get tested for tb. Tell your doctor if youve been to areas where certain fungal infections are common, and if youve had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flulike symptoms or sores. Dont start humira if you have an infection. Be there for you, and them. Ask your gastroenterologist about humira. With humira, remission is possible. Introducing new Vicks Vapopatch<\/a> easy to wear, with soothing vicks vapors for her, for you, for the whole family. New Vicks Vapopatch<\/a>. Breathe easy. Theyre americas bpursuing lifechanging cures. In a country that fosters innovation here, they find breakthroughs. Like a way to fight cancer by arming a patients own tcells. Because its not just about the next breakthrough. Its all the ones after that. Wh fake gagging noises its the easiest because its the cheesiest. Kraft. For the win win. Thats ensure max protein, with high protein and 1 gram sugar. Its a situp, banana bend at the waist im tryin keep it up. Youll get there. Whoahoahoa 30 grams of protein, and one gram of sugar. Ensure max protein. Upbeat music everything was so fresh in the beginning. [sniff] dramatic music but that plug quickly faded. Upbeat music luckily theres febreze plug. It cleans away odors and freshens for 1200 hours. [deep inhale] breathe happy with febreze plug. Hey. Im brian stelter. Welcome to washington and this edition of reliable sources. This is our weekly look at the story behind the story. How the media really works, how the news gets made, and how all of us can help make it better. This hour, theres more and more testimony in the ukraine scandal that is implementing President Trump<\/a>. So find out what its like for a republican commentator who wants trump impeached. Plus, comcast resisting calls for megyn kelly, gretchen carlson, and others. Theyre call calling on comcast to launch an outside investigation into nbc news. The letter was prompted in part by this man, ronan farrow, and hell join me live to talk about the fallout. And a","publisher":{"@type":"Organization","name":"archive.org","logo":{"@type":"ImageObject","width":"800","height":"600","url":"\/\/ia803109.us.archive.org\/6\/items\/CNNW_20191020_140000_Fareed_Zakaria_GPS\/CNNW_20191020_140000_Fareed_Zakaria_GPS.thumbs\/CNNW_20191020_140000_Fareed_Zakaria_GPS_000001.jpg"}},"autauthor":{"@type":"Organization"},"author":{"sameAs":"archive.org","name":"archive.org"}}],"coverageEndTime":"20240617T12:35:10+00:00"}