Ofis the latest in a series assaults on hotels in west africa. Malaysian Officials Say debris that may be part of a plane engine has been found on the coast of south africa. Disappears two years ago. For the First Time Since the , ith of Antonin Scalia ended in a tie. Global news, 24 hours a day powered by our 2400 journalists and 150 news bureaus around the world. Im mark crumpton. Bloomberg west to his next. Emily im emily chang and this is bloomberg west. Belgium reels from attacks in brussels. And after postponing its hearing against apple, we dig into just how the guy plans to unlock the iphone in question. And a dough before ahead with its transition to the cloud. We will talk to the ceo about where the company is headed next. First to hourly the world is rocked by yet another terrorist attack. This time, brussels is the target. Three coordinated last killed 31 people, deepening the sense of crisis. Elgin remains on the highest terror alert and islamic militants have claimed responsibility. The u. S. Government is stepping up security measures and president obama pledged to do whatever is necessary to help ring the perpetrators to justice. Some of the key questions we are exploring does todays attack further expose the limitations of europes Security Services and what technology can be used to improve National Security and surveillance efforts, not just in europe but in the United States. Joining us from chicago is a Digital Forensic specialist who has trained u. S. Law enforcement officials at the ei and nsa. The cia and nsa. And joining us is a mentor packet. Thank you for joining us. As someone who worked at the cia, the pentagon and the department of state, do you agree these attacks expose the limitations of Law Enforcement efforts in a European Capital that was already on high alert for terror . Guest thank you for the question. I think theres always limitations and always lessons to be learned in a kind of attack or any occurrence like this or any tragedy like this. On the other hand, there are opportunities to figure out ways to prevent the next attack and that we can work closely together. We have improved our coordination internally and our ability to deal with these sorts of attacks. We have stepped up our efforts to work with our allies as well. We murder we work more closely with the europeans and we have in the past but more needs to be done. We have to hope the europeans in general and belgians in particular can reach out. We have the best experts going and i think making better use of that and coordinating better is something that needs to be done. You can look at this as something that offers limitations or that points out limitations or look at it as an opportunity that we need to do more to make sure this doesnt happen again. Emily you help train fbi and Law Enforcement officers. What does it take to surveillance someone in the world of Technology Question mark you have the going dark problem in paris and you have more technology at your fingertips than ever before to track these people down. Guest it is a big problem alan goes far beyond the old wiretapping we know from the landline phones. It involves trying to pull communications out of devices that value top level encryption. As we see with San Bernardino another case is similar to it, federal Law Enforcement agencies and Law Enforcement agencies around the world have to literally get these devices in their hands to try to determine what kind of communications they were having. Its almost like finding a needle in the haystack given the technology we have at our fingertips. Emily it is such an interesting time with this hearing between apple and the f ei postponed. This issue of privacy versus security, how do you think this reflects on the original debate we have been having in the United States over whether apple should help . Guest certainly the more terrorism there is, the harder it is for any company to resist the mans resist the demands of security offenders. It is a complex set of issues that come into play and there are strong arguments why apple should take the stance they are taking. But theres no question as terrorism continues, people get more and more scared and the pressures increase for everybody to line up behind the government to supposedly man barricades, so to speak. I think theres all kinds of ways to use technology more intelligently as time goes on and this threat becomes more routine, which im sad to say, i think it will be. Guest i dont think its all about technology. I think a lot of it has to do with shoe level shoe Leather Community policing where it may be a little more vulnerable to these terrorists who may use these communities as a place to hide. I think it is connecting to these communities and doing oldfashioned work where you connect with the community and build bonds of trust but doesnt need to involve all the technology we have to us today. Guest i do agree with what has been said but it is highlighting the need for a partnership between Technology Manufacturers and the federal government. As this continues, this need will continue to grow for Law Enforcement agencies to have to get at this data. If it is encrypted, theyre going to work with these manufacturers to decrypt them so they can discover these apps. Emily i was speaking with general keith alexander, former head of the nsa and he talked about his concern that another attack on europe could be on the horizon. Listen to what he had to say. I think we will see significant terrorist events. It easier for terrorists to get there. I think the travel programs have helped a great deal. I dont think that is sufficient. I dont think we will see a number of jihadist and lone wolf type things and that will bring us back to the discussion on Civil Liberties and security. So why do i say solve that . Right now, we have an opportunity to do this in a nonemotional manner. We should take that opportunity and solve these problems to the best of our abilities. It wont be perfect get reasonable people to the table. Emily would you say the United States is just as susceptible to more attacks like this as europe . Is there any difference . Guest i wouldnt say we are more or less but we have had lone wolf attacks in the states as they have in europe. The key here is what general alexander said, its just finding the right balance between protecting our rights. If we dont protect our rights, the terrorists have won. Making sure lawn officials Law Enforcement officials have the ability to do the job so they can do what they want to. The key is working together and to do it before we are in a crisis situation where we cannot be quite as rational about it. Emily David Kirkpatrick is sticking with a. Gentlemen, thank you for joining us. A story we are watching check out shares of imagination technology. They spiked as much as 16 trading on a report that apple may be in talks to buy the company. Apple responded saying they hello they held parliamentary takeover talks and that sent the shares right back down. It is the latest twist in a turbulent year for the company. Its ceos to down in february after forecasting a full year loss in the company 350 jobs. Apple owns or gay percent of imagination and uses its Graphic Processing Unit in iphones and ipads. Coming up, the Justice Department says it might use a third party to unlock the iphone used by the San Bernardino gunman. The method that could be used to crack the code when we return. Emily the fbi backing down it sent off with apple for now after revealing a third party might be able to unlock the iphone without the help of apple itself. Possible methods have been streaming and since the news broke and our next guest has a strategy in mind. He joins us along with our guest host for the hour, david patrick. You and i talked about this and you said there are other ways to do this before this happened. So who could possibly do this for the fbi and how . Michael there are a ton of different ways they could be doing this but one stands out as possible. They asked for two weeks to test and verify this theory of how they could unlock this phone. That does not leave a lot of options. They are not going to use a destructive method or experimental method. I think what theyre going to uses use is what the Tech Community has been talking about witches mirroring the memory chip to replay it. Think of it like cheating at a video game. When you die, you restore a saved game. Its the same thing except in so saving the game, you are restoring back to before you tried 10 10 codes. Emily who could be helping them . There are suggestions that it could be outside governments. Michael its almost certainly not the government itself. Could it be an outside contractor from the u. S. . Maybe. But even that it came in sunday evening, my personal guess is it is probably a foreign contractor or foreign entity because it would have been monday morning their time, which seems to make sense. Although i have no insider knowledge. These are purely my suspicions. Emily it certainly seems that this undermines the governments argument against apple and almost lets apple off the hook. David i find it fascinating to speculate who it might be. I think it is possible it could be a foreign government. There are plenty of entities that want to win brownie points and gain negotiating leverage and sadly i believe especially when it comes to earlier technology, many governments we often dont agree with already have the technology to get things done that we may not be able to do. Certainly the Chinese Government comes to mind. I dont know how that negotiation might sound but it doesnt seem inconceivable that there could be interesting diplomatic overtures going on around this. Emily i am just getting headlines from the guardian, saying the government has classified these tests. It is so promising that they have classified what they are trying to do and have assured it will not damage or a race the data. They are trying to ensure that doesnt happen. Does that give you additional clues . Michael maybe they are trying to protect the method itself or maybe they are working with a government a dont want to say they are working with. Or maybe it is not a government. Maybe it is a rogue Chinese Group or Russian Group or other group the u. S. Does not want to put in the New York Times or bloomberg and say we are going to work with this group we have historically not interacted with. Emily if they find other vulnerabilities, are they required to tell apple . Michael thats a good question. We know based on previous leaks, the nsa and other agencies havent in the past. They are not alone. Theres a market phone market apple has yet to patch. The question is, is the fbi capable of finding those or using those in such a way apple wont find out anyway . I dont think it prevents the dialogue from occurring. I think it staves off for a little while. All of this means theyre going to wait until the next leg time. Emily obviously, we will follow this with aided breath. Thank you so much for sharing your expertise with us. David kirkpatrick, you are with me for the hour. Up next, we stay in the cloud and speak to the adobe ceo about the companys biggest area of this the on products like photoshop. We had to las vegas, next. Emily Business Analytics company dome of says it has raised 131 million from investors. The latest infusion boosts its funding to almost 590 million and holds its valuation study by 2 billion. They compete with good data and competing with information about cash sales over the cloud. Adobe shares remain higher after the Software Giant possibly this report, beating estimates for the Fourth Quarter and boosting their estimates for the year. All of this perhaps showing their multiyear effort to shift from the desktop to the cloud is paying off. Joining me with more on the health of adobe is someone who should know, the ceo, shantanu narayen. Great to have you on the show. I want to start with earnings because you reported a few days ago and there was a lot of concern around Enterprise Software companies and economic uncertainty. What do you think your latest Quarterly Report shows . Shantanu it is a pleasure to be back on your show, emily. When you look at q1, we had a Strong Quarter across the board. The creative cloud, the Adobe Marketing cloud did well. We have successfully re reimagined the Creative Process by moving the business to the cloud and in the marketing business, we had a very Strong Quarter. I think what is driving it is every single business around the world is talking about the impact of each bill and how they have to put the customer front and center. Our products and Technology Enables us to make that transformation and that is voting well for adobe. Emily you are close to completing this shift from subscription to licensebased sales. In what areas of the business are you seeing the most strength . Shantanu the creative, i would say through the heart of the transition, that is why we have talked about in the latest earnings how the creative is this is going to grow greater than 20 this year. That is from the peak. I think both of those businesses are fueling their growth. It is all about the mobile applications and video being consumed on mobile devices. On marketing, it is about replatforming peoples Core Infrastructure to deal with the demand of it shall. Emily longerterm, what are the areas of competition you are worried about . Weve been talking about andy and his famous line only the paranoid survive. What are you paranoid about . Shantanu we are paranoid like any other Company Technology is going to disrupt the entire industry. The good news for adobes we have always been a Product Company in our dna and as long as we continue to innovate, we have transformed our business is by focusing on the customers. While you are always looking for that innovative startup and individuals who have a great idea, we have been continuing to innovate in the company and will continue to do so. Emily you are in las vegas where you are hosting a digital conference which may be one of the lesserknown areas of your business. Why is marketing a big focus for adobe . Shantanu we have always been about art. If you look at our products like photoshop, there is not a piece of communication out there whether it is a website or video or mobile application that didnt have some use of adobe software. A few years ago, we recognize the world was moving to read plot form their web infrastructure and every business had to put the customers Digital Journey front and center. We recognized if we could bring together what we had done with art with the science of marketing, we thought that would be a unique opportunity. Supply and hr had been automated but no one was targeting the chief digital officer or marketing officer with technology. We are the undisputed leader in that category. It continues to grow north of 20 . I think we were first to recognize this untapped opportunity that we think is going to be like a 25 billion addressable opportunity. Emily you have announced a new data sharing coop where you can track consumers across multiple touch points. How are you planning to protect privacy this is a huge thing right now. As our data shifts to the cloud, how do you protect us . Shantanu you are absolutely right and adobe has been a pioneer to make sure we attacked data and lead the charge on what needs to happen with privacy in data. We were ranked very highly is one of the companies that champion that. With respect to the data coop specifically, the whole idea how can Companies Target people rather than target devices every one of us carries multiple devices. So what we are attempting to do is make sure we can identify how an individual might have multiple devices and target them in a more consistent and reliable way. Data privacy and confidentiality is front and center. Adobe collects this data on behalf of our customers and we will continue to champion it so you get the personalized experience you demand from any website you are visiting. Emily adobe ceo, shantanu narayen, live from las vegas. Coming up some we will remember one of Silicon Valleys greatest. Most asian stocks are following today. Killedated explosions people during the rush hour in the belgian capital. European leaders have promised a united front. Steppe stepped up at airports around the european union. Areas entering check in may create new security vulnerabilities. Credit suisse may announce cutbacks as soon as today. It is one of a number of banks struggling. Those are the headlines from bloomberg news. Lets get the latest from the markets. Thank you. Japan is coming back from its lunch break. Hong kong has 30 minutes left. The rest of asia continues as usual. Ofs paints a big picture what is happening or not happening in the market. We saw a spike yesterday on the reaction to the attacks in brussels. We are back down. That is the safe haven. The douche in tunisia climb, thatnues to relation has gone down. Argue risk off, not very much. It is very thin. 3040 lighter in hong kong and japan. Asia is looking lik